Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It seems people can no longer be bothered with adverbs - AIBU?

129 replies

Q2C4 · 12/09/2022 10:14

I keep seeing comments online in which people confused adjectives and adverbs. For example:
"He's done amazing to get this far."
"It's made different to other ones."
"She talks so loud!"

Can people no longer be bothered to write out the extra "ly" which is usually required to turn an adjective into an adverb? Or don't people know the difference?

YABU - English grammar is hard and teaching is patchy. Stop being pedantic.
YANBU - social media & smart phone auto correct have made people lazy and they should make the effort!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/09/2022 12:34

‘There is’ with a plural is my pet peeve at the moment.
It’s been spreading everywhere like sodding COVID.

Lima1 · 14/09/2022 11:42

BlueThingie · 12/09/2022 14:05

This is a regional variant and totally normal in much of Ireland, among other places.

I am Irish and I have never heard of any of these phrases. Definitely not normal in much of Ireland.

The phrase “I’m full of cold” makes no sense 😕

Thiswayorthatway · 14/09/2022 11:11

SAT’s is correct punctuation, you use an apostrophe for a plural of abbreviations and numbers, e.g, the 1980’s.

5foot5 · 14/09/2022 10:58

Q2C4 · 14/09/2022 08:03

@CaramelTwirl why is it condescending to highlight what appears to be declining levels of literacy? Should we not take more pride in our language? Time and time again I see examples of those speaking English as a second language having a better grasp of grammar than native speakers. Why is it condescending to be concerned about this? As other PPs have said, poor writing skills can cost an applicant a job.

If there were a similar rise in mathematical errors, would I be condescending in pointing those out?

Broadly I agree with you but I don't think that your last point about mathematical errors quite holds up.

Generally there will be an unarguable "right" answer in a day-to-day situation requiring numeracy skills and, in a situation where somebody proposes the wrong answer, it would not be considered condescending to correct them but absurd not to. For example, you buy five items costing £25 each and the vendor tried to charge you £150. Well, you would hardly pay up just to avoid offending him or hurting his feelings.

But literacy is governed by rules which have just been accepted as correct over time and if people apply these rules incorrectly one can still continue without the need to point out the error.

So you say "She talks so loudly" is better English usage than "She talks so loud" but nevertheless everyone understands what is meant by the latter.

However 5 x 25 IS 125. It just is. (Unless you are working in base 8 in which case it is 151 so in my example the vendor would actually be closer to the correct answer, but nobody would do that, would they?)

Q2C4 · 14/09/2022 09:39

PAFMO · 14/09/2022 08:31

We could, of course, also question your own use of a singular verb with a plural noun, your lack of capital letters and the wrong preposition following an adjective.
But that would be churlish. Fun, though.

I'm glad you enjoyed it! 😁

OP posts:
Q2C4 · 14/09/2022 09:39

@PAFMO so in all cases, people have been aware of the grammatically correct usage but have chosen to use something else?

OP posts:
Sunnidaze · 14/09/2022 08:46

goldfinchonthelawn · 12/09/2022 11:11

YANBU.

The one that makes me cringe though I am starting to realise the shift is probably permanent, is people using the past tense instead of present participle.

e.g. 'it needs mended' instead of 'it needs mending' or 'it needs to be mended.'
It's so lazy and I know this is snobbish but it sounds so uneducated. I always wonder if they ever listened at school.

This drives me nuts! For what it's worth, I live in Australia, this seems to be an English thing, I've only ever come across it on this site.

PAFMO · 14/09/2022 08:31

We could, of course, also question your own use of a singular verb with a plural noun, your lack of capital letters and the wrong preposition following an adjective.
But that would be churlish. Fun, though.

PAFMO · 14/09/2022 08:29

Q2C4 · 14/09/2022 08:03

@CaramelTwirl why is it condescending to highlight what appears to be declining levels of literacy? Should we not take more pride in our language? Time and time again I see examples of those speaking English as a second language having a better grasp of grammar than native speakers. Why is it condescending to be concerned about this? As other PPs have said, poor writing skills can cost an applicant a job.

If there were a similar rise in mathematical errors, would I be condescending in pointing those out?

The accusations of condescension come because almost all of the words, phrases, and usages on this thread that irritate people are NOT mistakes. They just reflect different usage.

To repeat what I said about "math". The singular form was in common usage in Britain and America. A couple of centuries ago, for unknown reasons, British English began adding a random S.
Yet on every thread like this, posters go on about how irritating the American usage is. Etc.

Q2C4 · 14/09/2022 08:03

@CaramelTwirl why is it condescending to highlight what appears to be declining levels of literacy? Should we not take more pride in our language? Time and time again I see examples of those speaking English as a second language having a better grasp of grammar than native speakers. Why is it condescending to be concerned about this? As other PPs have said, poor writing skills can cost an applicant a job.

If there were a similar rise in mathematical errors, would I be condescending in pointing those out?

OP posts:
NovaDeltas · 13/09/2022 12:36

Some people are just thick. Can't use the correct 'there/they're/their', can't use apostrophes, and write how they speak with rubbish like "he dun dead his lol luv u hun"

No point beating around the bush. Coddling people and making out that literacy is optional has led to a class of people whose written word is next to impossible to understand. "sleepin wiv da angles hun xx"

ComtesseDeSpair · 13/09/2022 12:32

goldfinchonthelawn · 13/09/2022 11:46

The author of every book you cited knows exactly how to write and speak in 'correct' English where the need arises. They don't write in those vernaculars because they have no choice. They are highly skilled at judicious use of idiomatic language for literary effect.

Yes, this is correct, though not the point: the OP and others were claiming that people using vernacular or non-standard English makes it too difficult to understand what they are trying to say, and this is demonstrably not the case: most people are adept at code-switching in both speech and comprehension, and the success of all of those novels is evidence of that. Nobody pretends they can’t understand The Color Purple because it’s written in AAVE. Likewise, nobody hears somebody say “she talks so loud” or “it needs mended” and has any doubt what the speaker means.

The Queen’s death and the many replays of her early speeches over the past few days has been an excellent demonstration that, even if people think it does or should, language doesn’t stand still. Even the Queen didn’t, by the end of her life, speak with the same vocabulary, cadence or grammar patterns as she did in her early years. The rest of us certainly don’t, and I think most of us would agree that we’d sound ridiculous if we tried to.

They say that history is the version of events told by the victorious, and I believe similar is true of language. Few people advocate resisting revision of our understanding or interpretation of history because the original version is that commonly accepted by those in positions of power and therefore superior.

BlueThingie · 13/09/2022 11:47

BlueThingie · 13/09/2022 11:43

@UniBallEye Not "it's need mended" but "it needs mended", "the baby needs fed" etc.

Very common in the north of Ireland and in Northern Ireland (although my colleague from Limerick also uses it). This fits with it also being used in parts of Scotland. There are examples in the OED, hang on...

This lists the usage as Scottish and Irish English and regional in the US.

It seems people can no longer be bothered with adverbs - AIBU?
goldfinchonthelawn · 13/09/2022 11:46

The author of every book you cited knows exactly how to write and speak in 'correct' English where the need arises. They don't write in those vernaculars because they have no choice. They are highly skilled at judicious use of idiomatic language for literary effect.

goldfinchonthelawn · 13/09/2022 11:44

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/09/2022 14:00

But part of me feels irritated that people aren't taught how to use their own language correctly at school.

I think “their own language” is an interesting but problematic concept. Who owns a language? Who ultimately got to decide which the correct way to use it was? Language exists to communicate, among other things, our experience of ourselves and our perception of the world. On that basis, why would a young black woman from a West African background living in Hackney, a white middle aged man from Surrey, an elderly man who’s lived all his life on Orkney, a Bradford-based woman who was born and learned English in India, an American expat woman and so on, all speak and write in exactly the same way? Standard English and Received Pronunciation reflect the language of a group which has always been a minority in the UK and is even more so now.

When we talk about “correct English” what we really mean is the English which was decided as the right way to speak and write by a small subset of the population at a time when this subset were considered (and considered themselves) superior. Trainspotting, Last Exit to Brooklyn, Their Eyes Were Watching God, The Color Purple, A Clockwork Orange to name just a few are no less great novels for being written in non-standard English; indeed, it’s the fact that they’re so written which contributes to them being great novels. They represent the usage of language reflecting who we are and how we live our lives.

I understand what you are saying. But I can't help being aware that there is a language common to those who are superior, in power, and by denying access to that language to ordinary people, by not correcting 'I seen, I done' etc we are pigeon-holing them. I think it is part of social mobility ethics to teach pupils how those in power speak and encouraging them to speak that way too until they are confident in the usage and can differentiate between grammatically correct common usage and vernacular. They then are armed with the knowledge should they choose to use it. To not know the impact of saying 'I would of' is disempowering. Fine to use it knowingly as a regional or social dialect that represents your roots and to converse with people you grew up with using this language, but know the alternative, know the power it holds socially and feel comfortable conversing on a level with those in power.

BlueThingie · 13/09/2022 11:43

@UniBallEye Not "it's need mended" but "it needs mended", "the baby needs fed" etc.

Very common in the north of Ireland and in Northern Ireland (although my colleague from Limerick also uses it). This fits with it also being used in parts of Scotland. There are examples in the OED, hang on...

BrightYellowDaffodil · 13/09/2022 11:33

People are badly educated. It depends where you live and work if it is socially acceptable. You take note, say nothing, but you don't then hand this person a job presenting or talking about anything of complexity.

I agree. People can say it's pedantry as much as they please (and Stephen Fry is hypocritical on this matter; I've definitely heard him correct others' grammar/language) but if someone presents me with a CV full of errors then they aren't getting an interview. A recent candidate gave an excellent interview and was one of the forerunners but her written test was shocking - poor punctuation, sentences not formed properly, colloquial language used in a formal context.

On MN? Write what you like. In a formal work communication? Sorry, it does matter.

UniBallEye · 13/09/2022 11:30

@BlueThingie I am Irish and I have never, ever heard an Irish person say 'it's need mended' etc, it is far more common to hear someone say 'it needs mending' though.
Where in Ireland are you hearing this being used?
The only person I've encountered using it is from Essex and they also day 'going down shops now' too

Idontknowwhatto · 13/09/2022 11:22

Something that also bugs me is adding an apostrophe and an 's' to the end of grocery shops, much in the manner one would if it was a local corner shop run by Mrs Smith or Mr Singh.

Tesco's
Asda's
Lidl's
Aldi's

Mr Tesco isn't out the back somewhere sorting the stock, nor is Mrs Asda doing out the rota in the staff room.

Nobody ever does this with any other kind of shop.

'Oh yeah, I got a new handbag from Zara's', or 'I got that coat years ago from Topshop's'

Can anyone enlighten me?

NeckFanInSoftPlay · 13/09/2022 11:14

YANBU Americans no longer bother with ed either and that's starting to creep in over here now too. "He's so chill" "He looks so tan" "She was well love" "Then it was stir for about 2 minutes"

Giggorata · 13/09/2022 10:38

I agree with most of the points raised, whether that makes me a grammar nazi or a snob. I’ve always excused the lack of adverbs in snooker commentary, for some reason.
My Scots father didn't use the “needs mended” type of phrase, btw.

SecondsAreTheBest · 13/09/2022 10:16

Yanbu, it grates muchly.

IamEarthymama · 13/09/2022 09:15

pjmasksitsthepjmasks

i totally agree it makes me sad, those poor little ‘to be’!

needs mended etc sound so clunky to me.

Culldesack · 13/09/2022 09:11

Glitterblue · 13/09/2022 03:22

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr These are my pet hates too - along with the ever increasing use of "I seen" and "I done" and "if I would of". Even the teaching assistants in DD's school all use these, and that really annoys me. My best friend is from down south and she moved to the north of England a few years ago. Up until she moved, she hadn't really heard anyone use these and she thought it was a northern thing, but I see Facebook friends from all over the country doing it.

Unacceptable for TAs to get that wrong. I can, however beat that one. I was once work shadowing a teacher, who 'corrected' a student's answer. Question: do you use bare or bear, when asking somebody to be patient? So could you please ---- with me. The student had written bear. I couldn't believe it when the teacher said she was wrong! Shocking.it was one of the only times I ever told a colleague, they were wrong, in front of a student.

gatehouseoffleet · 13/09/2022 08:30

Then there's the faux surprise at being told Mom or high school are actually British terms too

I don't think it's faux, until I used MN I didn't know Mom was used in the West Midlands (and perhaps other areas too).

I did know high school was a UK expression but that was only because there was a high school in a neighbouring town when I was growing up, though it's not called that anymore.