Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How far is too far? AIBU

63 replies

Strawberryrainbow · 11/09/2022 21:02

Was looking for your opinion on how far is too far?

Am looking at secondary schools for my child and there is a fantastic one that would suit perfectly - only catch it's a 2 mile walk. There isn't a bus route that doesn't go direct and would have to go out village to come back in again so doesn't make sense!

AIBU - Is this too far? Am I being unrealistic in expecting my year 7 to walk that far to/from school each day?

How far does your child look walk to get to school?

Thank you SmileSmile

OP posts:
Leeds2 · 12/09/2022 15:32

I don't think it is too far on a dry day, but might be a bit much when it is raining heavily or if she has to carry heavy musical instruments, sports kit, home economics stuff etc. I wouldn't commit to doing all drop offs or pick ups (I used to love a long walk home with my friend, even though we could've caught the bus!), but I would perhaps try and give lifts when she has a lot to carry.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 12/09/2022 15:15

Depends on the route I think. I used to walk to work, just under two miles. Fine to walk there and back in the summer, but I'd get the bus home in the winter as the route involved a footpath through a field.

Autumn101 · 12/09/2022 15:03

Mine do this and it’s fine, Year 8 and 10 now. Lots of children from our village go to same school so they often walk with friends so it’s a nice social time for them, would there be other children from your area also walking?

RobertsRadio · 12/09/2022 14:55

Two miles is perfectly fine. Make sure DC has appropriate wet weather gear and decent backpack for PE kit and books. If you are able to sometimes do the am drop off in bad weather that will break it up a bit. Good healthy exercise, fresh air and fostering independence, all good.

Surtsey · 12/09/2022 14:55

Walking home from school seems like a good idea to me. Gives them time to decompress from the day's schoolwork, they get fresh air and some exercise. I suspect that by the time we hit winter weather they may well have made friends with someone who lives in your direction and whose parent can be persuaded to give them a lift home sometimes.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/09/2022 14:55

Mine walk that far every day. It's not a problem.

Please don't aim to pick them or drop them. It's TWO MILES. She will make friends and be able to walk part of the way.

PS - mine are not arsed in the slightest whether or not they have to walk or not.

newbiename · 12/09/2022 14:46

Two mile walk is nothing at that age.
I walked three to school.

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 12/09/2022 14:34

Daughter has just started year 7. School is 2 miles away. I drop off and she walks home. Takes about 45 mins.

I used to walk 3.5 miles to and from school every day until I learned to drive at 17.

SweetsAndChocolates · 12/09/2022 14:25

@Strawberryrainbow are there any other children who live locally hoping to go to the same school? Would it be possible that you drop your dc and friend and then said friend's parent do pick up?

Atmywitsend29 · 12/09/2022 14:25

I feel like there's a difference between 2 town miles and 2 country miles 😂
It certainly feels like there is!

But no, it's not an unreasonable distance to walk.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/09/2022 14:24

Also, depends on the walking conditions. Are they safe? Again one thing now, but what about on a dark winter's day in bad weather.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/09/2022 14:24

Hmm, it's quite far. On a sunny day in the summer, no problem. But in sleet in February that's quite a way if there are no alternatives to walking. Do you have a back up? Or a potential lift share?

Strawberryrainbow · 12/09/2022 14:13

Thanks for all your replies. Appreciate it, swaying on dropping one way and letting my child walk back home.

OP posts:
SproutsAtChristmas · 11/09/2022 22:21

My school was about 1.5 miles away and I hated the walk (all uphill on the way) in the rain or on days where more equipment was needed i.e. PE kit or a homework project. It's 5 years of that walk, I'm assuming in British weather, that DC will have to do.

Also, will DC's new friends live nearer the school or do many in your area attend there? Nothing worse than all your friends being a 40-60 minute walk away from your house too at that age. I had this issue as I lived on one side of the school and many of my friends were the other side so I had to add more walking time just to get to theirs or meet them. I was a sporty kid so it wasn't a fitness and walking thing but more of the inconvenience of it all.

