Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To lower how much money I spend on my kids at Christmas this year?

84 replies

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 16:45

Will they notice if they don’t get as many presents this year? How much does everyone spend on their children at christmas? I always overspend and end up getting them things I wish I hadn’t or didn’t need so I want to set a limit and only get them a few really nice presents but they don’t understand money and I don’t want them to think Santa thought they wernt as good this year because they didn’t get as much as last year…they will be 9, 5 and 3 at Christmas time, they are each getting a bike as their main present as they all need a new one (that will be at least £100-150 each, slightly more for the 9 year old slightly less for the 3 year old) so majority of the budget will be going on those but working out what is a reasonable amount to budget to spend on other presents etc.

OP posts:
Von19 · 11/09/2022 19:45

Isn't one major gift like a new bike sufficient?

Mumspair1 · 11/09/2022 19:44

I'm surprised that you haven't had any discussions with your 9yo who is well old enough to understand if you need to cut back. We are fortunate that we can spend whatever we want on my dc but we don't. I do think children should learn the value of something not the price of it. You're getting them expensive bikes so shouldn't that and something else that's small be enough? The fact that you are concerned about the pile of gifts being smaller, shows that quantity over quality means more to you and that's what your kids will expect.

FrizzledFrazzle · 11/09/2022 19:44

Make sure the bikes are nice. If 9yo asks why less presents than before, you can point out that she got a really nice new bike which was her big present, whereas other years she got lots of smaller things. Could also get some bike accessories for them - like reflectors, spoke beads etc.

Also, maybe get another gift that is something like a family outing - don't have to pay the cost upfront, but can make nice individual "tickets" to an activity day they would enjoy but which doesn't have to be really expensive.

JubileeTissues · 11/09/2022 19:35

Come to the Christmas boards. The bargain threads are great.

FinallyHere · 11/09/2022 19:34

Tat. I meant tat.

FinallyHere · 11/09/2022 19:34

Adult DH really values the number of presents we each get. It makes no sense to me. One year he bought me an iPhone (much appreciated and loved) but then he bought a whole heap of other stuff none of which I wanted.

Maybe mention to your eldest that as people grow up, they tend to get fewer, more expensive presents. If you get what she wants, and feels grown up too, will she really miss a heap of fat ?

Sprogonthetyne · 11/09/2022 18:58

The 9yo will be old enough to understand that money is tight and the 3yo will be to young to notice or remember last year. The 5yo could be more problematic, I'd probably save by buying second hand but try to get close to the same amount, they won't care if it came in a box or not.

MooseBreath · 11/09/2022 18:58

They'll notice, but likely won't be bothered because of the lovely things they are getting. And if you remain positive, it will rub off on them.

We are doing stockings (little toys, socks, chocolate, book, etc.) and one bigger present each from Santa (marble run, train set, etc.), and then clothes and one shared present between the two from DH and I. We have also told the family that we are very much tightening our budgets for adults, so very pared back this year. I think MIL and FIL were relieved that we brought it up rather than them, to be honest.

PoppyFleur · 11/09/2022 18:51

We have never had all gifts come from Father Christmas, he just brings 1 gift, the rest are from us and family members. I think it’s important for children to know and acknowledge who the gifts are from and thank the person appropriately (so always written thanks to gifts from older generation).

The amount spent has always been a challenging issue between DH and I. My family were of modest means and we didn’t receive piles of gifts; we got something we wanted, something we needed and something to read. But I loved Christmas and never felt I missed out, there was a lot of emphasis on special family time together, baking biscuits, playing board games, and free things like going to see the Christmas lights in the nearest city.

DH family were, and still are, all about the piles of gifts. But he has few memories of spending quality time with his parents. Which is of great sadness now that FIL has passed away.

This year, why not take the opportunity to reset your Christmas and build new traditions. Christmas is not worth getting into debt for. Too often money is spent on fripperies that are forgotten.

We no longer buy any gifts for adult family other than our mothers (we have both lost our fathers).

DH, DC and I do a stocking for each other (names out of the hat, for who gets whom), we have a budget of £12.50 and we get very creative! Last year in my stocking was a compact mirror that my son spotted in a charity shop, I absolutely treasure it.

Get creative, Christmas doesn’t need to be stressful or break the bank.

mathanxiety · 11/09/2022 18:49

Wrt bikes (just read your comment, sorry) -

Your almost 3 yo doesn't need one.

Your DS can have a spray painted bike from older DD. DD can have a 'new' one from Marketplace. Clean it up if it's not in great visual shape.

Start looking now on Marketplace.

mathanxiety · 11/09/2022 18:45

If they all currently have bikes then the younger kids can inherit the cast offs.
If none of them has a bike then ignore.

Tell your 9yo about Santa.

Stop buying little bits and pieces to stuff stockings. Get them all used to a limited number of presents starting this year.

Do some nice family activity instead, preferably a cheap or free one. Spend a weekend afternoon making Christmas tree decorations, make some special hot cocoa one day, go for an evening family walk to see the lit up streets of your local town or city, make a gingerbread house...

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 18:39

Thanks for everyone’s ideas, it’s been good to see how everyone else does Christmas….I am going to take a lot of this on board and try the ideas given as I don’t want spoilt kids…my eldest can sometimes expect things and come across a little ungrateful at times but I can see that’s my fault as I did used to spoil her when she was the only one, I just need to try and break that and continuing to overspend at Christmas isnt going to help that….my middle child is grateful for anything and everything, I can take him in a charity shop and let him choose a 20p tiny car and it’s like he’s been given the world and my youngest is still a bit young to care about any presents at all, she just wants the same as the other 2.

