Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for not getting rid of dogs when niece is allergic?

643 replies

dogsdander · 12/09/2022 15:20

My husband and I don't have to work that many hours and when we do they're from home so it puts us in a good position to help our siblings and watch their kids. My husband has 1 sister with 2 children. I have a brother, with 2 children. A sister with 3 children. I also have a younger half brother with 1 child. My husband and I also have a son. So 9 kids all together between the ages 4-12. They’re usually not here all at the same time, but they all do come over often. Sort of a mix and match depending on various schedules. They all seem to have a fun time (in their words we have the “fun house”) and our son loves to socialize with his cousins.

Almost half a year ago we got two dogs. All the kids were very excited and have enjoyed playing with them. Unfortunately we found out that my one niece (Gemma) is allergic to dogs. She’s never been around a dog much before so neither she nor her parents knew about the allergy. It is not just a mild allergy either. She doesn’t just get sniffles she actually started wheezing and had trouble breathing.

We have tried to do things to minimize allergens in our home. However it is very difficult because of our home is fully carpeted. Regular vacuuming did nothing. We got an air purifier and steam cleaned our carpets before she came over one time and kept the dogs outside for the day and it worked, but of course after a day the dog dander had gotten everywhere and we were back to square one. We decided this wasn’t a viable option to do on a regular basis because of the cost and the increased amount of wear and tear. It also leaves the majority of our house unusable while we waited for the carpet to dry.

My brother and sil (Gemma’s parents) have taken her to the doctor to try different medications to help with her allergies. The problem is Gemma already takes medication for a different medical issue and it interferes with a lot of allergy medicines. They’ve tried some other things suggested by her doctor, but nothing really helps.

My brother has asked that we get rid of our dogs because Gemma had a fit the other day. She’s upset that she hasn’t been able to come over to the “fun house” and play with her cousins all these months while they still come over all the time. My brother thinks that we are causing her to feel left out by not getting rid of the dogs.

I understand how unfair it must feel for Gemma, but neither me or my husband or son want to get rid of our dogs. They’re part of the family now. We have become very attached to them. Especially our son. He would cry his eyes out if they had to be given up.

It’s not like we can stop watching the other kids to make Gemma feel less excluded either. Our siblings don’t have it as easy as us and they need the help sometimes.

OP posts:
Bookworm777 · 12/09/2022 19:44

What a horrible situation for you all, but I really feel for Gemma. She's only eight, so in her mind it must seem like she's gone from visiting her fun uncle and aunt twice a week to being effectively cast out because they prefer their new dogs more. No wonder she's so upset. Should you get rid of the dogs? I don't know, but it's that or living with the knowledge your niece will never be able to come to your house while you have them. Are you happy to explain that to her?

Blurp · 12/09/2022 19:43

@GhostFromTheOtherSide "It’s just not practical to think that the OP’s house should always be the centre of things and that the OP and only the OP should be the one making sacrifices.

The other siblings have houses. There are parks, there are other public places. If there genuinely is a good relationship here then the other siblings would be looking for a way to keep the children together. So why aren’t they?"

Totally agree with this. Why is OP the one having to get rid of her dogs, or get wooden floors or whatever? What are the other parents doing to help?

I really don't understand the families who are always going on about meeting up and cousins seeing each other all the time - it's nice when they see each other, of course, but living your life around it always ends with situations like this, because there are no boundaries in place. It always seems to be one person in particular who makes all the sacrifices, and the rest just get the benefits. Eventually, the benefits stop, and suddenly the "closeness" disappears too.

If Gemma's parents don't want her to be excluded, they need to put some effort in.

Boreded · 12/09/2022 19:41

If she is having fits because of the allergies, personally I would rehome the dogs, but that’s only because they’re super new to your home, and it’s a severe allergy.

if you don’t want to regime (completely understand why you wouldn’t, nobody could make me get rid of my cats) then you can’t really be the ‘fun house’ as it’s quite unfair for your niece to miss out.

personally, I don’t think that either you or your nieces father are being unreasonable though. He has a right to ask, and you have a right to say no, I just think that maybe by keeping the dogs your brother (and niece) may feel that you care for the dogs more than your niece (which might be the case lol)

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 12/09/2022 19:41

I don’t think @Discovereads posts are batshit in the slightest.

Terfydactyl · 12/09/2022 19:40

Contrary.

Terfydactyl · 12/09/2022 19:40

billybassie · 12/09/2022 18:38

@Discovereads your posts are completely batshit.

She is the same over on fwr, in fact the more of the posts I read the more I think she likes being of the opposite opinion to most. Theres a name for it that I cant remember rn

Mommabear20 · 12/09/2022 19:39

Don't get rid of the dogs!
It's absolutely awful of your brother to even ask you too! Yes I feel bad that your DN is missing out, but it's not her house and things don't have to revolve around her.

ConnectQ · 12/09/2022 19:38

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 12/09/2022 19:16

As has been said over and over, this is about a child knowingly being excluded from a family thing. It’s a thing in that extended family that the kids of the extended family hang out in OPs house. It’s the fact that tradition has been established that is the problem. Because there is no way to reframe that away from the niece is now excluded from that.

And as it has been pointed out over and over, it can take place somewhere else. Family Traditions change.

But OP has not suggested changing the tradition. ( i have! See my previous posts. I think the tradition of OP having the kids around needs to end if the dogs are to stay). What OP and most posters seem to want is that this tradition stays and Gemma is excluded.

TastesLikeFlavourlessFizz · 12/09/2022 19:38

Absolutely no chance I’d be getting rid of my dogs. I wouldn’t even consider it. Dogs are family too.

I8toys · 12/09/2022 19:35

I don't even think its the dog. Its the fact that other people are dictating what she does in her own house. The girl doesn't even live there 24/7. Its the occasional visit.

GhostFromTheOtherSide · 12/09/2022 19:34

The dogs will live longer than the children will be going to the OP’s house a couple of times a week.

At best Gemma will only want to hang out there for another 3 years if that, she certainly isn’t likely to want to by the time she starts secondary, and the 12 yo’s will be doing GCSE’s by then so they won’t be hanging out there so Gemma might not want to anyway.

So you get rid of the dogs because the kids might want to hang out there for a couple of years. And then what? Get some more?

The OP isn’t putting her dogs above her niece. She’s putting her child above her brother’s child and rightly so.

Her niece doesn’t live there. Her home is not putting her at risk. The world does not revolve around the OP’s house, there is a big wide world out there where these children can have a relationship.

If people genuinely think that the relationship is being compromised because the niece is allergic to the dogs and that there is no other alternative but to rehome them, then I think the relationships are already fractured. Because the reality is that life changes. Things change, circumstances change.

The brother could decide to move to another town in a couple of months. The OP could get a full time job, there could be illness in the family.

It’s just not practical to think that the OP’s house should always be the centre of things and that the OP and only the OP should be the one making sacrifices.

The other siblings have houses. There are parks, there are other public places. If there genuinely is a good relationship here then the other siblings would be looking for a way to keep the children together. So why aren’t they?

LicoricePizza · 12/09/2022 19:34

No way - dogs are family members. I appreciate they’re not requesting it over something trivial, but the implications are awful. Please don’t let them guilt you into anything. Plus you’re helping everyone a lot & there are limits to that help when it comes to your own family & its needs/makeup.

ConnectQ · 12/09/2022 19:34

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 12/09/2022 19:09

Dog allergies can be life threatening and I'd urge you to ignore advice from posters who can't understand that. I feel very sorry for Gemma. As a fellow severe allergy sufferer, there is loads I have, and do, miss out on. She may well never be able to go to friends house if they have animals. She will miss play dates, sleepovers, parties and she will have to get a job which does not take her into other people's homes. I think some people struggle to understand or be empathetic, regarding what they is like.

You can arrange things out of the home, but if she is missing things which occur in your home due to her allergies then of course that is a big deal. If kids get other medical diagnoses which will negatively impact their life for the rest of their lives and were dismissed in the way that some posters have here, that would not be considered acceptable. That said, there is no obligation on you to get rid of your dogs. I would personally minimise any events which effectively exclude her, however. Can you oversee get togethers at her house? At the park? Anywhere but the one place she now can't go?

I would not spend loads on hard floors, fancy remedies because for more severe allergies, the advice is avoid allergens and if there are dogs in your house, it's a no-go zone - all of it. It's not realistic to think you can keep one room allergen free.

All of this.

9thlife · 12/09/2022 19:30

Helleboring · 12/09/2022 19:22

Look, all you dog owners can calm down. The OP's dogs are going nowhere.

This thread isn't about what she should do - she just wants validation that she's not being unreasonable in not rehoming her dogs. Clearly, with the weight of outrage on here in response, she's had that.

Most posters have gone further, and stated with no proof at all, that the brother is only interested in free childcare, so that the OP can see him as just a grabby entitled chancer.

(Incidentally, the same posters glibly throw in that the brother can just step in and host the extended family, conveniently ignoring that the OP explicitly states she is in a more fortunate position in being able to do that (space? time? money?). They also insist airily the child who has a potentially life threatening allergy should just try some anti-histamines ).

It's not that the OP is being unreasonable, it's an unfortunate turn of events that is going to lead to part of the family being excluded from a previously life-enhancing routine. I think everyone involved needs to acknowledge that something has changed and at least one family is left feeling less valued.

I hope you can devise some way of making your brother's family feel that they are still important to you, OP.

Why do you assume people disagreeing are dog owners?
I’m not a dog owner, but think op should keep her dogs Hmm

PhoenixReincarnated · 12/09/2022 19:29

OP YANBU

Your brother could solve this problem by dropping his huge sense of entitlement to free childcare and arranging play dates for the cousins at his house. That way Gemma can continue to have a relationship with her cousins. It is the responsibility of her parents (not the OP) to facilitate and encourage the relationships.

As a pp said it won't be much longer before the cousins start growing up and prioritising time with their friends over family.

Don't give up your dogs. It's your brother's responsibility to put his child first and it's yours to put your child first. Your brother can prioritise his daughter by hosting. You prioritise your son by keeping your dogs.

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 12/09/2022 19:27

That’s bloody appalling, @Spacemonkey2016. I really don’t know what’s wrong with some
people.

Helendee · 12/09/2022 19:25

People, especially family, are far more important to me than a dog so the mutts would have to go.
I appreciate I’m in a minority here.

Spacemonkey2016 · 12/09/2022 19:24

I think the main thing here, is making sure you make lots of effort to make Gemma feel included in other ways: garden games, parks, offer to come and play at her house etc.

My two little ones (5 and 2) have multiple severe allergies, one of them being cats. My PILs, have cats, which is obviously their choice. But they won't make the 20 minute drive to us, because they like people to come to them. As a consequence, we literally visit them a few times in the warmer months and sit in their garden (all the while I think why on Earth should I?) but they never ever say 'You know what, let's not risk the kids, we'll come to you.' They just keep getting more cats. My children wouldn't recognise them if they passed them on a street. I just think it's really sad.

I do feel it's unreasonable of them asking you to rehome your dog. As long as you do your best not to exclude your niece, you're not in the wrong in my view.

happygertie · 12/09/2022 19:23

DN isn't your responsibility. I get that she is a loved family member, but it is for your DB and SIL to manage.

If I was asked to choose between my very loved dogs and my DN then I would choose MY dogs.

I'm sure you could maybe treat her to an occasional cinema trip and try bbq's in your garden during summer, but ultimately and in the nicest possible way, her allergies aren't your problem.

Helleboring · 12/09/2022 19:22

Look, all you dog owners can calm down. The OP's dogs are going nowhere.

This thread isn't about what she should do - she just wants validation that she's not being unreasonable in not rehoming her dogs. Clearly, with the weight of outrage on here in response, she's had that.

Most posters have gone further, and stated with no proof at all, that the brother is only interested in free childcare, so that the OP can see him as just a grabby entitled chancer.

(Incidentally, the same posters glibly throw in that the brother can just step in and host the extended family, conveniently ignoring that the OP explicitly states she is in a more fortunate position in being able to do that (space? time? money?). They also insist airily the child who has a potentially life threatening allergy should just try some anti-histamines ).

It's not that the OP is being unreasonable, it's an unfortunate turn of events that is going to lead to part of the family being excluded from a previously life-enhancing routine. I think everyone involved needs to acknowledge that something has changed and at least one family is left feeling less valued.

I hope you can devise some way of making your brother's family feel that they are still important to you, OP.

HellinGreece · 12/09/2022 19:22

KenzosFlower · 12/09/2022 19:12

I have read all of the OPs messages and am not seeing any vile messages from Gemma's parents.
You are being VERY weird re leather and holidays.

Don't think I am being weird. I am merely stating that gemmas parents entitlement will spiral out of control. If they have a cheek to demand someone gets rid of their pet to accommodate their child, what's next ?

Dragonskin · 12/09/2022 19:21

And even if you think the dogs would suffer as much as Gemma would, why is the dog being prioritised over Gemma?

Why would Gemma, someone who doesn't live in the house, be prioritised over OPs own family who do?

Gemma's parents need to make some changes to accommodate Gemma and ensure that she isn't left out, but I'm guessing it's less convenient getting everyone round to their house instead of OPs

Jaaxe · 12/09/2022 19:20

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 12/09/2022 19:19

Can't you read. It's not their own child. It's a niece.

Doesn't that poster mean OP child who wants the dog comes first? Rather than the allergic niece?

Yes definitely

HellinGreece · 12/09/2022 19:20

ConnectQ · 12/09/2022 19:07

@HellinGreece
humans bred dogs to suit humans! We bred dogs for our needs. We need them to crave our company to satisfy our emotions! Dog ownership was not created by humans to benefit dogs!

Human have domesticated dogs to start with as we needed them! Dogs were not for mental support. They were for hunting, protection, gundogs or herding. Then we have realised they are very clever animals and often in tune with humans and we can use them for other things. They can be taught specific protection, they often form a search party for missing humans. They can sense diseases and safely direct a blind person across the town. For a lot of dog owners, they are our family.
I agree relationship wasn't there to benefit dogs, but it is now. They are very reliant on people and thats why they form a huge part of peoples lives.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 12/09/2022 19:19

Can't you read. It's not their own child. It's a niece.

Doesn't that poster mean OP child who wants the dog comes first? Rather than the allergic niece?