Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my teenager wear this?

240 replies

imnotquitesure · 12/09/2022 16:31

My 16 year old DD is going to a party and I have bought her this dress. I at first said it was inappropriate but I caved and bought it anyway. I said if it is not appropriate when it arrives I will send it back. She thinks this unfair and I shouldn't control what she wears at 16 because all her friends wear the same. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
CakeMonster1 · 14/09/2022 19:22

The biggest mistake you made was saying no to her then ordering it. It should've been a categoric no from the start.

No way in god's earth would I allow a 16 year old daughter to wear that.

That's just my opinion though...

samyeagar · 14/09/2022 16:15

Kissingfrogs25 · 14/09/2022 15:54

This seems to me like a very lax naive view, without the benefit of considering the sheer impact on the girls wearing stuff like this - by being judged, assessed, groped and disrespected by men. I would be far more concerned about what this is going to do to their feelings of safety, self worth and potentially not all comments will be complimentary, and some might be extremely offensive. The girl is inevitably wearing to be noticed, because she thinks her body is the only currency to offer that. It is tragic.

And short sighted that so many parents can't see it.

Raise the bar lua! Show your girls how to dress powerfully, with confidence, with artistic flair - with creativity - but not to effectively sell her body at the tender age of 16.

Not sure that she or anyone else wearing something like this would think it is their ONLY currency, more that it is the easiest, lowest effort, with most immediate return.

Kissingfrogs25 · 14/09/2022 15:54

LuaDipa · 13/09/2022 12:12

I agree with this.

The current styles isn’t my cup of tea but I’d deal with it rather than getting into a debate and potentially body shaming with a 16 year old. They all dress like this now and tbh this dress is pretty covered up compared to some of the very cropped top and transparent lace flared trousers with thong combos that I’ve seen recently when picking ds up. The boys their age barely notice and they are a lot more respectful towards the girls than I remember young men being when I was that age.

Pushing the dress code is part of being a teenager. I often tell my dc the story of my own dm dropping my friends and I off for nights out wearing similar, midriff displaying clothing and calling ‘You’ve forgotten your kidney warmers, girls’ after us, usually in front of some ‘fit’ boys for maximum embarrassment. It was said in jest as my dm was very supportive and not at all stuffy. The kids think it’s hilarious and ds now apparently often says the same thing to his female friends.

Clothes are just clothes, they say nothing about the person in them. It’s not a 16 year old girl’s responsibility to worry about what anyone else thinks. They just want to
dress up and have fun as we did at their age. I would let them experiment and find their own style.

This seems to me like a very lax naive view, without the benefit of considering the sheer impact on the girls wearing stuff like this - by being judged, assessed, groped and disrespected by men. I would be far more concerned about what this is going to do to their feelings of safety, self worth and potentially not all comments will be complimentary, and some might be extremely offensive. The girl is inevitably wearing to be noticed, because she thinks her body is the only currency to offer that. It is tragic.

And short sighted that so many parents can't see it.

Raise the bar lua! Show your girls how to dress powerfully, with confidence, with artistic flair - with creativity - but not to effectively sell her body at the tender age of 16.

Butterfly44 · 13/09/2022 14:39

I think it looks nice and quiet typical of what a 16yo might wear to a party. All the party wear atm seem to have cut outs - it's the thing for clothing atm!

escapingthecity · 13/09/2022 14:31

I wouldn't buy a dress like that for my daughter, no. If she wanted to buy clothes like that she'd need to get a Saturday job or save up Christmas/birthday money.

No idea where to look for something nicer though!

Stravaig · 13/09/2022 14:16

ZealAndArdour Or maybe I'm just a farmer and grower of things, who thinks in organic, earthy metaphors.

ZealAndArdour · 13/09/2022 13:42

Stravaig · 13/09/2022 12:42

Kissingfrogs25 Off to University! In Scotland, so a 4-year undergraduate degree, and fine to go after Highers. Decades ago, so in the days of full grants during term; but still, I worked vacations to support myself, and never returned home.

Those were the days, where to rebel / flee you could grab a Uni place in Clearing, drop out of 6th year, pack a rucsac for Fresher's week! (Looking back, only just 17 was very young, but it was absolutely the right thing for me to do.)

So perhaps understandable that I expect kids to actually leave home after school, and 18 already feels well-ripened :)

My natural inclination is to multi-generational extended families living together, but that is not at all the model in the UK, and I think it can be hard to transition to mutually respectful adults sharing a home, in a society where we fetishise the nuclear family. So out the door it is!

“18 already feels well-ripened” is a rather disgusting turn of phrase considering the content of the thread.

Stravaig · 13/09/2022 12:42

Kissingfrogs25 Off to University! In Scotland, so a 4-year undergraduate degree, and fine to go after Highers. Decades ago, so in the days of full grants during term; but still, I worked vacations to support myself, and never returned home.

