Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Palace requests mourners to stop leaving stuff like marmalade sandwiches

284 replies

Sparklybutold · 12/09/2022 14:55

So the palace has now told people to stop leaving marmalade sarnies and such...

Those who thought it was ok the first time still think it's ok? Or now the palace acknowledges how ‘unsustainable’ it is change your opinion?

FWIW. It was idiotic the first time and still is.

OP posts:
Autumn61 · 14/09/2022 07:07

Excellent idea. No rotting flowers wrapped in plastic but tins of food, dry goods, flour, rice etc.
Now that would be a proper and useful tribute .

sunglassesonthetable · 14/09/2022 04:55

Yes, most households will spend more money and damage the environment more with their choices of Christmas food and drink, but they don't buy 20 households' worth of luxury comestibles; nor do they just leave what they do buy outside the back door to forget about and leave to rot.

Each floral tribute is left by one person. They arrive one by one. No one person is bringing ALL the flowers just as you wouldn't have to buy 20 trolleys at Christmas to damage the environment a bit more.

They are being left in a significant place as a death ritual. All flowers will rot. It is so different to being left outside the back door to rot.

I find the eco argument pretty lame as I think there is so much more going on every single day, by everyone of us, that has a worse impact than the leaving of these flowers, that will eventually be mulched for fertiliser.

Death rituals are important to people. That is what people are choosing to spend their money on. On this thread those people are brainless, performative, tasteless, death tourists but nevertheless they're important to them.

So the idea that this is "a pointless " thing to do is very much about how you personally view the laying of flowers. For many it is hugely significant . And those vast piles of flowers which are not just in London, actually mean something.

user1477391263 · 14/09/2022 03:19

From Twitter:

"The whole Paddington thing is what happens when you once mention to a relative that you like ladybirds so get ladybird themed presents for the rest of time - but for a whole country"
twitter.com/salvey1/status/1569258130323685381

limitedperiodonly · 14/09/2022 01:34

Lulusays · 13/09/2022 21:50

Lots of people agree with my opinion that it’s gratuitous, unnecessary and wasteful. You just happen to have a different opinion. I don’t literally mean they should donate to charity, I mean really, just please do anything other than buy utter shite to leave in the streets. So yes, I guess actually you’re absolutely right, I am rather dictating that they shouldn’t buy and leave crap as rubbish in the streets. It might well be cleaned up by Tuesday, but to where?? Landfill is where, to rot into the water table. I just really think it is totally unnecessary and I wish someone in a position of power had had the nouse and foresight to incentivise people towards a more productive outpouring into something positive and productive. The Queen and much of The Firm are deeply tied to numerous good causes. It’s a lost opportunity and a shame. But happy to respect your opinion that people can spunk their cash on what they want, just a shame it has ramifications for others.

@Lulusays do you know what the word "literally" means? Would you like me to explain it to you?. Probably not but I'm going to. It means exactly as it should happen.

You said people should donate to charity rather than buying flowers because that's exactly what you wanted to happen. You didn't explain why or specify any charities even though I asked you. Why do you think you have the right to tell other people what to do especially when you don't know anything about them?

Even more outrageous is that when I told you I live 10 minutes from Buckingham Palace and described the situation as entirely manageable you said that I just have a different opinion to you and that lots of people agree with you. How breathtaking is your arrogance? I would not dream of telling you what it was like on your doorstep so why do you think you should tell me?

I don't share your faith that the Queen and The Firm as you call it were or are deeply tied to good causes. I know they are committed to saving tax but that's not the same thing.

I'm not a Monarchist but I do think that the little people, and that includes me, should be allowed to do what we want to do within reason and the law. And if that means laying a bunch of chrysanths at the gates of Buckingham Palace because it will piss off mealy mouthed sneerers who think they somehow know better then I'm going to get down the petrol station first thing. I will take the cellophane off and dispose of it responsibly. I have no idea where it's going to go from there. If you know the best way to dispose of plastic waste which I guess you also use then do tell.

limitedperiodonly · 14/09/2022 00:39

Ifrozethehoumous · 13/09/2022 19:52

Oh thank you SO much for telling me where the flowers come from - it clarifies my point but I’ll stick with the coffee ta.

@Ifrozethehoumous That was to me,wasn't it? Because you asked where all the flowers were coming from and I told you they mainly come from Kenya along with lots of other fruit and vegetables that you and me and most other people in the UK consume. So how does that clarify whatever point it is you're struggling to make?

