Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shall I just send him in without a nappy ?

208 replies

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 07:13

We've been potty training for a while.

I've followed some books which get you to try bare bottomed for a few days and then move on to wearing leggings etc. We have tried this a few times now. Once for almost a week. Then waited a few weeks and tried again for a weekend.

The result is always the same.. he doesn't want to go in the potty or toilet and holds his pee until he bursts.

Then Monday comes around and I need to send him to nursery and I put a nappy back on him because he needs to go to nursery and I feel like he's not ready to be sent with no nappy because he hasn't progressed.

I think it's confusing for him, sometimes he has a nappy, other times he doesn't. Shall I just ditch them ? He will learn eventually that way.

He knows how to say he needs to go, tells me he needs to go- before he goes. It's just that last final bit of actually going that he is struggling with.

I know people will say he's not ready etc. But I think he just needs to learn. He's between 2 and a half and 3 years old now. I don't want to wait another six months and have the same issues. Maybe he just needs to push through and the fact that we keep going back to nappies is the problem.

Any advice appreciated, thanks.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ancientgran · 16/09/2022 20:46

ohidontknownow · 16/09/2022 07:41

Update on the situation..

I have sent him in without the nappy all week. He has been in nappies at all times at home too.

When he's been at home, I have noticed he gets upset when he has to ' go ' unless he's distracted and then he just does it. But often he walks around whinging and crying a little bit and saying mummy and ' oh no ' and holding his crotch.. not ideal, poor thing.

I try to distract him and then he eventually does it and tells me that he's done a poo poo and can I change his nappy, so I do.

Last night he was again pacing around and complaining ( with a nappy on ) and he was telling me he needs to do a poo poo. So basically, he knows he need to go, but he doesn't know where to go. It's obviously stuck with him that if he does it, then there is a mess. ( because we have been without a nappy so many times now ).. anyhow he was doing it last night so I just took the nappy off and put it on the potty. He didn't want to sit on the potty again at first, but with a little distraction he eventually sat down. In the end he finally did his business on the potty for the first time.

This is positive. But essentially we've ended up in a situation where he is worried about doing his business anywhere now. I think it's because he absolutely hates the mess of it. Has anyone had this situation ? I'm not sure today whether to just push through and encourage him to go on the potty and then he may slowly start to understand it, or whether to ignore it completely and put him back in nappies.

He has obviously developed an issue now where he is worried about doing it either way. So I either teach him to do it in the nappy again ( which I have encouraged, when he's has come to me and said he needs to do poo poo) or I actually show him that in the potty there is no mess. It's a tricky situation we are in !

As I said earlier with one of mine the nappy in the potty was the thing that worked. It is obviously some psychological thing but we let them do it for a few weeks and it really worked. Was wonderful when we could take the nappy away.

With mine we got rid of the nappy for wees first but he asked for it when he wanted a poo. Eventually they were fine without the nappy. The nice thing was I could buy dead cheap nappies, cheap brand small nappies to line the potty, so it wasn't so expensive. I didn't have much money at the time and was desperate to stop buying nappies.

I'd keep trying with the nappy in the potty and it probably won't be long till you've got it sorted.

CoastalWave · 16/09/2022 13:28

Sceptre86 · 12/09/2022 07:24

I potty trained all of mine during holidays so I was off too and could give them my full support. Also there was no confusing nappy on off situation. I took them to get big girl or big boy pants, we read a book about it, watched a few episodes on YouTube about wearing pants and then just went for it. My son took at week aged 2.5 years but my dd was 3. I did try with my dd at 2.5 years but she just wasn't ready.

^^ This.

There's no half hearted with potty training - you need to take a week off and just do it. If they're not ready it will be blatantly obvious quite quickly.

Leave it til the next holidays. Potty training takes a week - not a 'while' Focus on dry in the day - forget about training for night, whack on a nappy and start doing an 11pm 'lift' whilst they're half asleep.

Keep him in the house, with you for a full week. It's bloody hard graft but so worth it and doesn't confuse the child. When you finally venture outside on day 5 ish, make the walks/pram rides short, don't take them on a full blown shopping trip. Lots of rewards. Except lots of accidents in first few days. Cold turkey is the best way to do it.

antelopevalley · 16/09/2022 13:21

Regular trips to the potty used to be how everyone toilet trained at one time. After every meal and snack and drink. You started young so they were not frightened of the potty.

antelopevalley · 16/09/2022 13:20

He needs to learn to let go. It is a skill you can practise in the bath. Being in warm water can make it easier to let go.

ohidontknownow · 16/09/2022 11:15

@Discovereads I completely disagree. He knows when he needs to go. He just doesn't know how to go. He's not just telling me he needs to go to please me, he actually needs to go and knows what it feels like to need to go. It's the actually going that's the issue with him!

OP posts:
twoandcooplease · 16/09/2022 10:38

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 07:22

He’s not ready at all. You need to send him in with a nappy.
When he says he needs to go, he’s just saying that to please you which is why nothing comes out when you then take him to the loo. He doesn’t actually know what the urge to go feels like. This is very common in young children, especially boys.
What worked for us was regular trips to the potty to try for a wee when we knew they’d just had a lot to drink and their bladder was likely full. Then the objective is to simply make the potty relaxing and familiar. Give them a book to look at or a Teddy to hold. Sit for a few minutes. Then repeat every hour or so.
Once they have wee’d on the potty, then they’ll start associating certain bodily feelings with the potty and needing a wee. Over time, they then go from knowing the need to wee NOW! This second! To being able to tell when they need to go but can hold a bit, then hold for longer.

This is so helpful to know for when I potty train ds

ohidontknownow · 16/09/2022 09:24

MolliciousIntent · 16/09/2022 09:22

Ah I see, yeah that makes sense. Sorry was just spitballing ideas.

No problem. I really appreciate any ideas. Thank you !

OP posts:
MolliciousIntent · 16/09/2022 09:22

Ah I see, yeah that makes sense. Sorry was just spitballing ideas.

ohidontknownow · 16/09/2022 08:23

MolliciousIntent · 16/09/2022 08:17

Have you checked that the consistency of his poo is normal? Toddler poop should be pretty well formed, it shouldn't be messy. Do you take him with you when you use the loo? To show him it's not messy?

I think the poo is normal. It just gets messy when he poos in his trousers. I don't want to elaborate. But yes poo is normal.

I take him all the time to the toilet to check out what we do there.

OP posts:
MolliciousIntent · 16/09/2022 08:17

Have you checked that the consistency of his poo is normal? Toddler poop should be pretty well formed, it shouldn't be messy. Do you take him with you when you use the loo? To show him it's not messy?

ohidontknownow · 16/09/2022 07:52

MolliciousIntent · 16/09/2022 07:52

Can you get a seat and a step for the toilet? Much less messy than the potty.

I have that too. I have had no success in getting him to sit on that at all.

OP posts:
MolliciousIntent · 16/09/2022 07:52

Can you get a seat and a step for the toilet? Much less messy than the potty.

ohidontknownow · 16/09/2022 07:41

Update on the situation..

I have sent him in without the nappy all week. He has been in nappies at all times at home too.

When he's been at home, I have noticed he gets upset when he has to ' go ' unless he's distracted and then he just does it. But often he walks around whinging and crying a little bit and saying mummy and ' oh no ' and holding his crotch.. not ideal, poor thing.

I try to distract him and then he eventually does it and tells me that he's done a poo poo and can I change his nappy, so I do.

Last night he was again pacing around and complaining ( with a nappy on ) and he was telling me he needs to do a poo poo. So basically, he knows he need to go, but he doesn't know where to go. It's obviously stuck with him that if he does it, then there is a mess. ( because we have been without a nappy so many times now ).. anyhow he was doing it last night so I just took the nappy off and put it on the potty. He didn't want to sit on the potty again at first, but with a little distraction he eventually sat down. In the end he finally did his business on the potty for the first time.

This is positive. But essentially we've ended up in a situation where he is worried about doing his business anywhere now. I think it's because he absolutely hates the mess of it. Has anyone had this situation ? I'm not sure today whether to just push through and encourage him to go on the potty and then he may slowly start to understand it, or whether to ignore it completely and put him back in nappies.

