Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my teenager wear this?

240 replies

imnotquitesure · 12/09/2022 16:31

My 16 year old DD is going to a party and I have bought her this dress. I at first said it was inappropriate but I caved and bought it anyway. I said if it is not appropriate when it arrives I will send it back. She thinks this unfair and I shouldn't control what she wears at 16 because all her friends wear the same. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
roolz · 13/09/2022 09:09

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:04

But Roolz what makes you right in not allowing it compared to a parent who does. People parent how they believe is right and what suits them and their DCs. Teenage girls have been wearing this sort of thing for years, I am in my 40s and outfits were very skimpy and revealing when I was a teen. I was sexually assaulted on the rare day I wore trousers and a high necked top. Neither of my boys would wear that dress so it's only hypothetical in our house.

Like most other women/girls, I've been sexually assaulted too, I'm not denying outfit doesn't prevent it.

As a parent, you can say no. That's really my point- a short, low cut and tight dress is too much for a dd who is not yet an adult, IMO. Anyone else is free to parent as they like, I just don't get the whole ' you can't police it'. You can. Arguably it makes little difference but 🤷🏼‍♀️

roolz · 13/09/2022 09:07

Well it's certainly not my idea of looking good, it looks cheaply made and very insta-model-esque. I've stated I wouldn't allow that particular dress, but in the mind of a teen girl, they don't want to go to a house party wearing jeans and a hoodie, they want to dress like their friends. Fine for a party with people they know. Safety is definitely an issue when going out-out. @Kissingfrogs25

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:06

I would have definitely worn that dress however I don't necessarily think it looks good, it's just a stage some teenage girls go through.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 09:05

Kellie45 · 13/09/2022 08:57

Sorry but this is assuming an idealised world. I should be able to leave my laptop on the front seat of my car when I park it but I don’t as there are nasty people around who will steal things. Why I have to have a tight hold of my purse. A kid should be able to wear what she likes but there are men who take advantage and see it as an invitation. That is more and more the world we live in.

I think you misunderstood my post, or maybe I didn't write it very well. The dress is continuing the cycle of women being objectified in my view.

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:04

But Roolz what makes you right in not allowing it compared to a parent who does. People parent how they believe is right and what suits them and their DCs. Teenage girls have been wearing this sort of thing for years, I am in my 40s and outfits were very skimpy and revealing when I was a teen. I was sexually assaulted on the rare day I wore trousers and a high necked top. Neither of my boys would wear that dress so it's only hypothetical in our house.

onlythreenow · 13/09/2022 09:04

I agree that it is hideous and looks cheap and nasty. I'm not saying that because I am "old" either - I wouldn't have worn something like that at any stage of my life. Yes, we wore short skirts when I was young, but they were still far more modest than that dress and not skin tight.

Women have campaigned through the ages (and some have died ) to be taken seriously by men in industry, politics, commerce, science and education.
To me this minimalistic sort of attire undermines and devalues the efforts our forbearers have made, by portraying women as no more than a collection of body parts for men's amusement.

I totally agree with this. As for all the comments about how women should be able to wear what they want without having to deal with men leering, well yes they should, but this is the real world, not fantasyland. Why do young women want to have so much flesh on display anyway, what is the actual point?

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 09:01

roolz · 13/09/2022 08:54

Yes, but tbf if a 16yo is at a party, they don't care about this, they just want to look good and have fun in that moment. Nothing wrong with that.

I 100% agree however people want to defend their own parenting decisions because they allow very revealing attire like this on their teen. I just don't see how this particular outfit in the op is ok for a 16yo, why can't parents just say 'no, let's choose a similar, slightly less revealing dress?'

Look good? Are you kidding? I am not sure if that is a joke or not. Clearly it is going to be very hard to 'look good' in a dress like this. Why would they not care about their safety at a party? Or the bigger message about being objectified? Sorry I am struggling to understand why a girl/woman would suddenly not care just because she is at a party?

Unless we say to our girls - look we have spent years fighting and dying for equality do you think this dress is helping? What messages are giving the world.

YOU ARE MORE THAN GOOD ENOUGH AS YOU ARE

You don't need to be half naked to be cared about/noticed/listened to/on trend.

Unless we educate and talk to our young girls, then they will just continue the same cycle of being sexualised and objectified by boys and men before they have even managed to open their mouths or say a single word.

Kellie45 · 13/09/2022 08:57

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 08:51

We need to be judged on what we think and what we say rather than the dress we wear. Surely the aim is to get past being objectified and sexualised at a young age?

