Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My sister can be a bit odd

60 replies

Ritascornershop · 11/09/2022 23:45

My sister is unfailingly helpful and really does her bit for family. However, like all of us, she can be a bit odd.

Imo she’s got fixed ideas about how people ought to behave and any deviation from that is met with shock and disbelief. Recent things I’ve done that she’s been shocked about; not taken a book on a long flight (planned to read articles on my phone, watch onboard tv, and nap), ordered Thai after said long flight instead of shopping for food and cooking, killing an ant in my car “but you can’t do that. We are kind to animals”. I don’t care if people eat meat, but I haven’t for over 30 years. She eats meat, so I found that schoolmarmish telling off a bit peculiar. I said “you eat meat” & she said “sometimes, but I’d never kill an ant”. (I’m not saying I have a great excuse for it, but ants creep me right out and I don’t think they feel pain or process emotions in the same way animals do).

Am I being unreasonable to find it a bit annoying that a middle-aged woman can’t imagine someone has different habits than she does. She’s also shocked that I like wind, watching telly, and occasionally wearing high heels: ie, am a different person to her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StopStreet · 12/09/2022 21:50

I'm autistic and have had times of being like your sister. It is frequently a surprise that others think differently from me.

mycatisannoying · 12/09/2022 21:43

Everyone is different. I don't see it as an issue personally.

Iknowthis1 · 12/09/2022 21:40

In my sister's case I think it's to do controlling anxiety. She deals with anxiety by trying to be in control of everything. Over the years this control has evolved into a strong set of rules to live by. It's perplexing to her that sometime can live happily outside of these rules.

Hotandbothereds · 12/09/2022 16:30

10HailMarys · 12/09/2022 13:13

No, it's not. It's critiquing and lecturing about things that are none of her business and have no impact on her.

Why would anyone need to 'express a view' on the fact that someone ordered a Thai takeaway or watched in-flight TV, let alone react with 'shock and disbelief' as if it was something inappropriate or aberrant?

If I said to someone 'I had a really nice Thai takeaway last night', and they said 'You know, I've never really got that into Thai food - maybe it's just too spicy for me' or even something like 'I hardly ever order takeaways, I think I just prefer my own cooking' then that would be expressing an view.

But if they said 'You had a Thai takeway? Why would you do that? You could have gone shopping and cooked something, so why did you need to spend money on a takeway? It would have been much more sensible to go the supermarket and cook something instead of wasting money' then that's very different.

Yes! This is DHs mate, you might say, we’re going to France on holiday, and instead of saying, ‘oh I’ve never fancied France’ launches into a lecture about how you should only ever go to Portugal, and stay in the same hotel they stay, and go to the restaurant they go to….

Blah blah blah, it’s so tiresome, it makes me not want to have any kind of conversation!

Ritascornershop · 12/09/2022 16:18

And as to the ant: I’m a bit phobic about them. My mum briefly left my dad, with me in tow, for an ant-ridden flat. They seem so robotic, they give me the creeps. And I don’t think they feel pain the way mammals and birds do. The ant suddenly appeared in my car and I smushed it before remembering that she won’t kill (most) bugs but does eat animals (again, don’t care who eats what, but it confuses me that it’s abhorrent to her to kill an ant but not a lamb & that she gives me a hard time about the ant).

Wind? Windy day. The fresher the better. One of her kids feels the same way and decades on she is still gobsmacked that we don’t prefer 30 degrees in the shade.

OP posts:
Ritascornershop · 12/09/2022 16:14

10HailMarys · 12/09/2022 13:13

No, it's not. It's critiquing and lecturing about things that are none of her business and have no impact on her.

Why would anyone need to 'express a view' on the fact that someone ordered a Thai takeaway or watched in-flight TV, let alone react with 'shock and disbelief' as if it was something inappropriate or aberrant?

If I said to someone 'I had a really nice Thai takeaway last night', and they said 'You know, I've never really got that into Thai food - maybe it's just too spicy for me' or even something like 'I hardly ever order takeaways, I think I just prefer my own cooking' then that would be expressing an view.

