Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for not getting rid of dogs when niece is allergic?

643 replies

dogsdander · 12/09/2022 15:20

My husband and I don't have to work that many hours and when we do they're from home so it puts us in a good position to help our siblings and watch their kids. My husband has 1 sister with 2 children. I have a brother, with 2 children. A sister with 3 children. I also have a younger half brother with 1 child. My husband and I also have a son. So 9 kids all together between the ages 4-12. They’re usually not here all at the same time, but they all do come over often. Sort of a mix and match depending on various schedules. They all seem to have a fun time (in their words we have the “fun house”) and our son loves to socialize with his cousins.

Almost half a year ago we got two dogs. All the kids were very excited and have enjoyed playing with them. Unfortunately we found out that my one niece (Gemma) is allergic to dogs. She’s never been around a dog much before so neither she nor her parents knew about the allergy. It is not just a mild allergy either. She doesn’t just get sniffles she actually started wheezing and had trouble breathing.

We have tried to do things to minimize allergens in our home. However it is very difficult because of our home is fully carpeted. Regular vacuuming did nothing. We got an air purifier and steam cleaned our carpets before she came over one time and kept the dogs outside for the day and it worked, but of course after a day the dog dander had gotten everywhere and we were back to square one. We decided this wasn’t a viable option to do on a regular basis because of the cost and the increased amount of wear and tear. It also leaves the majority of our house unusable while we waited for the carpet to dry.

My brother and sil (Gemma’s parents) have taken her to the doctor to try different medications to help with her allergies. The problem is Gemma already takes medication for a different medical issue and it interferes with a lot of allergy medicines. They’ve tried some other things suggested by her doctor, but nothing really helps.

My brother has asked that we get rid of our dogs because Gemma had a fit the other day. She’s upset that she hasn’t been able to come over to the “fun house” and play with her cousins all these months while they still come over all the time. My brother thinks that we are causing her to feel left out by not getting rid of the dogs.

I understand how unfair it must feel for Gemma, but neither me or my husband or son want to get rid of our dogs. They’re part of the family now. We have become very attached to them. Especially our son. He would cry his eyes out if they had to be given up.

It’s not like we can stop watching the other kids to make Gemma feel less excluded either. Our siblings don’t have it as easy as us and they need the help sometimes.

OP posts:
ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/09/2022 18:12

Why can’t Gemma’s family do more to ensure their own child doesn’t miss out on playtime with her cousins by hosting all the children herself?

It wouldn’t be the same for Gemma as going to the ‘fun house’, but her parents could do enough that she doesn’t miss out on very much and her disappointment would be minimal. Especially compared to how heartbreaking it would be for your son to have to give up his beloved pets and the stress it would cause the dogs.

Booklover3 · 12/09/2022 18:12

I feel very sorry for Gemma… but no I wouldn’t be getting rid of my dog. It just means Gemma’s parents need to pull their finger out and host at theirs more. Surely?

MyneighbourisTotoro · 12/09/2022 18:11

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:05

Yes animals are living beings with feelings but the fact remains they would be equally happy with another family as they are with OPs family. However, the cost to Gemma’s happiness of being excluded from her family for however long these dogs are alive- the rest of the years of her childhood at least- is greater than the temporary stress to two new dogs of being rehomed. It’s not like the dogs have lived with OP for years, it’s been 6 months. They’re not that attached to OPs family at this point. Rehoming the dogs is the kindest solution to all involved.

What about the heartbreak OP and her family have to go through? Why is it OPs responsibility? Maybe her DB should step up and stop using his sister for free childcare and offer to have the cousins at his own house! Unfortunately they will have to find a way to manage Gemma’s allergy as she if she is very severe then she is going to have problems at school and any social events where people are pets owners.

Rainraindontgoaway · 12/09/2022 18:11

Hell no, they need to make other arrangements. You can’t do that to your son. Your brother is a cheeky twat for even asking, plus he is taking you for a mug for even suggesting it.

Washyourownfeet · 12/09/2022 18:10

I hope your niece doesn’t grow up as entitled as her father, I wouldn’t be getting rid of my dogs and neither would I be ripping my carpets up or changing my furniture, he needs to remember that it’s your house and maybe get someone else to provide free babysitting, he seems to think that he’s doing you a favour, is he always ridiculous?

Beautiful3 · 12/09/2022 18:09

No way would I get rid of my dog. I cannot believe he asked that of you.

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:08

scotscorner · 12/09/2022 18:05

“The dogs would be equally happy if rehomed” - I think this statement reveals you don’t know a lot about dogs but they absolutely suffer from rehoming (just as humans would suffer from being ripped away from their closest relationships). It’s about your responsibility to this animal you’ve chosen to take on, not puppy cuddles and walkies.

I have dogs. I just don’t worship them. You obviously don’t know much about dogs if you think that after 6months they’re going to be utterly devoted to you and suffer agony if they are rehomed. They’re not that complex.

And even if you think the dogs would suffer as much as Gemma would, why is the dog being prioritised over Gemma? She’s being “ripped away” from her relationships with her cousins and aunts and uncles. And unlike dogs, who can, let’s be real here, be happy with any decent family, Gemma can’t. She only has one family, and that family needs to do right by her.

BabyJellyShark · 12/09/2022 18:08

As a child with autism, dyspraxia and mental health issues, nothing would have been more detrimental to my wellbeing than to have my pets rehomed. There'd be nothing kind about it. Thankfully my family understood the value of pets.

EveningOverRooftops · 12/09/2022 18:08

NoSquirrels · 12/09/2022 18:07

In my opinion, the OP is under obligation to rehome the dogs she’s had for a mere 6 months, if she cares about family at all. There’s been a family dynamic for years of all the cousins at her home and the it’s the central family gathering place. This dynamic has been broken with the very recent introduction of two dogs. It’s no one’s fault that Gemma is severely allergic. No one chooses to have a severe allergy, it’s not like Gemma can “choose” to not be allergic. But choosing to keep the dogs and destroy that family dynamic where all the cousins were growing up and playing together would be selfish imho. Absolutely selfish.

But, Discoverreads, the OP is under absolutely no obligation at all to keep their home the ‘family gathering place’. The rest of the family have just as much obligation to keep the family dynamic of the cousins hanging out together as the OP does. They can ALL make a change if they ALL value this. It’s not the OP’s sacred duty to keep their home animal-free so that the cousins can all hang out.

Quite! If there’s a problem then Gemma’s parents need to be the hosts! They’re excluding their daughter by not stepping up to offer these play dates .

DancingBudgie · 12/09/2022 18:07

YellowTreeHouse · 12/09/2022 17:56

To be quite honest, I think it’s quite selfish of you to keep the animals and place them above your family.

They're just animals at the end of the day and they’re actively causing harm to a member of your family.

My dogs are a part of my family.
In fact, I prefer my dogs to some of my family!
Nothing and no one would make me give them up.
Anyone who doesn't like it can stay well away from my door. They're not welcome.

NoSquirrels · 12/09/2022 18:07

In my opinion, the OP is under obligation to rehome the dogs she’s had for a mere 6 months, if she cares about family at all. There’s been a family dynamic for years of all the cousins at her home and the it’s the central family gathering place. This dynamic has been broken with the very recent introduction of two dogs. It’s no one’s fault that Gemma is severely allergic. No one chooses to have a severe allergy, it’s not like Gemma can “choose” to not be allergic. But choosing to keep the dogs and destroy that family dynamic where all the cousins were growing up and playing together would be selfish imho. Absolutely selfish.

But, Discoverreads, the OP is under absolutely no obligation at all to keep their home the ‘family gathering place’. The rest of the family have just as much obligation to keep the family dynamic of the cousins hanging out together as the OP does. They can ALL make a change if they ALL value this. It’s not the OP’s sacred duty to keep their home animal-free so that the cousins can all hang out.

BabyJellyShark · 12/09/2022 18:06

They’re not that attached to OPs family at this point. Rehoming the dogs is the kindest solution to all involved.

Is it bollocks.

thesurrealist · 12/09/2022 18:06

*The message it gives is that a human family member’s health (potentially life) is more important than getting puppy cuddles and going on walkies. That sometimes we need to make sacrifices for the good of our family.

The dogs would be equally happy if rehomed with another human family- they’re not going to suffer if rehomed. So it’s not like it’s a choice between Gemma suffering or the dogs suffering.

The message you would be giving by saying fuck off, I’m keeping the dogs is that Gemma’s life and love is less important to you than puppy cuddles and walkies. That dogs are more fun to be around than her. That you don’t care about her safety or happiness at all, it’s all about you and your desires.*

And again, doesn't the feelings of the actual child who lives in the house matter? The message that he would be getting is that a cousin is more important than him.
There are ways of managing the girl's allergies and exposure to animals. That should not come at the cost of another child's happiness.
I personally do put my dog above people and I'm very open about the fact that the only people welcome in my house are those who accept that my dog is here and he is always more important.
However, in this case the OP"S own child is more important than a niece.

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:05

BabyJellyShark · 12/09/2022 17:59

The dogs would be equally happy if rehomed with another human family- they’re not going to suffer if rehomed. So it’s not like it’s a choice between Gemma suffering or the dogs suffering.

Being rehomed is stressful and harmful to animals and not something to be done lightly. Animals are living beings with feelings and not a piece of bric a brac to be offloaded at Oxfam whenever you tire of them or they become inconvenient.

