Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Dentists are greedy and disgrace

233 replies

Thisismynamenow · 12/09/2022 09:48

I have a hole in my tooth (thanks pregnancy for the poor teeth!)

My nhs dentist has apparentpy cancelled their nhs contract to go private (without telling patients) and not a single dentist within 20 miles is willing to take on nhs, but everyone can offer same day private appointments.

I know the nhs is underfunded but it's disgusting dentists are allowed to be only private, they should be made to be half nhs!

My tooth is killing me, I can't afford the £400 I've been quoted for the filling (it's a tiny hole, literally a pin hole!) And the hopsitall will only pull it which I don't want. Its annoying me more as i currently have a maternity exemption which I can't use.

Aibu to think dentists are greedy, and that it shouldn't be allowed?

OP posts:
User1563 · 13/09/2022 20:45

@gnilliwdog because they are not allowed to by the nhs contract.

You can’t pick and choose contracts. My practice asked for children only or emergency only contract and were refused.

my children are now seen privately.

It is a shame but I can’t blame the practice they really tried and I am dreading when the children need braces as the only nhs orthodontist within miles and miles had his contract taken back from him.

I have written to my MP but to no avail. Nhs is totally doomed and it is very sad

Alexandra2001 · 13/09/2022 20:43

@gnilliwdog Unless there is wholesale reform of dentistry, training more wont help and where would these highly educated students come from? its not like those with a string of top grade A levels are two a penny.

You'd also need to build more Dental schools, equip them and ensure students had the right mentoring with experienced dentists, whilst practising on us lot!

Sorry but i think dentistry will not improve for many years, if at all, the Brexit thing is purely self inflicted, we got what we wanted.

gnilliwdog · 13/09/2022 20:31

@Alexandra2001 Thanks Brexit, another marvellous benefit. We should remove tuition fees and train more here, perhaps, though I don't see our current government doing that.

Mangolist · 13/09/2022 20:28

TwoMonthsOff · 12/09/2022 18:11

@ForTheLoveOfSleep
MyDentist is a good service from what I hear, it is not extortionate you pay for the treatment you get but not as high as some Private Practices

I've had to go onto MyOptions as I was an NHS patient at MyDentist. I'm paying around £130 for each filling , £125 to recement a fallen out crown and £85 for a clean. I'm lucky I have savings - it will end up being around £1000 for everything, but it's cheaper than fully private and it needs to be done.
It's awful that so many people have lost their cheap dentistry

Alexandra2001 · 13/09/2022 20:27

gnilliwdog · 13/09/2022 20:18

Good to know, though I am not sure we have anything like that here. I think if someone is in excruciating pain and distress, it is wicked to refuse to treat them when you have the skills. I do not expect dentists to have the morals of hedge fund traders. If all dentists had to take on a very small number of NHS patients I am sure it would help, and they could still get rich from private clients.

Even if they did take a few each, it wouldn't really make much overall difference.

Too many, poor mouth hygiene and nothing like the number of Dentists we need.

The British Dental Association have said that Brexit has led to 1000s of EU Dentists leaving the UK, something to do with recognition of qualifications following BJ's deal that he got "done"

bda.org/news-centre/press-releases/Pages/Government-dragging-heels-as-1000s-of-overseas-dentists-left-unable-to-practise-during-access-crisis.aspx

gnilliwdog · 13/09/2022 20:18

Alexandra2001 · 13/09/2022 20:06

Many do, they offer NHS emergency care, a one off appointment.

They also, for free, go into Dental schools that also provide free treatment and over see work done on the general public.

Good to know, though I am not sure we have anything like that here. I think if someone is in excruciating pain and distress, it is wicked to refuse to treat them when you have the skills. I do not expect dentists to have the morals of hedge fund traders. If all dentists had to take on a very small number of NHS patients I am sure it would help, and they could still get rich from private clients.

girlfriend44 · 13/09/2022 20:08

dworky · 12/09/2022 18:19

I do agree they are greedy, surpassed only by vets.

I was going to mention vets.

Alexandra2001 · 13/09/2022 20:06

gnilliwdog · 13/09/2022 19:42

But if dentists are well paid for private work, why can't they keep a limited number of NHS patients on their books as well? I realise this would be charitable work, but dental care is a health necessity so I would have thought dentists might do it out of good will. Why get rid of all NHS patients?

Many do, they offer NHS emergency care, a one off appointment.

They also, for free, go into Dental schools that also provide free treatment and over see work done on the general public.

Alexandra2001 · 13/09/2022 20:03

SecretVictoria · 12/09/2022 10:14

I don’t get this attitude. Mine went private under the Major government. No more NHS dentists appeared in my area under either Blair/Brown.

My DD never had an NHS dentist under Blair, there simply wasn't one nearby but there were some in Cornwall, i had a good job so paid.

Now all of Cornwall & Devon don't have a single NHS Dentist taking on new patients.

The trouble is an nhs dentist get a fixed fee per banded treatment, regardless how long that treatment takes or costs them, so they go private.

The Tories have had 12 years to resolve the issue by paying more but have done nothing, its just got worse, they fucked up every aspect of healthcare, probably deliberately.

