Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Dentists are greedy and disgrace

233 replies

Thisismynamenow · 12/09/2022 09:48

I have a hole in my tooth (thanks pregnancy for the poor teeth!)

My nhs dentist has apparentpy cancelled their nhs contract to go private (without telling patients) and not a single dentist within 20 miles is willing to take on nhs, but everyone can offer same day private appointments.

I know the nhs is underfunded but it's disgusting dentists are allowed to be only private, they should be made to be half nhs!

My tooth is killing me, I can't afford the £400 I've been quoted for the filling (it's a tiny hole, literally a pin hole!) And the hopsitall will only pull it which I don't want. Its annoying me more as i currently have a maternity exemption which I can't use.

Aibu to think dentists are greedy, and that it shouldn't be allowed?

OP posts:
Freysimo · 11/04/2023 08:46

Alexandra2001 · 11/04/2023 08:07

Maybe you should take your own advice?

The Govt pay NHS dentists to treat NHS dentists, the amounts they pay them is pathetic, as is your attempt to link a lack of dentists to dental charges introduced in the 50s.

Brexit also led to EU dentists leaving the UK and a failure to recognise EU/Worldwide qualifications & Brexit and its after effects is purely down to the Tories, our present PM wanted it and they negotiated it, try finding a minister who doesn't support Brexit?

Aside, its also very short sighted, patients aren't getting checked for oral cancers, patients using AE services and down here in Cornwall, paying private companies, like BUPA private patient rates to treat NHS patients as emergencies.

If none of this is down to 13 years of Tory Govt, then what exactly is the Govt responsible for?

Every aspect of our lives is worse than it was in 2010 and in some cases, far far worse and thats down to Tory mismanagement, fraud and incompetence.

Dental care is worse in Wales, under a Welsh Labour government. Try getting an NHS dentist here.

MrsMorton · 11/04/2023 08:40

Well said @Lollygaggle sadly, it's not fashionable on MN to read the actual truth about dentistry! I do not miss it one iota.

Now if only there was some way to prevent the need to spend money on fillings and root canal treatments. Hmm. Let's have a think.

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 08:38

A very quick economic lesson.
The vast majority (78%) of dentists do not own their practice.

on the average UDA value (a system used to pay dentists) they get around £8 a UDA after practice expenses.

A check up, x rays, scaling etc earns one

all the above plus all root treatments , fillings extractions earns between one and five in total

a course of treatment , including all the above plus something that needs lab work earns 12.

a fast dentist, in a good day when no one needs much treatment will complete 30 UDAs in a day .

To practice they need GDC registration and indemnity , to pay for that is around 25 working days so let's say mid February in a working year .

They will have built up, on average £80,000 worth of student debt at a minimum that's 4 days working

They will need to pay tax and national insurance , approximately 1/3 of earnings so we are now into June before a dentist working on the NHS starts to earn any money , and that's without holidays.

But wait , every dentist has a target they have to hit , otherwise they have to pay money back (clawback) , around 86% of practices are estimated not to hit their target , so NHS dentist has to put money away for that.

phew it's over half way through the year , the dentist can relax and work hard earning money ..... no because they need to complete compulsory CPD (courses) which they need to pay for and take time off for.

If they are a sensible dentist they will also have policies to cover sick pay and loss of earnings because if they are sick they have to pay for a locum to do their job.

I have worked in dentistry for decades and have never earned enough to pay higher rate tax. My good friend sold their practice recently , in their last year they earned £17,000.

It costs , in a cheap area £120 an hour per room to run a dental practice . The NHS pays, including patient contribution around £36 per patient per year treated.

How do those figures equate to a NHS dental service that doesn't financially cripple anyone working in it?

Dentists have been, for years, subsidising the NHS side by doing private treatment . Eg if you repair someone's denture the fee doesn't even cover the lab fee , you would be better off giving someone £5 to go down the road . Extensive filling, root fillings the same.

Unfortunately the massive increase in costs of providing dentistry have shoved many over the financial edge , hence bupa closing 85 of their practices . 13 of these were private only , the finances of dentistry are perilous even privately.

Swansridinghorses · 11/04/2023 08:37

CulturePigeon · 13/09/2022 13:30

Going to put my head on the block here!

I feel the same about vets. Their image is one of 'caring about animals' but only for very large sums. Yes, I get that they've trained for many years and that it's a demanding job. Of course they deserve a good wage.

But I've had experiences where I've taken very small, elderly creatures (6/7-yr old hammies, gerbils and guinea pigs) over to be put to sleep only to be put under massive pressure to do surgery on them, or start some course of medication. The gerbil had 'come back from the dead' several times and had lost most of its hair - the poor think just needed to be put out of its misery. I think so many vets cynically exploit pet-owners' sentimentality for large fees, not always in the best interests of the animals. For an animal (particularly a small one with a short life-span), the treatment is sometimes worse than the illness and their interests need to come first. Vets sometimes guilt people into keeping animals alive beyond what is kind.