Sorry but this is assuming an idealised world. I should be able to leave my laptop on the front seat of my car when I park it but I don’t as there are nasty people around who will steal things. Why I have to have a tight hold of my purse. A kid should be able to wear what she likes but there are men who take advantage and see it as an invitation. That is more and more the world we live in.

roolz · 13/09/2022 08:54

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 08:51

We need to be judged on what we think and what we say rather than the dress we wear. Surely the aim is to get past being objectified and sexualised at a young age?

Yes, but tbf if a 16yo is at a party, they don't care about this, they just want to look good and have fun in that moment. Nothing wrong with that.

I 100% agree however people want to defend their own parenting decisions because they allow very revealing attire like this on their teen. I just don't see how this particular outfit in the op is ok for a 16yo, why can't parents just say 'no, let's choose a similar, slightly less revealing dress?'

sidewayswalking · 13/09/2022 08:53

GettingStuffed · 12/09/2022 20:47

Tell her the risks of a dress like that. Tell her the red flags and to stay close to a friend all night, if her friends are wearing dresses like that it'll keep them both Safe

Can you tell me?

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 08:51

We need to be judged on what we think and what we say rather than the dress we wear. Surely the aim is to get past being objectified and sexualised at a young age?

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 08:49

TheMoonisaBalloon · 13/09/2022 08:45

@Kissingfrogs25
I also fundamentally disagree that women are respected whatever they wear, I sincerely wish that was true, but it is not flissypaps there is such a thing as unconscious bias. Most people will form an opinion of another person within seconds and it is wishful thinking to imagine otherwise.

This ^

I want the people around them to listen to what they are saying, they are intelligent, articulate girls that don't need to reduce themselves to teetering around half naked.

This ^ x 1000.

Women have campaigned through the ages (and some have died ) to be taken seriously by men in industry, politics, commerce, science and education.
To me this minimalistic sort of attire undermines and devalues the efforts our forbearers have made, by portraying women as no more than a collection of body parts for men's amusement.

Yes I agree. This kind of dress reduces an intelligent, powerful woman back to a plaything for men. Surely we need to be moving on from this at some point.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 08:46

We all internalise misogyny to some point sadly, but things are changing slowly for the better. You can pretend we live in a completely ideal world with mutual respect and harmony - I will stick with reality thanks.

TheMoonisaBalloon · 13/09/2022 08:45

@Kissingfrogs25
I also fundamentally disagree that women are respected whatever they wear, I sincerely wish that was true, but it is not flissypaps there is such a thing as unconscious bias. Most people will form an opinion of another person within seconds and it is wishful thinking to imagine otherwise.

This ^

I want the people around them to listen to what they are saying, they are intelligent, articulate girls that don't need to reduce themselves to teetering around half naked.

This ^ x 1000.

Women have campaigned through the ages (and some have died ) to be taken seriously by men in industry, politics, commerce, science and education.
To me this minimalistic sort of attire undermines and devalues the efforts our forbearers have made, by portraying women as no more than a collection of body parts for men's amusement.

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 13/09/2022 08:42

You used a hell of a lot of words just to say "I've internalised a whole lot of misogyny", didn't you Kissingfrogs25

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 13/09/2022 08:40

CoolerThanIceCream · 12/09/2022 20:39

And @Iliveonahill is right - boys and men don’t go out in clothing that only covers the bare minimum of flesh.

Why is that?

You aren't really asking that question, are you. No adult could ask that question with faux wide-eyed innocence and expect to be taken seriously.

Men and boys haven't been objectified and sexualised by the opposite sex since the beginning of time. They haven't been told that their worth depends on their face and body.

Does that help to clarify things for you?

Iliveonahill · 13/09/2022 08:34

slashlover · 13/09/2022 04:28

I saw plenty of men out and about in the hot weather shirtless and wearing only a smallish pair of shorts and flip flops.

That is a very very different situation.

Iliveonahill · 13/09/2022 08:32

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 08:20

I travel to Amsterdam regularly for business, this is precisely what the girls in the windows wear, how on earth is it sexist to acknowledge that some women sell sex and wear exactly this kind of clothes to do so? If they were stood there in their fluffy PJs I am not sure they would get the same interest! Ot it would be incredibly niche if they did.

It is kind of ridiculous to say that wearing the same dresses that strippers and sex workers use to attract custom will be somehow different on a child, that somehow it is more acceptable on a teenager. Sadly I am not sure the average man or boy is that thoughtful, they just see what they see, and make their own deductions. You can't single handedly change the though processes and biological responses that a man has! As much as you might like to.