Those were the days, where to rebel / flee you could grab a Uni place in Clearing, drop out of 6th year, pack a rucsac for Fresher's week! (Looking back, only just 17 was very young, but it was absolutely the right thing for me to do.)

So perhaps understandable that I expect kids to actually leave home after school, and 18 already feels well-ripened :)

My natural inclination is to multi-generational extended families living together, but that is not at all the model in the UK, and I think it can be hard to transition to mutually respectful adults sharing a home, in a society where we fetishise the nuclear family. So out the door it is!

ihatespeed · 13/09/2022 12:37

This is difficult to answer because there are so many variables.
As parents we do our best to guide our daughters to be ready for the real world that we live in, but also a world that we aspire to, one that isn't here yet but that we hope will be one day. We try to be realistic but also inspire them to create a different path.
What a different family would do or have done in the same situation is only helpful up to a point because all teens are different, there's no point comparing a child who doesn't tend to rock the boat or is very easy going, to one who makes every issue, however small, an occasion to assert their independence.
If your daughter wants to wear this dress it's because she thinks that it is nice. There isn't much point in suggesting alternatives, unless you have a specific problem with the cut out or neck line etc, because what she likes will tend to be similar to what she has chosen because it's either her style or the style of her friendship group .

5128gap · 13/09/2022 12:31

I think the problem with defending a very young woman's right to 'her own style' to 'dress as she pleases' ignores the elephant in the room, that a dress like that is not HER style or what pleases HER.
It is a dress designed ( though not necessarily worn) with the express purpose of showing off her body to men.
Young women gravitate to these styles as they are promoted to them. They believe they are 'choosing for themselves' and fail to note the huge coincidence in that what they 'choose' is also what men would choose to leer at them in.
The decision by an adult woman who knows this, has thought it through, and is happy to wear it anyway, is entirely different from that of a young woman barely out of childhood, being manipulated by the fashion industry into showing off her body for men's pleasure.

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 12:19

Thanks @Stravaig I just hope I can be as level-headed when required

Stravaig · 13/09/2022 12:13

@PugInTheHouse Your folks sound like lovely grounded people.

LuaDipa · 13/09/2022 12:12

mommatoone · 12/09/2022 18:02

Im trying to raise my daughter to be confident in her mind and body and i wouldn't have a problem in her wearing this. Why shouldn't our girls wear what they like for fear of men leaching over them!
Lets teach our boys boundaries, and what is appropriate instead of laying the responsibility at the door of these young girls.
Lets face it , its a difficult world to grow up in these days.
Lets give our kids confidence to be themselves!!

I agree with this.

The current styles isn’t my cup of tea but I’d deal with it rather than getting into a debate and potentially body shaming with a 16 year old. They all dress like this now and tbh this dress is pretty covered up compared to some of the very cropped top and transparent lace flared trousers with thong combos that I’ve seen recently when picking ds up. The boys their age barely notice and they are a lot more respectful towards the girls than I remember young men being when I was that age.

Pushing the dress code is part of being a teenager. I often tell my dc the story of my own dm dropping my friends and I off for nights out wearing similar, midriff displaying clothing and calling ‘You’ve forgotten your kidney warmers, girls’ after us, usually in front of some ‘fit’ boys for maximum embarrassment. It was said in jest as my dm was very supportive and not at all stuffy. The kids think it’s hilarious and ds now apparently often says the same thing to his female friends.

Clothes are just clothes, they say nothing about the person in them. It’s not a 16 year old girl’s responsibility to worry about what anyone else thinks. They just want to
dress up and have fun as we did at their age. I would let them experiment and find their own style.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 12:12

why did you leave home at 17 strav you were not even an adult at that point?

My dc are very welcome to stay as long as they wish, and the good news is they can wear anything they like and I won't throw them out 😄Even those hideous oodies!

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 12:07

@Stravaig if my DCs were lovely people but had questionable dress sense I wouldn't be asking them to leave my house though, as you say they may have little choice but to stay but I would just hope I have raised them well enough to make reasonable decisions, and who is to say just because I disagree with them that I am right.

I left home at about 18, I had a good full time job and could afford to rent. I went back for a bit when I was about 21 to save for a house deposit then bought the following year. I wore ridiculous clothes out but was a good person who actually made sensible decisions overall. Just dressed how most other teens dressed (it was a lot of hot pants and crop tops at that point). My parents expressed their feelings but were happy to live with me still 😊

Stravaig · 13/09/2022 12:01

@PugInTheHouse Ah okay!

I think with under 18's parents have to parent, not indulge or appease or coddle. Once adults, then it becomes a question of who you choose to share your home with. For me, it's unlikely to be young women who place their value on their looks and their ability to draw sexual attention, and who support cheap throwaway fashion made of plastic in sweatshops abroad.

(Young adults still at home due to additional support needs is different, and a trickier balance to find.)

I'm being a little unfair, in that the housing situation today means some kids do linger in the family home. I left home just after my 17th birthday, so it's outwith my experience.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 12:00

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 11:55

Kissingfrogs - 100%. There are too many posters on here who don't get that though.

My parents compromise of not wanting me to stay out late between 16 & 18 when we went to clubs was that I left half hour early and they would collect me, they did not want me hanging around at a taxi rank. I thought I was getting a good deal and thought I was getting what I wanted (no hassle about going out, free lift home), obviously now I know they were ensuring my safety by me not being put in dangerous situations after clubs kick out or spending all my money and walking home instead of getting a cab. Again, my friends who weren't allowed either snuck out or said they were sleeping over at a mates house.

Your parents sound really smart Pug It is not about stopping/forcing but compromising so that your kid has a safe and good experience of life as far as possible. I definitely don't have all of the answers and I am blindsided by other things, but we can only do our best.

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 11:55

Kissingfrogs - 100%. There are too many posters on here who don't get that though.

My parents compromise of not wanting me to stay out late between 16 & 18 when we went to clubs was that I left half hour early and they would collect me, they did not want me hanging around at a taxi rank. I thought I was getting a good deal and thought I was getting what I wanted (no hassle about going out, free lift home), obviously now I know they were ensuring my safety by me not being put in dangerous situations after clubs kick out or spending all my money and walking home instead of getting a cab. Again, my friends who weren't allowed either snuck out or said they were sleeping over at a mates house.

MissingNashville · 13/09/2022 11:55

At 16, I don’t think you should stop her. She’ll be fine, a lot of girls go through the stage of wearing the least they can before finally realising they look better in something that shows less skin.

It’s a horrible dress that looks cheaply made though and Im glad my daughter wouldn’t wear it at the moment 😬....there’s still time for her to change though.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 11:51

zingally · 13/09/2022 11:47

To be honest, pick your battles. There's a small window of time for most women in having the body to get away with a dress like this. She's old enough to decide for herself whether she's comfortable or not when she puts it on.

For what it's worth, I had some similar questionable fashion choices at that age. I had a black top with white handprints over the boobs, another t-shirt that said "Manteaser" across the front, and many VERY low cute tops! My parents, to their eternal credit I think, never said a word. I'd grown out of the phase by the time I was done with sixth form.

And there it is.
It is very dispiriting to read this post.

"There is a small window of time for most women in having the body to get away with a dress like this"

Where do we even start with that....😱
No wonder women are so screwed - we can't even get past this kind of thinking.

Yes you better flaunt/sell yourself now whilst you still can hun, given its the only thing you have got going for you as a young woman! God help us 😩

Please tell me you don't have daughters? Or sons? I am not sure which one is worse.

zingally · 13/09/2022 11:47

To be honest, pick your battles. There's a small window of time for most women in having the body to get away with a dress like this. She's old enough to decide for herself whether she's comfortable or not when she puts it on.

For what it's worth, I had some similar questionable fashion choices at that age. I had a black top with white handprints over the boobs, another t-shirt that said "Manteaser" across the front, and many VERY low cute tops! My parents, to their eternal credit I think, never said a word. I'd grown out of the phase by the time I was done with sixth form.

Kissingfrogs25 · 13/09/2022 11:44

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 11:26

@Kissingfrogs25 in that case we have said the same thing, I don't understand your comments towards me TBH as we have basically said the same thing but you commented that what about educating them as that isn't controlling. What if you try to educate them but they still disagree and wish to wear such a dress? What happens then?

There are many posters on here that have said there is no way they would allow it at all, a ban on skimpy clothes is not any solution. As I said, my friend just snuck clothes out and wore them anyway.

If we had discussed the dress at length etc - usually my teens and I agree with a compromise. We respect their views, they respect ours, so that is how we are most of the time.
If dd was for some reason dead set on the dress and could not and would not compromise (rare) then of course she would wear it! I am not going to pay for it though. Nor am I am going to be encouraging her to wear it in any shape or form.
I would help her tighten the straps to ensure full coverage of her breasts. I would probably encourage to size up so it is not plastered onto her body. I would warn her it will not look anything like the photo!

I would definitely be questioning her lack of self esteem and/or friendship circles if she is being pressured to wear it.

We look at photos of Amal Clooney when she goes out versus Little Mix for example and we talk about messaging and self respect and that happened long ago, before the age of sixteen.

PugInTheHouse · 13/09/2022 11:39

@Stravaig I don't have 22 year olds, I was commenting to someone else who apparently dictates what their DCs wear because they pay the bills. I would hope by 22 that they are mature enough to realise that dress looks shit however if they didn't then each to their own by that age regardless of whether they were living in my house. 16 yos girls often have awful dress sense (those see through leggings and crop tops look as bad maybe even worse than that dress TBH).

Stravaig · 13/09/2022 11:36

PugInTheHouse Your 22nd year olds should be able to afford their own place if they're going out dressed like that!

thegreylady · 13/09/2022 11:36

I am 78 my granddaughters would wear this for parties. I like it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread