Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shall I just send him in without a nappy ?

208 replies

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 07:13

We've been potty training for a while.

I've followed some books which get you to try bare bottomed for a few days and then move on to wearing leggings etc. We have tried this a few times now. Once for almost a week. Then waited a few weeks and tried again for a weekend.

The result is always the same.. he doesn't want to go in the potty or toilet and holds his pee until he bursts.

Then Monday comes around and I need to send him to nursery and I put a nappy back on him because he needs to go to nursery and I feel like he's not ready to be sent with no nappy because he hasn't progressed.

I think it's confusing for him, sometimes he has a nappy, other times he doesn't. Shall I just ditch them ? He will learn eventually that way.

He knows how to say he needs to go, tells me he needs to go- before he goes. It's just that last final bit of actually going that he is struggling with.

I know people will say he's not ready etc. But I think he just needs to learn. He's between 2 and a half and 3 years old now. I don't want to wait another six months and have the same issues. Maybe he just needs to push through and the fact that we keep going back to nappies is the problem.

Any advice appreciated, thanks.

OP posts:
Rainallnight · 12/09/2022 15:41

My DP used to put a bit of pressure on me and my take was always that anyone who was mopping up piss and doing the laundry got a say. Otherwise, butt out.

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 15:19

Quartz2208 · 12/09/2022 15:15

ITs not about the feeling of wanting or having to go - that is easy to recognise its the letting go bit - its something that I suspect most adults dont even think about @ohidontknownow but if you think you have to relax muscles -it is a decision not something that happens automatically

Yeah that's likely. When he goes in the nappy and I can hear that he is peeing he goes ' MUMMMMYYY ' all shocked. Bless him.

OP posts:
ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 15:18

@cultkid Yes it's why and my husband too. ' oh it's abou time he learns ' ' he just has to learn ' ' you need to keep trying '... my mum often says it as well. ' it's about time he learns ' or when he's unhappy at nappy change, MIL has told him, ' well this is what you have to put up with until you do it in the potty '. Poor darling.

I am not going to try for a while now. I'm exhausted too. Much easier to leave him in nappies for a while and see how it goes.

OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 12/09/2022 15:15

ITs not about the feeling of wanting or having to go - that is easy to recognise its the letting go bit - its something that I suspect most adults dont even think about @ohidontknownow but if you think you have to relax muscles -it is a decision not something that happens automatically

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 15:14

lanthanum · 12/09/2022 15:11

My DD was failing at the same point as your DS - she was ready, and in principle wanted to use the potty, but would sit on it for ages with no result, only to have a massive "accident" five minutes later. I eventually realised that she was just scared of actually letting go. I said "you do realise that if you're on the potty it won't go all down your legs like when you have an accident", and that seemed to be the problem - the next time she relaxed, and from then on it was absolutely fine. It might be a bit different for a boys, but worth exploring.

I think that's definitely what he is afraid of. He's had so many accidents and he hates it so much. He doesn't realise that when he does it in the potty, it will be much nicer to clean up. He hates nappy changes too.

OP posts:
lanthanum · 12/09/2022 15:11

My DD was failing at the same point as your DS - she was ready, and in principle wanted to use the potty, but would sit on it for ages with no result, only to have a massive "accident" five minutes later. I eventually realised that she was just scared of actually letting go. I said "you do realise that if you're on the potty it won't go all down your legs like when you have an accident", and that seemed to be the problem - the next time she relaxed, and from then on it was absolutely fine. It might be a bit different for a boys, but worth exploring.

cultkid · 12/09/2022 15:07

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 07:41

It's annoying because relatives always ask and when I explain, they just say I need to keep going. No one ever says stop. I always say stop and feel like they think I am lazy and giving up. I've stop and started a few times now and decided he isn't ready and they always turn their noses up a bit because they all potty trained by two years old. We don't have toilet issues from being trained younger.

This will be why you feel shit about it

Tell them to stop asking it's incredibly nosey and your child isn't ready so you are not going to alienate him and make him anxious about it. Then ask them to "change the subject please, to something that is your business"

cultkid · 12/09/2022 15:06

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 07:33

I think there are three approaches to potty training.. one that takes ages- the one we are doing, because perhaps he's not ' ready '. Then there's waiting until he is a bit older, when he might get it quicker. Then there is waiting until hes a bit older and having to go through all this anyway, because this will be how he learns for some reason. There is no guarantee that in six months it will be different. I know children where it wasn't different and still took months to potty train and they were not confident when they were at school and this is not good for their self esteem. That's what I'm worried about. It could take ages anyway and he the same, even if we wait. I guess I don't know.