Where do you think your coffee comes from? Kenya or other east African countries. Or West Africa or Central or South America. It depends what beans you like but there are going to be a lot of air miles. You are just as culpable as me or any of the people laying flowers for the Queen. The difference is that you don't know that and appear to think coffee grows in England.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/09/2022 23:59

We don't just 'eat food to live'.It isn't as basic as that or we wouldn't choose to eat meat, choose to eat more at Christmas, choose to eat foreign foods brought many food miles. But most of us do. The eco impact of that is as much of a choice as our death rituals.

I don't think that's properly comparing like with like, though. It's not so much making a more profligate/luxury choice than the basic essential one, but pure pointless wastage. Cut flowers are not essential and have an environmental cost; but many people enjoy looking at them and having a bunch in a vase at home for a few days - and I completely get this popular choice; whereas this is just immediately stacking them up in a pile where they will be buried by somebody else's in a few minutes' time and leaving them.

Yes, most households will spend more money and damage the environment more with their choices of Christmas food and drink, but they don't buy 20 households' worth of luxury comestibles; nor do they just leave what they do buy outside the back door to forget about and leave to rot.

Toooldforthisshit49 · 13/09/2022 22:45

@Sparklybutold I take it you're not a royalist from your post?

Dashel · 13/09/2022 22:32

Sparklingbrook · 13/09/2022 19:17

I'm not sure how much marmalade foodbanks actually need.

I don’t know but I’m up North well away from where any marmalade left would be donated to. I really like the idea of buying some marmalade and jam for my local food bank tomorrow.

I find it strange that people want to spend so much collectively on flowers. It’s totally up to them of course, but I think in more practical terms and would rather do something more useful.

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 22:25

*Why are Londoners expected to put up with this - essentially people coming in to central London and leaving flowers, marmalade or whatever shite they feel like because ‘it’s for the queen” or because they want to ‘be part of history” in some minuscule way. Not to mention the burden this places on London’s transport, policing, etc

I’m going to remember this thread and bring it up next time someone from Cornwall, Norfolk or similar complains about the hordes of Londoners coming to their part of the country on holiday and leaving their rubbish.*

And the Lying in State and the Funeral and then the Coronation! Think of the burdens on the transport, policing. Fancy all those little people from the provinces wanting to be part of it!

You know what - tough s*. Could you sound more up yourself?

And littering rubbish on holiday is absolutely not the same as leaving flowers as act of mourning in a designated spot. God alive.

EugeneLevysEyebrow · 13/09/2022 22:17

Why are Londoners expected to put up with this - essentially people coming in to central London and leaving flowers, marmalade or whatever shite they feel like because ‘it’s for the queen” or because they want to ‘be part of history” in some minuscule way. Not to mention the burden this places on London’s transport, policing, etc

I’m going to remember this thread and bring it up next time someone from Cornwall, Norfolk or similar complains about the hordes of Londoners coming to their part of the country on holiday and leaving their rubbish.

Shauny098 · 13/09/2022 22:02

Guiltycat · 12/09/2022 15:24

Anyone genuinely grieving for someone that they have never met, who survived to a very old age in good health and in whose life every need was met is completely batshit.

Thousands of people died that day. Elderly people alone, scared and worried about money. Children with cancer. Mothers who grafted every day of their life worried about what would happen to their children.

If the Queen is the only stranger someone is ‘grieving’ over then personally I just assume they are an attention seeker who tends to jump on any passing bandwagon and not really think anything through.

Love it, well said 👍🏼….are we allowed freedom of speech now or do we still have to be “respectful” to ppl who think we are parasites and would never read our opinion anyway!

Ineke · 13/09/2022 21:53

Watching the crowds file past the Lying in State of The Queen in Scotland I was impressed by seeing that no one had their phone out taking pictures. Then I heard that the public had been asked not to, also asked not to flower throw. They didn’t. So the people laying flowers good easily have been instructed to not leave food items, soft toys or flower wrapping. Just Flowers. Yes, it’s wasteful but also is an act that is part of the grieving process. But definitely, no plastic. Easy to ask, easy to comply with.

Lulusays · 13/09/2022 21:50

Lots of people agree with my opinion that it’s gratuitous, unnecessary and wasteful. You just happen to have a different opinion. I don’t literally mean they should donate to charity, I mean really, just please do anything other than buy utter shite to leave in the streets. So yes, I guess actually you’re absolutely right, I am rather dictating that they shouldn’t buy and leave crap as rubbish in the streets. It might well be cleaned up by Tuesday, but to where?? Landfill is where, to rot into the water table. I just really think it is totally unnecessary and I wish someone in a position of power had had the nouse and foresight to incentivise people towards a more productive outpouring into something positive and productive. The Queen and much of The Firm are deeply tied to numerous good causes. It’s a lost opportunity and a shame. But happy to respect your opinion that people can spunk their cash on what they want, just a shame it has ramifications for others.

