Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Dentists are greedy and disgrace

233 replies

Thisismynamenow · 12/09/2022 09:48

I have a hole in my tooth (thanks pregnancy for the poor teeth!)

My nhs dentist has apparentpy cancelled their nhs contract to go private (without telling patients) and not a single dentist within 20 miles is willing to take on nhs, but everyone can offer same day private appointments.

I know the nhs is underfunded but it's disgusting dentists are allowed to be only private, they should be made to be half nhs!

My tooth is killing me, I can't afford the £400 I've been quoted for the filling (it's a tiny hole, literally a pin hole!) And the hopsitall will only pull it which I don't want. Its annoying me more as i currently have a maternity exemption which I can't use.

Aibu to think dentists are greedy, and that it shouldn't be allowed?

OP posts:
BunnyRabbitSandwich · 11/04/2023 12:19

Dentists aren’t greedy. The dental contract that they’re working under is so crap right now that for a lot of them, doing NHS work just simply doesn’t pay the bills. When you go and have a treatment and pay, say £23(ish) for the cheapest band of treatment, that money has to pay the dentist, the dental nurse, the receptionist, the cleaner, the rent of the building. It doesn’t go very far.

They get UDA’s (units of dental activity) and if the UDA is filled with private work then the money simply goes further. The NHS is struggling to keep dentists from going abroad after training because the financial conditions are so crap. Maybe one day it’ll change, who knows…

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 11:58

MelodyPondsMum · 11/04/2023 11:41

The situation in local dentistry practices has changed considerably since Covid. That's the point posters are making. Practices advertising NHS lists don't have them in reality. Practices that served the local community and most vulnerable are now refusing to treat them, see them or add them to lists.
@Lollygaggle are you still practising? Are you in community or private practice? Old articles aren't addressing this fairly new, post-Covid shift.

The biggest post covid shift is, perhaps, people like myself. We are the older generation who manned practices despite our own health issues .

Many ,perhaps, would have gone on to work a few more years yet , but the stress and strain of the last few years has made them feel life is too short and so they have retired or cut down days.

Dental nurses , who again, worked in very ,very physically and mentally demanding conditions during covid are now leaving to work in eg Aldi where they get paid more for an awful lot less stress and responsibility.

Dental technicians whose laboratories received very little support during covid and less work because of restrictions are now closing or refusing NHS work because they cannot make a profit on NHS work and the investment needed for high end work is beyond their means .

I myself will probably never do clinical work again because of damage from long covid. I have other dental related jobs I do which I hope to return to.
I have/still work in private/NHS and other dental practice, train young dentists and worked, on occasion , overseas.

Practices are handing back contracts and/or refusing to take on NHS patients because NO ONE wants to do NHS dentistry . The rate at which you have to work is not good for patient or practitioner. There is no more money so things will not get better and indeed new reform contracts are making things worse.

The debts many practice owners accrued during covid to keep businesses going (dental practices received virtually no support in most of the country) means they now have to make hard choices to avoid going bankrupt , hence the rush to shut down or go entirely private.

MelodyPondsMum · 11/04/2023 11:41

The situation in local dentistry practices has changed considerably since Covid. That's the point posters are making. Practices advertising NHS lists don't have them in reality. Practices that served the local community and most vulnerable are now refusing to treat them, see them or add them to lists.
@Lollygaggle are you still practising? Are you in community or private practice? Old articles aren't addressing this fairly new, post-Covid shift.

RobinHumphries · 11/04/2023 11:38

Alexandra2001 · 11/04/2023 11:23

NHS dental waiting lists in England is 3 years, with many patients removed from lists for missing an appointment.

Wales is very slightly longer.

We are arguing about how many teeth a hen has!!!! Dental care is shite UK wide, the worst in Europe, by far.

My DD is 23 and has never had an NHS dentist and the EU Polish private dental practice that would treat her for NHS prices, upped sticks and left the UK after Brexit... no practices in Cornwall are taking on any new patients, i believe Devon is the same.

No dentist would see someone privately but for NHS prices - that would be asking to go bankrupt.

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 11:31

You would think dental care is worst in Europe.... not so. Although we have low numbers of dentists compared to some , we have a higher number of dental schools .
Our decay rates are not too bad , at the moment , although our sugar consumption is very high compared to eg Spain.
As has been said before the U.K. is unusual in providing state controlled/run NHS dentistry . It is in modern times , where the cost of providing dentistry is exponentially increasing as technology improves , unsustainable.
The U.K. has only ever provided funding for 50% of the population to visit the dentist , but now even this funding is not enough to provide anything but a core service for the most vulnerable.
https://dentistry.co.uk/2020/05/27/uk-europe-dental-health-dentists/

UK among best in Europe for dental health despite lower number of dentists – Dentistry Online

The UK ranks joint second for dental health across Europe – despite having one of the lowest numbers of dentists per capita.

https://dentistry.co.uk/2020/05/27/uk-europe-dental-health-dentists/

BungleandGeorge · 11/04/2023 11:26

@ChickenDhansak82 20% are at private sixth form not 7%

Alexandra2001 · 11/04/2023 11:23

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 11:10

No the dental funding contract is not country wide. Scotland and NI have still a piecework pay as you go system , Wales has a UDA system similar to England but with much less value for a UDA. It has also tried out different pilot schemes including one at the moment very different from England.
Wages for dentists and teams are lower in Wales,Scotland and NI and rates of dentists per head of population are lower than in England.
Wales, by any metric has the worst dental health of the four nations.

NHS dental waiting lists in England is 3 years, with many patients removed from lists for missing an appointment.

Wales is very slightly longer.

We are arguing about how many teeth a hen has!!!! Dental care is shite UK wide, the worst in Europe, by far.

My DD is 23 and has never had an NHS dentist and the EU Polish private dental practice that would treat her for NHS prices, upped sticks and left the UK after Brexit... no practices in Cornwall are taking on any new patients, i believe Devon is the same.

ReadersD1gest · 11/04/2023 11:22

You have to pass an aptitude test to get into dentistry, but will struggle to pass this unless you pay for private coaching. I wonder who will therefore do better in these tests...? 🤔
Coaching for an aptitude test is a bit of an oxymoron.

OooGuv · 11/04/2023 11:19

I don't think YABU to expect teeth to be covered under NHS, I would class issues with teeth as a medical issue same as anything I go to the doctor for or hospital. Dental issue can get extremely nasty if they are left.

The lack of NHS dentists is crap. Do you have parents who live further afield who's address you could put down as your own? There are no NHS dentists where I live so I found one near my parents and registered me and my children there with my parents address, just have to remember to say that's where I live when they ask me to confirm my postcode! Yes technically it's not great but make it affordable/more accessable and people wouldn't have to. No I don't feel remotely guilty.

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 11:18

Alexandra2001 · 11/04/2023 11:07

We ve a local Dental School and many students are from overseas, they pay full fees and off set the losses made on UK students.

they are massively over subscribed for places, one reason is that they need volunteer qualified dentists to supervise them when they practice on the the general public... and not enough will work for nothing... why should they.

We need more dental schools, properly funded and reform of NHS charges....

You can train all the dentists you like but...... this year , for the first time , a sizeable chunk of new dentists did not enter foundation training. In order to work in the NHS you have to do compulsory one year training.

You have to do this training within 18 months of graduating .

In effect these young dentists have graduated and will never work in the NHS.

In the past we imported young dentists , but even before Brexit recruitment was a problem because as soon as these dentists realised the reality of NHS dentistry they moved on.

There is no more money for NHS dentistry , we need to decide with the limited pot what we can do with it . We have moved the deck chairs on the titanic around and it made no difference . Training more young cannon fodder is not going to solve the problem. These are the brightest and best . They start preparing for their career by their early teens . They have to be smart, pass exams, have great people skills , have great manual skills, have great business skills, have great leadership qualities . They have to be mentally and physically extremely resilient . They and more importantly the vulnerable for whom there is no alternative to NHS provision , deserve better.

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 11:10

Alexandra2001 · 11/04/2023 11:03

This old chestnut... Wales isn't an independent country and wasn't responsible for Austerity or Brexit and is centrally funded by Westminster, its little more than a council.
The dental funding contract is UK wide.

The Tories could have improved the dentists contract at anytime over the last 13 years but chose not too... because they don't use NHS dentistry ... that, pardon the pun, is the root cause for all of this short sighted debacle.

No the dental funding contract is not country wide. Scotland and NI have still a piecework pay as you go system , Wales has a UDA system similar to England but with much less value for a UDA. It has also tried out different pilot schemes including one at the moment very different from England.
Wages for dentists and teams are lower in Wales,Scotland and NI and rates of dentists per head of population are lower than in England.
Wales, by any metric has the worst dental health of the four nations.

Alexandra2001 · 11/04/2023 11:07

ChickenDhansak82 · 11/04/2023 10:58

I know a state school A Level student who is desperate to become a dentist.

But... they cannot get a place to study dentistry at university despite being predicted 3 grade As at A Level.

7% of UK pupils attend a private school but nearly 30% of all dentistry students are from private schools.

You have to pass an aptitude test to get into dentistry, but will struggle to pass this unless you pay for private coaching. I wonder who will therefore do better in these tests...? 🤔

So is it any wonder we have such a shortage of NHS dentists when those from average/lower income families who would perhaps more likely spend far longer working for the NHS are at a massive disadvantage already to even get to study dentistry?

We ve a local Dental School and many students are from overseas, they pay full fees and off set the losses made on UK students.

they are massively over subscribed for places, one reason is that they need volunteer qualified dentists to supervise them when they practice on the the general public... and not enough will work for nothing... why should they.

We need more dental schools, properly funded and reform of NHS charges....

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 11:06

There is no shortage of dentists, the amount of dentists on the GDC register has increased slightly .
However there is a massive shortage of people willing to do NHS dentistry.

In the past corporates lured in overseas dentists who were dazzled by what they were told they could earn , however having seen the reality of how you have to work in NHS dentistry moved on , either back home or into private dentistry.

I qualified in an era when we all worked full time in NHS dentistry and that's what we expected to do our whole careers. My age group never had to pay student loans back but in recent years even we have been affected by increased costs, paperwork and litigation.

The young dentists I have trained will work for the minimum time they can in the NHS and get out before it destroys them . They want to work in "portfolio"careers working in several places at once because the pressures on body and mind of clinical dentistry are so high.

Dentistry is acknowledged to be one of the most highly stressful professions , with high suicide rates . My first colleague to try suicide was in dental school.

You cannot be coached to pass the UKAT and BMAT tests , and in fact dentistry is very good in intake for diversity with the exception of people from black backgrounds.

Interestingly the vast majority of dentists (over 86% if I remember) would not recommend their children take up dentistry as a career. Does that not say something?

Alexandra2001 · 11/04/2023 11:03

Freysimo · 11/04/2023 08:46

Dental care is worse in Wales, under a Welsh Labour government. Try getting an NHS dentist here.

This old chestnut... Wales isn't an independent country and wasn't responsible for Austerity or Brexit and is centrally funded by Westminster, its little more than a council.
The dental funding contract is UK wide.

The Tories could have improved the dentists contract at anytime over the last 13 years but chose not too... because they don't use NHS dentistry ... that, pardon the pun, is the root cause for all of this short sighted debacle.

ChickenDhansak82 · 11/04/2023 10:58

I know a state school A Level student who is desperate to become a dentist.

But... they cannot get a place to study dentistry at university despite being predicted 3 grade As at A Level.

7% of UK pupils attend a private school but nearly 30% of all dentistry students are from private schools.

You have to pass an aptitude test to get into dentistry, but will struggle to pass this unless you pay for private coaching. I wonder who will therefore do better in these tests...? 🤔

So is it any wonder we have such a shortage of NHS dentists when those from average/lower income families who would perhaps more likely spend far longer working for the NHS are at a massive disadvantage already to even get to study dentistry?

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 10:56

midgemadgemodge · 11/04/2023 10:50

Nhs dentists earn 45 to 90k a year according to the nhs website

Doesn't sound shabby to me

That is dentists employed by the NHS ie those in hospital and community service. These are a tiny fraction of dentists , most of whom are self employed.

Catwithbigfeet · 11/04/2023 10:52

No not greedy.
Like the rest of the nhs the contracts they have totally take the mick out of them.
Also the time slots they have for patients doesn’t allow them time to do the job properly, so lots of botch jobs needing repeat appointments to fix the botch.
Easier to go private, do the job properly and get some job satisfaction.
The whole system needs an overhaul if it’s to function effectively.
They're highly skilled professionals and deserve to be paid properly.

midgemadgemodge · 11/04/2023 10:50

Nhs dentists earn 45 to 90k a year according to the nhs website

Doesn't sound shabby to me

Hbh17 · 11/04/2023 10:48

YABU. Of course they're not "greedy" and "a disgrace" They can't make a living from NHS work, so what are they supposed to do? Perhaps the costs make people realise that they shouldn't take the services of highly skilled and trained professionals for granted.

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 10:46

It also evaporates really easily so if a nurse accidentally leaves the top off....

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 10:45

It's ok , it's on special offer this week

To think Dentists are greedy and disgrace
Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 10:40

KnittedCardi · 11/04/2023 09:02

Dentistry is a different beast from healthcare. Look, once again, to our European neighbours. Very few have universal free or state subsidised dentistry. Most have cover for children but not adults. The result is competition (gasp), and resultant reasonably priced dental treatment. At the moment we have, as usual, the worse if both worlds. Private patients subsidising poor or non- existent NHS cover. It's not sustainable.

"Reasonably priced dental treatment "
let's take the country where dental tourism is at its greatest
Turkey

the average wage in Turkey is around £400 a month , so how affordable for the average Turk is dental treatment?

Dentistry in the U.K. is the most highly regulated in the world , 30 times more regulated than the EU. With such high regulation comes cost.

Over 52 different authorities can inspect a U.K. dental practice and this has costs . Eg each practice has at least one , and probably more , autoclaves . These are expensive to buy , but , on top

each has to have speacially treated water to run , the water in a dental practice is annually tested for legionella , the water used in lines has disinfectant and is tested daily/weekly , the water discharged is run through filters

each has to be serviced annually cost £400 plus

each has to have a pressure vessel inspection annually

each and every day a nurse has to test , inspect and report on the autoclave

every run the autoclave makes has to be recorded and kept for two years (it runs continuously during the day)

every dental practice will have regular inspections from CQC/HIW health authorities and autoclave checking will be part of that process .

This is but one small piece of equipment in a practice that has hundreds of pieces.

The dentists/dental nurses/hygienists/therapists/dental technicians have to be trained, registered every year and complete compulsory training . This is not the case for dental nurses and technicians in most other countries .

In the U.K. you are far more likely to be sued as a dentist , than in any other country in the world. In eg Turkey I think the average indemnity cost is around £200 , in the U.K. £5000 to £25000 plus .

Finally the biggest competition we have in the U.K. is the artificially low prices paid for highly complex microsurgery by the NHS . Unfortunately the general public do not have an idea of how much it costs to provide medical treatment. Look at the ire given to vets over costs , when the average vet earns £35,000. BUPA , specsavers, boots , and many others have tried to provide dentistry and pulled out when they could not make a profit NHS or private.

Finally to give a small idea , this is a bottle of glue used to glue in white fillings . It's not the most expensive glue and other chemicals and disposables are used in putting a filling in . This is a 5ml bottle . How much does it cost ?

To think Dentists are greedy and disgrace
MrsMorton · 11/04/2023 09:54

Lapland123 · 11/04/2023 09:07

Wow, that is absolutely shocking.
Thank you for explaining in such detail.
The Op should read this and then get rid of that untrue nasty title to this thread.

She won't though.

Lapland123 · 11/04/2023 09:07

Lollygaggle · 11/04/2023 08:38

A very quick economic lesson.
The vast majority (78%) of dentists do not own their practice.

on the average UDA value (a system used to pay dentists) they get around £8 a UDA after practice expenses.

A check up, x rays, scaling etc earns one

all the above plus all root treatments , fillings extractions earns between one and five in total

a course of treatment , including all the above plus something that needs lab work earns 12.

a fast dentist, in a good day when no one needs much treatment will complete 30 UDAs in a day .

To practice they need GDC registration and indemnity , to pay for that is around 25 working days so let's say mid February in a working year .

They will have built up, on average £80,000 worth of student debt at a minimum that's 4 days working

They will need to pay tax and national insurance , approximately 1/3 of earnings so we are now into June before a dentist working on the NHS starts to earn any money , and that's without holidays.

But wait , every dentist has a target they have to hit , otherwise they have to pay money back (clawback) , around 86% of practices are estimated not to hit their target , so NHS dentist has to put money away for that.

phew it's over half way through the year , the dentist can relax and work hard earning money ..... no because they need to complete compulsory CPD (courses) which they need to pay for and take time off for.

If they are a sensible dentist they will also have policies to cover sick pay and loss of earnings because if they are sick they have to pay for a locum to do their job.

I have worked in dentistry for decades and have never earned enough to pay higher rate tax. My good friend sold their practice recently , in their last year they earned £17,000.

It costs , in a cheap area £120 an hour per room to run a dental practice . The NHS pays, including patient contribution around £36 per patient per year treated.

How do those figures equate to a NHS dental service that doesn't financially cripple anyone working in it?

Dentists have been, for years, subsidising the NHS side by doing private treatment . Eg if you repair someone's denture the fee doesn't even cover the lab fee , you would be better off giving someone £5 to go down the road . Extensive filling, root fillings the same.

Unfortunately the massive increase in costs of providing dentistry have shoved many over the financial edge , hence bupa closing 85 of their practices . 13 of these were private only , the finances of dentistry are perilous even privately.

Wow, that is absolutely shocking.
Thank you for explaining in such detail.
The Op should read this and then get rid of that untrue nasty title to this thread.

KnittedCardi · 11/04/2023 09:02

Dentistry is a different beast from healthcare. Look, once again, to our European neighbours. Very few have universal free or state subsidised dentistry. Most have cover for children but not adults. The result is competition (gasp), and resultant reasonably priced dental treatment. At the moment we have, as usual, the worse if both worlds. Private patients subsidising poor or non- existent NHS cover. It's not sustainable.