OP posts:
BlackeyedSusan · 11/09/2022 18:29

Bloody hell, bikes are enough with a couple of little things such as a toy and a book.

Mysteryallergy · 11/09/2022 18:28

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 18:06

@Mysteryallergy I like this! Thanks for this idea!

It also gives your kids incentive to get rid of their old stuff, it's fun for them to decide what Santa can take away to give to another child! I put my old things on FB marketplace and buy stuff for them from there too. Kids don't care if it comes in a new box or not.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 11/09/2022 18:25

I never realised people said all the presents came from santa? 1 small present here from santa, everything else from the people who have gifted them. 8yo is old enough to understand that bigger toys cost more money.

We bought my DD a bike for xmas last year and only bought 3 other small things from us, we do 4 presents

SpiderinaWingMirror · 11/09/2022 18:19

Luckily FC only ever brought Stocking gifts to our house. Being self employed we had both feast and famine years.

ForestofD · 11/09/2022 18:19

Honestly, I think it would be a useful life lesson for the 9 year old. I know you don't want to disappoint her but there are good reasons why you are cutting back.

We've discussed with our two how, at the moment, everything is a lot more expensive because well, lots of reasons. They've already seen some stuff on Newsround. So this year, they get to pick things they really, really want- (rather than stuff I think they will like.) So far, youngest has asked for air dry clay and a jewellery box with a cat on it. Oldest has asked for a 'proper' piece of jewellery she can keep rather than fashion jewellery. I've been picking up stuff in Tiger and TKMax for the stocking (pens, scrunchies etc).

But, we have been making jam together, so we can 'put it up for Christmas.' I've bought a garland kit and I've started sewing them one each.

Daddy is having one bigger present this year, which they helped me choose (a kitbag in the sale) and Mummy has asked Father Christmas for a certain pair of slippers because they help her sore feet.

2 years ago, heating oil was 26p a litre. Now it is 96p a litre. To heat our home this year, we are all going to have to economise. As lots of people have said, you can make it special in other ways. My youngest has a special tiger toy- so last year, I knitted it a special blanket. She loved it and it always 'sleeps' tucked under its blanket.

TheEggChair · 11/09/2022 18:15

If people ask you for gift ideas, ask them for experience gifts like zoo passes etc that you can use throughout the year.

LittleLangdale · 11/09/2022 18:13

Spend less on the 3 year old. They won't know or care. Honestly it doesn't matter if you spend a bit more on the 9 year old as long as they each have roughly the same number of items. The value will balance out over the years.

When I was a kid it was all about the unwrapping. So one main present, a book, maybe a game, then tubes of sweets, cans of fizzy drink, pens, bubble bath, socks etc. Stuff they will either eat or use. It doesn't need to be a giant pile of toys.

TheEggChair · 11/09/2022 18:11

Go and have a look on the Christmas bargain thread on the Christmas board. I've saved loads of money over the years buying bargains & using discount codes posted on the threads.

purpledagger · 11/09/2022 18:09

Mine are slightly older than yours, but I've been trying to cut down their presents for a few years, as they get so much that they barely use. Here are a few tips:

I add some practical items along with their presents - water bottles, umbrellas, lunchboxes, gloves, pjs, body wash that smells like sweets. A lot of it is stuff they will need over the coming year and put it aside until it's needed, after it'/ been unwrapped.

I make up hampers eg sweets or toiletries. I display them to make them look a bit wow, even though they are really cheap items.

I spread out some of the gifts so it lasts a bit longer. They get an Xmas Eve hamper, which had their Santa plate for his mince pie and Santa key. I buy them new pjs (non Xmas ones they wear throughout the year) toothbrush an ld hot chocolate). I keep back a small gift, which they 'find' on Boxing Day evening.

I make sure they know there are lots of people who go without and they should be grateful for whatever they get.

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 18:09

elizaregina · 11/09/2022 18:01

Op once I gave 3 year old lot's of lovely gifts that were all free.
We don't have uncles/aunt's/GP to buy either.

Each month I then started to put £10 aside into a.tin for Xmas and added to it from eBay sale's.

Now we do it on line, and are able to save more.
What we have managed to save is what we spend.
Obviously some may be left over.
However doing it this way around really steadies the ship.

Why not start to save each month and look at charity shops. I'm just thinking with your incredibly large budget I could easily get second hand bike's that look new as well as loads of other gifts and probably buy panto /theatre/ attractions tickets!

@elizaregina yeah this is what I’d intended to do throughout the year but the year just got away with me 🤣 I’m getting a couple of hundred extra in my wage this month so I’m planning to put that aside for Christmas

OP posts:
Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 18:06

Mysteryallergy · 11/09/2022 18:00

My daughter goes through her toys before Xmas to get together anything she doesn't want any more, Santa takes these ones away and gifts to other children and this is why she also gets some second hand gifts. Santa is recycling. It's so much cheaper, and sometimes free.

@Mysteryallergy I like this! Thanks for this idea!

OP posts:
elizaregina · 11/09/2022 18:04

Op.

My 3 year old had no care nor concept of receiving exiting new toys that cost 25 from a shelf in Tesco or free from Freecycle?
She still got lot's of wonderful gifts!
Now they are older it's £ or clothes or tech.

I can't understand why it would be less magical when they will still be getting lots of lovely exciting new toys?

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 18:04

SavingsThreads · 11/09/2022 17:56

@Jaaxe why not just get it resprayed and lower the seat? What happened to the bill she had when she was 5? Or when she was 3 for the youngest?

@SavingsThreads I sold them, we don’t have the room to store them….I also didn’t even have the 2nd and 3rd child when I got rid of my eldest child’s first bike etc I’ve kept a lot of smaller things to pass down but bikes were too big

OP posts: