Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think detention for lateness is wrong

117 replies

BelleMarionette · 12/09/2022 09:04

My child's secondary school gives a detention for even one lateness in the morning.

My child left an hour early, for what should have been a 30 minute journey door to door by bus.

Unfortunately, 2 buses drove past them without stopping. They got very upset and anxious about being late, so I had to come and drive them (not ideal environmentally, and will not always be possible either, due to work).

My child has autism, so gets extremely anxious about the threat of detention, as rules are very important to them.

Aibu to think that detention in this circumstance is wrong, as it's often out of the child's control?

OP posts:
RiftGibbon · 12/09/2022 17:45

It depends on the reason for lateness. If the child is usually always on time, and the bus is delayed/breaks down then a detention is unfair because that is definitely out of their control.
If the bus doesn't stop, then it depends why, I think. If it's a case that the bus is full, then that should be something the bus co. can confirm and therefore again, no detention.
The issue of autism is relevant here as your child may not feel confident in flagging down the bus, and as this is a change to the routine, is likely to be unsettled by this.

If a child is consistently late because they leave home 15 minutes before school starts (when it's a 15 minute journey), or because they can't be bothered to come in, then it's a different issue altogether, and a detention is a relevant sanction.

itsgettingweird · 12/09/2022 17:37

StressfulBedtimes · 12/09/2022 09:10

The thing is though that every child could come up with a reason that they were late and it wasn’t their fault
Our school also does detentions for one lateness (also if they’re late to any classes during the day) and unfortunately as I regularly tell my children sometimes in life you just have to suck it up 🤷🏻‍♀️

Why?

Detention is meant to be a deterrent for behaviour.

How can a child do anything to correct his behaviour when it's busses not stopping?

If you were travelling to work and got stuck in traffic due to a RTA would you expect to get a formal warning?

itsgettingweird · 12/09/2022 17:35

I would say depends on child and circumstances.

In your case it wasn't anything he could control so they are punishing him and increasing his anxiety and he can't change the situation to prevent that iyswim?

Mh ds is also autistic and went on transport (MS school)

If his taxi was late I'd ring them in advance to warm them (he's turn up needing time out!) and never once did her get a detention or late mark because he couldn't prevent the situation.

If a child lives 2 minutes walk away it's entirely different and a 30 minute detention may help sharpen their minds about getting to school on time Grin

Lachimolala · 12/09/2022 17:21

Kellie45 · 12/09/2022 17:15

You have to teach your kids to bear with these things because life isn’t always fair. One of life’s lessons. What my mum said when I got stood in the corner because somebody else was talking

Sorry I don’t understand what you mean?

BertieQueen · 12/09/2022 17:20

Our school issue detentions for being late. A late equals a after school detention.

Detentions are not given if it’s the school buses that are late as they are informed.

We was late last term because of a accident on the road the school issued a detention as my child was 15 minutes late. I spoke to the school and told them it was out of his hands that he was late we had left in plenty of time and that he would not be doing the detention.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 12/09/2022 17:20

gatehouseoffleet · 12/09/2022 15:50

My mum used to get caned for being late. And she had to go to Mass every morning and that was often why she was late for school, because the priest overran!

It's unbelievable what parents used to put up with from schools for their kids. There's an argument the pendulum has swung too much the other way, but on the whole I'm glad parents have stopped doffing their caps to teachers.

If you had a lunchtime detention you had to learn a page of Shakespeare off by heart. I hate Shakespeare even to this day - I wasn’t a naughty schoolgirl, I was shy and an easy target for bullying. Unfortunately if the bully was RC (convent school so obviously the majority) it was always the non catholic who came off worse.
I can still see the prefect who was my tormentor, a first class bitch ☹️
My mother was no support, I had to suck it up.

Oblomov22 · 12/09/2022 17:17

Speak to HoY and Senco about it then.

Kellie45 · 12/09/2022 17:15

Lachimolala · 12/09/2022 17:13

My eldest got a 30 min lunch time detention last week on like day 4 of secondary because he got there at 8.35 instead of 8.30.

Normally I’d be supportive of this but the bus didn’t turn up so he ended up having to walk.

He ended up with 10 mins to eat lunch, I don’t think it’s very appropriate really. Felt very harsh.

You have to teach your kids to bear with these things because life isn’t always fair. One of life’s lessons. What my mum said when I got stood in the corner because somebody else was talking

Lachimolala · 12/09/2022 17:13

My eldest got a 30 min lunch time detention last week on like day 4 of secondary because he got there at 8.35 instead of 8.30.

Normally I’d be supportive of this but the bus didn’t turn up so he ended up having to walk.

He ended up with 10 mins to eat lunch, I don’t think it’s very appropriate really. Felt very harsh.

Kellie45 · 12/09/2022 17:03

I am not a good time keeper and remember quite often going out the door with a smack from mum on my behind to help me on my way to catch the bus. I think if there hadn’t been a sanction for being late I would’ve been late just about every morning

movingincircles · 12/09/2022 16:57

Maybe school just wasn't their priority that morning, the school doesn't own them. If they're late they're late better late than never.

swarvay · 12/09/2022 16:44

NyanBinaryJohn · 12/09/2022 16:31

sometimes in life you just have to suck it up

Not if it is an injustice. Why would you ever teach a child to serve a punishment for something they did not do?

Exactly

movingincircles · 12/09/2022 16:43

My dc would not be in that detention.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/09/2022 16:43

One school I worked at stopped issuing detentions for lateness. Within three weeks, 45% of year 8-11 were late every single day and a small number took to coming in some time between 10 and 11am.

By the time mocks came around, there was no guarantee there would be more than a third of students in by the time the exams started and there were still some coming in 40 minutes late for actual GCSEs. Turned out that those weren't even leaving their homes until fifteen minutes before the start time of the exams when they needed to be put their front doors before 7.30am to even have the slightest chance of getting there within the JCQ regulations for late entrance.

Late penalties were reintroduced, back to single digit numbers persistently late and an occasional bus load coming in 5-10 minutes late.

Give an inch, the group as a whole take ten miles.

Kellie45 · 12/09/2022 16:40

depends on why a kid is late. We got one warning if no good reason. If late after that detention. With travel these days kids can be late for all sorts of reasons.

vincettenoir · 12/09/2022 16:34

This sounds like a very rigid rule. At my school it was x3 lates before a detention. I was in late detention all the time. I learned bad time keeping from my family. I didn’t know how to function otherwise. I managed to get on top of it in my 20s and am rarely late now.

I don’t necessarily think my late detentions were unfair. But I wouldn’t say they served much of a purpose. They didn’t stop me being late. That was only something I managed to learn several years later.

bebanjo · 12/09/2022 16:33

My DDs school give detention for one lateness, not having correct uniform and a few other things. My DD has missed several days of school due to these rules, if she thinks she’s going to be late she is inconsolable so I just ring in sick for her. When we thought she’d lost her blazer, when her shoes fell apart on the way home. Now the school have realised they have an attendance problem.

NyanBinaryJohn · 12/09/2022 16:31

sometimes in life you just have to suck it up

Not if it is an injustice. Why would you ever teach a child to serve a punishment for something they did not do?

Pixiedust1234 · 12/09/2022 16:31

Thats good. Not everybody knows that. Its also good to know there are alternative routes they can take. If there are several buses is there one thats possibly 10 minutes before the one they want to get? If school, colleges and workers all aim for a short time period just getting the slightly earlier one can make all the difference. Worth trying maybe?

If thats a bit garbled. Everyone knows rush-hour starts at 8am, so leaving at 7.55am can mean not getting snarled up in a traffic jam. Its strange how those few seconds can change everything.

(Yes, I am ignoring your title, I'm trying to help with avoidance of future situations Smile)

Walkden · 12/09/2022 16:23

I'd say that many people expect schools to take pupils word for this, perhaps because posters, or friends they knew at school, would not usually be late.

Once you get an overview of a whole school population you can get lots of kids avoiding coming in for registration, going to local shops, Macdonald's etc so there has to be a late policy.

Usually emails will go out for amnesty for the day for tram problems, accidents on major roads the motorway whatever.

There Will also be exceptions where the school knows the pupil is late due to safeguarding issues e.g parent routinely refuses to get out of bed on time and will work with the family.

In almost every other case, correspondence from a carer vouching for a reasonable reason will cause a late detention to be cancelled.

Notlosinganyweight · 12/09/2022 16:13

Parents and the school need to be speaking to the bus company about lack of buses and not stopping for the children. Blaming the kids won't solve the problem.

BelleMarionette · 12/09/2022 16:04

Pixiedust1234 · 12/09/2022 15:57

Quick question - have you taught your child how to ask the bus to stop properly? Just being at a bus stop does not mean the bus has to actually stop. You need to request it. Some stops are request only, some aren't, so just request everything.

Step forward to be near the kerb, look directly towards the bus driver, put arm straight out.

It caught my dd out when she first went on buses by herself but since she started putting her arm out all buses stop (unless full).

They said they did request it, and lots of others did. It is a 'request only' bus stop. This bus goes to major stations, so quite likely it was just full.

I have looked at other routes and there are other buses they can take just a short walk away, but they didn't know this, hence the panic. Luckily, since I drove them in, there was no lateness today.

I'll have a discussion on how to hail the bus, and alternative routes today.

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 12/09/2022 15:57

Quick question - have you taught your child how to ask the bus to stop properly? Just being at a bus stop does not mean the bus has to actually stop. You need to request it. Some stops are request only, some aren't, so just request everything.

Step forward to be near the kerb, look directly towards the bus driver, put arm straight out.

It caught my dd out when she first went on buses by herself but since she started putting her arm out all buses stop (unless full).

gatehouseoffleet · 12/09/2022 15:52

Everanewbie · 12/09/2022 14:36

What kind of a teacher/school hands out detentions to a kid who's bus doesn't turn up? What happens to a teacher who gets stuck behind an accident or their bus no-shows? Are they disciplined?

It wouldn't surprise me - there seem to be some very toxic SMTs in some schools.

gatehouseoffleet · 12/09/2022 15:50

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 12/09/2022 15:45

I used to get Saturday morning detentions for the bus not arriving or getting in late. This was 50+ years ago, so nothing changes ☹️
The fact that I left home at 7am to walk 2 miles to the bus stop, 50 minutes bus ride then a further 20 minute walk counted for nothing.

My mum used to get caned for being late. And she had to go to Mass every morning and that was often why she was late for school, because the priest overran!

It's unbelievable what parents used to put up with from schools for their kids. There's an argument the pendulum has swung too much the other way, but on the whole I'm glad parents have stopped doffing their caps to teachers.