And then there's the problem of vets only wanting to treat small animals, ie pets of wealthy people. Apparently there's a problem getting enough vets to deal with farm animals - not lucrative enough, I guess. Please correct me if I'm wrong! Of course there are exceptions, but I think it's a trend.

I’m going to disagree. I’ve never ever met another vet who has pushed anything for money. I’m not saying they don’t exist but just that it’s not the majority. Also for an idea of how much I’m paid… my student loan has increased rather than reduced in amount since I graduated. I suspect it’s more related to feeling the need to ‘offer all the options’ and fearing risk of complaints or people wanting to sue because they could’ve been treated by were not. I do however know lots of vets that have left the profession due to feeling like clients think they’re only in it for the money. It’s a shame that this is what people think.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 11/04/2023 08:22

i have found an nhs dentist but many people now have some sort of plan so they can continue with the dentists that have gone wholly private

Fansandblankets · 11/04/2023 08:13

I was speaking to my dentist last week about this. She was telling me it’s a nightmare working with the nhs. She was pulled up on something (can’t remember exactly what procedure) and they stated that the average for this procedure was 5% but that hers was 17%, basically implying that she was claiming for unnecessary treatment. My daughter has been waiting for 2 years for a cap on her back tooth. The dentist referred her to the hospital. As we had not heard after 2 years the dentist did it herself. I asked why she just didn’t do it in the 1st place and she said she would have got questions when my daughter was 14/15 for the procedure but was so disgusted that we hadn’t heard anything that she’d argue the point.

Lordofmyflies · 11/04/2023 08:09

Don't blame the dentists - blame the government.
Dentists train for 5 years and qualify with a debt of £45,000 in tuition fees alone. There is no contract which means they have to join the NHS. They are free to work wherever they like.
I very much doubt any new grad would pick a job which pays half of what another company is offering? It's incredibly expensive to practice as a medical / dental practitioner in the UK, insurances, registration costs, unions, public liability, revalidation expenses, these often come to hundreds of pounds a month.

Alexandra2001 · 11/04/2023 08:07

Backinntheroom · 11/04/2023 07:53

dental and prescription charges were brought into the nhs in 1950 by the same Labour government who introduced the nhs 2 years previously.
They realised then that prroviding everything free on the nhs was untenable
Two years after they introduced it; great economics
Know your history before opening your keyboard

Maybe you should take your own advice?

The Govt pay NHS dentists to treat NHS dentists, the amounts they pay them is pathetic, as is your attempt to link a lack of dentists to dental charges introduced in the 50s.

Brexit also led to EU dentists leaving the UK and a failure to recognise EU/Worldwide qualifications & Brexit and its after effects is purely down to the Tories, our present PM wanted it and they negotiated it, try finding a minister who doesn't support Brexit?

Aside, its also very short sighted, patients aren't getting checked for oral cancers, patients using AE services and down here in Cornwall, paying private companies, like BUPA private patient rates to treat NHS patients as emergencies.

If none of this is down to 13 years of Tory Govt, then what exactly is the Govt responsible for?

Every aspect of our lives is worse than it was in 2010 and in some cases, far far worse and thats down to Tory mismanagement, fraud and incompetence.

Smoky1107 · 11/04/2023 08:06

We drive an hour to our dentist, the one we had before cancelled appt after appt so I found one local to my work at the time and I moved my daughters there this week. She nhs, she's good but it takes a half days annual leave for us all to go up, get checked and come home again

Backinntheroom · 11/04/2023 08:03

Namenic · 14/09/2022 07:20

@Coybubbles - members of the public could also crowdfund to pay for dental care for poor children. Ethics are similar to asking dentists to shoulder the cost. Restaurants and supermarkets could also give some free meals to disadvantaged and they could get free entry to museums and attractions.

This is the most ridiculous post I have seen on MN!

ReformedWaywardTeen · 11/04/2023 08:00

You think that's bad?
Our private and NHS dentist was shut throughout Covid unless you were a private patient which we aren't. In that time they decided to change the rules for all non-private patients that if you had not been seen in 6 months, they struck you off. They didn't tell anyone about this. They would not see anyone other than private patients.
So, after the second lockdown when they finally fully opened for non-private patients for the first time since February 2020, and DH needed an appointment for a terrible issue with a tooth, they refused to see him anymore. They said all of us except the DCs were removed under the terms and conditions they brought in in June 2020. The terms weren't even on their website, no patients had been contacted, nothing.

DH and I have now been trying to get a dentist to take us on since April 2021. We simply cannot find one and have called up to an hour's drive away in any direction. We keep being told they cannot add anyone else to their list to wait for a place on their patient list. So there is a waiting list for the waiting list in most

And when you report this to the NHS? They don't care. You get shrugged shoulders and a request to ask the dentist to let us back on their list. Who then tell you no.

The system with dentistry is broken. They get paid regardless. And they're going to find as more people are hit by Cost of living issues, many will quit private care so they will barely have any patients left.

Theluggage15 · 11/04/2023 07:58

AngeloMysterioso · 11/04/2023 00:53

They’re more than happy to be trained by the NHS at no small cost to the taxpayer.

