Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be cross about this (P.E. at school)

133 replies

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 15:10

Like many areas we are experiencing heavy down pours. And like many schools the DC wear their P.E kit to school and don't change.

On Friday there had been heavy rain the night before and rain showers on and off all day. My DD's class were expected to go for a run over muddy and slippery ground and play basketball in the pouring rain. The running club was cancelled but this went ahead. Considering they then had to wear their kit for the last hour of school, there was then a information meeting so they sat in wet kit for another 45 minutes and then however long their journey home is, would you think this reasonable? I personally, don't.

However, my DD has Long Covid which has all been documented in an Education plan. She has only just been able to start coming to school full time again and missed so much last year. And they got her soaked through (due to weak muscles she slipped multiple times in the mud as well as the pouring rain). She's had a respiratory illness all weekend and soldiered into school this morning for her Mock 11+ and then got sent home. I'm really cross. Where's the common sense? I emailed the school regarding this.

When I went to pick my DD up the P.E teacher had passed on a message asking me to detail all the reasons she can't do P.E in the rain (it was all in the email plus all previous meetings/correspondence re Long Covid) and wondering if she had a coat. Well, yes of course she does, but they obviously don't take them to P.E! It hardly answers why they were getting a child with Long Covid to get soaked through with no opportunity to change. I honestly feel like I have no trust in this teacher to do the right thing for the welfare of the children and especially my own DC. I'm so upset that she's missing school again due to this incident.

My immediate reaction is to email the principal and say my DD is not doing P.E. until this is properly resolved. Meaning I know everything is documented properly about her condition and what would happen in any given situation as it seems I can't rely on the P.E. teacher's common sense.

What would you do?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 23:06

SnowdaySewday · 12/09/2022 20:39

It sounds like your DD should have an Individual Health Care Plan (is that what you mean by her education plan), which should be shared with everyone who is teaching her, including the PE teacher/ sports coach. This is not the same thing as an EHCP.

Go to the headteacher. The responsibility for meeting the needs of children with medical needs in school sits with them. Either DD has an IHCP that wasn’t followed, or it needs updating now we’re heading into autumn/winter, or she needs one written. Once you know which of these is the case here, then you know what outcome you are looking for from the meeting (IHCP reissued to staff with clear reminder/instruction to follow it, her IHCP to be reviewed then reissued, or an IHCP to be written).

School is responsible for writing and reviewing the IHCP, using information from Health, in this case a report or letter from her paediatrician (not GP) - you will need to provide the report if you have one or give consent for the paediatrician to share your DD's relevant medical information with school. DD needs to know what she is to do instead of PE - most likely to go to another class or to a particular member of staff during the lesson.

Whether anyone else's child should have been outdoors for this session is for their parents to take up, and there may well be days when the weather is suitable for most healthy children to be outdoors, but not for your DD and you need to get this documented so there is no ambiguity.

Yes, so sorry - that is it! I thought what I was saying but couldn't think what it was called. And yes, I was told it was shared with everyone. I will say that I want it reviewing and updating. Thank you for the advice.

OP posts:
TheLampIsLighted · 12/09/2022 22:58

@WeeWillyWinkie9 , there's a difference between getting wet walking home, maybe carrying an umbrella, and then getting warm and changing into dry clothes, and getting soaking wet and then sitting in the wet clothes for a couple of hours feeling increasingly chilled.
I've done both. I have a weakened immune system. After the second, I developed a very bad cold that took a long time to throw off. I still regularly walk home in the rain but I would be a fool to repeat the first experience.

TheLampIsLighted · 12/09/2022 22:55

@Forestgate and @Plantstrees , I can't see that it's been debunked. There are studies suggesting there may be immune system effects in a subset of patients.
See here (found a statistically significant increase in participants developing a cold after having their feet chilled, and noted that those who developed cold symptoms were a group that seemed to be more vulnerable in general): https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16286463/

Also here: a literature review found studies supporting a link between chilling the feet/chilling the inside of the nose through breathing chilled air, and developing cold symptoms, but no evidence of a link between eating cold food and developing cold symptoms: https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/id/eprint/76299/

dontyouwishyourgirlfriendwas · 12/09/2022 22:48

YANBU at all. I can totally imagine what this teacher is like, I had a string of awful male PE teachers as school. Absolutely hard as nails, eat sleep and breathe PE and don’t give a damn about student’s well-being.