What makes me think we should wait is the UTI issue.
Will send him in with a nappy and try again in a month.

I think there is one approach
When the child is ready

Keep him naked at home with potty
Rewards stickers huge rounds of applause
Buy him a crown

I have three children. I like to think I'm fairly balanced and experienced as a parent.

First one potty trained approx 2.5 years old he is now 6 and still wets at night so he is in a pull up because you can't force it. Poo was another story and it took until about 3 for that to click and he wanted to use a nappy.

Second child, walking at 12 months and then potty trained himself as his brother was using the potty, by literally 14 months
He wore nappies in the car on school run until he was around 2. Often home dry, sometimes wet. Spared him his dignity. Now for a year he does not wear a nappy even in the car and we chat and he tells me and he goes in a large neck bottle in the car if there's no toilet

Third one, a baby, she will also be basically naked with a potty and I'm guessing she will follow suit with once she's walking she will want to do a wee in the potty too, if she doesn't, cool. She can take a nappy off and show us when she's interested. Nappies back on and we see what she does when she's ready.

When you rush a kid with the toilet they get anxious and stressed and it's no good.

I always always always always try to keep my kids as calm as possible. They pick up on your frustrations and he will feel ashamed if you force this

I know it's annoying for you, but get him back in nappies leave potties all over and let him work it out himself

I know it's hard being a parent trust me I cry about it a lot and I'm exhausted but honestly the toilet thing is one thing you can't come down heavy on

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 12/09/2022 15:01

Obviously he's not ready??

cultkid · 12/09/2022 14:59

No because he isn't potty trained
And he isn't ready by the sounds of things

Back to nappies or pull ups if you want to try to empower him and wait until he is.

Why should you stress him out with potty training if he is not ready

antelopevalley · 12/09/2022 14:58

Learning to let go is easier in the bath.

antelopevalley · 12/09/2022 14:56

MrsToadflax · 12/09/2022 13:37

I didn't mean 2.5. That is obviously normal and what I was advised by a health visitor. I meant in general it is now discussed much earlier. A friend tried to train her 16 month old and I've seem parents holding a 9 month old over a potty. Just let them be little and they'll train when it's the right time for them.

Average toilet training is much later now than in the past. The government has collected stats on this since the 1950s.

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 14:17

Quartz2208 · 12/09/2022 14:11

Readiness for potty training is made up of different factors.

Your child sounds emotionally ready, cognitively ready and has the motor and verbal skills.

What he seems to lack and what no amount of training or intervention can give you and does simply need to wait is the physiological element the learning of actually how to recognise you need to go and how to go - you think of how you need to go you relax the muscles.

WIth both of my it was that that was the missing bit, recognising how to control and use the bladder muscles and what it means. You are right he just isnt sure what to do

That's interesting because I think he knows what it feels like to go because he literally tells me or makes a noise and signals.

I think he's scared to do it because if he's not in a nappy it makes a mess ( because it's not going in the potty ). But perhaps your theory is right. I would say he's ready physically, but emotionally not ready. But I could be completely wrong.

OP posts:
Notplayingball · 12/09/2022 14:16

My advice. Back to nappies for six months. Then try again.

He isn't ready.

Redab · 12/09/2022 14:16

He's not ready.
You're doing this because of peer / family pressure.

I did the same with DS1. He was almost four before he got it (and then many years of accidents). Looking back it was stressful and unnecessary for all concerned, most of all for the child.
I vowed not to make the same mistake with DS2 and refused all suggestions of potty training at 2 and 2.5. I planned to wait until at least three and the start of holidays.
What actually happened at 2.5 is that he said mummy I don't need nappies any more and he took them off and that was it.
Moral of the story is they are all different. Leave it, take the pressure off. It will happen eventually.

Hugasauras · 12/09/2022 14:14

Never mind, just read on Eric and it's not always a hormonal thing. For some kids they just don't wake up because their brain and bladder aren't communicating, which is where the alarms come in.

Quartz2208 · 12/09/2022 14:11

Readiness for potty training is made up of different factors.

Your child sounds emotionally ready, cognitively ready and has the motor and verbal skills.