But if they said 'You had a Thai takeway? Why would you do that? You could have gone shopping and cooked something, so why did you need to spend money on a takeway? It would have been much more sensible to go the supermarket and cook something instead of wasting money' then that's very different.

Yes 10hailmarys, this is it! She quite often phrases things as “but why would you do that?!” in a tone of mixed horror/anxiety/disbelief.

There’s lots of behaviour that doesn’t align with mine; watching team sports, eating animals, driving slowly in the passing lane … but I just shrug and marvel at the diversity. My sister, who really is very kind in most ways, has awful taste in home decor (imo). She invited me over to see the recent changes and I said “wow! What a difference! You must be so happy with it! It makes the room seem really spacious. More sound-proof you say? Wonderful!” I did not say “But why would you have chosen this? It looks awful, I just don’t understand.”

Not all opinions need to be aired.

I appreciate the comments on the thread - I’ll work on just letting is slide by and view it as anxiety. We’re both pretty anxious, it just comes out differently.

OP posts:
BudgetBlast · 12/09/2022 15:03

whatwasIgoingtosay · 12/09/2022 14:43

I don't know about insecurity - I used to know an old woman who was the most frightful, screaming snob. She laid down a complex set of rigid laws on everything and was utterly scornful of anyone who did not come up to her standards, who did not do things 'properly'. She was the least insecure person I ever met.

Yes in a way I think it is the opposite of insecurity a lot of the time except where anxiety drives it. It is over confidence and lack of acceptance of your limitations.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 12/09/2022 14:43

I don't know about insecurity - I used to know an old woman who was the most frightful, screaming snob. She laid down a complex set of rigid laws on everything and was utterly scornful of anyone who did not come up to her standards, who did not do things 'properly'. She was the least insecure person I ever met.

10HailMarys · 12/09/2022 13:13

Choconut · 12/09/2022 11:05

Isn't it just a case of her having different views to you and expressing them? All sounds very minor.

No, it's not. It's critiquing and lecturing about things that are none of her business and have no impact on her.

Why would anyone need to 'express a view' on the fact that someone ordered a Thai takeaway or watched in-flight TV, let alone react with 'shock and disbelief' as if it was something inappropriate or aberrant?

If I said to someone 'I had a really nice Thai takeaway last night', and they said 'You know, I've never really got that into Thai food - maybe it's just too spicy for me' or even something like 'I hardly ever order takeaways, I think I just prefer my own cooking' then that would be expressing an view.

But if they said 'You had a Thai takeway? Why would you do that? You could have gone shopping and cooked something, so why did you need to spend money on a takeway? It would have been much more sensible to go the supermarket and cook something instead of wasting money' then that's very different.

DancinOnTheCeiling · 12/09/2022 13:09

Can someone explain why they think it’s down to insecurity? Do you mean over compensating for insecurity by coming across as self-assured?

To me it sounds very much like an autistic trait - struggling to see things from other people’s POV/poor Theory of Mind. Like young children eg covering their eyes when playing hide and seek as they don’t understand what you see is different from what they see..

I’m not meaning to sound judgemental but if your sister has been married four times it sounds like she might be a slightly difficult person, OP?

Ihatethenewlook · 12/09/2022 13:03

Mn. Not my

Ihatethenewlook · 12/09/2022 13:03

She sounds like half the people on my imo 😬I’d just repeat what I constantly tell people on here- ‘isn’t it funny how different people like different things’?

Churroschurros · 12/09/2022 12:57

My mum is like this. It used to upset and annoy me but know I’ve just accepted it and let it wash over me. Took me decades to get to that point. I’d say it was insecurity with her.

Ridelikethewindypops · 12/09/2022 12:52

I also believe it is insecurity. Dh whole family are a bit like this, driven by mil. There is simply " The Way we do it" and no other way. She has suceeded in convincing them all to abide by The Way and never make an independent move. Like one big hive mind. I tried to convince dh years ago to go to Barcelona for a weekend but he refused, on the basis that bil and his wife had gone once and they hated it! Absolutely bizarre. Like, why wouldn't you go and find out for yourself??? Maybe you'll still hate it but at least you made your own mind up. We went and he loved it. It was the first time he deviated from The Way and he started to realise how enmeshed and insular his family can be.

VatofTea · 12/09/2022 12:27

INeverSawAPurpleCow · 12/09/2022 12:05

I think it's insecurity. My brother gives me endless nasty little put-downs because, for example, I drink bottled beer and don't do expensive holidays overseas. I have explained to him more than once that I simply have different tastes from him but he continues to make snide comments and smirk when I do something he considers to have lower status than his own choices. Fact is, I could afford the things he chooses but I don't want to. I think that's what bothers him most of all. It's almost FOMO - what if my choices are better than his? For me, they are. I don't give an arse what he prefers, though.

This is exactly it - SCREAMS INSECURITY - My way is the only way, my world view is the only world view. Tedious, yawn, ignore.

INeverSawAPurpleCow · 12/09/2022 12:05

I think it's insecurity. My brother gives me endless nasty little put-downs because, for example, I drink bottled beer and don't do expensive holidays overseas. I have explained to him more than once that I simply have different tastes from him but he continues to make snide comments and smirk when I do something he considers to have lower status than his own choices. Fact is, I could afford the things he chooses but I don't want to. I think that's what bothers him most of all. It's almost FOMO - what if my choices are better than his? For me, they are. I don't give an arse what he prefers, though.

Fairyliz · 12/09/2022 12:03

My adult DD in her 20’s is like this. She feels there is a ‘right’ way to do things and get distressed / anxious when people do things differently.
She’s currently waiting for assessment and is clearly showing autistic traits. Looking back over her childhood I was able to protect her from lots of things but as an adult out in the world she h it s finding things difficult.

CosmopolitanPlease · 12/09/2022 11:59

My oldest friend was an extreme version of that, and would robustly criticise things like where I went on holiday or where I purchased my carpets from, and had rigid ideas about what was the 'right' thing to do in any situation (her way). Due to my own low self esteem it took me far too long to realise how detrimental she was to my own mental health.

She had a diagnosis of obsessive compulsive personality disorder, but didn't want any treatment because she thought hers was the right way to be. I eventually cut contact with her, and am very glad I did.

Funkyblues101 · 12/09/2022 11:54

You're mad to rely on electronic devices for a long haul flight. And killing an ant seems unnecessary, but I eat meat and see your point.

mondaytosunday · 12/09/2022 11:51

My sister is quite eccentric and at times it's amazing we were brought up in the same house by the same parents! I just accept her as she is - what else can you do?

Changechangychange · 12/09/2022 11:42

Off topic, but in what context do you like wind? You like passing wind? Being winded? Being out on a windy day? Support investment in wind power over fossil fuels? Winding up a bobbin?

VatofTea · 12/09/2022 11:38

It's called small mindedness.

"I'm safe in this bubble, and this frame of reference, and I want to be safe with you, where we re-enforce the communal blinkered world view. Anything that threatens that, make me feel uncomfortable".

Rosehugger · 12/09/2022 11:31

My dad was a bit like this all his life - narrow-minded and insecure basically. Could be do with losing his mum in his teens, I thought, he felt comfortable with food and drinks that were around in the 1950s but things that appeared after that he wouldn't even try and thought not just that things were disgusting but that people were idiots for liking them.

He thought anything other than sweet wine was a con and couldn't understand why people liked dry wine, we were just brainwashed sheep for enjoying it!

It can be very wearing- my sympathies!

Hotandbothereds · 12/09/2022 11:22

Choconut · 12/09/2022 11:05

Isn't it just a case of her having different views to you and expressing them? All sounds very minor.

No, this is different- most people understand that others have a different opinion and move on, some people, like the OPs sister and someone I know are unable to perceive that other people do/think differently and it’s exhausting to constantly have to feel you have to defend your perfectly normal ways to them.

TrashyPanda · 12/09/2022 11:13

killing an ant in my car “but you can’t do that. We are kind to animals”

Ask her how she feels about fleas, lice, maggots etc

Bet she wouldn’t willingly host them

Swipe left for the next trending thread