Once they’ve qualified the NHS and taxpayers who can’t afford private can apparently go fuck themselves.

Yawn, they owe zero to the NHS.

Backinntheroom · 11/04/2023 07:57

gnilliwdog · 12/09/2022 15:43

I think children should be prioritised for NHS dental treatment, at least.

😂😂 of course, we always have to 'think of the little children...'

Backinntheroom · 11/04/2023 07:53

LizzieSiddal · 12/09/2022 10:12

YABVU.
Blame the goverment who have been underfunding Dentistry for many years. Dentists have been warning this would happen but the public have continually voted for the Tory’s, so you get what you vote for. Maybe use the money from all those tax cuts and all that money saved from leaving the EU to pay for your dentistry. Hmm

(I appreciate you may not have voted for the Tory’s but Tory governments are the reason why you cannot get an NHS dentist.)

dental and prescription charges were brought into the nhs in 1950 by the same Labour government who introduced the nhs 2 years previously.
They realised then that prroviding everything free on the nhs was untenable
Two years after they introduced it; great economics
Know your history before opening your keyboard

Choppies · 11/04/2023 07:52

@TwentysixV i agree vets are grossly under paid but to suggest most dentists are earning over £150k is ludicrous. I am a full time NHS dentist (not freshly qualified either but with 6 years clinical practice behind me) who’s to-do-list for the day involves applying for child benefit….

Backinntheroom · 11/04/2023 07:49

WhereshouldIgo · 12/09/2022 10:04

It’s a disgrace because we pay to train dentists through the NHS and they’re supposed to have the NHS contract in place.
yes, they’re greedy. Yes this is what happens when you let someone regulate themselves.

No, we do not. They have to pay for their university degree, just as drs and nurses do. They end up with the same debts as other professionals
And they have no obligation to provide nhs care

TheComptonEffect · 11/04/2023 07:48

YBU
Dentists are not having thier costs fully covered by the NHS for NHS work, so they are having to cover these costs themselves (i.e from private patients). Nothing to do with greed. Why would they work for free. They have been telling us this would happen for years.
The NHS is being systemically underfunded so privatisation is creeping in. This is what the government wants, an American health care system. all to do with profit and money. For them!
We are very close to the point of no return across other sectors too. Staff are striking about it and shouting out but people are not taking it seriously 😣

RobinHumphries · 11/04/2023 07:38

TwentysixV · 11/04/2023 00:33

I don’t know about dentists but vets certainly aren’t greedy. As said previously they earn about £35k that’s about a fifth of a dentists salary. The degree course is the same length as dentistry and veterinary is harder to get into-so any vet could have got into dental school and become a dentist if they were driven by money.
most vet practices are owned by large companies and vets are on a salary. They have any input into the pricing and don’t earn more if they recommend a more expensive treatment option. The more expensive treatment options are not necessarily more profitable for the practice either-they cost more because of the time and expensive equipment/drugs involved.
compared to vets, doctors and dentists are vastly overpaid-but if the UK didn’t pay dentists as well as they do then many would go abroad/to the US and we’d struggle to recruit/retain any dentists

Dentists aren’t salaried so I don’t know where you’re getting your figures from. I earn nowhere near what you say I do and still have to pay my indemnity fees, ARF etc. also as I’m not salaried if I don’t work I don’t earn.
It’s also much harder to get into dental school than medicine and veterinary according to google

AngeloMysterioso · 11/04/2023 00:53

They’re more than happy to be trained by the NHS at no small cost to the taxpayer.

Once they’ve qualified the NHS and taxpayers who can’t afford private can apparently go fuck themselves.

MelodyPondsMum · 11/04/2023 00:51

Yy because it isn't a party political problem. It's a culture within dentistry problem. It's been negatively impacted by US dentistry trends and consumerist values.

Womanofcustard · 11/04/2023 00:40

It’s bad in Scotland as well, under the supervision of ….the SNP.

TwoMonthsOff · 11/04/2023 00:37

@TwentysixV
where would we be without vets I think they do an amazing job, that salary seems awful, they are worth so much more

ReadersD1gest · 11/04/2023 00:36

I know the nhs is underfunded but it's disgusting dentists are allowed to be only private, they should be made to be half nhs!
Don't be ridiculous. How could anyone be forced to work for the NHS? You sound like a petulant child.

TwentysixV · 11/04/2023 00:34

*vets have no input into pricing

TwentysixV · 11/04/2023 00:33

I don’t know about dentists but vets certainly aren’t greedy. As said previously they earn about £35k that’s about a fifth of a dentists salary. The degree course is the same length as dentistry and veterinary is harder to get into-so any vet could have got into dental school and become a dentist if they were driven by money.
most vet practices are owned by large companies and vets are on a salary. They have any input into the pricing and don’t earn more if they recommend a more expensive treatment option. The more expensive treatment options are not necessarily more profitable for the practice either-they cost more because of the time and expensive equipment/drugs involved.
compared to vets, doctors and dentists are vastly overpaid-but if the UK didn’t pay dentists as well as they do then many would go abroad/to the US and we’d struggle to recruit/retain any dentists