Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument situation with husband

259 replies

IHateArguments · 12/09/2022 18:41

I'm so ashamed of being upset about this that I've made a new u/n!

Lately my husband has been quite irritable and short fused. Flying off the handle about quite minor things, shouting and just generally losing his temper and saying quite mean things. Only with me (never with the kids) or about things or people.

I'm anti-confrontational to epic and annoying levels. I don't mind non-emotive confrontation, but I hate people being angry and upset. So I've found myself avoiding telling him things which I know will set him off.

I had a change of work plans for today due to the funeral bank holiday and I knew when I found out (Friday) that we'd have to rearrange childcare plans, because I'd be later home than I'd expected. And I caught myself that I was actually afraid to tell him, because I knew he'd fly off the handle.

I did tell him, but not as soon as I should have (Saturday afternoon). He completely flew off the handle and shouted at me for about an hour, swearing at me, saying stuff like he can't rely on me to sort out anything, I don't give a shit about anyone, I'm only interested in getting on at work.

I felt really - if I say not safe, I mean emotionally not safe in the situation, not that I actually felt threatened. Later I called a friend and had a bit of a cry, because some of the things he said hurt a bit. He obviously realised this, because he got angry with me over that.

Later he said sorry (but it was my fault) and he didn't mean those things, he just lost his temper. I still don't think it's okay and I wouldn't just say "yes, it's all fine", so he's now angry because I obviously don't give a damn about making things right.

It's not a LTB situation, or anything like that! But I can't just forget it and I don't know what to do. Maybe I am being unreasonable - holding a grudge and I should just drop it. But I don't like someone shouting and swearing in my face and saying unkind things, only to say "I didn't mean it" later. If you don't mean it, don't say it!

BTW, the childcare issue was solved. My youngest had a playdate and school agreed that the others could stay at after school club till 6.30.

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 13/09/2022 11:33

Air bnb sounds god. Maybe see if there's a roomzzz or aparthotel near you, might be cheaper.

What you're feeling is normal and natural. Take some time away to build your strength and decide your next move.

0live · 13/09/2022 11:31

I agree you need some space from him. I don’t suppose he would agree to a temporary separation and for him to move out ?

Since you would be the one caring for the children it makes sense for him to leave. But I’m guessing that you would be scared to even raise the subject and he’d probably refuse anyway 🙁

ZorbaTheHoarder · 13/09/2022 11:07

I think your idea of getting some space is a really good one, OP.

Imagine that you can't think clearly at home, as there is way too much tension.

Some time away might give you the peace and clarity to think about the next steps.

You sound completely ground down by him and no one should have to live like that.

Go away for a bit, find some strength and tell him that you have had enough and won't be putting up with his crap any more.

Good luck, OP - you can - and must - do it, for your own sake and for your children's!

IHateArguments · 13/09/2022 10:39

Thanks everyone, for taking the time to reply. Sorry I've been quiet - morning chaos.

I got to work and just started crying again. It was really embarrassing and I don't know why I'm being so feeble, I just feel really upset. My manager was lovely about it and said she could see something was clearly upsetting me yesterday and I've taken the rest of the morning to get my head together a bit (although I work in the centre and it is too far to go home so I'm just having a walk and a coffee!).

I don't really know what to do because I don't feel like it can continue like it is, but I don't feel strong enough to do anything. I feel like saying I need a break and going away for a couple of weeks might help, but I would want to take the kids and that makes it more complicated. My parents don't live in the UK and obviously taking kids abroad (and out of school) raises a whole bunch of issues. I have two friends who would definitely be happy for us to stay, but I think it is a bit much if it is for longer than a day or so (which it would be). I could see if I could find an air b'n'b or something, it might be the best option. In terms of work, I do at least have stacks of annual leave and TOIL to take, which would probably be necessary. It's a question of when/if the powers that be would allow me to take it, as we have a block on AL during September.

Sorry, I'm just thinking out loud here really. I just want some space to think and relax a bit, that's as far as I can get at the moment really.

OP posts:
BringItBackBruno · 13/09/2022 09:58

He needs to know this is absolutely not ok. While I may not be planning to LTB yet, I would if this continued once I'd made it crystal clear that I would not be left feeling worried about going back to my own home.