I think you’re right to keep her off PE entirely, they clearly can’t be trusted. She can read a book or do homework for an hour or something. It sounds like she does plenty of exercise out of school so I’m sure she won’t suffer greatly.

user1471447863 · 12/09/2022 22:25

There seems to be a lot on here with very healthy children who must never have had a days sick in their lives. Lucky for them.
But for those of us that have children with weakened immune systems, or just susceptible to catching anything and everything going or being hit hard by what they catch, then getting soaked and cold and then sitting the rest of the day in wet clothes would be a major issue. One of mine in those circumstances would have been coughing and wheezing by the end of the day and well on the way to a respiratory infection and up to a couple of weeks of school (because GP's don't like giving antibiotics for chest infections anymore despite there being certain groups of children for whom they are beneficial and necessary).
Some people just can't warm themselves up again easily after getting wet and cold like that either & could in the wrong circumstances risk hypothermia (you only have to lose heat faster than your body can replace it - and wet clothes accelerates heat loss particularly in a 'well ventilated' environment).

You are very right OP to be angry with the school and PE teacher over this & their email doesn't inspire confidence in their ability to think sensibly. You might have to break out the crayons to explain it in simple enough terms for them.

@Forestgate are you a covid denier? or just a bit thick?

PS - another one who found secondary school PE teachers to be sadistic bullying cretins who did more to put people off sport and exercise than to encourage them.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 12/09/2022 21:33

And I'm sure he did get a bit wet and then changed into dry clothes for his journey home. While the DC had to go back for the rest of class wet, then had to sit in the hall for the information afternoon, then had to walk home.. wet!

You've no idea if he got changed or not, if this person was doing PE all day, they likely would be wet all day from every lesson outside and wouldn't bring multiple changes of clothing. Also if it was raining, why would the walk home be an issue? Surely they would've got wet anyway on the walk home anyway? If your child is ok to walk home in the rain why can she not do PE in the rain?

CallMeLinda · 12/09/2022 21:18

Forestgate · 12/09/2022 20:46

Sorry OP but YABU

Long covid doesn't really exist in children and does nothing to the immune system. Damp clothes don't cause pneumonia and exercise is crucial for good health

If you've labelled your daughter with a chronic health condition for other reasons YABVU

Is she overweight perhaps?

Well that last paragraph/question seems a little unnecessary.

carefullycourageous · 12/09/2022 21:18

SproutsAtChristmas · 12/09/2022 20:23

@carefullycourageous 🤣🤣🤣🤣

No one likes a PE teacher clearly! Maybe I'm very fortunate who I know in the profession or maybe I should just give in and find a job that the nation likes more 🤣

What you do sounds good, I just think you don't realise what the average is like.

But yes, if you had a thin skin tonight's discussion of your profession might make you reconsider. Sorry Flowers

CallMeLinda · 12/09/2022 21:16

I think the main issue is that they are not being allowed to change out of wet/muddy clothing. Definitely challenge that. It can't be comfortable to sit around for a long period in dirty and wet clothes. It won't cause illness, but it will make them cold and miserable.
I would tell- not ask- them that she will be changing after PE and they need to allow this to happen. Even if it's into a clean and dry PE top and trousers.

Forestgate · 12/09/2022 20:47

www.bmj.com/content/376/bmj.o143

For details

Forestgate · 12/09/2022 20:46

Sorry OP but YABU

Long covid doesn't really exist in children and does nothing to the immune system. Damp clothes don't cause pneumonia and exercise is crucial for good health

If you've labelled your daughter with a chronic health condition for other reasons YABVU

Is she overweight perhaps?

SnowdaySewday · 12/09/2022 20:39

It sounds like your DD should have an Individual Health Care Plan (is that what you mean by her education plan), which should be shared with everyone who is teaching her, including the PE teacher/ sports coach. This is not the same thing as an EHCP.

Go to the headteacher. The responsibility for meeting the needs of children with medical needs in school sits with them. Either DD has an IHCP that wasn’t followed, or it needs updating now we’re heading into autumn/winter, or she needs one written. Once you know which of these is the case here, then you know what outcome you are looking for from the meeting (IHCP reissued to staff with clear reminder/instruction to follow it, her IHCP to be reviewed then reissued, or an IHCP to be written).

School is responsible for writing and reviewing the IHCP, using information from Health, in this case a report or letter from her paediatrician (not GP) - you will need to provide the report if you have one or give consent for the paediatrician to share your DD's relevant medical information with school. DD needs to know what she is to do instead of PE - most likely to go to another class or to a particular member of staff during the lesson.

Whether anyone else's child should have been outdoors for this session is for their parents to take up, and there may well be days when the weather is suitable for most healthy children to be outdoors, but not for your DD and you need to get this documented so there is no ambiguity.

Wheresmymoneytree · 12/09/2022 20:38

I have cold induced asthma, it was no issue until I got covid this time last year and has since been significantly more noticeable with me relying on an inhaler more.

I am a teacher and we are still having to keep windows open. My classroom is already cold, I couldn’t imagine sitting there in wet clothes, it’s not just mildly uncomfortable.

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 20:36

Motherchicken · 12/09/2022 20:15

So did she have a coat? Was she allowed to wear it? Did she wear it?
Did she have waterproofs in school that she used when walking to school? Does her healthcare plan state that she must be kept inside a warm at all times? What special arrangements does it say should be made for her?
Does the school regularly do PE outside in all weather? My DCs school used to say no bad weather just bad clothing - or something along those lines.

Yes, she had a waterproof coat. No, they weren't allowed to wear coats. Yes, she had her coat and wellies. No, it doesn't state she must be kept inside and warm at all times. In terms of P.E the plan is for her P.E teachers to be aware that she has lost a lot of fitness/has weakened muscles and struggles with breathing - cold air can affect this. She will most probably not be able to take part without breaks. They need to allow her to rest when she needs it. Now tell me how she can do that in the pouring rain! The plan also details her anxiety - so she would be very anxious speaking up for herself with this P.E teacher who she barely knows.

They have done P.E in drizzle before but not full on rain. If I'd known it was a possibility then I suppose I could have made sure the plan said no P.E for her in the pouring rain. But firstly, that had never happened before (they would always have indoor P.E if it rained) and secondly, I thought the P.E teacher would have some common sense.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 20:25

Plantstrees · 12/09/2022 19:57

I always hated PE because I completely numb fingers and toes in the cold so I do sympathise and I agree that PE teachers can be rather sadistic.

However, I believe that the myth that cold and wet reduces immunity has been completely debunked. If anything, research shows that getting cold boosts the immune system. The only reason people catch more colds in winter is because the virus itself thrives in cold weather. It has nothing to do with the individual getting cold.

People with post-viral illnesses have many problems with the cold. Their bodies often struggle to maintain temperature and when they get cold it can be hard to warm up. This leads to the cold having a larger effect on them and this can include reducing immunity. Getting cold can also lead to flare ups of their symptoms.

OP posts:
SproutsAtChristmas · 12/09/2022 20:23

@carefullycourageous 🤣🤣🤣🤣

No one likes a PE teacher clearly! Maybe I'm very fortunate who I know in the profession or maybe I should just give in and find a job that the nation likes more 🤣

Motherchicken · 12/09/2022 20:15

So did she have a coat? Was she allowed to wear it? Did she wear it?
Did she have waterproofs in school that she used when walking to school? Does her healthcare plan state that she must be kept inside a warm at all times? What special arrangements does it say should be made for her?
Does the school regularly do PE outside in all weather? My DCs school used to say no bad weather just bad clothing - or something along those lines.

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 20:12

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 12/09/2022 19:55

Where do you think the PE teacher was in all of this.....getting wet themselves! The kids don't do PE alone so why complain about getting wet to the person who was also wet at the time.

He was sheltering in the woodland area! And I'm sure he did get a bit wet and then changed into dry clothes for his journey home. While the DC had to go back for the rest of class wet, then had to sit in the hall for the information afternoon, then had to walk home.. wet!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 20:08

WheatShreds · 12/09/2022 19:38

If this is primary perhaps this p.e. teacher is in fact a bought in sports coach who is used as ppa cover rather than a qualified teacher.
In my experience as a teacher, they are often very young and, sorry but a bit wet behind the ears. It's probably a communication failure between the teacher and the coach.

Also - secondary P.E. teachers for me, nasty, evil bastards and utter, utter twats. I'm sure the one on here is nice and means well but there is definitely a type.

The P.E teachers are all 'specialists'. So maybe a sports coach? It is not her class teacher who has been very supportive and didn't seem happy about his decision. Her class teacher was actually in training when it happened. So yes, maybe he is a bit wet behind the ears as well as the poor kids being wet everywhere!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 20:03

Irridescantshimmmer · 12/09/2022 19:33

It makes no sense that your daughter who has long covid, is being forced to do PE especially as I am presuming she is not getting enough oxygen into her lungs.

Let alone to force the poor girl to get soaked in a down pour.

I think she should have been exempt from PE, and the same for other kids with the same condition.

She didn't do P.E for over 6 months. However, as she is improving, we decided with support from her paediatrician and thought talking to school to put a plan in place for her to join in a bit as much as her Long Covid allowed. This teacher has shown he obviously doesn't give a damn about any of that. Do P.E teachers not have to do risk assessments? My mind honestly boggles as to how he thought this was ok!

OP posts:
Plantstrees · 12/09/2022 19:57

I always hated PE because I completely numb fingers and toes in the cold so I do sympathise and I agree that PE teachers can be rather sadistic.

However, I believe that the myth that cold and wet reduces immunity has been completely debunked. If anything, research shows that getting cold boosts the immune system. The only reason people catch more colds in winter is because the virus itself thrives in cold weather. It has nothing to do with the individual getting cold.

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 19:57

Daisybuttercup12345 · 12/09/2022 19:21

Go over PE teacher's head to the headteacher.
I'd be getter a doctors letter too.

I will be. They already have letters.

OP posts:
WeeWillyWinkie9 · 12/09/2022 19:55

Aubriella · 12/09/2022 16:34

YANBU at all. Would all these adults like to sit in wet kit and make the journey home in it? I doubt it.

Where do you think the PE teacher was in all of this.....getting wet themselves! The kids don't do PE alone so why complain about getting wet to the person who was also wet at the time.

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 19:54

justfiveminutes · 12/09/2022 19:10

I wouldn't care that they had to run on muddy ground but I don't think they should be playing basketball in the 'pouring rain' - a bit of drizzle would be fine, caught in an unexpected downpour for a few minutes would be unavoidable. But actually taking them outside in heavy rain for an entire lesson is not ok and wouldn't happen at our school.

However, I am sympathetic to PE teachers because they do get shit day in, day out from precious parents wanting to excuse their children from PE lessons for the most spurious of reasons. And I think that must be annoying - child says they can't do sport unless it's a Thursday in May, light breeze, 18-22 degrees only, when in peak physical fitness. Teacher quite rightly tells them to get on with it. Parent complains.

The reason I mention the muddy ground was that my DD was slipping in it.

My DD's Long Covid has been fully documented at school with me providing all updates from her paediatrician. She has an Education plan with all sorts of details including about P.E. If based on that the P.E teacher thinks they can just tell my child 'to get on with it' then they deserve all the complaints I will be making about them.

OP posts: