Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be cross about this (P.E. at school)

133 replies

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 15:10

Like many areas we are experiencing heavy down pours. And like many schools the DC wear their P.E kit to school and don't change.

On Friday there had been heavy rain the night before and rain showers on and off all day. My DD's class were expected to go for a run over muddy and slippery ground and play basketball in the pouring rain. The running club was cancelled but this went ahead. Considering they then had to wear their kit for the last hour of school, there was then a information meeting so they sat in wet kit for another 45 minutes and then however long their journey home is, would you think this reasonable? I personally, don't.

However, my DD has Long Covid which has all been documented in an Education plan. She has only just been able to start coming to school full time again and missed so much last year. And they got her soaked through (due to weak muscles she slipped multiple times in the mud as well as the pouring rain). She's had a respiratory illness all weekend and soldiered into school this morning for her Mock 11+ and then got sent home. I'm really cross. Where's the common sense? I emailed the school regarding this.

When I went to pick my DD up the P.E teacher had passed on a message asking me to detail all the reasons she can't do P.E in the rain (it was all in the email plus all previous meetings/correspondence re Long Covid) and wondering if she had a coat. Well, yes of course she does, but they obviously don't take them to P.E! It hardly answers why they were getting a child with Long Covid to get soaked through with no opportunity to change. I honestly feel like I have no trust in this teacher to do the right thing for the welfare of the children and especially my own DC. I'm so upset that she's missing school again due to this incident.

My immediate reaction is to email the principal and say my DD is not doing P.E. until this is properly resolved. Meaning I know everything is documented properly about her condition and what would happen in any given situation as it seems I can't rely on the P.E. teacher's common sense.

What would you do?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 17:07

10HailMarys · 12/09/2022 16:51

@daisyjgrey No. I hated PE at school. I have dyspraxia and I hated team sports of any kind and I fell over a lot. PE was just ritual humiliation for me. I just don't really think it's the end of the world for a child to get rained on, and I'm not convinced that getting rained on is any different for a child with Long Covid than it is for another child. It's mildly uncomfortable to sit in damp clothes, but not harmful.

As I said - if the OP's daughter is struggling with PE in general because of fatigue or poor muscle tone from Long Covid, then perhaps she needs to be excused from PE generally. Maybe her doctor could advise exercise that's more low-impact or strength-building to do at home for now, if school PE is still too much for her to the extent that she's constantly falling over due to muscle weakness.

But the rain thing alone just doesn't feel like a big deal to me at all. It's just rain. Appreciate others may feel differently, but personally I just don't think the rain itself has any bearing on the OP's daughter's health issues or struggles with PE.

Well, I suppose I'm just glad you're not a HCP. I'm a nurse and yes, getting cold and wet for a DC with lowered immunity has a direct bearing on their health. She has just gone back to P.E as I suppose myself and her paediatrician felt with her education plan there would be a duty of care and along with some common sense it would be possible for her to take part in P.E, but clearly not. She already does Physio at home.

OP posts:
FlorettaB · 12/09/2022 17:07

I’d pull her from PE for the foreseeable future and specify that she stays inside where it’s warm and dry. Otherwise she could well end up being dragged outside to stand in the cold and the rain and watch or ‘help’ (fetch the ball) while the other children do P.E.

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 17:00

Aubriella · 12/09/2022 16:34

YANBU at all. Would all these adults like to sit in wet kit and make the journey home in it? I doubt it.

I think all the adults worked out they could leave home later/get home earlier by cancelling all the clubs due to rain! If anyone wants to talk about people 'trying to get out of' P.E.! But no, of course they wouldn't. I suppose this teacher gets to change so thinks 'I'm all right, Jack!'

OP posts:
SproutsAtChristmas · 12/09/2022 17:00

@carefullycourageous The reason I responded to your comment is because my entire career is based around making sure children enjoy physical activity. Hence, I think that asking children to run around in the freezing cold/mud/rain is not a way to help them enjoy PE, physical activity or sport. I want them to live healthy, active lives as they get older and look back fondly on physical exercise rather than how many posters on this thread feel about PE teachers/PE at school. I'm not sure how my job makes me "statistically more likely to be a dickhead". We actually conduct surveys to ensure children do enjoy PE at our school and we choose the sports to teach based on what they ask to learn.

I just think it's very unfair to suggest PE teachers are all awful when that isn't the case. I've often found that children who dislike PE have parents who openly tell me they hated PE when they were at school. Setting an example for healthy, active living comes from home just as much as school.

@UndertheCedartree do you know if the PE class is split boys and girls? Is there another group DC could go with indoors? Definitely meet the teacher in person and you could request the pastoral leader (Head of Year? Form tutor) also attends so they are all fully clear on the medical issues.

noclothesinbed · 12/09/2022 16:57

I think what the doctor meant was no definite test for long Covid but yes I do have all the signs of long Covid and was just interested incase there was something possible I didn't know about. Thank you and I hope your daughter gets well soon Bear

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 16:54

greenacrylicpaint · 12/09/2022 16:29

yabu
you knew the weather forecast
you could have provided your child with a change of clothes.

it's still warm for the time of year. dc are not made from sugar.
being outside is good for us.

I did but I stupidly thought some common sense would be used. The before/after school sports clubs were cancelled due to the rain. The DC do not have time to change. However, I do not want my DD being soaked for an hour. Why? Because it can lead to respiratory illness due to her Long Covid. Because she then misses school.

I am fully aware she is not made from sugar. We walk to and from school everyday even when raining (while most parents are driving their DC up to the gate and lifting them over the barrier so that rain will barely touch their heads!), but we wear waterproofs. I know being outside is good for us. We spend lots of time outdoors when we can, indeed we would have done this weekend except we were at home with my ill DD. Honestly, how has it benefited her to spend an hour outside in the rain and now can't play outside, can't go to school all because a P.E teacher couldn't just move the class inside? Or at least just leave my DD inside!

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 12/09/2022 16:51

daisyjgrey · 12/09/2022 15:51

@10HailMarys are you a pe teacher?

@daisyjgrey No. I hated PE at school. I have dyspraxia and I hated team sports of any kind and I fell over a lot. PE was just ritual humiliation for me. I just don't really think it's the end of the world for a child to get rained on, and I'm not convinced that getting rained on is any different for a child with Long Covid than it is for another child. It's mildly uncomfortable to sit in damp clothes, but not harmful.

As I said - if the OP's daughter is struggling with PE in general because of fatigue or poor muscle tone from Long Covid, then perhaps she needs to be excused from PE generally. Maybe her doctor could advise exercise that's more low-impact or strength-building to do at home for now, if school PE is still too much for her to the extent that she's constantly falling over due to muscle weakness.

But the rain thing alone just doesn't feel like a big deal to me at all. It's just rain. Appreciate others may feel differently, but personally I just don't think the rain itself has any bearing on the OP's daughter's health issues or struggles with PE.

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 16:44

noclothesinbed · 12/09/2022 16:27

How did you get your daughter diagnosed with long Covid ? My doctor said there was no test for it I'd really be grateful to know

They diagnose it by symptoms. She was then referred to the paediatrician that she's under. I think our GP said Covid symptoms for longer that 3 months=Long Covid. Your doctor is being disingenuous saying there is no test - there's no test for many things but they can still be diagnosed.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 16:41

TolkiensFallow · 12/09/2022 16:23

It’s ridiculous that the children had to sit in wet clothes.

you would wear full waterproofs if walking in the rain so that you were dry when finishes, it should be perfectly obvious that it’s not healthy to sit around in wet clothes.

You would think!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 16:39

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/09/2022 16:21

Can't she just bring a change of clothes for the days that look like they are going to be wet? PE is important to children (although many parents clearly think not), and it's something lots of children try to avoid, so I think schools tend to be a little extra strict on missing it.

She would still get cold being soaking for an hour. For a healthy DC, yes changing would be fine, except there is no facility for that anymore.

I appreciate P.E. is important but so are other lessons and now my DD is off school because of that P.E. lesson and this may extend to more time off. My DD has had to have so much time off school, off her sports club, off other clubs, missing her friends, being in pain, unwell, exhausted, depressed and anxious, believe me the novelty of 'getting off' something has well and truly worn off. And if this P.E. teacher is really unable to understand the difference between that and a DC wanting to avoid P.E. then honestly, I don't want him anywhere near my DC. But actually you've made me realise exactly why his response got my back up - because it was this attitude! Despite my DC never missing P.E before Covid, her doing Sport in after school clubs at school and outside of school. That she's had a hell of a time with Covid/Long Covid - had to miss so much school. Has just been able to go back full time and he wants to make out she's just trying to avoid P.E. even though I explained clearly the (common sense) issue. We have worked so hard to get to this point and she has missed out on so much and this teacher's not bothered that his decisions are now making her miss more school - I am so frustrated!!!

OP posts:
carefullycourageous · 12/09/2022 16:37

Sorry, should have added too @SproutsAtChristmas it is not one PE teacher I was basing my remark on, it was a surprising number over many years of parenting. The example I cited was just the latest, in a long period of sending kids to secondary.

Aubriella · 12/09/2022 16:36

SproutsAtChristmas · 12/09/2022 15:55

@carefullycourageous Where on earth are you pulling this "fact" from? I'm a Head of PE and often find the PE teachers have brilliant relationships with a huge volume of children. I think tarring them all with the same brush because you've come across an adult you didn't like seems uncalled for.

OP- our pupils wore kit to school the last 2 years on PE days due to us being unable to social distance our changing rooms. I made it clear to my teaching team (around 8 PE staff) that no pupils should do PE in rain (except maybe a light drizzle of they had coats with them) and no muddy field use as they wear these clothes all day and it's unfair. I also relaxed the rules so children could wear any coat to PE as long as it wasn't a health and safety/hygiene risk i.e. no leather jackets but a puffer jacket was fine.

I agree the children at the school really shouldn't have to wear muddy, damp kit. Don't pull her out of PE lessons but request a meeting with the PE teacher to discuss the health of your DC.

Not really my experience. PE teachers were the most detached teachers in our school. They only had time for their favourite students.

Aubriella · 12/09/2022 16:34

YANBU at all. Would all these adults like to sit in wet kit and make the journey home in it? I doubt it.

carefullycourageous · 12/09/2022 16:32

SproutsAtChristmas · 12/09/2022 15:55

@carefullycourageous Where on earth are you pulling this "fact" from? I'm a Head of PE and often find the PE teachers have brilliant relationships with a huge volume of children. I think tarring them all with the same brush because you've come across an adult you didn't like seems uncalled for.

OP- our pupils wore kit to school the last 2 years on PE days due to us being unable to social distance our changing rooms. I made it clear to my teaching team (around 8 PE staff) that no pupils should do PE in rain (except maybe a light drizzle of they had coats with them) and no muddy field use as they wear these clothes all day and it's unfair. I also relaxed the rules so children could wear any coat to PE as long as it wasn't a health and safety/hygiene risk i.e. no leather jackets but a puffer jacket was fine.

I agree the children at the school really shouldn't have to wear muddy, damp kit. Don't pull her out of PE lessons but request a meeting with the PE teacher to discuss the health of your DC.

If you are a Head of PE, I can only urge you to reflect not on how you feel about PE, but on why vast numbers of young people who are still put off sport for life by the awful teaching of sport that goes on in schools.

I was being tongue in cheek and of course not all are the same but I basically stand by what I said.

greenacrylicpaint · 12/09/2022 16:29

yabu
you knew the weather forecast
you could have provided your child with a change of clothes.

it's still warm for the time of year. dc are not made from sugar.
being outside is good for us.

noclothesinbed · 12/09/2022 16:27

How did you get your daughter diagnosed with long Covid ? My doctor said there was no test for it I'd really be grateful to know

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 16:26

SproutsAtChristmas · 12/09/2022 15:55

@carefullycourageous Where on earth are you pulling this "fact" from? I'm a Head of PE and often find the PE teachers have brilliant relationships with a huge volume of children. I think tarring them all with the same brush because you've come across an adult you didn't like seems uncalled for.

OP- our pupils wore kit to school the last 2 years on PE days due to us being unable to social distance our changing rooms. I made it clear to my teaching team (around 8 PE staff) that no pupils should do PE in rain (except maybe a light drizzle of they had coats with them) and no muddy field use as they wear these clothes all day and it's unfair. I also relaxed the rules so children could wear any coat to PE as long as it wasn't a health and safety/hygiene risk i.e. no leather jackets but a puffer jacket was fine.

I agree the children at the school really shouldn't have to wear muddy, damp kit. Don't pull her out of PE lessons but request a meeting with the PE teacher to discuss the health of your DC.