Next time I would say "I will NOT be spoken to like that. You have an anger problem and you need to sort it out" and see what happened next. It would tell me everything. And I'll be honest, the fact he's having a go at you for confiding your sadness in a friend means I wouldn't be getting my hopes up. He cares what others think of him, but not what you think apparently.

ParentallyUnprepared · 13/09/2022 09:47

If you're not ready to leave him, and he won't have counselling, then you need strategies to get through it.

Can you leave when he starts getting angry? The room, or the house completely? Tell him you will not engage in conversation while he's shouting and walk away.

Can you text/email him things that'll set him off instead of face to face?

No one should have to live like this. No one deserves to be shouted and screamed at. Please remember that.

CatsandFish · 13/09/2022 08:38

IHateArguments · 12/09/2022 23:25

I will suggest it, I'm just worried he won't take it well.

I'm sorry I'm coming across as so feeble. I just feel really edgy and stressed, and really tired (weird combination).

Don't just suggest it, OP. Demand it! Tell him you will file for divorce if he doesn't agree, and tell him you mean it.

I'd take the kids and go to your parents (or even a motel) for a few days. Leave him a note summarising what you've said here. Tell him in it you are on edge from his abusive behaviour, and he either agrees to urgent couples therapy, or you will file for a divorce, that you mean this and there is absolutely no going back from this if he doesn't change.

ReluctantCourier · 13/09/2022 08:35

I discovered my ExH was having an affair and confronted him… he didn’t shout in my face for an hour! We had heated exchanges briefly but at no point did I feel unsafe, OP. I can’t say much nice about the guy but it still was never that bad. This isn’t ok.

PercyPigInAWig · 13/09/2022 08:29

IHateArguments · 12/09/2022 21:18

If it were just me I could do this... and I probably would, just to have some space. But I wouldn't want to leave him alone with the kids if he's really angry, because what if he starts blowing up at them instead? And realistically, if I inform him that I'm leaving and I don't want to talk to him for X amount of time, he probably would be upset and angry.

So you can't leave your children with their own father and it's not a LTB situation.
It doesn't really matter how it's come to that, this man is not a good dad or husband, or person.

What if they were in your kind of relationship as either the perpetrator or victim of emotional abuse?

Your life could be so much better not walking on eggshells.

Umbellifer · 13/09/2022 08:20

@IHateArguments it is painful and bewildering to realise that you are in an abusive relationship - I told myself I was over-reacting/had imagined it/had caused the problem in some way - but eventually, sadly, I saw it for what it was, with the help of the girls on here.

I am now on my own with the DC and life day-to-day is easier and sunnier and happier. No eggshells, no wondering what the kids saw/overheard or comforting them when he’d shouted at them.

you all deserve better lovely, take the time you need to take this in, read Lundy Bancroft or do the Freedom Programme, and then when you’re ready get yourself and the kids away from him. If you do it before you’re convinced you’ll persuade yourself to go back…and if you’re seeing a therapist make sure it’s someone who understands abuse.

Herejustforthisone · 13/09/2022 08:09

KickUpAFusss · 13/09/2022 07:52

This sounds exactly like my abusive ex who'd rant and rave and shout in my face whilst I sat there quietly then later tell me it was my fault and if I didn't accept that "apology" that wasn't an actual apology and accept it was all down to me he'd start off again.

It was the same as you, according to him no one else made him as angry as I did (over basically anything and everything). What I realise now is that he just didn't feel comfortable enough with anyone else to show his true self. He couldn't act like that with colleagues because he'd get fired. He couldn't act like that with friends because he'd had none. He couldn't act like that with strangers because he'd get a punch in the face. It's horrible to know that they CAN help how they are/ control themselves in other situations but don't with you.

I was the same, scared to tell him anything that I knew would send him off.

He turned physical in the end, not saying your husband will of course, but mine did. I actually found the emotional side worse personally it still affects me today. I felt completely worthless by the time I'd left and like I was just useless at everything, just really annoying and hardwork because that's what he'd made me feel, everything I did was wrong, I was stupid and no good at anything. I was apologising every 5 minutes to everyone in my life for every little thing.

I'm married to my now DH. He works a stressful jobs and like everyone he has his moments where he's a bit of a grump but they are few and far between and one thing I noticed is that even when he is being a dick I'm not scared. I don't sit there quietly, if he's being a dick I'll damn well tell him he's being a dick, I don't sit there cowering when we argue, I don't apologise for things I don't think I've done wrong. Yeah we argue like most couples do, we aren't perfect. But I actually love the fact that WE argue. It's not just him shouting at me like it was with ex! Weird thing to love about a relationship I know!

So yes it is LTB situation OP especially if he doesn't realise it's a problem and take ownership of how he's making you feel and make changes to himself.

@IHateArguments read this. And then read it again.

ReneBumsWombats · 13/09/2022 08:02

IHateArguments · 13/09/2022 06:19

It probably is a good idea and I've been thinking about it. I find that I am too anxious and behaving in an avoidant way. I find that I wake up all through the night and I was bolt awake at 5.30 feeling really churned up, I've got stomach cramps because I'm stressing, etc. etc. Definitely not normal!

Yeah, I was like this when I was living with my abuser too. Sadly I couldn't dump him, but my mother could have. She thought it was partly her fault and he'd never do it to the kids and he used to be lovely.

He too thought he could tell us all to fuck off, to fucking die, that we were shits and parasites and whatnot, and we should know that he didn't mean it and not be upset by it.

KickUpAFusss · 13/09/2022 07:52

This sounds exactly like my abusive ex who'd rant and rave and shout in my face whilst I sat there quietly then later tell me it was my fault and if I didn't accept that "apology" that wasn't an actual apology and accept it was all down to me he'd start off again.

It was the same as you, according to him no one else made him as angry as I did (over basically anything and everything). What I realise now is that he just didn't feel comfortable enough with anyone else to show his true self. He couldn't act like that with colleagues because he'd get fired. He couldn't act like that with friends because he'd had none. He couldn't act like that with strangers because he'd get a punch in the face. It's horrible to know that they CAN help how they are/ control themselves in other situations but don't with you.

I was the same, scared to tell him anything that I knew would send him off.

He turned physical in the end, not saying your husband will of course, but mine did. I actually found the emotional side worse personally it still affects me today. I felt completely worthless by the time I'd left and like I was just useless at everything, just really annoying and hardwork because that's what he'd made me feel, everything I did was wrong, I was stupid and no good at anything. I was apologising every 5 minutes to everyone in my life for every little thing.

I'm married to my now DH. He works a stressful jobs and like everyone he has his moments where he's a bit of a grump but they are few and far between and one thing I noticed is that even when he is being a dick I'm not scared. I don't sit there quietly, if he's being a dick I'll damn well tell him he's being a dick, I don't sit there cowering when we argue, I don't apologise for things I don't think I've done wrong. Yeah we argue like most couples do, we aren't perfect. But I actually love the fact that WE argue. It's not just him shouting at me like it was with ex! Weird thing to love about a relationship I know!

So yes it is LTB situation OP especially if he doesn't realise it's a problem and take ownership of how he's making you feel and make changes to himself.

RequiemForAcat · 13/09/2022 07:39

Echoing that relationship counselling isn’t going to work. OP you’re with an abusive man here, he may not be physically hurting you but the level of emotional damage he’s going to be doing to you AND your children is massive. Just because he doesn’t aim his shouting at the children doesn’t mean it’s not emotionally harming them.

Go for some counselling on your own, and try to find a therapist who specialises in trauma therapy, it’s absolutely invaluable!

Herejustforthisone · 13/09/2022 07:34

I hate that that you cannot see that you’re husband is abusing you. And I hate that you’re making immense excuses for him and blaming yourself.

Would you treat someone you supposedly love the way he’s treating you? No. It’s abhorrent behaviour.

beastlyslumber · 13/09/2022 07:15

Please stop suggesting relationship counselling. This is not a relationship problem. It's an abuse problem. Couples counselling in this situation is a terrible idea.

beastlyslumber · 13/09/2022 07:12

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/09/2022 23:35

And do not on any account have couples therapy with him. Couples therapy is never recommended with an abuser.

This is correct. Maybe someone could link to the recent thread where a woman talked about how her therapist colluded with husband's abuse. Lots of comments saying similar.

Therapy on your own could be an idea though.

LastWordsOfALiar · 13/09/2022 06:54

I will freely admit that I'm annoying as hell in arguments because I just go quiet or say I don't want to continue the discussion while he's so angry.

That's not annoying, that's normal.

It's your husband who acts abnormal in arguments. Most adults don't react like that to disagreement/stressful situations.

It sounds like you don't feel able to communicate effectively with him.

It sounds like there are things you can say, and things you can't.

I think you have three options;

  1. find a time when all is well and tell him that you're finding he's getting angry more frequently and that you don't like it. It's affecting your relationship and you need it to change or you'll have to think about what you do going forwards as you can't spend your whole life in confrontational situations with him.

  2. you do nothing. You accept this is the way it all, and you accept the damage he causes you and your kids. (Unless they're deaf, they will be hearing it and feeling awful for you).

  3. you insist on relationship counselling or you're leaving.

He needs to know that's not acceptable language, whether he's stressed, angry or whatever.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 13/09/2022 06:44

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/09/2022 19:02

It is a LTB situation. He makes you feel frightened over trivia stuff. And he is trying to limit you ability to advance in your career.

That is text book LTB.

What do you get out of this relationship? And what has happened to you to make you believe you deserve to be shouted at because of something completely outside your control.

Fuck that. Seriously. You have a job, which is good. Do you have somewhere to go?

This...

This is vile emotional abuse stuff...

Yelled at for an hour over stuff outside your control? Nah...

Womencanlift · 13/09/2022 06:40

IHateArguments · 13/09/2022 06:19

It probably is a good idea and I've been thinking about it. I find that I am too anxious and behaving in an avoidant way. I find that I wake up all through the night and I was bolt awake at 5.30 feeling really churned up, I've got stomach cramps because I'm stressing, etc. etc. Definitely not normal!

If you are waking up feeling like that you need to think about (and take responsibility for) how your children feel waking up every morning. Every day they will not know what mood their dad is going to be in. That is no way for children to grow up

Also your manager absolutely knows what is going on, or has a very good idea, and was likely giving you an opportunity to talk. Take that opportunity

carefullycourageous · 13/09/2022 06:27

He's abusing you. Sorry if you're scared by that but what he's doing isn't normal married people arguing.

I can't tell you what to do but there are charities that will listen and can advise, please start thinking about how to respond.

Modestandatinybitsexy · 13/09/2022 06:22

I think you should LTB or he needs to take some big fucking steps to show you he's serious about changing. He needs anger therapy and you probably need couples therapy to learn how to talk without blowing up or shutting down.

Where are your kids when these outbursts happen? What's it teaching them about communication? They can't feel safe, especially if it can go on for hours. It must be horrible to live in your house wondering if you're going to set off a fuse. It's not ok that he just shouts at you, it'll affect everyone and it's clear emotional abuse.

He needs to take accountability for his actions or he's going to lose his family, you can't go on much longer like this.

IHateArguments · 13/09/2022 06:19

It probably is a good idea and I've been thinking about it. I find that I am too anxious and behaving in an avoidant way. I find that I wake up all through the night and I was bolt awake at 5.30 feeling really churned up, I've got stomach cramps because I'm stressing, etc. etc. Definitely not normal!

OP posts:
FantasticButtocks · 13/09/2022 00:18

You can't change his behaviour. You can only choose what you will and won't tolerate.

It's difficult if you've got into a pattern of him being allowed to shout at you and you feeling ashamed for minding that. It's absolutely healthy and right that you don't want to be shouted at and bullied.

So if you feel that you love each other and want to stay together, you need to have some clear boundaries for yourself that you stick to. That might look like - if he starts to raise his voice you immediately raise your hand and say loudly "I need to stop you there. There is absolutely no reason for you to speak to me like that, and I won't have it." If he continues you could leave the room.

Perhaps you could get your own counselling if he won't agree to go, and maybe that would help you to find a way to stay together without continuing those patterns, by you breaking your part of the pattern (which is allowing yourself to live like this). Or counselling might help you to clarify your thoughts about whether this relationship really works for you and what you want to do about it. You clearly don't want to continue with things as they are.

Always4Brenner · 13/09/2022 00:10

Grumpy stbx in my case I’m leaving don’t know when but I can’t wait no more grumpiness I can walk away if we meet for a coffee. I’ve had it up to here with grumpiness moods snappiness. Funny enough he’s not too bad now I pull him up now. I’d get duck in a row and make plans to leave walking on egg shelves is just miserable. Been there don’t that never again.