Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think keeping thermostat at 20 will cost the same as keeping it at 17?

156 replies

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:02

I know it's said that turning the heating down a few degrees will save money, but how?

If I'm, say, October I set the heating to 20 degrees and leave it like that, and if it falls to 19 degrees it automatically kicks in until the house is up to 20 then switches off, how would that cost any more than keeping it at 17 and it kicking in when it dropped to 16 to heat the house one degree? In both cases it's only kicking in to heat the house by one degree, so how does keeping it lower cost less money?

I understand that if I turn it on when the house is at, say 15 degrees, then it would cost more to get to 20 than 17, but once it's there surely it would be the same to keep it there?

OP posts:
LaPerduta · 11/09/2022 23:48

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:21

I don't think blind acceptance and unwillingness to learn are particularly good traits.

Neither is a tendency to ignore science/experts and to believe your own faulty logic. That's why we have anti-vaxxers and flat-earthers.

I'm sorry that probably sounds a bit rude, but if you're not good at a particular field (be it logic, maths, languages, music, DIY, grammar, whatever) then - as a PP said - at least trust those who are.

I'm short, assuming a real-life house that loses heat (rather than a theoretical one that doesn't), your heating will have to work harder to keep your home at 20° than 17°, therefore it will use more energy, therefore it will cost you more.

larkstar · 11/09/2022 23:43

friends=depends!

larkstar · 11/09/2022 23:42

@Cigent several people have said the same thing but I see it's not as obvious as you would like it to be - that the rate at which your house losses heat friends on the difference between the temperature inside and the temperature outside. I'll try another way to picture it.

If you hold a bottle of water with the cap off horizontally and tip it up a few degrees to start pouring some of the water out can you understand that the bottle will empty write slowly add you aren't tipping it up at too great an angle. Now picture what would happen if you tipped the bottle up a lot more - can you see that the water would pour out much faster? The water pouring out is really the equivalent of the heat leaving your house -

the more you tip the bottle up,
the greater the angle of tilt,
the greater the rate at which the water leaves the bottle.

the more you turn up the thermostat in the house
the greater the difference between the inside and outside temperature the greater the rate at which heat leaves your house

So - if you want your house to stay at the higher temperature you will have to put heat back in to the house at a higher rate - the thermostat will keep telling the boiler to turn on to put heat back in because hest is being lost more quickly - because you set the thermostat to 20 and not 17.

You turning the thermostat up to 20 is like tipping the bottle up more - the water (or heat) flows out faster.

Whokno · 11/09/2022 23:28

I'll give it a go with made up figures & dodgy science, to illustrate the point. Say your house loses heat at 1 degree per hour if the air temperature is a little colder outside than inside. Increasing the heating by 1 degree costs £1.

You heat your house to 20 degrees and the outside temperature is 18 degrees, after an hour your house temp has fallen to 19 degrees. To get back to 20 degrees costs £1. This cycle repeats over and over, as your house repeatedly loses heat and regains it.

However, if your house temperature is 17 degrees then the heating never kicks in when the air temp is 18 degrees, costing you nothing.

Now imagine the air temperature outside falls to 10 degrees. Maybe your house loses 5 degrees of heat per hour when the outside temperature is 10 degrees below the inside temperature.

So, if your house is heated to 20 degrees, it's now losing 5 degrees per hour, and after an hour it would be down to 15 degrees. But the heating has kicked in and it costs £5 (£1 per degree) to keep it at 20. Of course, this cycle is continual as the house keeps losing heat.

But if your house is heated to 17 degrees, and the outside temperature is 10 degrees. It is still losing heat, but not as rapidly, as the difference is not as great. At this point maybe the house loses 3 degrees per hour. So after an hour it would be down to 14 degrees. So to replace the 'lost' 3 degrees only costs you £3 (this keeps happening too, but the rate of loss is slower, so the cost is a lot less)

TwoWeeksislong · 11/09/2022 23:28

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:12

If only there were some way we could stop houses losing heat......

Your sarcasm doesn’t make you look clever when you’re wrong. Insulation is hugely important and makes a huge difference to how much is costs to heat your home, but a house is never going to loose no heat whatsoever. Windows, even double glazed, are one weak point. You open the door multiple times a day. It’s a good idea to open the windows a little to stop moisture building up too.
You really wouldn’t want a perfectly insulated house anyway. A perfectly insulated house would require stopping are exchange or air between inside the house and outside. When you put something that breathes in an airtight space they tend to run out of oxygen…

Talipesmum · 11/09/2022 23:27

Imagine if you wanted to keep your house at 35 degrees. Every time the temp dropped to 34 the heating would have to kick in. You can probably imagine that the heating would be coming on a lot because it’d clearly be a lot of effort to maintain a house that hot all the time.

Or if you wanted to keep it at 52 degrees, and set the thermostat to 52. Can you picture that this would take a lot of heating to maintain a 52 degree house in the UK with our outside temperatures? Even if the house was heated up at the start of the season to 52 degrees, and you “just” needed to heat it back up that one degree from 51 to 52 every time it dipped down.

Basically, the more above the standard outside temp you keep your house, the more often the thermostat will kick in. I bet you can imagine it wouldn’t come on very often if you set the winter thermostat to 12 degrees. And I bet you can imagine it would be on a lot if you set it to 52 degrees. So it’s a sliding scale.

TiredButDancing · 11/09/2022 23:27

It might be easier to visualise if you swap it round. Imagine you have an ice block which you take out of the freezer and leave on a plate. You need the ice block to be on the plate but you can't let it melt. So as soon as it starts melting, you have to put it back in the freezer for a bit.

If its a hot day, you are going to be constantly running back and forth to the freezer. And thr hotter it is, the more this is true and in fact, you probably can't maintain your ice block. If its a cool day, your ice block Will melt much slower and you will have plenty of time to refreeze it.

It's the same with heating, but in reverse. So keeping the house at 20 when it's mild out probably won't be that difficult. But when it's properly cold, your heating will need to constantly come on and work to maintain the temperature. Which of course then costs more.

Dexionmagic · 11/09/2022 23:18

Basically….. the hotter you want your house the more it will cost.

If you have decent/lots of insulation then heat loss will be less but my first statement still applies.

The greater the difference between interior temperature and exterior temperature the more the heating will be on and burning gas/oil etc. Insulation will lessen the fuel burnt but the first statement still applies.

Boreded · 11/09/2022 23:18

Do people really leave their heating on overnight? I just noticed a few replies that seemed to be saying they do. mine is set to off (which is actually 5 degrees to stop pipes freezing) but never comes on. isn’t the point of duvets so that we don’t need night time heating?

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 23:16

lightisnotwhite · 11/09/2022 23:05

This is the bit I can’t understand as everyone says keeping your windows in winter is good, let’s in the fresh air, stops condensation etc. Yet that completely defies the point if insulating to my mind.

Your house does need to breathe as well - moisture builds up as does the effect of having humans in a house.

Fresh air is good - but it does let the heat out.

Summerfun54321 · 11/09/2022 23:15

Your heating isn’t the only thing that heats the house. Even without the heating on its generally warmer inside than it is outside due to humans giving off heat, appliances such as cookers giving off heat and sunlight. These are called “internal heat gains” and “solar heat gains”. The job of heating i.e a boiler is to simply top up these internal and solar gains to reach a target indoor temperature (set at your thermostat). The lower the target indoor temperature, the more likely the internal and solar gains alone will be sufficient to meet this target temperature without the need for heating at all.

FinanceLPlates · 11/09/2022 23:05

TinySaltLick · 11/09/2022 22:41

This isn't correct. If your house was perfectly insulated, it would still be exactly the same temperature as outside if you had nothing emitting heat inside. It just slows down the loss of energy via heat loss.

The rest of the logic makes sense minus this erroneous statement

OP says “… once it’s at 20 degrees”. So yes, of course she’ll need to get it to that temperature first, but that wasn’t her question.

The question was why does it cost more to maintain a temperature of 20 vs 17 degrees.

For temperature maintenance (hot or cold) insulation makes all the difference, as it makes you independent from the outside temperature.

lightisnotwhite · 11/09/2022 23:05

FinanceLPlates · 11/09/2022 22:26

This is why insulation matters! If your house were perfectly insulated it would stay at 20 degrees. Most U.K. houses are very “leaky”. So when the outside temperature is lower your boiler has to keep working hard to maintain 20 degrees inside, as it’s constantly replacing lost heat/energy. Keeping it to 17 degrees uses less power as the temperature difference isn’t as high.
Of course with proper insulation you’d be warm and use less energy…

This is the bit I can’t understand as everyone says keeping your windows in winter is good, let’s in the fresh air, stops condensation etc. Yet that completely defies the point if insulating to my mind.

Pootle40 · 11/09/2022 22:55

FTHC · 11/09/2022 22:38

If you set it at 20° everytime it drops below 20° in your house, the boiler will kick in using gas to maintain the temperature at 20°.

If you set it at 17° it will do the same to maintain that temperature but it's not as likely to drop below 17° as often as it is to drop below 20°, so you won't use as much gas keeping the house heated to 17°.

THIS. It will click on much more to maintain 20c than 17c.

ConfusedBear · 11/09/2022 22:54

You cannot see a temperature difference of a few degrees with your eyes so it is difficult to visualise how heat leaks out of a house.

Imagine you were trying (for some reason) to fill a shopping bag with water and it was leaking out along all the seams. The more full you tried to have the bag, the more side seams available for water to leak out along. So the higher the water level the more water you would need to add to the bag to replace what is being lost. This is because the water wants to find the lowest point and be as flat as possible.

Heat works in a similar way, it wants to flow from hot things to colder things. The bigger the temperature difference between the hot and cold thing the bigger the heat flow between them and the more you need to top up the heat in your house. This uses more energy and so costs more.

Hopefully this is useful - ignore the post if it makes things more confusing.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 11/09/2022 22:51

HarpicHarpy · 11/09/2022 22:08

Damn. I was with the op until the rest of you rocked up with your common sense.

🤣🤣🤣

watingroom2 · 11/09/2022 22:48

I do not think the temperature is the same in all houses - in some houses (low ceilings good insulation) 18 degrees would feel far warmer than in other houses (high ceilings - single glazing - poor insulation) :

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:45

Worth an experiment to see what the financial difference is between 17 and 20, I meant. I know it will lose heat

Lots of variables to control for.

Turning down the heating does save you money - and with energy at an expensive price, it will add up.

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:41

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:37

I've had a look and my house is rated C with 'the potential to be C', with everything considered 'good' or 'very good'. So maybe it won't lose too much heat if I keep it on 20. Worth an experiment anyway

But it will still cost more energy to get it to that temperature.

It uses more energy to make something warmer.

Your house will lose heat.

Experiment if you will...but you can't change the laws of thermodynamics

Worth an experiment to see what the financial difference is between 17 and 20, I meant. I know it will lose heat.

OP posts:
TinySaltLick · 11/09/2022 22:41

FinanceLPlates · 11/09/2022 22:26

This is why insulation matters! If your house were perfectly insulated it would stay at 20 degrees. Most U.K. houses are very “leaky”. So when the outside temperature is lower your boiler has to keep working hard to maintain 20 degrees inside, as it’s constantly replacing lost heat/energy. Keeping it to 17 degrees uses less power as the temperature difference isn’t as high.
Of course with proper insulation you’d be warm and use less energy…

This isn't correct. If your house was perfectly insulated, it would still be exactly the same temperature as outside if you had nothing emitting heat inside. It just slows down the loss of energy via heat loss.

The rest of the logic makes sense minus this erroneous statement

EducatingArti · 11/09/2022 22:40

MistyBean · 11/09/2022 22:29

I agree about not having blind acceptance over novel and complex issues, but this is basic science. I just get frustrated at how much the basics get questioned these days and how no one values expert opinion.

I am also rather sad about this!

FTHC · 11/09/2022 22:38

If you set it at 20° everytime it drops below 20° in your house, the boiler will kick in using gas to maintain the temperature at 20°.

If you set it at 17° it will do the same to maintain that temperature but it's not as likely to drop below 17° as often as it is to drop below 20°, so you won't use as much gas keeping the house heated to 17°.

EducatingArti · 11/09/2022 22:37

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:34

I've had a look and my house is rated C with 'the potential to be C', with everything considered 'good' or 'very good'. So maybe it won't lose too much heat if I keep it on 20. Worth an experiment anyway.

You will still lose heat more rapidly and need the heating on more to keep it at 20 degrees than at 17.
I don't think C insulation rating is anywhere near 100% ( and actual 100% insulation would be impossible to achieve anyway).

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 22:37

I've had a look and my house is rated C with 'the potential to be C', with everything considered 'good' or 'very good'. So maybe it won't lose too much heat if I keep it on 20. Worth an experiment anyway

But it will still cost more energy to get it to that temperature.

It uses more energy to make something warmer.

Your house will lose heat.

Experiment if you will...but you can't change the laws of thermodynamics