Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think keeping thermostat at 20 will cost the same as keeping it at 17?

156 replies

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:02

I know it's said that turning the heating down a few degrees will save money, but how?

If I'm, say, October I set the heating to 20 degrees and leave it like that, and if it falls to 19 degrees it automatically kicks in until the house is up to 20 then switches off, how would that cost any more than keeping it at 17 and it kicking in when it dropped to 16 to heat the house one degree? In both cases it's only kicking in to heat the house by one degree, so how does keeping it lower cost less money?

I understand that if I turn it on when the house is at, say 15 degrees, then it would cost more to get to 20 than 17, but once it's there surely it would be the same to keep it there?

OP posts:
pd339 · 12/09/2022 08:20

Jesus christ.

Proudboomer · 12/09/2022 08:15

Radiators work by circulating hot water through them so if you shut off a trv or turn down a trv then no no or less hot water will enter that radiator. When the radiator is full of circulating hot water the water the more it circulates the more heat it loses as that radiator uses radiant energy to transfer heat to the air so if you shut down or turn down a radiator it uses less so your boiler doesn’t have to fire up so often to maintain the water to the tempture that you have set you flow rate to.

nachoavocado · 12/09/2022 08:15

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:19

This is what I do. Just set it to 20 and leave it, so it's 'on' all winter then when the weather gets nicer I just wind it down to 11 so it never clicks on in the summer.

Because the boiler has to work more to keep it at 20 as it is cold outside? Something like that.

ValerieDoonican · 12/09/2022 08:13

If you are switching off radiators anywhere be careful rhose eooms don't get damp.

Another valuable tip is turning down the flow temperature from the boiler. This makes the boiler work more efficiently (so even though the heating is on for longer it is gentler, and in total you use less gas , because you are catching the heat that would otherwise be lost out of the boiler flue).

There are some explanations at this link www.theheatinghub.co.uk/mission

Crikeyblimey · 12/09/2022 08:03

I totally get the ‘don’t heat a room you’re not using’ thing but is there any benefit to only having one radiator on in a room that currently has two radiators? Intuitively, I don’t think so as the one ‘working’ radiator will need to work harder / be on longer to heat the space. Is that right?

Merlott · 12/09/2022 07:53

Good idea to run a 2 week experiment OP!

If you measure the energy use and keep a record of the outside temperature you will be able to calculate the heat loss co efficient of the house!

Rain makes a massive difference depending on the house construction i.e. a single skin Victorian house will lose heat much faster when it rains because the bricks get wet.

Wind will also make a huge difference depending on how "leaky" the house is.

But, if your house is modern cavity construction, well insulated, and relatively airtight then it might well show consistent performance tied closely to the outside air temp.

cakeorwine · 12/09/2022 07:36

TwoWeeksislong · 11/09/2022 23:28

Your sarcasm doesn’t make you look clever when you’re wrong. Insulation is hugely important and makes a huge difference to how much is costs to heat your home, but a house is never going to loose no heat whatsoever. Windows, even double glazed, are one weak point. You open the door multiple times a day. It’s a good idea to open the windows a little to stop moisture building up too.
You really wouldn’t want a perfectly insulated house anyway. A perfectly insulated house would require stopping are exchange or air between inside the house and outside. When you put something that breathes in an airtight space they tend to run out of oxygen…

That's a lot of scienceplaining going on there.....

Kashmirsilver · 12/09/2022 07:23

TwoWeeksislong · 11/09/2022 23:28

Your sarcasm doesn’t make you look clever when you’re wrong. Insulation is hugely important and makes a huge difference to how much is costs to heat your home, but a house is never going to loose no heat whatsoever. Windows, even double glazed, are one weak point. You open the door multiple times a day. It’s a good idea to open the windows a little to stop moisture building up too.
You really wouldn’t want a perfectly insulated house anyway. A perfectly insulated house would require stopping are exchange or air between inside the house and outside. When you put something that breathes in an airtight space they tend to run out of oxygen…

That's why highly insulated homes use a bespoke ventilation system.
MEV.
PIV.
MVHR.

Doingmybest12 · 12/09/2022 07:21

I thought it meant turn down your target heat by a degree or two, so if you usually aim to have your house at 21 degrees, change to 19 and put a layer on instead?

TinySaltLick · 12/09/2022 07:12

colourmebladd · 12/09/2022 07:02

Jumping on this to ask - is it very cost effective to switch off a radiator in one of the bedrooms or does it not make much difference?

Everything makes a difference - in this example the energy used to heat the room is effectively funneled into the loop connected to the other radiators (assuming thermostat isn't in the switched off room in question!)

It's not an exact science as radiators aren't 100pc efficient, and the heat will migrate from the hot to the cold room, but if you have ten radiators - and you switch one off - some of the energy you would have used to heat the cold room isn't used

If you do it the other way - only heat the room you are in - the savings can be significant

colourmebladd · 12/09/2022 07:02

Jumping on this to ask - is it very cost effective to switch off a radiator in one of the bedrooms or does it not make much difference?

Darbs76 · 12/09/2022 06:59

My heating works on the same principle. If I sent it to 17 it would rarely come on at all. So I’d definitely save money. I find though when I changed it from 19 to 18 during the daytime I found it just stayed on longer when it did finally come on, so not sure how much money it saved. I like to be warm, so I’d rather sacrifice other things first than reduce my central heating cost further. I have a log burner so I tend to come down and work next to the fire on my days off when I get very chilly. I am in the office 3 days per week which helps, could up to 4 if I needed to save money as it doesn’t cost me much to get there

BloodyCamping · 12/09/2022 06:57

Some very good explanations here!

