Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think detention for lateness is wrong

117 replies

BelleMarionette · 12/09/2022 09:04

My child's secondary school gives a detention for even one lateness in the morning.

My child left an hour early, for what should have been a 30 minute journey door to door by bus.

Unfortunately, 2 buses drove past them without stopping. They got very upset and anxious about being late, so I had to come and drive them (not ideal environmentally, and will not always be possible either, due to work).

My child has autism, so gets extremely anxious about the threat of detention, as rules are very important to them.

Aibu to think that detention in this circumstance is wrong, as it's often out of the child's control?

OP posts:
Kellie45 · 15/09/2022 07:43

Libertyqueen · 15/09/2022 06:55

What a pointless and heartless policy. I just have no time for this kind of batshit authoritarianism.

I love the language. The school puts a kid in detention and it’s ‘batshit authoritarianism’. No it’s trying to teach kids not to be late to prepare them for later life

dudsville · 15/09/2022 07:35

I can't believe this is still being done. I used to really struggle with getting to school on time. I had many reasons for this and they were visible in my appearance. A pure behaviour approach is blind.

Idroppedthescrewinthetuna · 15/09/2022 07:34

I remember getting 2 detentions when I was late. I was in year 10, I had never been late or had any detentions at all.
A girl was run over. I had to walk to school as the road was blocked off.
I called the school explaining I was going to be late.
I got to school and a teacher was standing in reception, she handed me a late detention slip. Then berated me for having a mobile phone (which I used to remove the battery when I was in school to show no usage) she handed me a detention slip for the next day and confiscated my phone.

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 07:30

RiftGibbon · 14/09/2022 18:53

I understand that we could ring the school. However, it isn't necessarily possible to do so, if we are travelling ourselves/already at work.

I was more concerned about whether they want proof of lateness.

Take a selfie at the bus stop when they arrive! Time stamped prove Grin

itsgettingweird · 15/09/2022 07:28

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/09/2022 20:29

If you were travelling to work and got stuck in traffic due to a RTA would you expect to get a formal warning?

Yes. In almost every job I've ever had - NHS, Insurance, call centres, reception, schools, it was completely unacceptable to be late for any reason - I got fired from one for being in an accident where I literally broke my neck (fractured the second cervical vertebrae) because the paramedic phoned in for me whilst my head was sellotaped to a stretcher when the rules said I had to phone personally.

Well in any job I've ever worked you wouldn't get a warning for something you couldn't control. There was an accident once on the motorway that closed it for 6 hours.

Many teachers didn't make it to work. They could do nothing but sit there until it cleared.

We just kept calm and carried on. Not one person got a warning for unfortunately being on a motorway when a mile or so shrewd of them a lorry overturned and caught fire. That wasn't anywhere close to being in their control. They were on their way - on time.

And yes. Unfair dismissal.

Highfivemum · 15/09/2022 07:28

The school are right to issue detention for lateness. As it does have a huge disruption on school. However if you phone ahead and explain then No there shouldn’t be detention. Schools have to be seen to be fair to all and I do think detention for lateness is a good idea but as I say they need to be flexible with the rule for the genuine. Next time quick call to school should sort it. If not then they are being unreasonable.

LouisCatorze · 15/09/2022 07:21

I think when DC have to rely on public transport to get to school it does need to be factored in. Often transport delays are totally beyond their control, and there really is a limit as to how much 'extra' time they should have to build into getting to and from school. Many leave at around 7am which is ridiculously early.

FWIW, DD has just started at a next school for sixth form. She got a 'late' on her second day and doesn't know why (she was at school with plenty of time to spare). Nothing like cutting 'newbies' a bit of slack.

MinervaTerrathorn · 15/09/2022 07:15

RiftGibbon · 14/09/2022 12:27

This nearly happened to DC today.
School starts at 9, and it's a 30 minute journey door to door.
They got to the bus stop at 7.35. Bus due 7.45.
Bus didn't turn up. Next bus due 8.05. Turned up at 8.10 with no space. Next bus isn't until 8.35. Thankfully today we were able to organise a lift.

I need to work out what we can do to prove being at the stop in ample time and the fact that the bus didn't arrive/second was too full. There are going to be days when a lift isn't available.
No way am I prepared to have a punishment for something beyond control. Its not at all practical to get the earlier bus (7.25) as the school site isn't open to pupils until 8am.

How old is the DC? I'd get the earlier one if an ongoing issue, 30 minute journey would mean they'd only be waiting outside the gates for 5 minutes?

MinervaTerrathorn · 15/09/2022 07:10

If it's public or school transport related, and they are not choosing to get the bus that gets them to school with 5 minutes to spare when there is an alternative, then there should be no detention. DS gets a dedicated school bus that is very variable in timing, the school understands the issue.

GiantTortoise · 15/09/2022 07:04

Deadringer · 15/09/2022 00:20

The school sounds ott. My dc have a note in their bag, undated, excusing their lateness citing unavoidable circumstances. They are very rarely late but having the note makes them feel more secure and stops them worrying about getting into trouble.

This is a really good idea.

GiantTortoise · 15/09/2022 07:03

I agree OP. My DC get the bus to school and it's late sometimes. They've never been given a detention and I would be cross if they were.

Libertyqueen · 15/09/2022 06:55

What a pointless and heartless policy. I just have no time for this kind of batshit authoritarianism.

Deadringer · 15/09/2022 00:20

The school sounds ott. My dc have a note in their bag, undated, excusing their lateness citing unavoidable circumstances. They are very rarely late but having the note makes them feel more secure and stops them worrying about getting into trouble.

knockyknees · 15/09/2022 00:13

Kellie45 · 13/09/2022 09:29

This attitude always strikes me as unhelpful both to kid and school. Yes we want to be on our kid’s side but not to go storming in. Have a word with the school about it and see if something can be worked out. You often find people are reasonable.

Who said anything about storming in? What a very strange thing to say. Unless that's your way of dealing with school issues?

I would be phoning the school and calmly and civily telling them the facts about the bus, and that I do not, under any circumstances, give permission for my child to be punished for something beyond their control.

RiftGibbon · 14/09/2022 18:53

I understand that we could ring the school. However, it isn't necessarily possible to do so, if we are travelling ourselves/already at work.

I was more concerned about whether they want proof of lateness.

Kellie45 · 14/09/2022 18:37

RiftGibbon · 14/09/2022 12:27

This nearly happened to DC today.
School starts at 9, and it's a 30 minute journey door to door.
They got to the bus stop at 7.35. Bus due 7.45.
Bus didn't turn up. Next bus due 8.05. Turned up at 8.10 with no space. Next bus isn't until 8.35. Thankfully today we were able to organise a lift.

I need to work out what we can do to prove being at the stop in ample time and the fact that the bus didn't arrive/second was too full. There are going to be days when a lift isn't available.
No way am I prepared to have a punishment for something beyond control. Its not at all practical to get the earlier bus (7.25) as the school site isn't open to pupils until 8am.

To me the answer in this age of mobile phones is simple in that the parent rings the school and explains the reason for lateness. Schools are reasonable in these cases.

RiftGibbon · 14/09/2022 12:27

This nearly happened to DC today.
School starts at 9, and it's a 30 minute journey door to door.
They got to the bus stop at 7.35. Bus due 7.45.
Bus didn't turn up. Next bus due 8.05. Turned up at 8.10 with no space. Next bus isn't until 8.35. Thankfully today we were able to organise a lift.

I need to work out what we can do to prove being at the stop in ample time and the fact that the bus didn't arrive/second was too full. There are going to be days when a lift isn't available.
No way am I prepared to have a punishment for something beyond control. Its not at all practical to get the earlier bus (7.25) as the school site isn't open to pupils until 8am.

Mackie5 · 13/09/2022 15:31

it is good when schools clamp down on things like lateness. Our school was pretty hot on it. I remember complaining to mum after getting the slipper for being late, “But I was only a few minutes late, mum!” She said, “Don’t you realise in the real world being a few minutes late for your job can get you fired?” Having said that it is an awkward situation where it is probably not the kids fault if they are late but if it is just a detention maybe best if they just suck it up.

Kellie45 · 13/09/2022 09:29

knockyknees · 13/09/2022 00:12

Like hell would my child be doing detention under these circumstances. I'd be informing the school that my child will not be punished for something that is beyond his/her control.

This attitude always strikes me as unhelpful both to kid and school. Yes we want to be on our kid’s side but not to go storming in. Have a word with the school about it and see if something can be worked out. You often find people are reasonable.

knockyknees · 13/09/2022 00:12

Like hell would my child be doing detention under these circumstances. I'd be informing the school that my child will not be punished for something that is beyond his/her control.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/09/2022 22:51

Needmorelego · 12/09/2022 22:38

@NeverDropYourMooncup I hope you sued that company for unfair dismissal.

Hadn't been there long enough, so they could do whatever the hell they liked.

Marvellousmadness · 12/09/2022 22:49

Oh stop it op

ALL kids dread detention not just your kid. And don't pull out the asd card for this example. Kids get detention when they are late as it is disruptive. It makes sense. Weve all been there.

If two busses pass him and dont stop Because they were full :flag with the school. And teach him to flag down a bus op!

@LondonWolf when YOU bring your kid to school late. You are right. Its not her fault. But it is yours. So leave earlier. Her special needs have nothing to do with you leaving your house too late.

Needmorelego · 12/09/2022 22:38

@NeverDropYourMooncup I hope you sued that company for unfair dismissal.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/09/2022 20:29

If you were travelling to work and got stuck in traffic due to a RTA would you expect to get a formal warning?

Yes. In almost every job I've ever had - NHS, Insurance, call centres, reception, schools, it was completely unacceptable to be late for any reason - I got fired from one for being in an accident where I literally broke my neck (fractured the second cervical vertebrae) because the paramedic phoned in for me whilst my head was sellotaped to a stretcher when the rules said I had to phone personally.

carefullycourageous · 12/09/2022 17:49

I would email the school and discuss - I would go to someone senior but not as high as the head (ours has a deputy speciically responsible for these type of issues). Usually at our school the rules are all flexible enough to take into account these real life situations - have you actually asked a teacher if this detention would be issued?

I wouldn't accept my child being punished for something they were not responsible for, so I think you are right to pursue this.