He has obviously developed an issue now where he is worried about doing it either way. So I either teach him to do it in the nappy again ( which I have encouraged, when he's has come to me and said he needs to do poo poo) or I actually show him that in the potty there is no mess. It's a tricky situation we are in !

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 09:13

In the same boat as you, my daughter has just turned 3 and is clueless to knowing in time. We tried but haven't pushed it and have gone back to normal nappies instead of pull ups for a few months. I know she'll be older than many but I'd rather her develop elsewhere than fight something she can't yet control

antelopevalley · 12/09/2022 23:13

MrsToadflax · 12/09/2022 22:24

Average toilet training is much later now than in the past. The government has collected stats on this since the 1950s.

Interesting to know that on a national level. In my local area, at toddler groups etc, it was weirdly competitive as to who was potty training and how young they were - never understood it!

When mothers used to have wash cloth nappies without modern washing machines, there was a large incentive to toilet train as soon as possible.

CecilyP · 12/09/2022 23:07

I am not going to try for a while now. I'm exhausted too. Much easier to leave him in nappies for a while and see how it goes.

Yes, it seems like he’s physically ready if he can hold on for ages, but is really anxious about it. Which is hardly surprising with the whole family going on and on and on about it. Tell them in no uncertain terms to back off. Forget about the potty for at least 6 weeks, no mention of it whatsoever from anyone. Try again when your all more relaxed.

MrsToadflax · 12/09/2022 22:24

Average toilet training is much later now than in the past. The government has collected stats on this since the 1950s.

Interesting to know that on a national level. In my local area, at toddler groups etc, it was weirdly competitive as to who was potty training and how young they were - never understood it!

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 18:04

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2022 18:01

Well he didn't seem to want his nappy, so I took it off. He kept doing it, like he was uncomfortable. Why is that such a horrid thing to do ??

Because that's not TT.

You don't just take off his nappy & let him poo wherever. You have a plan for how you'll approach it. If you knew he was going to poo, why handle it like that? Of course it was going to go everywhere if you took off his nappy & let it! And he is old enough to find that distressing.

The 90-minute thing is just odd. It doesn't sound like anything I've heard re kids & TT. I would never have left them there for that time. I'd have watched really carefully & at the moment he was close to going to the toilet, whisked him in there. You seem to be devolving responsibility to your DS all the time.

Eh that's what I was doing for 90 minutes ! What do you think i was doing ? I was interacting with him and watching him. He was pacing around / playing and sitting on the potty occasionally. Did you think he was just sitting on the potty for 90 minutes ?

As for when I took the nappy off, I also placed him on the potty. But it went everywhere. I didn't whipp the nappy off wherever. I'm not a complete idiot.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2022 18:01

Well he didn't seem to want his nappy, so I took it off. He kept doing it, like he was uncomfortable. Why is that such a horrid thing to do ??

Because that's not TT.

You don't just take off his nappy & let him poo wherever. You have a plan for how you'll approach it. If you knew he was going to poo, why handle it like that? Of course it was going to go everywhere if you took off his nappy & let it! And he is old enough to find that distressing.

The 90-minute thing is just odd. It doesn't sound like anything I've heard re kids & TT. I would never have left them there for that time. I'd have watched really carefully & at the moment he was close to going to the toilet, whisked him in there. You seem to be devolving responsibility to your DS all the time.

DixonD · 12/09/2022 17:03

GiftIdeasAlwaysNeeded · 12/09/2022 07:23

I know people will say he's not ready etc. But I think he just needs to learn.

I've potty trained 3 kinds, and disagree with this. In my experience, if it's not working then they're not ready, and trying to push it just makes it more stressful for you in the long run.

My middle child got up one day, at 3yo, told me she was going to use the potty and that was the end of nappies 🤷🏼‍♀️

Same here - my daughter was nearly 3. You’re pushing him when he’s not ready.

My daughter just decided she was going to try it and then that was it. It shouldn’t be as hard as you’re making it. If it’s hard, it not the right time.