Reluctantadult · 12/09/2022 06:53

Friars23 · 12/09/2022 01:14

Much of the media was critical of the Insulate Britain campaigners but their campaign is a sensible one. The U.K. has some of the worse insulated homes in Europe and a govt should be funding insulating houses with poor insulation. Better for carbon emissions and better for people’s energy bills.

Absolutely this.

Cigent · 12/09/2022 01:48

Ratherperplexed · 12/09/2022 01:02

More worried as to why you would consider having the heat on in October?
Golden rule in our house, if cold before end of autumn half term holiday, stick a vest on. If really cold, vest, shirt and jumper.

I put the heating on when it gets cold, which is very much October.

Thanks to everyone for the explanations.

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 12/09/2022 01:46

I live in a place where winter temps will vary from -20 to 5. We have a nice modern heating system in good repair. The house is well insulated and has good windows. At 5, the heating system has no trouble keeping up with whatever temperature we want the house set at. At -20, it struggles to reach the target indoor temperature.

you really cant discount the impact of the outdoor temperature on heat loss from the house.

SheSaidHummingbird · 12/09/2022 01:35

The size of the space that you are heating is also a factor. More energy, and therefore more money, would be needed to regulate the temperature of a large (and probably draughty) space compared to a smaller space.

Friars23 · 12/09/2022 01:14

Much of the media was critical of the Insulate Britain campaigners but their campaign is a sensible one. The U.K. has some of the worse insulated homes in Europe and a govt should be funding insulating houses with poor insulation. Better for carbon emissions and better for people’s energy bills.

TheTeenageYears · 12/09/2022 01:14

Without adding heat my house will fall below 20 degrees many more times than it would fall below 17 so the heating would kick in more often if the thermostat was set to 20 rather than 17.

Ratherperplexed · 12/09/2022 01:02

More worried as to why you would consider having the heat on in October?
Golden rule in our house, if cold before end of autumn half term holiday, stick a vest on. If really cold, vest, shirt and jumper.

Calliop · 12/09/2022 00:44

Imagine it as cups of tea instead.

Get 2 cups, with the same volume of water, one at say 60 degrees and one at 80 degrees. Your aim is to keep them at those temperatures by topping up with boiling water from the kettle whenever their temp drops. Do you think you'll use the same amount of water to maintain them at 60 and 80 for, say, an hour, or will you end up using more water to keep the 80 degree one so hot?

I think common sense/experience says you'll need to add a lot more water to the 80 degree one. (If you're not convinced, try it.) You also know from experience that the hotter a cup of tea is, the more heat it gives off. You can physically feel it losing more heat to your hand or the coaster. It's easier to see with an everyday object than with something you're actually inside.

You're tricking yourself with a false comparison that a house at fifteen degrees is roughly the same as a house at nineteen degrees.

johnd2 · 12/09/2022 00:12

Interesting thread

Since the OP has asked about the cost side I would like to add something slightly unintuitive.
You get the biggest percentage savings from turning your thermostat down in autumn and spring. This is because the heating isn't working hard at that time, so 17 to 20 would be maybe half the temperature drop to outside. So your bill would double.
If it's the middle of winter and it's -5c outside, it's going to be super expensive regardless, so that 3 degrees extra, although still costing you similar, it would be negligible in terms of percentage.
So if you're going to bump your thermostat to 25c for a month a year, doesn't matter when you do it but you may as well do it in January when it's cold anyway!

Cigent · 11/09/2022 23:57

LaPerduta · 11/09/2022 23:48

Neither is a tendency to ignore science/experts and to believe your own faulty logic. That's why we have anti-vaxxers and flat-earthers.

I'm sorry that probably sounds a bit rude, but if you're not good at a particular field (be it logic, maths, languages, music, DIY, grammar, whatever) then - as a PP said - at least trust those who are.

I'm short, assuming a real-life house that loses heat (rather than a theoretical one that doesn't), your heating will have to work harder to keep your home at 20° than 17°, therefore it will use more energy, therefore it will cost you more.

😂 Asking why a piece of logic is wrong is not the same as refusing to believe science. It's asking what the science is, which has now been explained.

But I do understand that some posters cannot help themselves when it comes to spotting an opportunity to be rude and condescending.

OP posts:
LaPerduta · 11/09/2022 23:50

LaPerduta · 11/09/2022 23:49

FFS. I am fairly short, but if course I meant in short.

Oh for a fucking edit button. 😡OF course.

LaPerduta · 11/09/2022 23:49

LaPerduta · 11/09/2022 23:48

Neither is a tendency to ignore science/experts and to believe your own faulty logic. That's why we have anti-vaxxers and flat-earthers.

I'm sorry that probably sounds a bit rude, but if you're not good at a particular field (be it logic, maths, languages, music, DIY, grammar, whatever) then - as a PP said - at least trust those who are.

I'm short, assuming a real-life house that loses heat (rather than a theoretical one that doesn't), your heating will have to work harder to keep your home at 20° than 17°, therefore it will use more energy, therefore it will cost you more.

FFS. I am fairly short, but if course I meant in short.

Swipe left for the next trending thread