I also fundamentally disagree that women are respected whatever they wear, I sincerely wish that was true, but it is not flissypaps there is such a thing as unconscious bias. Most people will form an opinion of another person within seconds and it is wishful thinking to imagine otherwise.
In fantasyland we can all skip around naked or with hardly anything on, and we would be perfectly safe and everyone would respect us, no, back in the real world that would either see us in a prison cell or best case scenario there would be some raised eyebrows and maybe some kindly person would put a cardigan over our shoulders.

I strongly suspect you are defending this dress because you allow your own young teenagers to go out in stuff like this. It is up to you (and them) I have teens too, and I am very relaxed about what they wear to a point but honestly I will not paying for or encouraging them to go out semi naked. I want them to be equal to the fully clothed boys that they meet, not already massively disadvantaged by being half dressed from the get go. I want the people around them to listen to what they are saying, they are intelligent, articulate girls that don't need to reduce themselves to teetering around half naked. I think it is a crying bloody shame that women and girls are still thinking this is any way cool or aspirational to be honest.

This. Agree.

ShandaLear · 13/09/2022 08:23

It’s tacky as hell and looks like it cost £3.50 from a market stall, but if that’s what she wants to wear let her get on with it.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 08:20

FlissyPaps · 12/09/2022 19:28

@Kissingfrogs25 There is no reason why she would miss the party

She can't change if op drops her off at the party

Don’t be naive. Of course she can change if she gets dropped off at the party. She could take it hidden in a bag, arrange for a friend to bring one for her. Wear in underneath clothes she’s already got on. Teens aren’t daft.

Calling the dress a “stripper dress” is vile. It really shows your internalised misogyny.

Women can still be assertive, strong and respected whilst wearing whatever clothes they want to.

Do whatever you want with your teens. But don’t judge other parents who do different to you.

I travel to Amsterdam regularly for business, this is precisely what the girls in the windows wear, how on earth is it sexist to acknowledge that some women sell sex and wear exactly this kind of clothes to do so? If they were stood there in their fluffy PJs I am not sure they would get the same interest! Ot it would be incredibly niche if they did.

It is kind of ridiculous to say that wearing the same dresses that strippers and sex workers use to attract custom will be somehow different on a child, that somehow it is more acceptable on a teenager. Sadly I am not sure the average man or boy is that thoughtful, they just see what they see, and make their own deductions. You can't single handedly change the though processes and biological responses that a man has! As much as you might like to.

I also fundamentally disagree that women are respected whatever they wear, I sincerely wish that was true, but it is not flissypaps there is such a thing as unconscious bias. Most people will form an opinion of another person within seconds and it is wishful thinking to imagine otherwise.
In fantasyland we can all skip around naked or with hardly anything on, and we would be perfectly safe and everyone would respect us, no, back in the real world that would either see us in a prison cell or best case scenario there would be some raised eyebrows and maybe some kindly person would put a cardigan over our shoulders.

I strongly suspect you are defending this dress because you allow your own young teenagers to go out in stuff like this. It is up to you (and them) I have teens too, and I am very relaxed about what they wear to a point but honestly I will not paying for or encouraging them to go out semi naked. I want them to be equal to the fully clothed boys that they meet, not already massively disadvantaged by being half dressed from the get go. I want the people around them to listen to what they are saying, they are intelligent, articulate girls that don't need to reduce themselves to teetering around half naked. I think it is a crying bloody shame that women and girls are still thinking this is any way cool or aspirational to be honest.

Lalliella · 13/09/2022 08:17

You can’t police what she wears at 16! Her body, her choice. My DD is 16 and I’d never dream of telling her what to wear. She wears dresses like that and looks amazing, and I tell her so.

KimberleyClark · 13/09/2022 08:16

slashlover · 13/09/2022 04:28

I saw plenty of men out and about in the hot weather shirtless and wearing only a smallish pair of shorts and flip flops.

Yes but generally speaking they don’t go to parties dressed like that.

Stompythedinosaur · 13/09/2022 08:13

The dress is hideous, but I wouldn't be getting into a fight about it. Her body so her choice.

Martinisarebetterdirty · 13/09/2022 07:44

Yes it is the man, but I know if I were to go out in that dress I’d get a lot more comments and looks than if I were in something less revealing. It’s draining to have to deal with it and I would want my 16 year old to understand that. These comments and looks are not invited, it’s just how some men are. We spend our lives up against the patriarchy, sometimes you just want to shelter your 16 year old child from that.

BlueSkeleton · 13/09/2022 04:58

TRIGGER WARNING VERY UPSETTING CONTENT

For anyone who thinks the dress will attract unwanted attention/make her look like she can ‘handle herself’/will invited sexual assault, you should read this article. It’s not the clothes, it’s the man. www.boredpanda.com/what-were-you-wearing-sexual-assault-art-exhibition/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=organic

Swipe left for the next trending thread