Dental students get into huge debt training for 5 years, they have no obligation to do nhs work on the cheap.

sageandbasil · 13/09/2022 20:02

@gnilliwdog did you not see my post about how much dentists pay out! I hope you also work for free

gnilliwdog · 13/09/2022 19:53

@sageandbasil Because if private work is as lucrative as this thread claims, they should want to do it out of common decency. It is essential healthcare. Only morally bankrupt people would refuse to treat anyone on the NHS if they are making plenty of money elsewhere.

sageandbasil · 13/09/2022 19:51

@gnilliwdog why on earth should they do it out of good will? Why should they be out of pocket it's not their responsibility.

gnilliwdog · 13/09/2022 19:42

But if dentists are well paid for private work, why can't they keep a limited number of NHS patients on their books as well? I realise this would be charitable work, but dental care is a health necessity so I would have thought dentists might do it out of good will. Why get rid of all NHS patients?

sageandbasil · 13/09/2022 19:36

@thefamilyupstairs- NHS dentists have a contract with the NHS. They are given a set number of UDAs and have to reach that number by the end of the tax year so April- that's why dental practices open their books again in April.

Once they hit their numbers they don't get paid a thing.

I can't remember exactly because it's been a while since I worked in an nhs practice but there's 3 bands in the nhs that you pay and the price is different in England and Wales.

Band 1- check up- this is 1 UDA

Band 2- 1 filling, 20 fillings, root canals, extractions etc. you pay one fee. The dentist will get 3 UDA points for this in total.

Band 3- lab work- highest band as you have to pay a lab fee. This is worth 12 UDAs

Does that make sense? It's a really shit system

Grumpybutfunny · 13/09/2022 19:35

Time to pay professionals properly, I also work for the NHS. Recently found out what a friend from the same course is making in the private sector. It's nearly double what I make and a lot less responsibility/stress.

Choppies · 13/09/2022 19:33

How much do you think an NHS dentist gets paid for an exam and a clean and 2 fillings OP?? I would bet £100 you overestimate how well the NHS pays…..

declutteringmymind · 13/09/2022 19:33

Sonicare sorry

declutteringmymind · 13/09/2022 19:32

As an over worked, harassed NHS dentist, please please write to your MP about your lack of access to care.

And please brush your teeth with a skincare and floss at night before you go to bed. Keep an eye on sugar between meals and do a fluoride mouth rinse during the day.

You'll save yourself thousands and it keeps the pressure of me and my colleagues!

Thank you.

sageandbasil · 13/09/2022 19:29

This is how my much my husband pays to be a dentist-

Student fees (9 years as he's a specialist)- £80K

GDC- £900 a year

Indemnity- 10K a year

Add on equipment, courses... not even starting on actually running a dental practice!

That is all self funded. So yeah it's no surprise that dentists turn private!

sageandbasil · 13/09/2022 19:24

Do you know how little dentists get paid in the NHS?

It dosent matter if you need one tiny filling or 20 root canals it's the same price. There's literally no incentive to be a NHS dentist!

Also you're not qualified to know it it's a tiny hole 😂🤦🏽‍♀️

thefamilyupstairs · 13/09/2022 15:46

Thanks for that @User1563

BeetyAxe · 13/09/2022 13:59

You are being totally unreasonable. The government are barely paying enough to cover running costs let alone make a living. Dentists are people with families and bills to pay like other people- and they are people who have studied long and hard to become skilled at a difficult job, which is by and large thankless. The government are systemically running down the NHS on purpose. Stop voting for tories.

WotsitsQuavers · 13/09/2022 13:50

deedledeedledum · 12/09/2022 11:11

They do work for the NHS for years. Then they go private. It's not some sort of servitude and they themselves do pay thousands in fees to train. You can't claim a lifetime of service anymore than you could claim the same for every lawyer, accountant, vet, architect any other profession. Ridiculous

Plus the amount of tuition fees that they have incurred as students.

CulturePigeon · 13/09/2022 13:30

Going to put my head on the block here!

I feel the same about vets. Their image is one of 'caring about animals' but only for very large sums. Yes, I get that they've trained for many years and that it's a demanding job. Of course they deserve a good wage.

But I've had experiences where I've taken very small, elderly creatures (6/7-yr old hammies, gerbils and guinea pigs) over to be put to sleep only to be put under massive pressure to do surgery on them, or start some course of medication. The gerbil had 'come back from the dead' several times and had lost most of its hair - the poor think just needed to be put out of its misery. I think so many vets cynically exploit pet-owners' sentimentality for large fees, not always in the best interests of the animals. For an animal (particularly a small one with a short life-span), the treatment is sometimes worse than the illness and their interests need to come first. Vets sometimes guilt people into keeping animals alive beyond what is kind.

And then there's the problem of vets only wanting to treat small animals, ie pets of wealthy people. Apparently there's a problem getting enough vets to deal with farm animals - not lucrative enough, I guess. Please correct me if I'm wrong! Of course there are exceptions, but I think it's a trend.

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 13/09/2022 13:13

Please check your employer's perks. Many years ago one employer joined HSF. I was able to pick a package that suited my needs (in terms of what I paid for that package). As it was a corporate package I got a discounted rate versus approaching HSF as an individual.

Depending on the package there are a variety of things you can claim on. Either 50% or 100% of the cost.

My family gets £400 per year to spend on dental and optical. It doesn't sound much for the monthly fee (now not discounted as we go direct and not via a corporate discounted package) but we also get money for loads of other things.

I've had £300 for spending time in an NHS hospital. My DD got money when she broke her arm. I got a birth grant.

You need to really consider if it's right for you. We've had more money out than we've paid in. So it works for us. Plus HSF transfer any profit they make to a grant making foundation which makes grants to support health charities in the UK.