Could you test the walk out together before applying? Could DC ride a bike there instead to reduce the travel time?

Craftybodger · 11/09/2022 22:17

It really depends on the route. Pavements, busy roads, others from school likely to be doing the same? It would also depend on the resilience and fitness of the child and the amount of clobber they take.

Tomorrow my Y8 has a full and heavy school backpack, a bulky and full PE kit and another bag of dance kit - that is a lot to carry! She could easily do the walk but not so sure when she has all that to carry too.

ChippingLeCrue · 11/09/2022 22:14

I think the main issue for me with that walk would be any after school clubs and winter with it getting darker earlier and what time she would be walking home. Mainly what route she would take home, how well lit it is and how confident she would feel doing it.

Are there any friends she could potentially walk with who may also attend the same school? Both my sons walked 20 minutes but had waterproof coats and waterproof bag covers for their rucksacks and umbrellas and were happy to use them. I did however run them and drop them off if it was pouring with rain.

Lcb123 · 11/09/2022 22:12

I used to walk 2 miles to secondary school: can they cycle as that would be quicker?

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 11/09/2022 22:10

Just to add, since my poor children are clearly deprived of free time and subject to brutal conditions, they were given the option this year of a school bus service that would pick up and drop off outside our front door but they both elected to keep doing the walk. Time might be precious but 2 miles isn't long! Plus at least they get to walk and move after a day spent at a desk. Mine still find the time for extracurricular activities pretty much every night too.

demokitty · 11/09/2022 22:05

Depends on the child.

I just looked at google maps for my childhood secondary, it would have been a 49 minute walk and I never did it! I was either driven the majority of the way (which was a 20-25 min drive and a 5 min walk as it was too busy near school), or got the bus (5 minute walk to stop, 13 mins ish on bus, 16 min walk to school).

Though my bag was always heavy and it was really uncool to wear your bag over both shoulders. So one of my shoulders always ached, especially on PE day!

I did walk to primary school though, but that was just over 15 mins.

Things to consider, will your child have heavy/awkward stuff to carry? Eg, hockey stick, guitar, food tech ingredients on the same day they need football boots for PE! Plus heavy water bottle (all the kids seem to have those metal ones) and will they be taking a packed lunch.

Also bear in mind, they might make a best friend 2 miles in the opposite direction! Not necessarily a big deal. It wasn't too much for me as school was near the main town so we all met there. But sometimes I went to a friends house and needed collecting.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 11/09/2022 21:54

I walk two miles to work at least half the time. Takes me 27mins there when I'm full of energy and it's downhill, probably 35-40 on the way back. It is definitely harder with heavy bags - I have a backpack and a second bag with laptop and other equipment - but honestly it's pleasant most of the time.

Difference for me is that I can drive if the weather is shocking. If you can drop in the morning though then getting wet on the way home is no biggie.

Strawberryrainbow · 11/09/2022 21:51

Thanks for your answers/suggestions so far

I'm so torn. I could definitely drop off in the morning, but I wouldn't be able to do pick up.

OP posts:
Nospringchix · 11/09/2022 21:47

Rowen32 · 11/09/2022 21:40

I think that's much too far for the weight of school bags alone but also time is so precious at that age - that time spent walking about be used for getting homework/study done and leaving your child free to have free time which is so rare as the exam years come :-(

I agree.

Dragmedown · 11/09/2022 21:46

Can she cycle or contact the school and ask if they think a lift share would be likely?

Rowen32 · 11/09/2022 21:40

I think that's much too far for the weight of school bags alone but also time is so precious at that age - that time spent walking about be used for getting homework/study done and leaving your child free to have free time which is so rare as the exam years come :-(

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 11/09/2022 21:38

2 miles safe walk is fine. Mine do 1 mile to the bus stop, bus then another mile from bus stop the school and the reverse on the way home.