Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think keeping thermostat at 20 will cost the same as keeping it at 17?

156 replies

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:02

I know it's said that turning the heating down a few degrees will save money, but how?

If I'm, say, October I set the heating to 20 degrees and leave it like that, and if it falls to 19 degrees it automatically kicks in until the house is up to 20 then switches off, how would that cost any more than keeping it at 17 and it kicking in when it dropped to 16 to heat the house one degree? In both cases it's only kicking in to heat the house by one degree, so how does keeping it lower cost less money?

I understand that if I turn it on when the house is at, say 15 degrees, then it would cost more to get to 20 than 17, but once it's there surely it would be the same to keep it there?

OP posts:
Nolongera · 13/09/2022 08:43

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 13/09/2022 06:41

Well that's a worthwhile contribution to the thread

It was though, that's the point.

The fact that people can't work out the "science" of why it costs more to heat a room to 20C rather than 17C.

Jesus Christ.

Caspianberg · 13/09/2022 07:51

Houses must be really badly insulated in the uk.

Here winter temp is anywhere between 0 and -25. Even at -20, our heating goes off at 8pm and on again at 6am. If it’s 21 degrees at 8pm, it only drops to 18/19 by 6am. With no heating on for 10 hours.

Our heating is set to constant 6am-8pm, but when you look at actual times you will see it’s only on for 4/5 hours of that as it clicks of when it reaches set temperature and only back on when below that.

midgetastic · 13/09/2022 07:20

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/09/2022 06:43

At 20 in most places (assuming you’re UK), it will keep going on and off. Heating up is more costly than keeping at a constant I think.

Not true

If you are keeping the house at 20 all the time you are constantly adding heat to make up for the heat loss all the time

Say you lose ten units of heat per hour at 20 then you burn 10*24 units of energy every 24 to stay stable

If you say turn it off for 12 hrs at night you lose heat until you reach the outside temperatures and then you stop losing heat. You might lose 40 units if heat - so to reheat would be 40 units not 10*12 = 120 units.

Because heat loss depends on the difference between outside

And inside temperature, If you lose 10 units of heat per hour at 20 you might might only lose 2 unit of heat per hour at 15

Mimimise your energy cost by turning the thermostat down and only using heating when you need it - morning and evening if you are out at work

In both cases turning on half an hour before you need it - so it's nice when you get up - and turning it off an hour before you leave ( and 2+ before bedtime ) in a well insulated home - because you should not notice it getting colder in that time.

The only time keeping a stead temperature helps is if you tend to overheat - blast the heat out - and then turn it off - so you oscillate around an average of 20

picklemewalnuts · 13/09/2022 07:17

@Cigent do you need to get your bills down? As well as reducing by a degree, you can have it on less often.

At the moment your boiler is running all the time, which uses gas.
If you use the timer on the thermostat, you can run it for a couple of hours a day to heat up water. It will stay hot in the tank.

When you need the heating as well, you can run that for a few hours morning and evening. Most people don't need it at night as they are in bed.

Using it less often will save even more than turning it down a notch. It will be cooler, obviously, but if you are going out or home but active there's no need to heat the house.

Walkden · 13/09/2022 07:12

It is worrying how difficult some people find it to grasp. There are a few reasons but surely at least the first 2 of these are common sense

  1. the temperature varies each month. You can look up monthly averages but generally if you set your thermostat at 20 all day the heating will come on much earlier in the calendar year than one set at 16

  2. obviously it varies during the day also so a thermostat set at 20 will activate the heating earlier at night.

  3. It takes time to raise the temperature of the building and all the material in it like bricks etc so it takes more energy to heat to higher temperatures.

  4. as many posters have said heat loss increases as the difference between the outside temperatures and inside temperature does so maintaining higher temperature indoors takes more energy

5)as many pp have said insulation reduces the rate of this loss but it can never be completely prevented.

Plumedenom · 13/09/2022 06:50

I am now beginning to understand why the whole "insulate your homes" bonanza of financial incentives hasn't really taken off. Fucking hell, this thread is eye opening.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/09/2022 06:43

At 20 in most places (assuming you’re UK), it will keep going on and off. Heating up is more costly than keeping at a constant I think.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 13/09/2022 06:41

pd339 · 12/09/2022 08:20

Jesus christ.

Well that's a worthwhile contribution to the thread

carefullycourageous · 13/09/2022 06:34

Cigent · 11/09/2022 22:21

I don't think blind acceptance and unwillingness to learn are particularly good traits.

I don't have to understand exactly how a process works to know that the weight of science is behind it.

I am expert in some things, then for other things I trust other experts. The key is choosing carefully who to listen to.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 13/09/2022 06:26

Crikeyblimey · 12/09/2022 08:03

I totally get the ‘don’t heat a room you’re not using’ thing but is there any benefit to only having one radiator on in a room that currently has two radiators? Intuitively, I don’t think so as the one ‘working’ radiator will need to work harder / be on longer to heat the space. Is that right?

Generally that would be right, but it will depend where your thermostat is.

I know I sound like a broken record, but it's something a lot of people don't take into consideration.

same with when they say what temperature they keep the house at. People may need to picture the extremes of that for it to really make sense. If the thermostat was in a cupboard under the stairs that had a radiator and set to 20° Opposed to in the porch set to 20° Your lounge would be very different temperatures.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 13/09/2022 06:17

colourmebladd · 12/09/2022 07:02

Jumping on this to ask - is it very cost effective to switch off a radiator in one of the bedrooms or does it not make much difference?

