Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My sister can be a bit odd

60 replies

Ritascornershop · 11/09/2022 23:45

My sister is unfailingly helpful and really does her bit for family. However, like all of us, she can be a bit odd.

Imo she’s got fixed ideas about how people ought to behave and any deviation from that is met with shock and disbelief. Recent things I’ve done that she’s been shocked about; not taken a book on a long flight (planned to read articles on my phone, watch onboard tv, and nap), ordered Thai after said long flight instead of shopping for food and cooking, killing an ant in my car “but you can’t do that. We are kind to animals”. I don’t care if people eat meat, but I haven’t for over 30 years. She eats meat, so I found that schoolmarmish telling off a bit peculiar. I said “you eat meat” & she said “sometimes, but I’d never kill an ant”. (I’m not saying I have a great excuse for it, but ants creep me right out and I don’t think they feel pain or process emotions in the same way animals do).

Am I being unreasonable to find it a bit annoying that a middle-aged woman can’t imagine someone has different habits than she does. She’s also shocked that I like wind, watching telly, and occasionally wearing high heels: ie, am a different person to her.

OP posts:
LongLivedQueen · 12/09/2022 11:07

Choconut · 12/09/2022 11:05

Isn't it just a case of her having different views to you and expressing them? All sounds very minor.

No, it isn't. That isn't at all what OP is describing.

Choconut · 12/09/2022 11:05

Isn't it just a case of her having different views to you and expressing them? All sounds very minor.

Hotandbothereds · 12/09/2022 11:02

I reckon the people who can’t understand why this is irritating are people who do this 😆

Adversity · 12/09/2022 09:15

Unless someone’s behaviour is going to actually harm me or someone else I really couldn’t get my knickers in a twist over those sort of low key things.

Pineappleslush · 12/09/2022 09:10

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 12/09/2022 09:00

My DF is like this and it gets exhausting in every conversation, even the smallest things.

But judging by the threads on here I’m sure your DS is a prolific mumsnetter! The amount of people who ‘simply cannot understand why neighbour/DH/Friend does x and not y’ never ceases to amaze me. Maybe it’s because different people like / do different things?!

Ha! I was just about to say that she is probably a mumsnetter! Some posters just can't accept that others are different.

There's a saying isn't there... "can't see past her/his own nose" for people like this. I don't know what it is, I mean empathy is being able to see the situation through another persons eyes? So, it's a lack of empathy but added to that the genuine confusion. You say she does a lot for your family? It might just be a case of learning to live with it.

MsRosley · 12/09/2022 09:09

She sounds rather endearing actually. Can you just have a laugh about it, OP?

ManateeFair · 12/09/2022 09:06

Your sister sounds like all those Mumsnetters who get hugely irate about choices made by other people that affect them in no way whatsoever, like what sort of haircuts other people’s children have, whether they wear pyjamas to relax in, and whether their neighbours open/close their curtains at particular times.

As others have said, there’s probably an element of insecurity in your sister’s comments, but I also think some of them hint at a certain type of snobbery - telly, heels, takeaway, not taking a book on a plane etc. I used to have a colleague who was a bit like this - anything that she perceived to be shallow or frivolous, she claimed to find strange and would question. She used to quiz another colleague of mine about why she wore heels every day and she was weird about another who bought expensive trainers for his little boy. She was very odd about me liking football too, arguing with me when I explained why I like it. I got the strong impression that it was her way of trying to tell us she was on a higher plane than people who liked clothes or makeup or reading a magazine occasionally.

Ragged · 12/09/2022 09:05

MIL can be like this. She was raised to think their family way was right & other people are strange to do different. It's a prejudice and arrogance. Have to work to stop DH from thinking the same way.

My family is enormously opposite in a zillion ways, but also have their own prejudices. "I'm sure [MIL] just wants [DH name] to be happy" my dad said, once. I had to correct him, that MIL most wanted DH to be "safe". Happiness was incidental. My dad found that too weird (his prejudice revealed).

Duvetcoverofdoom · 12/09/2022 09:02

My whole family can be a bit like this. There are other autistic traits in the family and my DS has been diagnosed as autistic. So I know it's the usual MN cop out, but I do think that is part of it.

The worst I've noticed is that my DSIS seems unable to accept that people 'move on' from hobbies, interests and just general things in their lives. I have two primary aged kids who naturally very quickly change interests and hobbies. She seems unable to fathom that my 7YO doesn't love Thomas the Tank engine anymore like when he did when he was 3YO.

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 12/09/2022 09:00

My DF is like this and it gets exhausting in every conversation, even the smallest things.

But judging by the threads on here I’m sure your DS is a prolific mumsnetter! The amount of people who ‘simply cannot understand why neighbour/DH/Friend does x and not y’ never ceases to amaze me. Maybe it’s because different people like / do different things?!

maddy68 · 12/09/2022 08:56

Surely she is just making conversation. ...

Badgirlriri · 12/09/2022 08:53

YABU for making a big issue out of this when it just sounds like she’s making conversation.

Hotandbothereds · 12/09/2022 08:50

SleeplessInEngland · 12/09/2022 08:14

Doesn’t sound like a big deal, to be honest, unless there’s more you’re not telling us.

I think unless you’ve been around someone like this for a significant amount of time it’s perhaps difficult to understand quite how irritating being ‘corrected’ for your own thoughts and ideas constantly is.

BudgetBlast · 12/09/2022 08:45

I have 2 sils (sisters) who are both a bit like this. One is likely autistic, I have an autistic son and she was the initial driver for going to get him checked out and the other has significant anxiety. It is absolutely exhausting but like your sister they are really nice people and we get along well but we limit our time with them to make it work.

honeylulu · 12/09/2022 08:43

My mum is like this and it took years to realise she has very low self esteem. She comes across as quite bolshy and domineering which is why it took me so long to recognise.

Anything I did that was different to her really seemed to offend her, as if it was a huge rejection of who she was (as opposed to just being a different person in a different generation!) She gets on much better with my sister who is much more like her and has followed in her footsteps much more.

I've learned to brush it off cheerily. Though this is after many years of feeling like a terrible disappointment!

I don't know if there is anything you can do. Low self esteem is ingrained and can't be easily fixed, especially if the person does not recognise that is the issue.

EL8888 · 12/09/2022 08:36

YANBU sounds very wearing. I have family members like this and it drives me insane. I feel like l should make a recording on my phone saying “everyone’s different, it would be boring if we were all the same”. Then play it all the time

My mum has poor theory of mind and is a particular culprit of this. She just can’t get other people’s perspectives. She was moaning about her neighbour not doing enough gardening and her front garden looking a mess (looked fine to me by the way). I pointed out she had 3 children under 5, worked full time and probably didn’t care. The not caring bit blew my mums mind but then again she only had 2 children and worked part time so quite a different set up

itsnotmeitsdefinitelyyou · 12/09/2022 08:33

My DH can be like this, can't understand that I've got my own brain and own way of thinking / doing things.

I'm pretty sure he has undiagnosed 'something' but as I'm not a psychiatrist I don't know what - just further up the spectrum (not based purely on this trait, there are many other 'tells')

SleeplessInEngland · 12/09/2022 08:14

Doesn’t sound like a big deal, to be honest, unless there’s more you’re not telling us.

IMustMakeAmends · 12/09/2022 08:10

YANBU for finding it exhausting although some people really do struggle to consider there are other ways of doing things, or other things people might like. I've got better at this as I've got older but I'm not sure it's something that comes naturally to me.

It is a self-esteem thing, ultimately. If someone does something differently, or doesn't like something I love, does that make me wrong? I must be wrong. God, if I'm wrong about this, what else am I wrong about? Fuck, I'm wrong about everything! I am a piece of shit that doesn't deserve room on this earth!

Ok that's a slightly exaggerated timeline/thought process but for people with anxiety, low self esteem etc, it can be hard to have their way of living 'challenged' by the existence of other ways. I have got a lot better at shrugging this off as I've got older.

Also she's right about the ants! Let her deal with it if you don't want to.

Hotandbothereds · 12/09/2022 07:51

One of my DHs mates is like this about everything and it’s so wearing, we went on holiday with him & his wife and god I was done by the end.

Every little thing, if not how he’d do it, was ‘wrong’, no concept that people just have different ideas, ways of doing things, none of it was hurting anyone, he’s just incapable of understanding that people have their own minds, it’s quite bizarre.

BlueThingie · 12/09/2022 07:47

I spent a while wondering how you killed an ant in your car, imagining that you had driven over one (how would you know?) but you mean it was inside the car, don't you? 😭

Anyway, we all have our quirks and it sounds like hers is a lack of imagination as to how other people live. My MIL was just like this. I tended to say mildly "I'll have to give that a try" every time she remarked that I wasn't doing things how she would do them.

Butchyrestingface · 12/09/2022 07:41

She DOES sound a bit different. Doubt she’ll change at this point though.

Still,

killing an ant in my car “but you can’t do that. We are kind to animals”

♥️

Hyacinth2 · 12/09/2022 07:27

Your. DPs are different people - probably one takes after DM and the other after DF.

Mummadeze · 12/09/2022 06:14

My Mum went on and on about the fact that I chose a partner who can’t drive. She said it makes him less of a man, why won’t he have lessons, she would only ever be with someone who can drive etc etc. We live in London, I don’t drive myself and I couldn’t give a toss if he drives or not. Of all the things she could have chose to obsess over, that was it. I found it so weird.

Wouldloveanother · 12/09/2022 06:09

Mines the same. She has a very narrow spectrum of behaviour that she finds acceptable in others, and can’t really process that other people can be different but that doesn’t make them rude/offensive/insulting. She’s very thin skinned and has to make everything work to her advantage or convenience. Yeah, it’s exhausting. But family and that 🤷🏼‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread