Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think keeping thermostat at 20 will cost the same as keeping it at 17?

156 replies

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:02

I know it's said that turning the heating down a few degrees will save money, but how?

If I'm, say, October I set the heating to 20 degrees and leave it like that, and if it falls to 19 degrees it automatically kicks in until the house is up to 20 then switches off, how would that cost any more than keeping it at 17 and it kicking in when it dropped to 16 to heat the house one degree? In both cases it's only kicking in to heat the house by one degree, so how does keeping it lower cost less money?

I understand that if I turn it on when the house is at, say 15 degrees, then it would cost more to get to 20 than 17, but once it's there surely it would be the same to keep it there?

OP posts:
TinySaltLick · 11/09/2022 22:36

Newton solved this a while ago:

Newton's law of cooling states that the rate of heat loss of a body is directly proportional to the difference in the temperatures between the body and its environment.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton%27s_law_of_cooling

Your house is constantly losing heat if it is colder outside. The greater the temperature difference the quicker it cools down. The error in your logic is the comparison from 19 to 20 to 16 to 17. In the former it is losing heat quicker - so not only will it take longer to raise 1 degree, it will cool 1 degree faster

ValerieDoonican · 11/09/2022 22:34

Think of your house as a veey tall glass with a small hole at the bottom. Imagine the bottom of the glass is the average outside temperature in January 8 degrees. About 3/4 of the way up the glass draw a line called "17", at the top, another line called "20".

If you fill the glass up to 17 the water won't leak out if the little hole as much as if you fill to the top (20), because there is less pressure.

Your job is to run to the tap with a thimble (b/c water is expensive so you have to do a lot of work to get it) tip it into the glass and then run back for another one, trying to fill the glass faster than the water runs out. The fuller the glass, the faster it leaks out, the faster you have to run with your thimble.

Even when youve filled the glass (warmed up the house) you have to keep going backwards and forwards to replace what leaks out. At 20 you have to go backwards and forwards rather more often, as the higher pressure means the leak is faster.

Pro tip: insulating your house is the equivalent of making the hole in the glass smaller.

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:34

FinanceLPlates · 11/09/2022 22:26

This is why insulation matters! If your house were perfectly insulated it would stay at 20 degrees. Most U.K. houses are very “leaky”. So when the outside temperature is lower your boiler has to keep working hard to maintain 20 degrees inside, as it’s constantly replacing lost heat/energy. Keeping it to 17 degrees uses less power as the temperature difference isn’t as high.
Of course with proper insulation you’d be warm and use less energy…

I've had a look and my house is rated C with 'the potential to be C', with everything considered 'good' or 'very good'. So maybe it won't lose too much heat if I keep it on 20. Worth an experiment anyway.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:31

On a colder day, you get colder than on a warmer day. As your body loses heat quicker.

You can insulate yourself but you use more energy to keep yourself warm.

If you want to keep yourself at a lower temperature, you would use less energy.

And on a hot day, well - you can actually over heat.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:29

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:26

That's an excellent idea. I'm going to do that.

Assuming on day 1, it's 10 c outside and day 2, it's 4 degrees outside

If you tried to maintain the heating at 20 c, you would use more energy on the colder day.

That's why heating bills are highest on the coldest days.

If you set it at 17 c, and the temperature was 10 C on 1 day and 4c the next day, you would use less energy than setting at at 20C and you would use more energy on the colder day.

MistyBean · 11/09/2022 22:29

I agree about not having blind acceptance over novel and complex issues, but this is basic science. I just get frustrated at how much the basics get questioned these days and how no one values expert opinion.

EducatingArti · 11/09/2022 22:29

HarpicHarpy · 11/09/2022 22:08

Damn. I was with the op until the rest of you rocked up with your common sense.

See, next time a teenager asks why they should study physics as they'll never use it, then you can tell them!

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 11/09/2022 22:28

I think the explanation will still be the one PPs have said. The higher the temperature differential the faster heat is lost, so the more times the heater comes on.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:27

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 11/09/2022 22:24

If you've got a smart metre you could run an experiment usage over 2 weeks at each different temperatures. It wouldn't be completely accurate as you can't control the outside temperature and the relative difference. I don't know the why, but our heater does come on more when the temperature is set higher.

It comes on more because it is needed to get to a higher temperature?

And when it reaches that temperature, the gradient to the outside is greater so it loses energy more?

A bit like how your body works to maintain its internal temperature.

