Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Palace requests mourners to stop leaving stuff like marmalade sandwiches

284 replies

Sparklybutold · 12/09/2022 14:55

So the palace has now told people to stop leaving marmalade sarnies and such...

Those who thought it was ok the first time still think it's ok? Or now the palace acknowledges how ‘unsustainable’ it is change your opinion?

FWIW. It was idiotic the first time and still is.

OP posts:
sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 18:25

Donation bins for food banks would have been great.

But I think people would have still brought flowers. It's part of death in so many countries.

Ifrozethehoumous · 13/09/2022 18:24

Cut flowers are flown in from heaven-knows-where and then are wrapped in reams of plastic; all damaging to the environment. Large bins for food bank donations would be better - or stuff for the homeless.

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 18:20

Yes, roll on next Tuesday.

indeed

Sparklingbrook · 13/09/2022 18:19

menopausalbloat · 13/09/2022 18:13

I have no problem with how people are choosing to mourn. I can't wait for it all to be over though. I was hoping that she would be our last monarch.

Yes, roll on next Tuesday.

menopausalbloat · 13/09/2022 18:13

I have no problem with how people are choosing to mourn. I can't wait for it all to be over though. I was hoping that she would be our last monarch.

limitedperiodonly · 13/09/2022 18:09

If we are being honest we all do things that aren't strictly necessary for survival. Even eating, or at least I hope so. The knowledge that many people exist at subsistence level or below distresses me and I hope every other person. Happily, for most of us there is a line to be drawn between profligacy and penitence and again, if we are being honest most of err away from a diet of bread and water.

Of course the flowers are a waste but they bring joy. To the people who lay them but also and here I am daring to presume the thoughts of the Royal Family because that's not stopping others, to the Queen's children. They might find it disgusting but they haven't said so we can't say either way.

What I can say is that I was moved to tears by the people who sent wreaths to my parents' funerals or just laid a bunch of lilies or freesias in the front garden. It was nothing on this scale but there were a lot of flowers. Some had cellophane on them.

I'was touched but not that surprised at the response to my mum's death because she was very outgoing and had lots of friends. But my dad was a quiet man and I was overwhelmed by how many neighbours wanted to show us how much they cared. But why shouldn't they? My dad was a good man. If they also gave money to research into Alzheimer's, which is what he died of, I'd have been happy. But I don't care because I fucking loved those flowers.

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 18:05

No, we shouldn't keep quiet when people are imposing their faux-grief on others who are genuinely bereft. Where on earth is that acceptable?

Who's imposing their faux grief on others? Just because they're laying flowers? ?? It may also be in remembrance or out of respect.

Why even feign grief? Trying to appropriate someone else's grief is appalling. People didn't used to behave like this. I still shudder at those awful women screeching 'Diaaaaannnna' as her cortege passed. The two boys walking behind it. Horrific day for them and then that.

Well that was 25 years ago. When was it that people didn't behave like "this"?

LetMeSpeak · 13/09/2022 17:58

The best way to honour the Queen is to donate to many of the organisations that she visited during her long reign. Better then buying flowers that will just be thrown in the bin in a few days.

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 17:55

I eat food to stay alive. Hundreds of tonnes of flowers are not necessary to anything, and I doubt they even really serve a purpose by being helpful/comforting to her family. I imagine her family would find the grief process easier if they didn't have to engage with this public spectacle.

It's not insane.

Everything we do has eco impact. Most of it much more than these flowers, so it's pretty disingenuous to bring that to the argument.

We don't just 'eat food to live'.It isn't as basic as that or we wouldn't choose to eat meat, choose to eat more at Christmas, choose to eat foreign foods brought many food miles. But most of us do. The eco impact of that is as much of a choice as our death rituals.

You don't like or approve of this ritual but I can't really think of any rituals in Western Society that doesn't have negative environmental impact. Weddings, Funerals or even Baptisms.

Octomore · 13/09/2022 17:26

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 12:40

It doesn't matter that the flowers themselves get composted. The production, transport and packaging (both for transportation and for sale) of flowers produces just as much waste/emissions as many other industries.

Of course. Just like the food you ate this morning, the heat in your house and the clothes you are wearing.

Apologies if you live a totally self sufficient life and don't use electricity.

Of course it matters that the flowers get composted. It's a very positive way of dealing with them. The flower mulch from Diana's tributes were used on Kensington Gardens.

This argument is insane.

I eat food to stay alive. Hundreds of tonnes of flowers are not necessary to anything, and I doubt they even really serve a purpose by being helpful/comforting to her family. I imagine her family would find the grief process easier if they didn't have to engage with this public spectacle.

The fact is that piling hundreds of tonnes of anything (teddies, marmalade, flowers..) up as part of a public spectacle will always be inherently wasteful in a way that e.g. eating a marmalade sandwich is not.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 13/09/2022 17:24

Wishyfishy · 12/09/2022 16:40

It’s so bloody weird. The queen agreed to take part in a short Paddington skit, just as she did with James Bond in 2012. Why is she apparently forevermore linked to Paddington?
Leaving a James Bond book or a martini would be no weirder than a marmalade sandwich.

She'd probably have preferred the martini. Grin

I haven't seen anybody leaving a bottle of Dubonnet yet, but give it time...

Octomore · 13/09/2022 17:20

I still shudder at those awful women screeching 'Diaaaaannnna' as her cortege passed. The two boys walking behind it.

Yes, exactly.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 13/09/2022 17:08

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 12:34

*was significant of people's need to feel a part of something bigger than themselves. But genuine grief? No.

I don't think it's reasonable to equate the sadness and vague sense of loss that one might feel when a public figure dies with the raw, wounding grief that people often feel at the death of a close loved one.*

I doubt it's the same feeling but so what ? I thought we were over telling other people what they felt?

"people's need to feel part of something bigger " Absolutely yes. And?

No, we shouldn't keep quiet when people are imposing their faux-grief on others who are genuinely bereft. Where on earth is that acceptable?

Why even feign grief? Trying to appropriate someone else's grief is appalling. People didn't used to behave like this. I still shudder at those awful women screeching 'Diaaaaannnna' as her cortege passed. The two boys walking behind it. Horrific day for them and then that.

Is it all down to social media and the prevalence of phones? Perhaps, but I know that if I'd been trying to get my face on camera as so many feel it their right to do, I'd be shamed. Grief is for the bereaved and nobody else should be making it about themselves.

I felt a jolt when I heard that the queen had died, I'm not a royalist but she has been part of the fabric of all of my lifetime and I feel sorry that she's gone as I believe she was a positive model for UK PLC. If we have a royal family then the queen was about as good as it gets. To her family she was so much more.

limitedperiodonly · 13/09/2022 16:37

@carrotsandpeaass I live in Westminster Tons of rubbish and food waste is discarded by residents, workers, tourists and hospitality businesses every day in bins and on the street and is cleared away as if by elves overnight. So if I told you that I'm relaxed about this stuff being left in the relatively small area in front of Buckingham Palace and in Green Park until next Tuesday at the latest would it make you feel better for your sake and of course as a local resident, mine? After all, though I realise this is a wider environmental issue for us all, I'm the one who is directly affected. I can report there are a lot of flowers but not as many as for Diana. Like then, the overwhelming smell is of lilies and they are starting to go over but as I said, there are no rats yet.

carrotsandpeaass · 13/09/2022 13:40

I will attract rats, and cause lots of litter and rotting food in the street.

And marmalade sandwiches are actually Paddington's thing, the queen wasn't exactly known for her love of marmalade or keeping sandwiches in her hat.
I understand the nod to the scene she did with Paddington but it's not really relevant to her on a huge scale.

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 13:26

The food that I've eaten today and the heating that I use in the winter keep me healthy and alive. It would be different if I were setting out a trolley-load (or 100 trolley-loads) of food in my kitchen just to look at and then throwing it away after a week.

