Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shall I just send him in without a nappy ?

208 replies

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 07:13

We've been potty training for a while.

I've followed some books which get you to try bare bottomed for a few days and then move on to wearing leggings etc. We have tried this a few times now. Once for almost a week. Then waited a few weeks and tried again for a weekend.

The result is always the same.. he doesn't want to go in the potty or toilet and holds his pee until he bursts.

Then Monday comes around and I need to send him to nursery and I put a nappy back on him because he needs to go to nursery and I feel like he's not ready to be sent with no nappy because he hasn't progressed.

I think it's confusing for him, sometimes he has a nappy, other times he doesn't. Shall I just ditch them ? He will learn eventually that way.

He knows how to say he needs to go, tells me he needs to go- before he goes. It's just that last final bit of actually going that he is struggling with.

I know people will say he's not ready etc. But I think he just needs to learn. He's between 2 and a half and 3 years old now. I don't want to wait another six months and have the same issues. Maybe he just needs to push through and the fact that we keep going back to nappies is the problem.

Any advice appreciated, thanks.

OP posts:
MolliciousIntent · 12/09/2022 09:28

Just FYI @TravellingJack night dryness doesn't have anything to do with potty training, it's hormonal. You basically just lucked out with your DS, it's v common for kids to be dry in the day but wet at night for years, up to age 7 or 8.

TravellingJack · 12/09/2022 09:22

We didn't potty train DS at all. We had a potty, he was welcome to sit on it (he seemed to find it a comfortable seat!) but it was never pushed on him. He was in nappies (later in pull-ups) until nursery took me aside one day (he was maybe 3 and 3 months or so) and said he had gone to the toilet consistently during the day so they hadn't needed to change his pull-up, in case I was wondering... So that evening he tried on the special big boy pants that had been waiting for him (Paw Patrol) and went to the toilet from then on. We did still put him in a pull-up at night just in case (mostly to not have to deal with a wet bed on a weekday when we were both working full time - it would have fallen to me and I was already run ragged) but it was almost always dry in the morning. My exH forgot to put it on him one night and there were no accidents, so that was that! The only accidents he has had have been when he's been ill or exceptionally tired and just didn't wake in time, maybe three occasions in total in the last 4 years.

Conversely, I have three friends with sons the same age as DS who actively potty trained at 2-2.5, and two of them still have enough accidents at night that they don't go for sleepovers, and the third is better but still has a few accidents every month. The first two have a variety of aids (mats with alarms, being woken by a parent to go) and reward charts but it's still going on. Just anecdotal and of course not everyone who potty trains is too early or has accidents! I remember feeling guilty and like we were being lazy when my friends were being so proactive, but I had too much on my plate (hence DS's father becoming an ex!) to manage potty training on top, and it turned out well in the end - luck!

Long story short - it sounds like your child isn't ready and you're just creating work for yourself, so in your shoes I would stop for now and see what happens over the next few months.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/09/2022 09:21

I don't understand why people advocate for just pushing on when the child is clearly not ready? You win no medals, and like one poster says - by the time they are older and have it nailed you don't remember anyway! Well actually, you might remember what a nightmare it was. Barring special needs, no child is going to grow up not knowing how to use the toilet just because their parent decided to do it at 3 or 3 and a half in a week instead of persevering from age 2 to age 3!

I also tried two or three times from age 2. All three of mine were done at age 3 in less than a week. Overnight took a lot longer for 2 of them.

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 09:20

londonlass71 · 12/09/2022 09:14

Why are you relying on him telling you? You need to remind him/tell him he needs to go...

Im not. I was just illustrating that he tells me.

OP posts:
AloysiusBear · 12/09/2022 09:16

The fact that he can and is choosing to hold it means physically he has bladder control and is ready.

So you need to work on why he doesn't want to go in the potty - its psychological. He is not "not ready" at between 2.5 & 3 if he has bladder control, he's just developed some negative associations/habits you need to undo.

Have you tried the approaches on Eric.com where you first ask them to sit or stand over the potty to pee but with their nappy on. Progress to sitting, then a few days later, undo one side of the nappy. A few days later, undo both. Then work in having a loose nappy in the potty and gradually cut it smaller and smaller until you can replace it with some loo roll.

londonlass71 · 12/09/2022 09:14

Why are you relying on him telling you? You need to remind him/tell him he needs to go...

Hugasauras · 12/09/2022 09:12

We had an abortive attempt about 2y4m where she wouldn't even sit on the potty or toilet without screaming. Then at 2y6m she just sat on the potty and did a wee, and within three days was 90% dry. So things can change quite rapidly I think. In another couple of months, he might just 'get' it

If he's not really made any progress I wouldn't send to nursery in pants, because nursery tends to make them go back a bit before they get as reliable as home (different environment, lots going on, toilet setup different, etc.) and if he hasn't got it sussed at home, it's unlikely he will do any better at nursery. It's also not really fair to nursery staff IMO, who are there to support potty training but not do it from scratch. They don't have the time to be watching every child closely for signs they need to go; they do require some level of communication and willingness about it from the child.

I think I would want my child to be at least 80% reliable at home before sending to nursery in pants. DD was about 95% reliable at home before she went back to nursery, but the first week she still had 3/4 accidents a day as she got used to a different place.

anon2022anon · 12/09/2022 09:05

I tried for a week with my daughter when under 2.5, she couldn't let go of the wee. She would be naked and hold on for hours, then as soon as pants went on or she got distracted, she would wee.

She's 3 next week, and we're very slowly trying again (at the moment, just at home, started with first wee of the day). It took a few days to click, but she had a day of a desperate wee going in the potty, then she seemed to get how to let go, and we've had 4 days this week of a morning half naked at home, all wees on the potty. She needed a bit more time, she's easily distracted and the type of child who can look at a screen for hours if you let her.

My next step will be a couple more naked home days, then try to introduce pants when she knows what the feeling is like. We're cracking it at home before trying at nursery- our last nursery attempt ended up with 7 pairs of wet trousers in 1 day.

Lndnmummy · 12/09/2022 09:03

I'd leave it abit. Mine weren't ready until just after 3. Then it took (I kid you not) 3 days. 1 day with the youngest.

maddy68 · 12/09/2022 09:01

He's not ready. Relax. Keep the happy on try again when the holidays start

MadamMaltesers · 12/09/2022 08:58

What I did withy one at that age was that I made sure he was put on the potty last thing before we left the house. Then took him to nursery at that age with spare clothes. After a few days of a couple of accidents in school he learnt to go sit on the toilet in nursery because the nursery workers took the children at the same time in groups to sit on the toilet at different intervals. He started copying everyone else and was dry within 2 weeks. Worth giving it a go.

Goldbar · 12/09/2022 08:57

You're making this into something negative and stressful for him. He's just not ready.

Leave the potty out, get some child seats for the toilet, buy some character pants and leave them around and tell him he can wear them when he can start using the toilet/potty for wees and poos. And then lots of praise if he has a go.

wildseas · 12/09/2022 08:56

Interestingly i feel quite differently to the majority here, and both mine were out of nappies (except overnight) by 2 - although hard to tell if that’s something I did or just chance.

I think you’ve got lots of signs there that he’s ready - the pacing and repeatedly sitting down is a good example.

id leave him in pull ups for nursery but ask them to take him to the toilet regularly.

At home id go bare bottom as soon as you get in. When it looks like he needs a wee I’d pop him on the potty, turn on some running water and read him a story to keep him sitting longer. Lots of praise when he goes in the potty. Any time he wets himself put him straight onto the potty (literally mid wee if you can)

Nappy back on again for bed time.

No adult stress about it and no telling off for accidents.

mynameiscalypso · 12/09/2022 08:52

I feel your pain. We have a 3 year old and we tried to potty train a couple of weeks ago. After a few days of zero progress (refusing to sit on the potty, denying he needed a wee and then doing one on the floor approx 30 seconds later), we gave up as it was just stressing him out. We'll leave it a while and then try again, in the meantime, he watches us use the loo and we read books about it. The comparison thing is hard though. We saw his cousin at the weekend who is a year younger and potty trained already. DS has all the signs of being ready to train but is incredibly stubborn so the more we try to push it, the more he digs in.

Saltisford · 12/09/2022 08:50

I agree he’s not ready but equally I think the nursery aren’t being very helpful - our nursery said they help with potty training and I literally sent him in in pants two days after he declared he wanted to wear pants (granted that meant he was suddenly ready)

JubileeTissues · 12/09/2022 08:43

He's not even 3 for goodness sake and you've been doing this for "ages"?

Just stop. Try again next summer

BertieBotts · 12/09/2022 08:37

Also, I disagree with some PPs that you've fucked up. You haven't at all - you've had two separate attempts, neither of which were successful. That makes sense and is fine. I would leave it for a longer period, so that you stop stressing and feeling pressure about it. Just take it totally off the table and set a further away point to address it again.

Maybe try for example over Christmas when you'll have a longer break. That's long enough for the pressure to go away. Of course in the meantime, keep showing him the toilet and explaining how you need to go for a wee and letting him see the flush etc and offering him the toilet if he wants to, but leave him in nappies and don't do any pressure, persuading, offering rewards etc. Until Christmas. Then say we're going to have a nappy free day. Offer a reward at this point if you like (single chocolate button or sticker per successful part-wee on the toilet tends to work well). Boys also like weeing standing up. DS1 liked aiming at a cheerio floating in the water - you can also use a ping pong ball (they don't flush, but I didn't want to risk it!)

In the meantime if you feel yourself wanting to say something persuasive or pleading relating to toilet use, try replacing it with the phrase "I know you'll use the toilet when you're ready." It seems to remind ME that they will one day be ready and also shows confidence in them without pressure, which can be counterproductive.

HoppingPavlova · 12/09/2022 08:36

Sounds like you started way too early and it’s caused issues. Why swap to pull ups at 18 months if not trying to start it then?

I would think you need to wait. Some of mine were over 3yo before they were ready and that’s normal. Trying when a kid isn’t ready is a) damaging for them and means the whole thing then takes longer, and b) like trying to flog a dead horse, you won’t get anywhere.

IDontLikeMondays88 · 12/09/2022 08:32

@Rutland2022 do you have anything positive to contribute?

BertieBotts · 12/09/2022 08:29

You're saying it might be how he learns, but have you been just putting him in pants and letting him wet himself over a couple of days to see if it improves? If no improvement, then it's not working and he's not learning. He's just learning that wetting himself is normal. Go back to nappies in that case.

I agree in and out of nappies all the time is confusing. So don't do that - give it a good try for a few days, if there is no improvement at all, go back to nappies full time, try again in a couple of months. One month is likely to be too soon.

Is there a deadline? Or is it only the family members you are worried about? I would ignore them. As soon as he's potty trained they will forget all about what age he was and move onto the next thing, ooh he needs to do/not do this, it doesn't matter. Listen to your child not random judgemental adults who are not even offering to help.

Twizbe · 12/09/2022 08:29

He's not ready.

Stop and stop completely for a good few months.

Boys can also be a bit slower than girls to get it.

FWIW, my eldest (boy) we tried at 2.5 and he wasn't ready. Tried again a month before he turned 3 and he got it straight away. No poo issues. Some issues with public toilets but I think that was more lockdown and just not having that experience.

My youngest (girl) was showing signs at 2 and we tried but she wasn't quite ready:m. Tried at 2.5 and she was trained in days. She does have poo issues now (almost 4) but they are directly linked to a bout of dehydration requiring hospital treatment. Nothing to do with training.

Rutland2022 · 12/09/2022 08:28

You can’t keep stopping and starting! I’m afraid you have rather fucked it.
Poor child, this will take some undoing!

autienotnaughty · 12/09/2022 08:28

When he's ready you will see the difference. It will take a couple of weeks and there will be a steady progress from start. Before then you are wasting your time and causing distress to your child. I'd leave it a few months and have another go. Nothing wrong with nappy free time in the meantime when your home and have the potty available. But wait for him to be ready.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 12/09/2022 08:28

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 12/09/2022 08:01

MN is obsessed with the not ready- consistency is key imo, that’s not to say some kids aren’t more stubborn. But going back to nappies reenforces the msg he gets a choice. When he’s pacing can you sit him on the potty with a tablet and snacks and walk away?

Do you eat on the toilet?
Years ago there was a campaign to stop forcing bfing being confined to the toilet in public areas. Hygiene was one of the reasons.

FoxtrotSkarloey · 12/09/2022 08:27

We've always left things "late", according to perceived wisdom, with DS and not seen any negative side effects.

The main reason has been that we have another younger DC and both work FT. I simply couldn't have coped with the routine you've just described.

We trained DS at 3 and a quarter and he was more than ready. He was used to seeing older children use the potty or toilet at nursery and able to tell us what he wanted to do when he wanted to. We'd chosen his big boy pants together and he said when he wanted to make the changeover. We had half a week of accidents and then he was fine.

If you are going to leave it for now, IMHO, I would leave it for a long time. To try again in a month sends mixed messages and also puts him in control.