Yes animals are living beings with feelings but the fact remains they would be equally happy with another family as they are with OPs family. However, the cost to Gemma’s happiness of being excluded from her family for however long these dogs are alive- the rest of the years of her childhood at least- is greater than the temporary stress to two new dogs of being rehomed. It’s not like the dogs have lived with OP for years, it’s been 6 months. They’re not that attached to OPs family at this point. Rehoming the dogs is the kindest solution to all involved.

scotscorner · 12/09/2022 18:05

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 17:53

The message it gives is that a human family member’s health (potentially life) is more important than getting puppy cuddles and going on walkies. That sometimes we need to make sacrifices for the good of our family.

The dogs would be equally happy if rehomed with another human family- they’re not going to suffer if rehomed. So it’s not like it’s a choice between Gemma suffering or the dogs suffering.

The message you would be giving by saying fuck off, I’m keeping the dogs is that Gemma’s life and love is less important to you than puppy cuddles and walkies. That dogs are more fun to be around than her. That you don’t care about her safety or happiness at all, it’s all about you and your desires.

“The dogs would be equally happy if rehomed” - I think this statement reveals you don’t know a lot about dogs but they absolutely suffer from rehoming (just as humans would suffer from being ripped away from their closest relationships). It’s about your responsibility to this animal you’ve chosen to take on, not puppy cuddles and walkies.

ScamelaAnderson · 12/09/2022 18:04

Family is everything
Live. Laugh. Love

HellinGreece · 12/09/2022 18:04

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 17:53

The message it gives is that a human family member’s health (potentially life) is more important than getting puppy cuddles and going on walkies. That sometimes we need to make sacrifices for the good of our family.

The dogs would be equally happy if rehomed with another human family- they’re not going to suffer if rehomed. So it’s not like it’s a choice between Gemma suffering or the dogs suffering.

The message you would be giving by saying fuck off, I’m keeping the dogs is that Gemma’s life and love is less important to you than puppy cuddles and walkies. That dogs are more fun to be around than her. That you don’t care about her safety or happiness at all, it’s all about you and your desires.

Wow you have a bee in your bonnet.

I have dogs. If my nephews or nieces were allergic, would I rehome them? Like hell I would. My dogs are my family and the only people I would ever consider rehoming them would be my kids ( they would have to be severely sick for me to consider that). It's not just about cuddles and walkies. You are suggesting that because they are blood relatives they trump the love one has for their pets? They should give up their pets even when their own child loves them to accommodate a cousin? You are absolutely mental to suggest that and if you were my family I would be thanking God if you chose to go NC with me.

KosherDill · 12/09/2022 18:03

Bobby80 · 12/09/2022 17:55

This seems to boil down to you having to change your lifestyle and re home a family member in order to continue supplying free childcare, which I am incredulous at!

Gemma is still going to see her cousins.
She will have to deal with her allergies at some point either that or avoid dogs forever. Either way, it’s not your problem to fix. If you rehome your dogs it’ll impact your whole family. Gemma’s allergies and childcare only affect her/her parents.

how would you feel if you rehomed the dogs then 4 months down the line circumstances change and she no longer comes to you as regularly….

Agree.

They aren't the only dogs in the world; she and her parents will have to put more effort into managing her allergies regardless of what the OP does.

Can the girl wear a mask in the OP's home? Play outdoors primarily? Or can OP provide the free childcare at her brother's house?

Hopefully the problem will resolve itself as she grows up but I would think ill of anyone who asked me to dump my pets for their convenience.

DancingBudgie · 12/09/2022 18:03

SarahSissions · 12/09/2022 17:27

I find the commodification of dogs (and animals in general) and the lack of responsibility that some posters have towards dogs and other pets really sad. So often on these boards I see comments of I got a pet and now so and so is allergic, or it’s hard work or mouthing and dozens of people pile on saying “rehome it”.
i find the use of the word “it” particularly distasteful. But it’s the way this is seen as an easy and acceptable solution. Rescue centres are overwhelmed at the moment, and there is never any suggestion of find a rehoming centre and pay for their upkeep until a new home can be found.

When you take on a defensless animal with no agency or control in our world you take on responsibility for it for its lifetime. It is shit to hand it over because someone (in this case an adult sibling) no longer finds it convenient.

there’s plenty the OP can do with her niece still, it appears that the problem is free after school childcare.

let’s be honest rescues at the moment are full to bursting, realistically you aren’t “rehoming” you are putting the dog into kennels for an undetermined period unless it strikes it lucky and is picked by another family. I notice none of those saying give the dog up are saying stick it is a shelter to wonder when it’s loved family are coming back- “rehoming” what a fucking euphemism

I couldn't agree more.

TiddleyWink · 12/09/2022 18:03

10HailMarys · 12/09/2022 17:26

I loathe dogs and find it really sad when real human people miss out on family stuff because they either can’t or don’t want to be around dogs.

The OP didn't know her niece would be allergic to dogs. Just like your kids' uncle didn't know your kids would be too scared of his dog to visit his home. It's sad that you feel you can't visit there any more, but it's also very much your problem and not his.

Actually they knew full well that our kids were afraid of dogs so it would create a massive barrier to spending time with them (due to distance visits have to be overnight), and they didn’t care which of course is their prerogative but it sends a very clear message to close family when you make that choice. Choices have consequences and now when they complain that we don’t rush to visit them, or invite them to us, that’s the consequence occurring. It’s not rocket science.

Saying it’s ‘our problem’ sounds like very typical dog owner arrogance. It’s not actually a problem for us, I just find it a shame that our kids now barely know one set of cousins but are very close with the other set. Of course anyone can choose to get a dog but they run the risk of creating barriers with the humans in their lives. I know which I value more! And I don’t really care about no longer having people in our lives who prefer dogs to us, that’s no loss to us!

EveningOverRooftops · 12/09/2022 18:02

Do not get rid of the dogs.

if you do what does this teach Gemma? That if she had any reaction to anything then everyone must stop using/keeping whatever they’re allergic to? That’s just going to raise an entitled child.

I have allergies, pets, pollen, latex, mould and aerosols in particular are a bastard. I can’t demand everyone stop using them in their homes. though environmentally it would be a good idea to use solid deodorants and natural oils etc for fragrancing homes.

I just have to tough it out and avoid the worst homes. One was a friend with cats dogs and horses, could never go in her house but I’d visit and we’d drink tea outside on any dry day.

I second what other posters have said.

that your family is taking the piss a bit and they should be offering up some ‘kid fun days’ at their houses so everyone can join in the responsibility of raising all the kids and the fund stuff too

NoSquirrels · 12/09/2022 18:02

You need to talk with the other adults in the family about how to make Gemma feel less isolated, and to keep having time with all the cousins, whilst being clear that getting rid of the dogs is not an option.

As you are choosing to keep the dogs, and you have tried all you can to make the house less triggering to her allergy short of rehoming the dogs, Gemma now cannot come to your house, so your part of the compromise is to do things a bit differently and offer to mind Gemma at her house or at her other cousins house.

Your siblings part in this is to facilitate that being the case.

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:01

Cannotmakeadecison · 12/09/2022 17:51

Christ, talk about the biggest overreaction ever. It’s very likely my children will have asthma and animal allergies as my husband does. Every single member of my family has a dog. I would never imagine asking them to get rid of their beloved pet for my child. When we visit, we will stay in an Airbnb or similar nearby and arrange activities outside their house to limit their exposure.

This child’s parents need to be handling this and looking at ways Gemma can manage her symptoms as she will encounter this all through her life. She’ll go to school friends houses that will have dogs and probably cats (which are even worse for allergy sufferers) and meet people with dogs, go to pubs/restaurants where dogs are allowed. If the OP can do some things in the house to help manage Gemma’s symptoms that would be kind but she’s under no obligation to rehome her pets.

Your DH has a mild dog allergy if all he needs is Benadryl and an inhaler. That’s not the same as the severe reaction the OP is describing for Gemma, or the fact the OP has said Gemma’s parents have sought medical advice and there are no medications to help.

In my opinion, the OP is under obligation to rehome the dogs she’s had for a mere 6 months, if she cares about family at all. There’s been a family dynamic for years of all the cousins at her home and the it’s the central family gathering place. This dynamic has been broken with the very recent introduction of two dogs. It’s no one’s fault that Gemma is severely allergic. No one chooses to have a severe allergy, it’s not like Gemma can “choose” to not be allergic. But choosing to keep the dogs and destroy that family dynamic where all the cousins were growing up and playing together would be selfish imho. Absolutely selfish.

KosherDill · 12/09/2022 18:01

No, you can't get rid of the dogs. What an unfair request.

Dog allergies are very seldom life-threatening.

I would suggest that your brother pay to have hard flooring installed in your house, if that and daily damp-mopping would alleviate much of the problem.

Otherwise, see your neice elsewhere. It's too bad but you can't jettison living creatures.

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 12/09/2022 18:00

It's true that Gemma may grow out of her allergy. DS used to be really allergic to cats but he isn't now - his employer has one and he's around it a lot with no problems. He also used to be allergic to feathers, so I'm wondering if you have feather cushions that might make her worse? Anyway, no, you definitely should not consider rehoming your dogs.