Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think detention for lateness is wrong

117 replies

BelleMarionette · 12/09/2022 09:04

My child's secondary school gives a detention for even one lateness in the morning.

My child left an hour early, for what should have been a 30 minute journey door to door by bus.

Unfortunately, 2 buses drove past them without stopping. They got very upset and anxious about being late, so I had to come and drive them (not ideal environmentally, and will not always be possible either, due to work).

My child has autism, so gets extremely anxious about the threat of detention, as rules are very important to them.

Aibu to think that detention in this circumstance is wrong, as it's often out of the child's control?

OP posts:
gatehouseoffleet · 12/09/2022 15:48

Needmorelego · 12/09/2022 09:09

If it's beyond the child's control - ie public transport - then there should never be a punishment for the child.
I would definitely refuse to have my child do the detention.

I would as well. I'd email in, explaining the issue with the buses and saying that I would not support a detention for something that was outwith the child's control.

I assume it's not an academy. Academies have unreasonable rules and limited accountability.

I don't think SN are relevant here, it isn't fair to punish any child for public transport failures.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 12/09/2022 15:45

I used to get Saturday morning detentions for the bus not arriving or getting in late. This was 50+ years ago, so nothing changes ☹️
The fact that I left home at 7am to walk 2 miles to the bus stop, 50 minutes bus ride then a further 20 minute walk counted for nothing.

lanthanum · 12/09/2022 14:57

Brefugee · 12/09/2022 14:26

My DC went to German school. The Train station used to stamp a "the XX:XX train was late today" with the date and the kids gave it to the school. No detentions for that.

One teacher did once suggest that the kids from our town all just got a later train (so at 5:35 in the morning...) but the parents all a) politely declined and b) pointed out the 6:35 was the first train of the day.

What great cooperation from the station. I can't see Stagecoach doing that!

lanthanum · 12/09/2022 14:54

Definitely talk to the school and find out what the right thing to do is when something like this happens. Provided the child's route/timings can be reasonably expected to get them there on time, they shouldn't really be punished if very occasionally it doesn't.

There two options for the bus from near us to the next secondary along - one theoretically gets there 2 minutes before the bell, the other 20/30 minutes earlier. Those who get the later one are frequently late, and get late marks and whatever sanctions follow from those. On one occasion the earlier bus just didn't appear, so they were all on the later one, which of course was running late because it had twice as many passengers. One mum rang the school to let them know what had happened, and when they arrived, they issued late marks to those who regularly came on the later one but not to those who normally caught the earlier one!

FawnFrenchieMum · 12/09/2022 14:45

My DS uses the trains, I take a screen shot of the trainline app or of the info screen on the platform and email it to the school, he isn't then punished.

Do you have live bus tracking where you are? Ours usually shows it a bus is busy or full? His old school were less reasonable though and after the first time would say get up earlier.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/09/2022 14:45

No, I don't think it's wrong as such. I bet you'd otherwise get loads of kids hanging around before school and getting in late. But they should listen to the reasons why and where outside the control of the kids' let them off.

cakewench · 12/09/2022 14:43

Definitely worth getting in contact with the school. Head of year and senco should be made aware at least. My DS has autism, is absolutely never in any kind of trouble, but really stresses at the idea of it happening someday. So I totally get where you're coming from.

He was in actual tears one weekend because he hadn't done his homework correctly (hit 'send' on a Forms assignment when he was only done with one page, so no way of bringing it back to finish it). I found him in his room with tears in his eyes, looking at the map in his school planner "to find the room where detention is held" because he was sure he'd be sent there. I contacted his form tutor and they were absolutely fine and understanding about it. It turned out most of the class had done the same thing. anyway.

(only giving that as my example! Hope you have luck speaking to them!)

Everanewbie · 12/09/2022 14:36

What kind of a teacher/school hands out detentions to a kid who's bus doesn't turn up? What happens to a teacher who gets stuck behind an accident or their bus no-shows? Are they disciplined?

Dixiechickonhols · 12/09/2022 14:31

Is it worth contacting the bus company? It does sound like bus full. Might need to get earlier bus.

LimeCheesecake · 12/09/2022 14:30

If your son feels uncomfortable calling the school reception, he could call you to call in and say he is stuck waiting for a bus.

Brefugee · 12/09/2022 14:26

My DC went to German school. The Train station used to stamp a "the XX:XX train was late today" with the date and the kids gave it to the school. No detentions for that.

One teacher did once suggest that the kids from our town all just got a later train (so at 5:35 in the morning...) but the parents all a) politely declined and b) pointed out the 6:35 was the first train of the day.

BlackeyedSusan · 12/09/2022 14:23

Our school is a bit more lenient. Parents get a email to say if has been late.3lates per week= detention. school bus lates at excused.

WoolyMammoth55 · 12/09/2022 13:57

Hi OP, I'm just flashing back to my own bus journey to school 30 years ago :)

We just happened to live at a bus stop that was a few stops before a rail station. So even though my journey involved getting on the bus and staying on it for an hour, then getting off near school, there were a lot of adult commuters who would normally walk to the station but in bad weather or in winter would 'just jump on the bus' to the rail station.

This meant that OFTEN, often, in winter or in the rain, I would sit waiting while 4 or 5 full buses drove past my stop - and they were all about to empty out at the station a few stops along, and then be barely full for the rest of the route.

It was maddening and in the end my mum used to agree to drive me in winter - not all the way to school, but just to the local train station! So that way I could wait there and get on the bus once the commuters had all got off.

My school didn't have a detention policy so I can't comment on that bit, but you may find that there's an obvious 'bottle neck' on the bus route that if you can bypass, things might get better for your DC? Best of luck.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 12/09/2022 13:45

Very good advice from @EnidSpyton
Our school used to do this, even when it was due to lateness of the paid for school bus, due to traffic.

They had to do something about it when all the bus parents complained as Initially only one or two did, and the school didn't believe them!

VladmirsPoutine · 12/09/2022 13:44

Yanbu. Detentions for something entirely out of your control is very unhelpful, especially from the perspective of an autistic child.

Doormatnomore · 12/09/2022 13:43

I don’t really get the “real world” chat either. If I’m going to be late for work I can call my boss and explain, or turn up late and explain or utilise flexi time. Yes not everyone has these options but some do and those that don’t can choose to put up with it or look for another job. School kids don’t have the choice and dealing with normal inconveniences is a life skill. This day and age they should be able to call school and say the number 44 hasn’t turned up, me, my sister and Tim from 6B are going to need to wait for the 26. Once fine, every week not fine and consequences.

EnidSpyton · 12/09/2022 13:35

I'm a secondary school teacher - you need to contact the school.

Detentions for lateness when the lateness is not the child's fault are ridiculous and serve no purpose.

Detentions are a punishment for deliberate poor behaviour or deliberate poor decision making. They are designed as a deterrent to encourage children who make persistently poor choices to change their ways.

If a child hasn't made a poor choice but has simply been unlucky with transport, the detention is pointless and reduced to a mere 'one punishment for all no matter the circumstances' box ticking exercise, which teaches children that inflexible, totally compassionless behaviour is acceptable.

Schools with blanket policies like this are often miserable places run by idiot despots. They need to be told.

Email the Head of Year and SENCo, cc in the Head, and explain exactly why this policy is bollocks and why your child won't be attending the pointless detention.

In future you need to ensure your child calls the school when they are running late. I presume they have a mobile phone on them - calling reception and saying hello, I'm in class 7B, my bus has gone past and I'm going to be late' means the form tutor can be informed in advance and an authorised lateness box (or equivalent) ticked on the register. If your child is too nervous to do this, then you can do it for them.

GiltEdges · 12/09/2022 13:32

Well, I wouldn’t personally be allowing this, your child did nothing wrong. Contact the school and hopefully they’ll be reasonable about it once you’ve explained.

MarshaBradyo · 12/09/2022 13:28

You’re right sometimes full buses don’t stop

I agree with pp contact the school, I’m sure they’ll make an adjustment so your dc is feeling more ok if it happens again

ErrolTheDragon · 12/09/2022 13:25

StressfulBedtimes · 12/09/2022 09:10

The thing is though that every child could come up with a reason that they were late and it wasn’t their fault
Our school also does detentions for one lateness (also if they’re late to any classes during the day) and unfortunately as I regularly tell my children sometimes in life you just have to suck it up 🤷🏻‍♀️

If there's been a problem with transport, it's likely to be several all arriving late - easy to tell its genuine in that case.

The attitude of assuming the worst of all the kids and punishing them for circumstances beyond their control is awful, a really bad lesson in how to treat and manage people.

LondonWolf · 12/09/2022 13:11

I agree. We live in London and traffic in the mornings can never be predicted. My child also has additional needs and needs to taken to and picked up from school. If we are delayed for any reason it's a 20 minute same day detention. It's hardly her fault if she's late. I don't make a fuss although it pisses me off, because I have to pick my battles, which are many, while trying to support her through a mainstream secondary.

neverbeenskiing · 12/09/2022 13:07

Email your child's Head of Year and copy in the Senco. At my school we make allowances for public transport disruption as it is not in the child's control. We also consider children's SEN before putting consequences in place that could be detrimental to them or that they might not understand.

Whatwouldscullydo · 12/09/2022 13:04

In this circumstance there should be no detention. This used ti happen to me all eh time at that age. The bus being full and driving straight past us at the bus stop. The kid did everything right . Left on time. Called u when the buses refused ti take them.

There should be no punishment for this

Beachsidesunset · 12/09/2022 13:03

I used to leave for school at 0720 every morning, and due to awful public transport and traffic, was late nearly every day. I never got a detention (the school was aware of the transport problems) but my classmates were outraged.

Redqueenheart · 12/09/2022 12:34

What would be the point of detention in this case?

The child has done nothing wrong and had no power to make the buses stop...

OP, I would have pre-empted this by speaking to the school about what happened when you got there.

It teaches a child absolutely nothing if they are punished for something that was completely out of their control.

In fact I always think that if rules are silly/nonsensical you are much less likely to follow them.