It'll save a bit, not loads and it'll depend on where your thermostat is and if that room is shut off from the rest of the house efficiently. If the air is circulating around the house it will save much less than if the air is unable to escape.

mountainsunsets · 13/09/2022 06:14

The date has NO affect on the temperature.

Yes, I think people are aware of that 🤣

But most households can't afford to have the heating on regularly for months at a time so having a start date of (say) November means they aren't spending a fortune on gas bills.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 13/09/2022 06:08

Ratherperplexed · 12/09/2022 01:02

More worried as to why you would consider having the heat on in October?
Golden rule in our house, if cold before end of autumn half term holiday, stick a vest on. If really cold, vest, shirt and jumper.

@Ratherperplexed well if people in your house are wandering about naked in October with no heating on, it's not surprising if they're cold.

it still amuses me that people have rigid dates that determine their heating. It's bizarre.

you can put extra layers on in Nov/Dec etc to be warm enough without putting the heat on/higher and you can put the heating on before half term is extra layers aren't enough. The date has NO affect on the temperature.

Nolongera · 12/09/2022 13:58

pd339 · 12/09/2022 08:20

Jesus christ.

Indeed.

Lunar270 · 12/09/2022 11:56

DonnaBanana · 12/09/2022 11:34

This thread makes me think it would be a good idea if schools introduced science as a subject

😂 the issue isn't whether it's taught but how much of it sinks in, or what you do for a career.

I work with lots of thermal engineers but wasn't interested, other than for what I do as a mech eng. It wasn't immediately obvious to me that cooling was exponential and not linear.

Cigent · 12/09/2022 11:56

DonnaBanana · 12/09/2022 11:34

This thread makes me think it would be a good idea if schools introduced science as a subject

Perhaps English too.

OP posts:
Lunar270 · 12/09/2022 11:52

midgetastic · 12/09/2022 11:01

@Lunar270

1 degree is 1 degree

But you need that 1 degree heating more often if it's lost quicker which happens if the difference between outside and in is larger

Yes, 1° is 1° but a PP has said that cooling from 20° to 19° will happen more quickly than cooling from 18° to 17°.

I appreciate the frequency at which you change that 1° is important but that isn't what I was asking.

DonnaBanana · 12/09/2022 11:34

This thread makes me think it would be a good idea if schools introduced science as a subject

Proudboomer · 12/09/2022 11:12

Whoops should have quoted Ratherperplexed not Longlivedqueen so my apologies to her

Proudboomer · 12/09/2022 11:11

LongLivedQueen · 12/09/2022 10:40

I don't suppose it occurred to you that not everyone lives in your town, and other people may live somewhere that is colder than where you live?

and not everyone is you. I have my mother living with me. She is a disabled wheelchair user. She cannot move more to keep warm and I just can’t walk extra layers on her as wearing anything bulky limits what little mobility she has. She feels the cold pretty much all year round so wears the same regardless of it being summer or winter so whilst I am still sitting here in shorts and t shirt without socks my mum is wearing a nighty under a fleece dress with slippers and a heated throw. By October the heating will be on 24/7 set at 20 as she doesn’t sleep like a younger person. She doses in her chair on and off all day and night so doesn’t actually go to bed as she can’t lie down. She might be awake at 2 in the morning watching telly and going backwards and forwards to the loo and she has bowel and incontinence problems hence my heating on in the areas she uses.

midgetastic · 12/09/2022 11:01

@Lunar270

1 degree is 1 degree

But you need that 1 degree heating more often if it's lost quicker which happens if the difference between outside and in is larger

LongLivedQueen · 12/09/2022 10:40

Ratherperplexed · 12/09/2022 01:02

More worried as to why you would consider having the heat on in October?
Golden rule in our house, if cold before end of autumn half term holiday, stick a vest on. If really cold, vest, shirt and jumper.

I don't suppose it occurred to you that not everyone lives in your town, and other people may live somewhere that is colder than where you live?

Cigent · 12/09/2022 10:35

saraclara · 12/09/2022 09:40

You asking the question in order to understand something better is good. But your unwillingness to accept basic science is not.
It's not blind acceptance to listen to and accept actual provable scientific fact. Michael Gove has a lot to answer for.

By all means experiment with your smart meter. Experimenting to see what works is again, a good way to approach questions. But if you're experimenting, the conditions at for each two weeks need to be the same. If two of three weeks are mild outside and two of them very cold, you won't get your answer. Likewise unless your smart meter can differentiate between the fuel used for heating and the fuel used for everything else, your other activities during those experimental periods will also skew the results

Good lord. I've said I must be wrong, that I'm wrong, and thanks everyone for their explanations.

The irony of not reading something properly in a desperate rush to criticise someone for not understanding something properly.

OP posts:
Lunar270 · 12/09/2022 10:31

Reallybadidea · 12/09/2022 10:12

Because the temperature gradient isn't 20-19 or 17-16, it's the internal to external temperature. So if your external temperature is eg 14 degrees, your temperature gradient is 20-14 vs 17-14. Hence cooling more quickly.

Not a thermal engineer but I spend a lot of my working life cooling down people and warming them up again!

Sorry, I thought the external temp would be 19 and the internal 20. Thus a 1 degree delta.

Likewise for the 18-17 case, a 1 degree delta.

SafferUpNorth · 12/09/2022 10:31

Errrr..... OP hopefully you've woken this morning and realised the answer is obvious. Now go turn that thermostat to 18 and save yourself some money

Swipe left for the next trending thread