Probably more equivalent to your Christmas food trolley when you don't just buy what you need to stay alive. You buy things that help you celebrate.

bunnytailbreakfast · 13/09/2022 13:11

TwinGirlsOnTheWay · 13/09/2022 12:49

Ridiculous. I hope everyone who is leaving them has also donated to a food bank

Of course they won't be - how else would they humblebrag to their followers on Facebook and Instagram about how kind they are without a perfectly coordinated photograph?

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 13:06

If the flowers are going to be left, then it's obviously far better that they be composted than not; but it seems quite bizarre to me to be cutting down tons of living flowers across the world, transporting them from across the world to London (or wherever), leaving them for a week and then mulching them to use as compost to help flowers grow!

I suppose his thread could be one on the sustainably of the flower industry. It isn't.

Or even the sustainability of the funeral industry or the sustainability of the entire Royal Funeral. It won't be.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/09/2022 12:59

Could it be that the optics of getting at least as large a pile as Princess Diana might be important here?

Maybe that does matter to some people, but how do you even measure that? Did somebody think to make a clear, lasting flood-level-style mark back in 1997, so they know what they have to 'beat' now?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/09/2022 12:55

Of course it matters that the flowers get composted. It's a very positive way of dealing with them. The flower mulch from Diana's tributes were used on Kensington Gardens.

If the flowers are going to be left, then it's obviously far better that they be composted than not; but it seems quite bizarre to me to be cutting down tons of living flowers across the world, transporting them from across the world to London (or wherever), leaving them for a week and then mulching them to use as compost to help flowers grow!

The food that I've eaten today and the heating that I use in the winter keep me healthy and alive. It would be different if I were setting out a trolley-load (or 100 trolley-loads) of food in my kitchen just to look at and then throwing it away after a week. I can see a link between omnivores killing animals in order to eat their meat and use their hides for shoes - which a lot of people still find ethically objectionable - and somebody going to Kenya to shoot endangered species, for no other reason than to brag about it and be Charlie Big Potatoes in their social circles, which the vast, vast majority of people would heartily condemn.

They also had the 'Ash for Cash' scheme in NI a few years ago, where people were effectively financially rewarded for burning off as much fuel as possible, without needing or even actually using it for anybody's benefit.

I get that people who love flowers derive great pleasure and enjoyment in looking at and sniffing a pretty bunch for the few days before they die - and thus do consider that a very worthwhile use of them; but it's a bit difficult to do that when they're at the bottom of a great big heap in a park.

TwinGirlsOnTheWay · 13/09/2022 12:49

Ridiculous. I hope everyone who is leaving them has also donated to a food bank

GlitterB0mb · 13/09/2022 12:42

BestZebbie · 12/09/2022 18:14

Could it be that the optics of getting at least as large a pile as Princess Diana might be important here?

This in spades

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 12:40

It doesn't matter that the flowers themselves get composted. The production, transport and packaging (both for transportation and for sale) of flowers produces just as much waste/emissions as many other industries.

Of course. Just like the food you ate this morning, the heat in your house and the clothes you are wearing.

Apologies if you live a totally self sufficient life and don't use electricity.

Of course it matters that the flowers get composted. It's a very positive way of dealing with them. The flower mulch from Diana's tributes were used on Kensington Gardens.

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 12:34

*was significant of people's need to feel a part of something bigger than themselves. But genuine grief? No.

I don't think it's reasonable to equate the sadness and vague sense of loss that one might feel when a public figure dies with the raw, wounding grief that people often feel at the death of a close loved one.*

I doubt it's the same feeling but so what ? I thought we were over telling other people what they felt?

"people's need to feel part of something bigger " Absolutely yes. And?

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 12:24

I think many death rituals are for the benefit of those doing them. And I don't see that as a problem. Apart from the religious aspects that's what they're for.

There is healing power and comfort in observed rituals and being part of community. Whether it's about death or not. And flowers ( and other items ) have been left as a death ritual forever.

Each tribute is one tribute. More is not better but there are more , because literally hundreds of thousands feel a connection.

Swipe left for the next trending thread