Jaaxe · 12/09/2022 16:57

He doesn’t sound ready quite yet but it’s good you have tried and I’m sure it’ll come in time but I’d perhaps take a step back and wait for him. I have trained 3 of my children and they each cracked it within 3/4 days from when they decided to use the potty at age 2.5 but I didnt put any pressure on and it wasn’t stressful for either myself or them.

I start off by introducing the potty and just having it around and discussing that’s where we wee and poo.

I get some potty training books in we read together regularly. My kids loved “poo poo bum bum wee wee” because it’s funny and also “pip and posy the little puddle” where we’d discuss the potty and link it to the potty we have in the house.

My kids are constantly stripping off anyway so id let them be bottomless for parts of the day when I thought theyd took to not minding the potty etc I’d say things like “remember if you need a wee, use the potty like pip (character in book)” if I nipped out the room.

With each child they just decided to go and use the potty one day. We had big celebrations when they did and how clever they were. Stickers and chocolate button as a well done (3rd child didn’t even require this).

Any accidents it was just “oh no doesn’t matter, just an accident, try again next time”

Big fuss taking them out to choose “big boy/girl pants/knickers” of their choice.

Once they were comfortable using the potty at home for a couple of days bottomless I’d venture out with them somewhere easy and relaxing wearing clothes and keep reminding them they had their big boy/girl pants on and asking do they need a wee or going for a try.

They were all accident free within a week. Night time the girls were also dry within the week. My son still has accidents now and again.

Lastly don’t take any notice what family / friends say u no ur child best and all children are different but I guarantee he won’t go school in nappies don’t worry, my son was VERY against the potty when I first introduced it, I thought he was going to be a nightmare, he wasn’t at all I was shocked

ancientgran · 12/09/2022 16:21

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 15:14

I think that's definitely what he is afraid of. He's had so many accidents and he hates it so much. He doesn't realise that when he does it in the potty, it will be much nicer to clean up. He hates nappy changes too.

That was why we put the nappy in the potty, once he sat down on the potty with his nappy he was OK, after a couple of weeks we just didn't put the nappy in the potty and he was fine.

Goldbar · 12/09/2022 16:15

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 15:18

@cultkid Yes it's why and my husband too. ' oh it's abou time he learns ' ' he just has to learn ' ' you need to keep trying '... my mum often says it as well. ' it's about time he learns ' or when he's unhappy at nappy change, MIL has told him, ' well this is what you have to put up with until you do it in the potty '. Poor darling.

I am not going to try for a while now. I'm exhausted too. Much easier to leave him in nappies for a while and see how it goes.

Your problem isn't your son. He's doing fine. Your problem is your husband and wider family. They're putting pressure on you and pressure on him and stressing you both out. This is making your son anxious about the whole process, which is probably half of the problem.

My MIL/mother also potty-trained their own children earlier, but wisely kept their views to themselves when we were potty-training DC except for the odd encouraging remark. And they never said anything to DC... if they had, I would have flipped out. DH had the odd exasperated sigh when DC had an accident that we had to clear up until I made it clear that this wasn't acceptable. There should be no shame, upset or embarrassment around nappies or toileting.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/09/2022 16:11

I've never understood why people are in such a hurry with this. When children are ready they generally pick it up really quick saving lots of hassle for child and parent. Plus nappies are much more convenient for a child that isn't properly dry. What's the point of "training" them earlier than they are ready?

cultkid · 12/09/2022 16:08

ohidontknownow · 12/09/2022 15:18

@cultkid Yes it's why and my husband too. ' oh it's abou time he learns ' ' he just has to learn ' ' you need to keep trying '... my mum often says it as well. ' it's about time he learns ' or when he's unhappy at nappy change, MIL has told him, ' well this is what you have to put up with until you do it in the potty '. Poor darling.

I am not going to try for a while now. I'm exhausted too. Much easier to leave him in nappies for a while and see how it goes.

I hear you

I'm sorry they are pressuring you
Show him the thread

You can't force a kid it's frustrating but a kid who's insecure is even worse and also one who smells of wee is insecure too

I'm sorry they are not supportive
Lots of love you've taken a beating with all of the he isn't ready on this thread xx