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 21:29

I’m pretty sure most of these people aren't genuinely upset, it’s a weird media circus of Death Tourists. Anyway, each to their own, I just think it’s a strange frenzy of peer pressure induced false grief.

It's not just about being sad. It's also about paying your respects, honouring someone and being part of something, including history.

You might not like the tradition of laying flowers but slaying all those 100, 1000s of people as Death Tourists is so weirdly arrogant.

limitedperiodonly · 13/09/2022 21:28

@Lulusays you dictated to people when you said "donate to charity" and presumably meant: "and don't ;leave flowers". Or is it okay with you if people leave flowers as long as they donate to charity? And which charities would be okay with you?

I'd rather people didn't leave litter, especially since it's right near my home. But people who come to this part of London leave litter. I'm always sweeping it out of my front garden. The good thing is that is very efficiently cleared up in the rest of the borough.

The litter generated by this is as nothing to the amount I pay Westminster Council through my taxes to clean up the litter generated by tourists to this borough at all other times.

I know you didn';t say it but I'm patiently waiting for two handwringers about rats to reply to me because I said it wasn't a problem because it is in a small area and will all be gone first thing Tuesday morning.

If I'm not bothered why are you and they?

CallMeLinda · 13/09/2022 21:27

The first one was sweet. But they will attract rats etc.
RF should have encouraged people to donate to a named charity in lieu of flowers. The Queen was patron of loads, though, so how do you choose which one?

Lulusays · 13/09/2022 21:03

limitedperiodonly I’m not dictating what people spend their money on. I’m asking them to think about the reality of what they’re doing. And especially not to come into London and spread landfill trash all over it. It’s insanity. It’s littering. It’s wrong. We have such issues with pigeons, rats and foxes. Why you’d think it’s ok to leave plastic wrapped sandwiches and teddies and cellophane is beyond me. I’m pretty sure most of these people aren't genuinely upset, it’s a weird media circus of Death Tourists. Anyway, each to their own, I just think it’s a strange frenzy of peer pressure induced false grief.

Berrietos · 13/09/2022 20:43

I hope this new awareness of plastic waste will apply to everyday life, particularly to graveyards. There is always so much litter around graveyards - plastic wrapping and the fake flowers that have been blown around. No team of "royal gardeners" to clean up all that rubbish.

twinmum2007 · 13/09/2022 20:36

I'm genuinely curious about the Remuneration angle here? Who do you think should get remuneration? How would one go about working out who would get the money? And how much? Just can't get my head around the logistics of it.

ThistleTits · 13/09/2022 20:25

@EscapeRoomToTheSun fantastic idea.

Littlepicker · 13/09/2022 19:55

I do believe the world has finally gone mad 🤦🏻‍♀️

Ifrozethehoumous · 13/09/2022 19:52

Oh thank you SO much for telling me where the flowers come from - it clarifies my point but I’ll stick with the coffee ta.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 13/09/2022 19:52

Sparklybutold · 12/09/2022 15:21

@sevenbyseven @LatteCappucino

They should have done this but they won't because it wouldn't serve them the same. They want the outward show of affection as it supports their agenda. The RF continue to exist owing to peoples complete blind admiration of them.

Maybe it’s not blind admiration. Maybe they just like having a monarchy, like the history and pomp and ceremony that go with it.
I agree with the sandwiches encouraging vermin but how people grieve and whether or not they decide to buy flowers is up to them. I would happily give to a food bank but for a funeral, I’d want to buy flowers. Two separate issues. You need to step down from that high horse.

giveovernate · 13/09/2022 19:40

bluesapphire48 · 13/09/2022 19:33

How stupid! Do people think Prince Harry is going to eat their silly marmalade sandwich? Or maybe it's for Kate. Or Camilla.

P.S. They should gather up all the flowers and give them to hospitals and rest homes.

PPS flowers are often not allowed in hospitals!

PPPS do you think nurses and staff have time to find endless vases for these flowers?

PPPS Who is this "they" that should be collecting all these flowers are driving round London etc distributing them?

Some people are even more stupid than those leaving the sandwiches.....

sunglassesonthetable · 13/09/2022 19:36

*How stupid! Do people think Prince Harry is going to eat their silly marmalade sandwich? Or maybe it's for Kate. Or Camilla.

P.S. They should gather up all the flowers and give them to hospitals and rest homes.*

Is it chilly up there in the Superior seats ?