Thank you for that from a P.E teacher. The response really got my back up - like surely they had made some kind of risk assessment for her last term when she was well enough to try P.E. for the last couple of weeks. What happened to that? Was one even made? Just makes them seem incompetent as well as uncaring and lacking any common sense. I will request a meeting but I don't want to take the risk of her doing P.E. until then, but hopefully can get a meeting before Friday as they only do P.E. one day a week as still swimming on the other day.

OP posts:
TolkiensFallow · 12/09/2022 16:23

It’s ridiculous that the children had to sit in wet clothes.

you would wear full waterproofs if walking in the rain so that you were dry when finishes, it should be perfectly obvious that it’s not healthy to sit around in wet clothes.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/09/2022 16:21

Can't she just bring a change of clothes for the days that look like they are going to be wet? PE is important to children (although many parents clearly think not), and it's something lots of children try to avoid, so I think schools tend to be a little extra strict on missing it.

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 16:18

daisyjgrey · 12/09/2022 15:51

@10HailMarys are you a pe teacher?

Sounds like it doesn't it! No common sense or duty of care!

OP posts:
RaRaRaspoutine · 12/09/2022 16:03

PE teachers are a special kind of sadistic.

SproutsAtChristmas · 12/09/2022 15:55

carefullycourageous · 12/09/2022 15:13

I would escalate to the head. PE teachers are, unfortunately, statistically more likely to be dickheads than all other types of teacher and the only way to get anywhere is to go round them.

I have had a stupid argument with a PE teacher at the end of last term. Escalated to the head, resolved in half a day.

@carefullycourageous Where on earth are you pulling this "fact" from? I'm a Head of PE and often find the PE teachers have brilliant relationships with a huge volume of children. I think tarring them all with the same brush because you've come across an adult you didn't like seems uncalled for.

OP- our pupils wore kit to school the last 2 years on PE days due to us being unable to social distance our changing rooms. I made it clear to my teaching team (around 8 PE staff) that no pupils should do PE in rain (except maybe a light drizzle of they had coats with them) and no muddy field use as they wear these clothes all day and it's unfair. I also relaxed the rules so children could wear any coat to PE as long as it wasn't a health and safety/hygiene risk i.e. no leather jackets but a puffer jacket was fine.

I agree the children at the school really shouldn't have to wear muddy, damp kit. Don't pull her out of PE lessons but request a meeting with the PE teacher to discuss the health of your DC.

daisyjgrey · 12/09/2022 15:51

@10HailMarys are you a pe teacher?

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 15:47

edwinbear · 12/09/2022 15:29

It wouldn't particularly bother me, but then DS spends his entire autumn/winter either doing cross country or playing rugby - where they are expected to suck it up if it's wet/muddy.

However, given your DD's health issues, maybe a chat with her GP to see if she should be avoiding PE for the time being.

I will see if I can get hold of her paediatrician but I think when we discussed it some while ago we assumed the P.E. staff would have some common sense!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 15:44

10HailMarys · 12/09/2022 15:21

Sorry to hear she's had a cold over the weekend, but you don't catch a cold by getting wet.

If you're concerned that Long Covid means your daughter can't cope with PE at all, then I think you need to consult her doctor about that and see what they advise.

But if she can do PE with Long Covid, then she can do PE with Long Covid in the rain. Sitting in damp clothes is mildly uncomfortable, but it's not harmful and if they called off PE every time it rained they'd barely do any PE at all in winter.

Lots of kids walk to school rain or shine and then spend the whole day in the clothes they got drenched in. It's a pain, but that's life. I get that you're particularly concerned because your daughter's had health issues lately, but I think you're perhaps being a little bit precious here.

When you have Long Covid you have a weaker immune system, when you get cold from being soaked through you further impair your immune system therefore making you more susceptible to respiratory illness. I guess the P.E. teacher doesn't know this either! So no, she can't do P.E. in the rain. And P.E. can be moved indoors rather than missing P.E. for the class as a whole.

She is under the paediatrician and she was allowed to start P.E. again on the proviso she could stop if she needed to. I don't think either of us felt we needed to give specific instruction regarding the recent weather.

We walk to school rain or shine. But we wear waterproofs/wellies and walk carefully so no falling over in puddles. So no not sitting soaked through all day. On Friday they had to stay in due to the weather at break and lunch. When they'd be in their coats - but P.E fine with no coats? Running club cancelled due to weather? How does this make sense?

OP posts: