Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my teenager wear this?

240 replies

imnotquitesure · 12/09/2022 16:31

My 16 year old DD is going to a party and I have bought her this dress. I at first said it was inappropriate but I caved and bought it anyway. I said if it is not appropriate when it arrives I will send it back. She thinks this unfair and I shouldn't control what she wears at 16 because all her friends wear the same. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 11:31

Kellie45 - dictating to teens never ends well, just because you think they conform doesn't mean they do. You may be lucky, many others wouldn't be and that is not because you are a better parent than them. I just don't understand your attitude though re paying the bills, so if your DCs are 22 and living at home still would you dictate what they wore out because you were still putting a roof over their heads?

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 11:26

@Kissingfrogs25 in that case we have said the same thing, I don't understand your comments towards me TBH as we have basically said the same thing but you commented that what about educating them as that isn't controlling. What if you try to educate them but they still disagree and wish to wear such a dress? What happens then?

There are many posters on here that have said there is no way they would allow it at all, a ban on skimpy clothes is not any solution. As I said, my friend just snuck clothes out and wore them anyway.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 11:12

I love my teen girls! They are great fun and lovely, and they never wear this crap so there is arguments either!

caringcarer · 13/09/2022 11:11

So thankful I have boys. 😁

Stravaig · 13/09/2022 10:56

TheMoonisaBalloon · 13/09/2022 08:45

@Kissingfrogs25
I also fundamentally disagree that women are respected whatever they wear, I sincerely wish that was true, but it is not flissypaps there is such a thing as unconscious bias. Most people will form an opinion of another person within seconds and it is wishful thinking to imagine otherwise.

This ^

I want the people around them to listen to what they are saying, they are intelligent, articulate girls that don't need to reduce themselves to teetering around half naked.

This ^ x 1000.

Women have campaigned through the ages (and some have died ) to be taken seriously by men in industry, politics, commerce, science and education.
To me this minimalistic sort of attire undermines and devalues the efforts our forbearers have made, by portraying women as no more than a collection of body parts for men's amusement.

Well said @Kissingfrogs25 and @TheMoonisaBalloon !

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 10:51

My son has a beautiful body he isn't pressured to show off his abs and wear a mankini to highlight himself, he feels no need at all, so why should my dd? Both are intelligent, articulate and interesting people.

Kellie45 · 13/09/2022 10:46

It is of course difficult with teenage girls but the main thing is that we set out the rules that things they wear are not overly provocative. Of course they want to wear short skirts but something like has been described which shows acres of boob is provocative and makes them look cheap. As the parents we have a right to dictate to a certain limit what they wear. My mother did with me and I do. We are paying the bills so we have the right. When they pay the bills they can wear what they like

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 10:29

Anyone that actually has a teenage girl would know how far a blanket ban would get you? 😂
Far better to sit down and have a conversation about stereotypes and let them have an opinion and view and agree to compromise. I would absolutely be asking them WHY they felt the need to wear it? Where is it coming from? I don't do 'blanket bans' with teen dc from doing anything, it is pointless - there is discussion in our house and conversation.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 10:24

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:34

Kissingfrogs25 you've clearly not read all of what I've written though, of course we should be educating but educating is not the same as controlling. I have many discussions with my boys about stuff I don't think they should do that perhaps I may have done but we have mature discussions about it rather than a blanket ban, I hope they make sensible decisions but I am not going to control their every move. They will try stupid things and they will make mistakes, me trying to enforce everything on them still won't stop that, they'll just do things behind my back. My friend wasn't even allowed to wear heels so she hid clothes at my house and just got changed.

And yes Roolz, I was assuming college age as opposed to 16 and at school. I do think it's very different as they are now learning to be adults with the independence of 6th form etc.

Who said anything about a 'blanket ban'? What a strange comment

Pinkpeony2 · 13/09/2022 10:08

Redbone · 12/09/2022 19:08

If she were my 16 daughter she definitely would not be wearing that! Fortunately I have only boys.

omg. Love all these responses.
‘I would never let my daughter out like that but I have all boys’ classic. How on Earth do you know how you would be ffs 🤣
As a parent of a younger teenage girl I also hate it. But I have to say this is what many girls are wearing at the moment.
Back in the 60’s it was the mini skirt parents went nuts about. My 13 year old wants to wear very tight very short dresses. We have already had arguments. However, seeing them in photos all go to a friends for a party or out to a resturant / bowling, yes, they are literally all in pretty much the same dress. Some have even bought the exact same ones from the same shop. They strive to fit in. To have a friendship group who accepts them. It’s literally what most teenage girls think about all the time. It’s everything to them. Heck, it’s what many adults strive for as well!
I think you have to take each occasion and weight it up. So going to a friends house for a party is totally different to going out to a club or pub in that dress. I would try to talk her into a similar dress without the cut out or the deep cleavage but if she was absolutely dead set on this one then I would let it go and let her wear it.
I am more bothered personally about safety when out and about. Not being alone at night, never leaving anyone else in your group alone, using instincts when taking to strangers, never going off alone with anyone and not drinking so much that you lose those instincts. Feeling very comfortable ringing home if they are in a difficult or uncomfortable situation and not being afraid to tell me anything they are worried about or a mistake they have made. Those sorts of things are the hills I die on, clothes come somewhere behind.

IhMrsPr · 13/09/2022 09:38

@Kissingfrogs25 I agree with you 100%

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:34

Kissingfrogs25 you've clearly not read all of what I've written though, of course we should be educating but educating is not the same as controlling. I have many discussions with my boys about stuff I don't think they should do that perhaps I may have done but we have mature discussions about it rather than a blanket ban, I hope they make sensible decisions but I am not going to control their every move. They will try stupid things and they will make mistakes, me trying to enforce everything on them still won't stop that, they'll just do things behind my back. My friend wasn't even allowed to wear heels so she hid clothes at my house and just got changed.

And yes Roolz, I was assuming college age as opposed to 16 and at school. I do think it's very different as they are now learning to be adults with the independence of 6th form etc.

ShaneTwane · 13/09/2022 09:34

This thread is actually sad.

A few posters mention self esteem and confidence in wearing that. Why should we teach girls that their body confidence comes from getting their clothes off and wearing as little as possible? We dont teach boys that and they overall have lower levels of body issues. I would be mortified if my childs self esteem came from being scantily clad.

Also at 16 its called parenting. You absolutely can say yes or no to certain clothes unless they earn their own money and live alone they arent adults for another two years. Its mad how mn see 16 year olds as children in some situations and adults in others depending on the mood of the thread.

Also sexual assault and rape are never the fault of the victim or what they are wearing. However you are naive if you think this dress isnt designed for people to look at the wearers body and that often comes with unwanted attention which is abd enough as an adult let alone a 16 year old without the maturity to deal with that.

Goingforarun · 13/09/2022 09:25

fashion Is a form of free speech. But what is she saying?

BarrelOfOtters · 13/09/2022 09:22

movingincircles · 12/09/2022 16:38

Let her wear it while she has the body and confidence to, your a long time too old to wear it.

This. And also the comment about how to handle unwanted attention....it's all about confidence really!

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 09:20

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:15

Roolz - yes you can police it but I personally dont necessarily think you should, I would make suggestions and give guidance of course, in the same way as I would for other things. I don't believe in controlling 16/17 yos like you would a 12/13 yo as for me them learning to make their own decisions and become independent adults is the role I believe I have. On MN this seems less common than in real life though.

Obviously I wouldn't want to see my (hypothetical) daughter wearing this and I know my dad hated it but it's part of grow8ng up IMO.

So you don't see any need for evolution whatsoever? You did it, therefore you expect every generation to do the same.

It is not about controlling anyone, it is about educating. We share the knowledge we have gained, we talk about equality, symbolism, the power base, the ability to shine as they are and not as a plaything, to have confidence and good self esteem. They need to be aware that they are role models for the younger girls following them and what they do/wear/say matters, it counts.

roolz · 13/09/2022 09:20

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:15

Roolz - yes you can police it but I personally dont necessarily think you should, I would make suggestions and give guidance of course, in the same way as I would for other things. I don't believe in controlling 16/17 yos like you would a 12/13 yo as for me them learning to make their own decisions and become independent adults is the role I believe I have. On MN this seems less common than in real life though.

Obviously I wouldn't want to see my (hypothetical) daughter wearing this and I know my dad hated it but it's part of grow8ng up IMO.

I agree here too. I'd only police it because 16 could still be in secondary school. In sixth form/college you have to loosen your grip. Once they're 18 you have zero say.

aokii · 13/09/2022 09:19

Kissingfrogs25 - totally agree with all your posts. I despair at the "let them wear what they want" brigade on here sometimes.

roolz · 13/09/2022 09:19

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 09:15

No, I am not getting confused maybe you are? You are saying as long as she doesn't go out, she will be fine in the dress. I am saying how come? Assuming she is going to a party with other people, it is not likely to be any 'safer'

'Looking good' does not equate to showing as much flesh as humanly possible, and why does she have to look good? Is she not good enough exactly as she is?

No, I agree with you for the most part.

Except that you have to be articulate and intelligent at a party.

I don't think as much flesh as possible is a good idea, hence why I'd say 'no' to this dress and suggest an equally fashionable but less exposed outfit.

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:15

Roolz - yes you can police it but I personally dont necessarily think you should, I would make suggestions and give guidance of course, in the same way as I would for other things. I don't believe in controlling 16/17 yos like you would a 12/13 yo as for me them learning to make their own decisions and become independent adults is the role I believe I have. On MN this seems less common than in real life though.

Obviously I wouldn't want to see my (hypothetical) daughter wearing this and I know my dad hated it but it's part of grow8ng up IMO.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 09:15

No, I am not getting confused maybe you are? You are saying as long as she doesn't go out, she will be fine in the dress. I am saying how come? Assuming she is going to a party with other people, it is not likely to be any 'safer'

'Looking good' does not equate to showing as much flesh as humanly possible, and why does she have to look good? Is she not good enough exactly as she is?

roolz · 13/09/2022 09:12

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 09:10

Rape and sexual assaults happen at parties as well roolz
They are not 'safer' because it is a party.

I think we're all getting a bit confused here. Sure, but you're not going to convince your dd to go in a maxi dress and cardi regardless. It's ok to want to look good and keep up with fashion, this particular dress is just too far.

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 09:11

Aretheyhavingalaugh - I can imagine the reaction of a 16 yo if you showed them that dress. I mean there's a happy medium between the dress in the OP and that one.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 09:10

Rape and sexual assaults happen at parties as well roolz
They are not 'safer' because it is a party.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 09:10

Rape and sexual assaults happen at parties as well roolz
They are not 'safer' because it is a party.