What he seems to lack and what no amount of training or intervention can give you and does simply need to wait is the physiological element the learning of actually how to recognise you need to go and how to go - you think of how you need to go you relax the muscles.

WIth both of my it was that that was the missing bit, recognising how to control and use the bladder muscles and what it means. You are right he just isnt sure what to do

Hugasauras · 12/09/2022 14:10

What I'm curious about is that if it's solely hormone controlled, how do bedwetting alarms work?

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 14:10

Summerfun54321 · 12/09/2022 14:01

Both mine potty trained around age 2 - 2.5. I took 2 weeks off work to do a stint of no nappy then pant wearing and yes there were lots of accidents but that’s part of the process. I think a week isn’t long enough. In order to stop going backwards, have you tried re-usable nappies? They sense when they are wet unlike the disposable nappies which are comfortable when wet. A lot of people who use reusable nappies just potty train earlier mostly because there’s more motivation for the child. It sounds like it’s getting stressful for you so maybe take some time out, but it also doesn’t sound like your nursery is being very helpful at all. They push for potty training before age 3 at my DCs nursery as by pre-school age they expect them all to be out of nappies. Good luck.

The week not being long enough is also a point I've been thinking about. Some posters have said it wasn't progress. But after 3-4 days he stopped holding his pee in and there was more opportunity for me then to show him to do it on the potty. I would watch him like a hawk and then gently move him onto the potty as soon as he started peeing.

As for the books.. I have read a couple and he shows many signs he's ready. I haven't seen anything in the books about kids who try to hold it. Maybe I need another one !

OP posts:
ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 14:07

cavia · 12/09/2022 14:02

He's not ready. Stop and try again when he's 3 unless he tells you he's ready before then

Like I said, he did tell me the other night he wanted to go and use the potty. But then he didn't do it. I think he wants to. I'll just have a break, no pressure. We have both really given it a go. So at least I know we tried. It's not the right time yet.

OP posts:
Hugasauras · 12/09/2022 14:07

@FirstAidKitNowPlease I know that! It was in response to the discussion about being heavy sleepers possibly having an impact too.

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 14:05

Summerfun54321 · 12/09/2022 14:01

Both mine potty trained around age 2 - 2.5. I took 2 weeks off work to do a stint of no nappy then pant wearing and yes there were lots of accidents but that’s part of the process. I think a week isn’t long enough. In order to stop going backwards, have you tried re-usable nappies? They sense when they are wet unlike the disposable nappies which are comfortable when wet. A lot of people who use reusable nappies just potty train earlier mostly because there’s more motivation for the child. It sounds like it’s getting stressful for you so maybe take some time out, but it also doesn’t sound like your nursery is being very helpful at all. They push for potty training before age 3 at my DCs nursery as by pre-school age they expect them all to be out of nappies. Good luck.

I have tried thick underwear type things. Doesn't make much difference..but I could give that another go, rather than pull ups.

As for the nursery, they're really nice and willing to help. They take him to the potty with the other kids that are potty training, but he doesn't do anything there. Just sits on it. We haven't progressed enough for me to send him without a nappy. He would just wet himself all day.

OP posts:
FirstAidKitNowPlease · 12/09/2022 14:04

Hugasauras · 12/09/2022 13:55

DD(3.5) has been dry during day for about a year but still wets overnight. She's a super heavy sleeper so I think that's partly to blame! If she does get woken in the night she often goes to pee before going back to sleep but she won't wake up from needing to pee, if that makes sense.

The overnight dryness is hormone driven. Nothing to do with training or heavy sleeping.

cavia · 12/09/2022 14:02

He's not ready. Stop and try again when he's 3 unless he tells you he's ready before then

Summerfun54321 · 12/09/2022 14:01

Both mine potty trained around age 2 - 2.5. I took 2 weeks off work to do a stint of no nappy then pant wearing and yes there were lots of accidents but that’s part of the process. I think a week isn’t long enough. In order to stop going backwards, have you tried re-usable nappies? They sense when they are wet unlike the disposable nappies which are comfortable when wet. A lot of people who use reusable nappies just potty train earlier mostly because there’s more motivation for the child. It sounds like it’s getting stressful for you so maybe take some time out, but it also doesn’t sound like your nursery is being very helpful at all. They push for potty training before age 3 at my DCs nursery as by pre-school age they expect them all to be out of nappies. Good luck.