Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To boycott MIL’s Sunday Dinners

183 replies

Cantbebotheredanymore · 11/09/2022 19:56

It’s a story as old as time, DIL and MIL don’t get along. But I’m tired, and so so over this shit.

Ive been with DH for 10 years. MIL was super hostile in the beginning (you’re taking my eldest son away waaaaah) and we had a semi frosty relationship for a few years but the past 5 years we’ve had a decent relationship. Not going for coffees and spa days etc, but can speak cordially when left alone together and have a mutual love of certain hobbies.

Then I got pregnant :)

Tbf, she was brilliant during my pregnancy which had some challenges. Very respectful and caring.

Then I gave birth… and the insecure, passive-aggressive witch arrived.

Since giving birth last year, MIL has been insufferable. She’s had FOUR kids, lest I forget, and she oversteps in every possible area of DC life.

There is far too much to list but tldr, every Sunday her adult children and grandchild are summoned for Sunday dinner.

She isn’t like this everytime, but maybe once a month she’ll be “on one”. Making sly digs at me, suggesting my child isn’t clean/fed/happy. Eg…

“oooooh you LOVE nanny’s food, not that food mummy gives you”

“ what?!? You don’t give DC a bath EVERY night?! Ive raised FOUR kids and in my day….”

“oooow you want nanny don’t you /grabs child from my arms/ come to nannnnnnyyy”

And so on. Obviously I have raised this with DH and to his credit he does acknowledge some of her neurotic behaviour (but chalks it up to love/enthusiasm) “she doesn’t mean any harm” we’ve argued about it at times, and he’s pulled her up on some of the less subtle things.

But for the most part, it’s very underhand. I don’t believe she is vindictive in nature but she is deeply insecure and wants to use my child to validate her worth and experience, and put me down to make herself feel like mum of the year.

Shes been through a lot but quite frankly I don’t give a fuck about her feelings anymore. I’m sick of coming home on a Sunday feeling angry and not able to vent. Today was really awful, she made about 5/6 jibes at me, and while most of them I shrug off because they’re actually ridiculous, the ones suggesting DC isn’t being looked after properly are starting to irk me. I do snap back occasionally but I don’t like her getting the satisfaction of knowing I’m bothered.

So, I want to stop going all together. AIBU?

(And if not, should I tell DH the real reason or just make an excuse as to why I can no longer go? He is in a difficult situation, and I don’t want him stressed about us not getting on. But DH can take DC on his own.

I’d much rather sign up for a pottery class on a Sunday and “sadly not be able to go anymore”, rather than say your mum’s acting like a passive-aggressive pos and she can shove her roast up her...)

OP posts:
urbanbuddha · 11/09/2022 21:26

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 11/09/2022 20:59

  1. Dont go this week and take a break.
  2. Speak to her directly and tell her you are taking a break because every now and then she seems to have nothing but negative things to say about you such as xxxx and give her examples. Tell her you appreciate her but you will not put up with these.
  3. When you go again if she starts up get up and leave. Don't make a scene, just quietly tell her 'that is not called for'.
  4. Make sure DH is on side first or it wont work.

This.

KM99 · 11/09/2022 21:26

I'm astonished at some responses saying she's not that bad! There are some real snide comments even if it only happens every so often.

I think you have two choices. 1. You call her out every time "Wow MIL, are you OK? Because its sounds like you think I'm an inadequate parent". Or 2. Change up your Sundays and go less often.

Sounds to me like she's been getting away with this behaviour largely unchallenged so it might be a shock if you do pull her up every time.

Porcupineintherough · 11/09/2022 21:25

For your sanity you need to mix it up a bit. So some Sundays you all go, dome your dh send child go and some none of you go, just do your own thing.

As an aside: baby led weaning - don't do that at other people's houses. No one wants the mess all over their floors (unless they own a lab or similar greedy dog to hoover as the child goes).

maddiemookins16mum · 11/09/2022 21:24

I usually think MIL’s get an unfair deal on MN, but if this is as you say, YANBU. I honestly think I’d have burst into tears by now in front of her out if pure frustration and upset. She’s being unpleasant and cruel. I wonder what she’d say if her GC (in say 11 years time), told her she was being picked on/talked about in such a cruel way at a new school. She’s bullying you. I am sorry.

Amipreg1 · 11/09/2022 21:22

I wouldn't be going again and I also wouldn't be letting DC go. Why would you want your child to be around someone that is trying to undermine you? Who knows what she'll say to DC if you're not there.

NeapolitanDreams · 11/09/2022 21:22

Refuse to go. As another said, I wouldn’t be giving her the satisfaction of a grandchild either; especially if she’s likely to give the same jibes without you present. She sounds ridiculous - I’d put it down to insecurity too, but it is toxic if it’s at a cost to you (and your child).

MrsClarkandPercy · 11/09/2022 21:20

Personally I think this is a bit like a first world problem in terms of love and relationships and motherhood. Your kid is not just yours. He is also the child of your father. In fact, your child is a stand-alone person. And his father's mother loves him to bits.

She has clearly tried hard to toe the line and not upset you. She has calmed down and you have had some kind of even keel of interaction. Now there is a third party - a child. Yes, you gave birth to the child. He is 'yours'. But honestly, a child is always a child of the family. I don't see eye to eye with my MIL but I am very respectful of her relationship to my child. Basically, without her, my child wouldn't be here. So I respect that.

Your MIL doesn't sound bad. Sunday lunch all bought and cooked and served and washed up afterwards? What a dream. And she just wants to be close to her grandchild. I kind of agree with her as well about the bathing. (sorry)) ... I think you should appreciate what you have in her. She doesn't live with you. She only means to offer helpful advice. I think you are not seeing what you have in her. I feel you should back down, be more gentle, listen to what she has to say.

I know this may not be a popular view, but it's what I think you should do.

Listen to her, respect her, care about her. She wants to do the same for you and your child, by the sound of it. But she will tell you some things you might not want to hear. It is totally up to you, but the nighttime ritual of bath and bed is very soothing. She has a point.

Crayfishforyou · 11/09/2022 21:19

Refuse to go every Sunday.
i had a similar situation. I got the courage in the end to say to DH ‘she winds me up, I think it’s best to maintain a good relationship by stepping back’
I know generally feign boredom when my MIL starts. I yawn, and say ‘hmmm, that’s nice’ or ‘OK, everyone does things their own way’ and then check my phone or nails or stifle another yawn. I’d also laugh at some of the batshit (infuriating) things as though she was joking.
You have to refuse to rise, or find it funny.
a couple of times she overstepped the mark and I would pick up dd and say ‘right. That’s it. We’re done here’.
next time MiL interjects with some slow acting poison, cut in with ‘well yes of course, you have raised FOUR children’ followed by tinkly laugh.

houseofboy · 11/09/2022 21:19

Hi honestly now you are a family of 3 I think it's time to say you can't go every week. As child gets older you will have other things on. Can't imagine going to the in-laws for lunch every Sunday even if they were the loveliest people going. I like a roast dinner on a Sunday but just with my DH and sons.

Darbs76 · 11/09/2022 21:17

I don’t think she sounds that bad, but obviously not me suffering it. Sundays are family time, so I’d start some traditions of your own, which means you all go only once per month

hattie43 · 11/09/2022 21:17

I can see what she says being said up and down the country all the time . I think you are being overly sensitive . Tbh though weekly visits are too much . Monthly at Best but even that's too much .
I think just be honest , send OH on his own but say you have another interest / hobby / too busy with baby etc etc

BatshitBanshee · 11/09/2022 21:16

I'd stop going altogether and DC wouldn't be going either, no way would I let a walking thundering bitch talk saccharine laced shit about me to my child. And if anyone asks 'it just doesn't suit anymore". DH can still go. Let him do the joined up thinking to work out there's only so much offensive shit a woman can take from a nasty MiL.

And it's abundantly clear who the nasty MiLs are on this thread.

Soontobe60 · 11/09/2022 21:15

You’re an adult - you don’t have to go! YABU calling her a witch and neurotic. It’s bad enough when a man uses those insults, but from another woman?
stay home next week and have a quiet day at home whilst DH takes the baby.

LimpBiskit · 11/09/2022 21:13

Bow out and tell your DH you're not prepared to put up with the BS any longer.

Cantbebotheredanymore · 11/09/2022 21:12

@AssignedSlytherinAtBirth when she criticised my choice of wine with my dinner in a restaurant.

THIS!! My MIL is also a wine snob.

Whenever I used to bring over a bottle of wine for her she would pull a face and said on multiple occasions “uhhh I guess I could use it for cooking with”

I don’t bring wine anymore :)

OP posts:
Ottersmith · 11/09/2022 21:10

Every Sunday is too much! Your DH has got his own family now so boundaries need to be put in. Yeah fuck her off completely.

BeautifulDragon · 11/09/2022 21:09

My MIL used to be just like this. My DC's are both primary school age now and she's calmed down a lot.

It did lots of damage to our relationship. She saw (& still does to some extent) far less of the children than she would have, if she hadn't decided to spend her grandchildren's early days/ years jabbing at their mother!

It's such bizarre behaviour because ultimately it comes from wanting to be with the GC as much as possible, but obviously no wants to spend their time with a person who behaves this way. It just drove a massive wedge between us.

I used to sit at MIL's house full of anxiety and hoping that DD wouldn't cry, because I knew if she did MIL would snatch her off me in an effort to prove she could settle her better than I could. She wouldn't give her back when I asked either.

I would back right off OP. No one is entitled to your time if they can't even be nice to you.

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 11/09/2022 21:07

I think what I would do is write her a note tomorrow and say that you counted up the number of jibes she made at you today. I would list them all. I would say I have tried really hard to have a good relationship with you but when you talk to me like that it just makes me not want to be anywhere near you. I would say, I don't think you would put up with this from anyone else. Then I'd say bearing that in mind, I'm happy for my husband and child to come to see you but I'm going to bow out at this point unless it's a big special occasion.

Folklore9074 · 11/09/2022 21:07

If you make a big deal out of this it'll add fuel to her fire. Your instinct is right be less available, have a hobby that keeps you elsewhere, or just need a bit of time to yourself some weekends - whatever excuse works. If you're husband presses you, don't lie but I'd not make a huge thing out of this woman's occasional silly annoying comments.

Sounds like she has her good side but can just be a total pain in the bum. If you see her a bit less she'll presumably irk you less but ultimately it's a relationship that you'll need to have for some time to come so finding a way to handle it (in your case by not subjecting yourself to the weekly roast) is probably the sensible, real-world way to handle it.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 11/09/2022 21:06

She can dick off. Quite a few people on here have got the measure of her. When your DC are older she'll be undermining you in other ways. This isn't a grit your teeth and get through it situation. Seeing her grandkids is a privilege and respect is earned.
It doesn't sound like she's done anything at all to earn your respect, such as being polite and gracious towards you. In fact, quite the opposite.
Her reiterations of "I raised FOUR children" reminds me of that Victoria Wood quote about how the captain of the school netball team is still going on about the fact she was captain of the school netball team when she's in her thirties because that was the pinnacle of her life's achievements. Obv that's a paraphrase.

Cantbebotheredanymore · 11/09/2022 21:06

@C8H10N4O2 My BIL had a partner but recently split up, she did come to a few dinners, and was also on the receiving end of suspicious comments, but unfortunately she didn’t last long. My SILs are single, so I’m the only partner there.

I think everyone knows what she’s like, and sometimes they stick up for me but mostly they just roll their eyes or ignore it, as it is often very subtle.

Eg MIL isn’t a fan of baby led weaning and insists on spoonfeeding her DELICIOUS food to DC. Today I said, you can just give her the spoon as she can feed herself. She ignored me and kept aeroplaning food into her mouth. BIL said “are you not listening, she said DC can use a spoon” so she huffed and gave DC the spoon (which she through straight on the floor lol much to her delight)

OP posts:
SavingsThreads · 11/09/2022 21:05

Any chance any of the other siblings will have children soon? That'll help. Otherwise just sit at the opposite end of the table and let your dh and dc deal with her!

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 11/09/2022 21:05

If the OP tells MIL she is upset, MIL will be pleased and probably won't hide that fact. My MIL was the same. DH thought it was funny, until I put my foot down and he had a word with her and told her that her comments were unacceptable. This was after DD became old enough to say "that's not very nice. Nanna," and "people like different things, Nanna" when she criticised my choice of wine with my dinner in a restaurant. But anyway, I convinced DH she WBU and he now sticks up for me, and understands. We don't see them very often.

Dishwashersaurous · 11/09/2022 21:04

Or indeed option 3. Don't go and visit every single Sunday

Iloveacurry · 11/09/2022 21:03

She expects you every Sunday? No no no. That’s too much. Yes definitely opt out.