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:26

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 11/09/2022 22:24

If you've got a smart metre you could run an experiment usage over 2 weeks at each different temperatures. It wouldn't be completely accurate as you can't control the outside temperature and the relative difference. I don't know the why, but our heater does come on more when the temperature is set higher.

That's an excellent idea. I'm going to do that.

OP posts:
FinanceLPlates · 11/09/2022 22:26

This is why insulation matters! If your house were perfectly insulated it would stay at 20 degrees. Most U.K. houses are very “leaky”. So when the outside temperature is lower your boiler has to keep working hard to maintain 20 degrees inside, as it’s constantly replacing lost heat/energy. Keeping it to 17 degrees uses less power as the temperature difference isn’t as high.
Of course with proper insulation you’d be warm and use less energy…

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:24

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:21

I don't think blind acceptance and unwillingness to learn are particularly good traits.

You will save money and energy usage if you have your heating lower during winter.

Now the question is - should you leave it lower during the day and a bit warmer in the evening or just turn it on when you need it.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 11/09/2022 22:24

If you've got a smart metre you could run an experiment usage over 2 weeks at each different temperatures. It wouldn't be completely accurate as you can't control the outside temperature and the relative difference. I don't know the why, but our heater does come on more when the temperature is set higher.

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:21

MistyBean · 11/09/2022 22:17

Why not trust the experts and scientists if you do not understand it yourself?

I don't think blind acceptance and unwillingness to learn are particularly good traits.

OP posts:
Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:19

HotPenguin · 11/09/2022 22:12

Unless you keep your heating on all the time, it's going to fall by more than one degree overnight. Say it falls to 15 degrees, it's going to take a lot more energy to get it to 20 than to 17.

This is what I do. Just set it to 20 and leave it, so it's 'on' all winter then when the weather gets nicer I just wind it down to 11 so it never clicks on in the summer.

OP posts:
MistyBean · 11/09/2022 22:17

Why not trust the experts and scientists if you do not understand it yourself?

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:16

Thanks everyone - I do believe I must be wrong, because it's said so frequently, but I still struggle to understand how.

From October - February the outside temperature won't rise above 10 degrees or so, so whether it's 17 or 20 it will be much colder outside, so would it really come on that much more frequently at 20? Would it not be that when the house reached 17 then cooled to 16 it would do say at the same pace as it reaching 20 and cooling to 19?

OP posts:
HotPenguin · 11/09/2022 22:12

Unless you keep your heating on all the time, it's going to fall by more than one degree overnight. Say it falls to 15 degrees, it's going to take a lot more energy to get it to 20 than to 17.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:12

TwoWeeksislong · 11/09/2022 22:10

Your house does not exist in a vacuum. The outside temperature matters. If your house never lost any heat then it wouldn’t make a difference whether you heat 19 degree air to 20 degrees or 16 degree air to 17 degrees but houses do lose heat.

If only there were some way we could stop houses losing heat......

anon2022anon · 11/09/2022 22:11

Because the temperature outside will be lower, so the boiler will have to work harder/ longer to get it to a temp.
So if outside is 14, it will click on for maybe half an hour to get it up to 17, compred to an hour for 20 (random times, I don't know). And when the temperature drops, it has to click on sooner for a higher temp, so if it's been 18 outside it might have to click on to raise it to 20, where it wouldnt need to at 17.

In short, yes more expensive, as it on more often & longer.

TwoWeeksislong · 11/09/2022 22:10

Your house does not exist in a vacuum. The outside temperature matters. If your house never lost any heat then it wouldn’t make a difference whether you heat 19 degree air to 20 degrees or 16 degree air to 17 degrees but houses do lose heat.

Babdoc · 11/09/2022 22:10

You aren’t allowing for the different rate of heat loss from the house to the outside.
The greater the difference in temp between the inside and the outside, the steeper the gradient. If the outside air temp is 17C, you
need expend no energy at all to keep your house at 17C - there will be no temp gradient and no heat loss to the exterior.
But if you want to have the house at 20C, the house will (unless hermetically sealed) keep losing heat to the exterior, which you have to burn gas to compensate for.

UniversalTruth · 11/09/2022 22:09

You're also not accounting for the energy required to maintain at 20degC prior to this. In October, the outside temperature is not going to be 19degC so you need to heat the whole house the extra already.

HarpicHarpy · 11/09/2022 22:08

Damn. I was with the op until the rest of you rocked up with your common sense.

Lcb123 · 11/09/2022 22:07

At 20 degrees the heating will come on far
more often, in order for your house to be that warm. At 17 degrees it will come on less frequently and not stay on so long, so will be much cheaper.