Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for not getting rid of dogs when niece is allergic?

643 replies

dogsdander · 12/09/2022 15:20

My husband and I don't have to work that many hours and when we do they're from home so it puts us in a good position to help our siblings and watch their kids. My husband has 1 sister with 2 children. I have a brother, with 2 children. A sister with 3 children. I also have a younger half brother with 1 child. My husband and I also have a son. So 9 kids all together between the ages 4-12. They’re usually not here all at the same time, but they all do come over often. Sort of a mix and match depending on various schedules. They all seem to have a fun time (in their words we have the “fun house”) and our son loves to socialize with his cousins.

Almost half a year ago we got two dogs. All the kids were very excited and have enjoyed playing with them. Unfortunately we found out that my one niece (Gemma) is allergic to dogs. She’s never been around a dog much before so neither she nor her parents knew about the allergy. It is not just a mild allergy either. She doesn’t just get sniffles she actually started wheezing and had trouble breathing.

We have tried to do things to minimize allergens in our home. However it is very difficult because of our home is fully carpeted. Regular vacuuming did nothing. We got an air purifier and steam cleaned our carpets before she came over one time and kept the dogs outside for the day and it worked, but of course after a day the dog dander had gotten everywhere and we were back to square one. We decided this wasn’t a viable option to do on a regular basis because of the cost and the increased amount of wear and tear. It also leaves the majority of our house unusable while we waited for the carpet to dry.

My brother and sil (Gemma’s parents) have taken her to the doctor to try different medications to help with her allergies. The problem is Gemma already takes medication for a different medical issue and it interferes with a lot of allergy medicines. They’ve tried some other things suggested by her doctor, but nothing really helps.

My brother has asked that we get rid of our dogs because Gemma had a fit the other day. She’s upset that she hasn’t been able to come over to the “fun house” and play with her cousins all these months while they still come over all the time. My brother thinks that we are causing her to feel left out by not getting rid of the dogs.

I understand how unfair it must feel for Gemma, but neither me or my husband or son want to get rid of our dogs. They’re part of the family now. We have become very attached to them. Especially our son. He would cry his eyes out if they had to be given up.

It’s not like we can stop watching the other kids to make Gemma feel less excluded either. Our siblings don’t have it as easy as us and they need the help sometimes.

OP posts:
gatehouseoffleet · 14/09/2022 12:47

Because you would be sending a message to your DC and to Gemma and others that animals are expendable and can be thrown out when not convenient

I imagine at least some of the family eat meat or at least animal products.

Anyway, having a pet at all is exploitative.

That isn't the issue though, I am sure if the OP's own son had allergies, the dogs would have been rehomed. But this isn't her own child.

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 12:24

I hardly think the intention is to go out of their way to replicate the ‘fun house’ in a park on a regular basis. Time with family means more to kids than you realise.

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 12:21

That’s okay. In my culture, it’s normal to consider ALL children of the family.

whumpthereitis · 14/09/2022 12:20

Aesop45 · 14/09/2022 12:08

Exactly this!!

All the vegans put your hand up???

Why? Not a vegan but a vegetarian that eats eggs laid by my own chickens. However, you clearly you don’t need to be vegan in order to bond with pets, anymore than bonding with some people means you have to bond with all of them. Unless you’re being deliberately obtuse, it’s quite evident.

whumpthereitis · 14/09/2022 12:17

SleeplessInEngland · 14/09/2022 12:12

And we all bow to your infinite wisdom. Apparenly it still eludes the OP.

I would raise your standards as to what constitutes wisdom, because this really doesn’t qualify. ‘No’ to this request doesn’t require any great insight or thought, with or without ‘fuck off’ as an addendum.

CatsandFish · 14/09/2022 12:14

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 11:35

Im quite surprised too! Yes care for animals is important but to treat a child like they are not cared for? These people must really have awful relationships with their siblings if they can’t see their children as important as their own. My sister and I are two different people but I would do anything for her children.

Meeting their niece outside of the house at a park or somewhere nice is not "treating a child like they are not cared for" you are being irrational. There is never an excuse to treat an animal like disposable garbage, and if you did you wouldn't be a good role model for children anyway.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/09/2022 12:12

whumpthereitis · 14/09/2022 11:56

I doubt that anyone is pretending anything. For some of us the answer is obvious.

And we all bow to your infinite wisdom. Apparenly it still eludes the OP.

Aesop45 · 14/09/2022 12:08

SleeplessInEngland · 14/09/2022 11:38

Your brother is being really selfish and unreasonable in asking you to get rid of the dogs and I hope you never do that. Because you would be sending a message to your DC and to Gemma and others that animals are expendable and can be thrown out when not convenient

Most humans are meat eaters and effectively believe that. They just make exceptions for a few lucky animals like cats and dogs. And even then, inconvenient pets often don't last long.

Exactly this!!

All the vegans put your hand up???

TrashyPanda · 14/09/2022 12:07

many people seem to be suggesting that the Ops brother could arrange to have a similar scenario happen in other locations but that isn't the case. You can't replicate that OP has happening in her home and the nieces and nephews coming are getting something that no one including Gemma's parents can create for her

there is no reason why Gemma’s dad could not make the commitment to create this for her in her own home. It might take a financial commitment, but people have suggested it’s ok for OP to change her flooring (expensive), build a playhouse (expensive) get dogs groomed more often (expensive and it’s not good to wash dogs too often). The other siblings could also step up re hosting kids.

instead, he wants the OP, who is already incredibly generous, to change her and her family’s lives. He needs to do everything in his power for his kid, not expect his sister to rearrange her life.

whumpthereitis · 14/09/2022 11:56

SleeplessInEngland · 14/09/2022 11:40

I think people are being silly pretending this has an obvious answer. If the OP lived in a normal house and saw her niece every few months the decision would be obvious. But she's fashioned a 'fun house' (her words) where family members are over all the time and where missing out on that would be a big deal for any of them.

Going by her posts I expect she'll keep the dogs, but I don't envy her position.

I doubt that anyone is pretending anything. For some of us the answer is obvious.

aSofaNearYou · 14/09/2022 11:55

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 11:35

Im quite surprised too! Yes care for animals is important but to treat a child like they are not cared for? These people must really have awful relationships with their siblings if they can’t see their children as important as their own. My sister and I are two different people but I would do anything for her children.

This is quite extreme. I know few people who are as close to their nieces and nephews as their own children. My DP has a perfectly fine relationship with his sibling and is found of his DN's, sees them every few weeks, but it is nowhere near that deep. The idea that anything less than "as important as their own" equals an awful relationship is a bit much.

whumpthereitis · 14/09/2022 11:54

ChaosMoon · 14/09/2022 11:43

What an incredibly sad situation.

The fact is, your pets are more important to you than your niece. I'm really not judging you for it, but there's no point in pretending that isn't isn't the case, because your brother and niece will clearly see it for what it is.

Even outside of the commitment she made to the dogs, I imagine her child and husband’s feelings coming into it also, as no one wants to get rid of the dogs. It’s hardly shocking that someone would value the feelings of those that actually live in the home, over someone that visits.

whumpthereitis · 14/09/2022 11:47

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 11:35

Im quite surprised too! Yes care for animals is important but to treat a child like they are not cared for? These people must really have awful relationships with their siblings if they can’t see their children as important as their own. My sister and I are two different people but I would do anything for her children.

Yeah, so my brother would never ask me to rehome my pets. I’d consider the request itself indicative of a shitty relationship.

it’s a shame for the niece, but it’s no one fault. Her father can arrange for her to see her aunt and cousin either at his house, or somewhere else where dogs aren’t present.

ChaosMoon · 14/09/2022 11:44

And I completely agree with @Midlifemusings

ChaosMoon · 14/09/2022 11:43

What an incredibly sad situation.

The fact is, your pets are more important to you than your niece. I'm really not judging you for it, but there's no point in pretending that isn't isn't the case, because your brother and niece will clearly see it for what it is.

Midlifemusings · 14/09/2022 11:41

I think some people are missing teh fact that OP isn't arranging or planning fun dates at her house. It seems more her house has an open door policy and lots of fun things and the kids come and go as they (and their parents) wish. That is a really easy way to host and to enjoy having family around and completely different from planning events at other people's houses or at outdoor places or other activity spaces. Those things require planning, often money, and a time commitment. Having kids over to your own house who are familiar visitors means you just go about your day while the kids play and you really aren't needing to put out time, money, energy, or additional resources.

So while I am not saying the dogs should be rehomed - many people seem to be suggesting that the Ops brother could arrange to have a similar scenario happen in other locations but that isn't the case. You can't replicate that OP has happening in her home and the nieces and nephews coming are getting something that no one including Gemma's parents can create for her. Yes, that is the reality and touch shit for Gemma but just call it what it is. She is excluded due to her disability. Just like if Gemma was in a wheelchair and the house wasn't wheelchair accessible so she stayed home while all the other kids had fun. It is social exclusion due to a disability. And yes, not uncommon for people with disabilities to experience that exclusion.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/09/2022 11:40

I think people are being silly pretending this has an obvious answer. If the OP lived in a normal house and saw her niece every few months the decision would be obvious. But she's fashioned a 'fun house' (her words) where family members are over all the time and where missing out on that would be a big deal for any of them.

Going by her posts I expect she'll keep the dogs, but I don't envy her position.

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 11:40

Oh wow that’s awful. Thankfully my sisters allergies are not that bad it’s manageable with an anti histamine.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/09/2022 11:38

Your brother is being really selfish and unreasonable in asking you to get rid of the dogs and I hope you never do that. Because you would be sending a message to your DC and to Gemma and others that animals are expendable and can be thrown out when not convenient

Most humans are meat eaters and effectively believe that. They just make exceptions for a few lucky animals like cats and dogs. And even then, inconvenient pets often don't last long.

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 11:35

Im quite surprised too! Yes care for animals is important but to treat a child like they are not cared for? These people must really have awful relationships with their siblings if they can’t see their children as important as their own. My sister and I are two different people but I would do anything for her children.

KosherDill · 14/09/2022 11:35

ecosystem · 14/09/2022 08:23

YABU - humans come first

Nonsense. The niece will have many other ways to stay connected if her parents exert themselves.

OP is not obliged to cater to these entitled demands. Dog allergies are inconvenient but it's extremely rare that they are life-threatening.

Dis626 · 14/09/2022 11:34

ecosystem · 14/09/2022 08:23

YABU - humans come first

What about the humans and other children that would be devastated about getting rid of the dogs? Don't they matter?

whumpthereitis · 14/09/2022 11:34

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 11:22

Wow I can’t believe how rude some replies are 😩 I’m very close to my family too and spend a lot of time with my nieces and I see them as my own children. I could never let any of them feel left out as I know when they’re older it is something that will affect them whether you care or not that’s another issue. My sister is allergic to my cat so I comb him twice a day and he NEVER goes in two rooms of the house so my sister has a space to go. We also have wood flooring as cat hair can get everywhere especially the longer haired ones like my cat. He is part of the family but so is a niece.

I’d be polite if I was asked to make alternative arrangements, like going to their house or meeting at the park. Anyone who thinks that ‘can you rehome your pets?’ is a reasonable request to make is getting rudeness back. The fact that I’m capable of formulating a diplomatic response does not mean I would be inclined to extend one. They would indeed have to do with an Anglo Saxon shorthand.

Midlifemusings · 14/09/2022 11:33

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 11:22

Wow I can’t believe how rude some replies are 😩 I’m very close to my family too and spend a lot of time with my nieces and I see them as my own children. I could never let any of them feel left out as I know when they’re older it is something that will affect them whether you care or not that’s another issue. My sister is allergic to my cat so I comb him twice a day and he NEVER goes in two rooms of the house so my sister has a space to go. We also have wood flooring as cat hair can get everywhere especially the longer haired ones like my cat. He is part of the family but so is a niece.

Cat hair travels through the ventilation system in a house. For someone with more severe allegies / asthma, there is no such thing as safe rooms in a house just because the cat doesn't go in them. That might work for a mild allergy but unless the rooms had separate ventilation systems - they are not safe rooms. I had major reactions to a cat in a completely different apartment in my building - it was an old building and while I had checked to ensure there hadn't been animals in the apartment I was moving into. It soon became clear that the apartments had enough shared ventilation that whenever the heat came on, I would have an allergic reaction due to a cat in another apartment.

I also once moved into an apartment (after checking to be sure there wasn't shared ventilation) and they told me it hadn't had animals. Turns out it had but since there had been a tenant in between who didn't have animals and it had been 'cleaned', they thought they could say it was clean. Thankfully there was another unit that opened soon after and I was able to move into that one.

When allergies trigger severe reaction and asthma attacks, you can't trust a safe room or any other mitigating effort, they just don't work. As an adult, I can control my coming and goings now, but as a child you can't do that. Recently there was a major milestone family event being hosted at a family member's house who has a dog. I chose to medicate and attend for about ten minutes to say hello and best wishes and deal with the allergies but that was because I knew I could leave right away again and have full autonomy and control over my life. Also as an adult I know my own body and how it reacts and when I need to get out.

Agonymama · 14/09/2022 11:22

Wow I can’t believe how rude some replies are 😩 I’m very close to my family too and spend a lot of time with my nieces and I see them as my own children. I could never let any of them feel left out as I know when they’re older it is something that will affect them whether you care or not that’s another issue. My sister is allergic to my cat so I comb him twice a day and he NEVER goes in two rooms of the house so my sister has a space to go. We also have wood flooring as cat hair can get everywhere especially the longer haired ones like my cat. He is part of the family but so is a niece.