Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for not getting rid of dogs when niece is allergic?

643 replies

dogsdander · 12/09/2022 15:20

My husband and I don't have to work that many hours and when we do they're from home so it puts us in a good position to help our siblings and watch their kids. My husband has 1 sister with 2 children. I have a brother, with 2 children. A sister with 3 children. I also have a younger half brother with 1 child. My husband and I also have a son. So 9 kids all together between the ages 4-12. They’re usually not here all at the same time, but they all do come over often. Sort of a mix and match depending on various schedules. They all seem to have a fun time (in their words we have the “fun house”) and our son loves to socialize with his cousins.

Almost half a year ago we got two dogs. All the kids were very excited and have enjoyed playing with them. Unfortunately we found out that my one niece (Gemma) is allergic to dogs. She’s never been around a dog much before so neither she nor her parents knew about the allergy. It is not just a mild allergy either. She doesn’t just get sniffles she actually started wheezing and had trouble breathing.

We have tried to do things to minimize allergens in our home. However it is very difficult because of our home is fully carpeted. Regular vacuuming did nothing. We got an air purifier and steam cleaned our carpets before she came over one time and kept the dogs outside for the day and it worked, but of course after a day the dog dander had gotten everywhere and we were back to square one. We decided this wasn’t a viable option to do on a regular basis because of the cost and the increased amount of wear and tear. It also leaves the majority of our house unusable while we waited for the carpet to dry.

My brother and sil (Gemma’s parents) have taken her to the doctor to try different medications to help with her allergies. The problem is Gemma already takes medication for a different medical issue and it interferes with a lot of allergy medicines. They’ve tried some other things suggested by her doctor, but nothing really helps.

My brother has asked that we get rid of our dogs because Gemma had a fit the other day. She’s upset that she hasn’t been able to come over to the “fun house” and play with her cousins all these months while they still come over all the time. My brother thinks that we are causing her to feel left out by not getting rid of the dogs.

I understand how unfair it must feel for Gemma, but neither me or my husband or son want to get rid of our dogs. They’re part of the family now. We have become very attached to them. Especially our son. He would cry his eyes out if they had to be given up.

It’s not like we can stop watching the other kids to make Gemma feel less excluded either. Our siblings don’t have it as easy as us and they need the help sometimes.

OP posts:
thesurrealist · 12/09/2022 18:29

@Discovereads you really do lack compete and utter empathy for a child who has obviously grown to love his pets.
If a child living in the house had severe allergies then rehoming is understandable, but this is a child who visits and who could be seen elsewhere.
I don't actually have children, but I can understand how the OP's son would feel. Losing a leg through death can be hard enough for a child to come to terms with, but what you, and other people are suggesting is a blatant message to that child that he matters less than this other child who, whilst obviously suffering from a serious allergy, can be kept away from the dogs, visited in her own pet free home, have meet ups in parks and other family members houses.

If you do have dogs then you really don't understand that they are not disposable at the whim of someone else's demands. They are living, breathing, sentient creatures that form tight bonds with their families. And yes, after 6 months those bonds are very much there and, it would appear, reciprocated by the people who these dogs live with.

I don't think anything anyone will say to you will change your mind and frankly, I don't care to do so. I have my own very low opinion of you, and people like you, who view animals as commodities and I am very glad our paths will never cross.

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:28

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/09/2022 18:25

The feelings of the child, the OPs son, in the joy of having a pet dog do matter. They just don’t matter as much as the health and safety of his cousin Gemma.

Bit Gemma can be kept perfectly safe and healthy in her own home. There’s no need for her to go to her Aunts house except that she wants to, but we can’t always have what we want and she’s old enough to understand why.

pffft a child can get over not having a pet dog alot easier than a child with a dog induced asthma attack being blue lighted to hospital can breathe. Children can be perfectly happy in a pet free home.

Then why can’t Gemma be perfectly happy in her own pet free home? Can’t you see the massive contradiction you’ve made there? And again, there’s no need for any child to be put in the position of having a dog induced asthma attack and being blue lighted to hospital because OP isn’t going round to her nieces home and forcing her dogs on them.

Yes Gemma can be excluded like a fucking leper and kept away from her cousins. They can all continue to have fun and grow up together while she is conveniently excluded in favour of a couple of dogs. That’s going to do wonders for her self esteem and mental health to know that the company of two dogs is soooo much better than having her around to her family. She will understand perfectly why she is home alone.

bellac11 · 12/09/2022 18:27

There are some utter piss takers on this thread!!

Terfydactyl · 12/09/2022 18:27

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 17:18

The girl used to come over frequently. It’s not a “handful of times a year”
Theyve only had the dogs for 6months, the dogs will not be that attached and can easily find a better forever home.

I love dogs. I just happen to love my human family members more than I love dogs. It’s not ethically right imho to put the pleasure of owning a dog over the safety and relationship with a human family member. Having a severe dog allergy is a medical condition, a disability. It’s cruel to purposely keep the dogs and exclude Gemma from family life and relationships. She only has one family. Dogs can be found another family and be equally happy.

Gemma has parents to make sure Gemma is not left out.
They have options like
Always meet outside.
Have all the nephews and nieces over to their house.
Find a drug that works on the allergy.
Pay for OP to change her entire house furnishings, that petal stuff for the dogs.

If Gemma parents wanted to they could become the fun house. There is nothing preventing them doing any or all these or something else I haven't thought of to help Gemma stay in close contact with niblings.
The very last persons problem this allergy is, is OPs.
Gemma's life will be more curtailed by this allergy anyway unless decent drugs can be found, this too is not OPs problem to solve.

HellinGreece · 12/09/2022 18:27

Wow some people are so entitled

Let's change a scenario. Gemmas dad gets a job on the other side of the country or even different country and they move. Yes it's hypothetical but it can happen. Would it be OK for Gemma to then loose contact with cousins? Would anyone even consider that or would it be irrelevant as other issues would tramp gemmas feelings?

Sounds like someone said above, they are pissed off about loosing free childcare and are demanding the OP gets rid of the dogs. Gemma can still see her cousins at her own home our other cousins homes or even outdoors.

cranberrymilkshake · 12/09/2022 18:26

Definitely don't get rid off your dogs, OP!

Do you have a garden? Can everyone spend one afternoon (you said it's a few hours) a week in the garden instead of inside the house. If you wanted to, you could get some kind of gazebo thing for when it gets wet.
Might that work?

nocoolnamesleft · 12/09/2022 18:25

You hadn't had the dogs 6 months when Gemma first had an allergic reaction, though, had you? Not if she was coming round twice a week. But you spent months faffing around with measures that were blindingly obviously very unlikely to do any good. So now you have dragged it out to 6 months you can say you can't rehome them because you've had them 6 months. Delightfully ableist to exclude a child for a potentially life threatening medical condition.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/09/2022 18:25

The feelings of the child, the OPs son, in the joy of having a pet dog do matter. They just don’t matter as much as the health and safety of his cousin Gemma.

Bit Gemma can be kept perfectly safe and healthy in her own home. There’s no need for her to go to her Aunts house except that she wants to, but we can’t always have what we want and she’s old enough to understand why.

pffft a child can get over not having a pet dog alot easier than a child with a dog induced asthma attack being blue lighted to hospital can breathe. Children can be perfectly happy in a pet free home.

Then why can’t Gemma be perfectly happy in her own pet free home? Can’t you see the massive contradiction you’ve made there? And again, there’s no need for any child to be put in the position of having a dog induced asthma attack and being blue lighted to hospital because OP isn’t going round to her nieces home and forcing her dogs on them.

NoSquirrels · 12/09/2022 18:25

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:21

You know that’s not a practical solution. OP can’t afford and probably can’t transport 9 children on days out activities that fully replace the time spent at her home. Anything along those lines would weekend events and be few and far between.

Oh, I see. You’re just being goady (unless you’re actually not grasping the situation.)

MyneighbourisTotoro · 12/09/2022 18:24

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:21

You know that’s not a practical solution. OP can’t afford and probably can’t transport 9 children on days out activities that fully replace the time spent at her home. Anything along those lines would weekend events and be few and far between.

They can go to the park of one of the other parents houses or DB can pay as the niece is his child and therefore his responsibility.

saraclara · 12/09/2022 18:24

What you are providing for your nephews and nieces sounds wonderful, OP. They're really lucky, and having read your posts I can see how Gemma would be devastated not to every be part of it again. I can also understand how sad her parents would be to know that her allergy will now exclude her from what's obviously such a lovely atosphere in your home.

But your sibling can''t ask you to get rid of the dog. He just can't. The best you can do is provide activities outside the house that she can join in with. In the meantime I really hope that the doctors can get the allergy under control.

MyneighbourisTotoro · 12/09/2022 18:23

Helleboring · 12/09/2022 18:21

Again, you deliberately misread.

It's not about the nieces FEELINGS. It's about not risking her life!!

Arranging to do things outside of OPs home and having OPs DB have the cousins at his house for once solves that issue.
The niece is no longer excluded and no longer at risk.

I8toys · 12/09/2022 18:22

YANBU. No way on this earth would I get rid of my pets. They are part of my family.

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:21

NoSquirrels · 12/09/2022 18:18

The feelings of the child, the OPs son, in the joy of having a pet dog do matter. They just don’t matter as much as the health and safety of his cousin Gemma.

And thus the obvious solution is not that the OP’s son lose his pets, but that Gemma is kept safe by not being in contact with the pets and that everyone meets elsewhere than OP’s house.

You know that’s not a practical solution. OP can’t afford and probably can’t transport 9 children on days out activities that fully replace the time spent at her home. Anything along those lines would weekend events and be few and far between.

Helleboring · 12/09/2022 18:21

9thlife · 12/09/2022 18:17

Once again, why is the nieces feelings more important than ops and HER actual kids?

Again, you deliberately misread.

It's not about the nieces FEELINGS. It's about not risking her life!!

surreygirl1987 · 12/09/2022 18:20

Gosh. I can't stand dogs and even I think YANBU. I can't believe they asked that of you!!

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:20

DancingBudgie · 12/09/2022 18:15

Though you may have dogs, you clearly have no understanding of them, nor care much for them if you're happy to give them up to accommodate someone who doesn't even live in your home!
Gemma's dad sounds as barking as the dogs he wants rehoming!

Like I said, I don’t worship dogs. I understand them very well, it’s you who are anthropomorphising them. Yes, I would rehome my dogs if a human family member were severely allergic to them because I value the health, safety and happiness of a human family member above the causing of temporary stress to a dog family member of finding them a new family. Especially if I’d only had those dogs for six months. It’s not like these are 12yr old dogs I’d had since they were weaned and have known no other home. These are new dogs that have barely settled. That makes a huge difference.

NoSquirrels · 12/09/2022 18:18

The feelings of the child, the OPs son, in the joy of having a pet dog do matter. They just don’t matter as much as the health and safety of his cousin Gemma.

And thus the obvious solution is not that the OP’s son lose his pets, but that Gemma is kept safe by not being in contact with the pets and that everyone meets elsewhere than OP’s house.

9thlife · 12/09/2022 18:17

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:15

The feelings of the child, the OPs son, in the joy of having a pet dog do matter. They just don’t matter as much as the health and safety of his cousin Gemma.

There are ways of managing the girl's allergies and exposure to animals.
Apparently that’s a dead end, she can’t be exposed. It’s a severe allergy and despite seeking medical advice no medication exists to negate her allergy

That should not come at the cost of another child's happiness. pffft a child can get over not having a pet dog alot easier than a child with a dog induced asthma attack being blue lighted to hospital can breathe. Children can be perfectly happy in a pet free home. Pets are luxuries. And added happiness always comes behind health and safety.

However, in this case the OP"S own child is more important than a niece.
Yes the OPs own childs enjoyment of a pet is more important than her nieces health, companionship, and potentially life. That’s really ducked up set of values imho, the kind of values that result in OPs child growing up with a me first, I’m alright Jack so fuck you attitude.

Once again, why is the nieces feelings more important than ops and HER actual kids?

9thlife · 12/09/2022 18:16

Nonews · 12/09/2022 15:55

I would get rid of the dogs. I think the human family is more important.

She clearly has a severe allergy. She’s been excluded from your home and time with family at your home due to a medical condition. I would get rid of the dogs to ensure she is as included as other members of the family.

This is why we think pets are disposable.

sad for Gemma, but she is not ops child!
why should op get rid of HER animals, that she loves, her kids ( her actually family) for a child that doesn’t even live with her!

bonkers!

the reason why we treat pets as if they are nothing.

no I would not get rid of, my pets are my family.

AdoraBell · 12/09/2022 18:15

YANBU . Don’t get rid of your dogs. Could all of the children have a fun space at GPs? Obviously not every day. Or as pp have suggested have a dog free room for the DC to play in.

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:15

thesurrealist · 12/09/2022 18:06

*The message it gives is that a human family member’s health (potentially life) is more important than getting puppy cuddles and going on walkies. That sometimes we need to make sacrifices for the good of our family.

The dogs would be equally happy if rehomed with another human family- they’re not going to suffer if rehomed. So it’s not like it’s a choice between Gemma suffering or the dogs suffering.

The message you would be giving by saying fuck off, I’m keeping the dogs is that Gemma’s life and love is less important to you than puppy cuddles and walkies. That dogs are more fun to be around than her. That you don’t care about her safety or happiness at all, it’s all about you and your desires.*

And again, doesn't the feelings of the actual child who lives in the house matter? The message that he would be getting is that a cousin is more important than him.
There are ways of managing the girl's allergies and exposure to animals. That should not come at the cost of another child's happiness.
I personally do put my dog above people and I'm very open about the fact that the only people welcome in my house are those who accept that my dog is here and he is always more important.
However, in this case the OP"S own child is more important than a niece.

The feelings of the child, the OPs son, in the joy of having a pet dog do matter. They just don’t matter as much as the health and safety of his cousin Gemma.

There are ways of managing the girl's allergies and exposure to animals.
Apparently that’s a dead end, she can’t be exposed. It’s a severe allergy and despite seeking medical advice no medication exists to negate her allergy

That should not come at the cost of another child's happiness. pffft a child can get over not having a pet dog alot easier than a child with a dog induced asthma attack being blue lighted to hospital can breathe. Children can be perfectly happy in a pet free home. Pets are luxuries. And added happiness always comes behind health and safety.

However, in this case the OP"S own child is more important than a niece.
Yes the OPs own childs enjoyment of a pet is more important than her nieces health, companionship, and potentially life. That’s really ducked up set of values imho, the kind of values that result in OPs child growing up with a me first, I’m alright Jack so fuck you attitude.

DancingBudgie · 12/09/2022 18:15

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 18:08

I have dogs. I just don’t worship them. You obviously don’t know much about dogs if you think that after 6months they’re going to be utterly devoted to you and suffer agony if they are rehomed. They’re not that complex.

And even if you think the dogs would suffer as much as Gemma would, why is the dog being prioritised over Gemma? She’s being “ripped away” from her relationships with her cousins and aunts and uncles. And unlike dogs, who can, let’s be real here, be happy with any decent family, Gemma can’t. She only has one family, and that family needs to do right by her.

Though you may have dogs, you clearly have no understanding of them, nor care much for them if you're happy to give them up to accommodate someone who doesn't even live in your home!
Gemma's dad sounds as barking as the dogs he wants rehoming!

MrsMcBride · 12/09/2022 18:14

Obviously don't get rid of your dogs. (Tell your brother they are not possessions to be disposed of!)

Could the allergic child wear a filtration mask of some kind when she visits?

BabyJellyShark · 12/09/2022 18:12

I have dogs.

Are they taxidermied? Considering your complete lack of understanding dogs and non existent regard for their welfare I can only assume that they must be.

I've dealt with severe mental issues in a dog before, in part caused by being rehomed twice in just a few months. It can cause very real harm and that's not to mention the impact on the OP and her son.