Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To lower how much money I spend on my kids at Christmas this year?

84 replies

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 16:45

Will they notice if they don’t get as many presents this year? How much does everyone spend on their children at christmas? I always overspend and end up getting them things I wish I hadn’t or didn’t need so I want to set a limit and only get them a few really nice presents but they don’t understand money and I don’t want them to think Santa thought they wernt as good this year because they didn’t get as much as last year…they will be 9, 5 and 3 at Christmas time, they are each getting a bike as their main present as they all need a new one (that will be at least £100-150 each, slightly more for the 9 year old slightly less for the 3 year old) so majority of the budget will be going on those but working out what is a reasonable amount to budget to spend on other presents etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
E12355 · 13/09/2022 09:08

What I have learnt from going unnecessarily overboard in the past is that I literally only get what my daughter asks for in her list to Santa (and obviously if she would ask for ridiculously expensive stuff then I would explain that Santa has a lot of children to give presents too and that he can’t get something so big/expensive. But luckily she’s not got there yet!).

This is what I did last year and it just makes more sense I think.

A couple of years ago my cousin had spent close to £500 on her daughter, if not more, and I felt awful that I’d only spent like £150 (on things that were actually asked for), so to try and keep up I bought loads of extras, baby Annabell doll, the cot, a pram, which cost and extra £200 almost. Guess what, those extras have never been played with! So I learnt that there is no point in going off the santa list! I will obviously buy extras that she hasn’t asked for, craft things, maybe some other things I know she will like and they will be from Mum and Dad. But the bigger things, the main things she wants will be from Santa.

Another thing I do is, if I know early on what she wants, like she’s already mentioned a couple of things, I will keep an eye out to see if they go on sale!

Cocktail70 · 12/09/2022 15:07

I completely agree and we too shall be cutting back this Xmas, family members have already discussed no gifts for adults etc.
When our kids were younger it was pretty easy to give them second hand, etc and I was pretty savvy with their gifts. But I have preteens now. I do find it hard to understand when people on here say £50 per child for example, even older ones. We have always got our kids one main gift each and then a selection of other stuff, clothes, toys etc. This year my daughter wants a phone. This will be £200. She has written me a list of a few toys from smyths, think barbie sets etc and these are between £30 & £50 each so we can very, very easily hit £500 for her.
My son is having a Ps5. Been wanting one for 2 years. This is £500 on its own, combined with accessorise needed for it such as chargers, controllers, games etc again it runs into hundreds for just a few things. This is not a braggy post at all, I'm just stating costs of items. We easily spend over 1k at Xmas on not that much at all. It's a crazy amount of money to me.
But with regards to the op question about the amount their kids have, we have also made the mistake over the years of having a big bike (mostly second hand) as we also have all families gifts under the tree aswell. I'm not saying they expect that every year but its something we've always done

templesit · 12/09/2022 02:44

I know what you mean. I don't have a 'budget' so buy when I see and overspend.
So much so last year after Christmas I found a box of gifts with some clothing in I'd forgotten about. DC had no idea there were things missing and it made me rethink!

This year I'll keep a list.

I'd make sure you wrap their bikes (even a sheet over the top) as then it becomes a big present not just a bike with a bow.

I would hold on to some things like new slippers pj's outfits to give at Christmas.
And some basics they get anyway like toothbrushes, chocolate, snacks, socks. Also, if a present can have something bigger with it like a dvd- wrap with a big bad of popcorn or a new book with a new fleece blanket.

Boxowine · 12/09/2022 01:43

My children are grown now, but in retrospect I honestly regret all the stuff I bought them every Christmas. Much of it they never even wanted. It takes forever to get rid of it all now. I wish I had cut back and put some of that money towards activities

Pillowbed · 12/09/2022 01:31

I have just declutttered my kids' bedroom and found unopened things from last year. Plus some other stuff they've had for a while that looks as good as new or is actually new.

I've put it all to one side. Stuff that I think they won't touch, I'm going to sell and put that towards one main gift each. Stuff that I know they'll like but they just haven't got around to playing with, they're getting back this year! I've also bought some branded clothes in the summer sales. That's it for them unless there's one small thing that they ask for!

I see seeds a few months before Christmas regarding things I've already got them. So I'll say something like, "that looks like a good game. Perhaps you should ask FC for that this year?" Or "wouldn't it be great if FC got you that this year?"

ohmyohmy123 · 12/09/2022 01:16

I'm not doing the usual this year of bulking out with presents they don't need just so it looks more. I'm going to get them what they want and a few extras and that's it. I still have stuff from last year that they didn't want.

BigChesterDraws · 12/09/2022 01:01

as my eldest was always used to getting tonnes (as she was the only child for a good few years)

She’s 9 and her younger sibling is 5. So she was an only child for 4 years at best. Most of that time she won’t even remember. And she certainly wouldn’t have been able to calculate the value of her Christmas presents.

DIYandEatCake · 11/09/2022 23:49

Our kids get one present each from us, and it’ll be something they really want (at the moment, I think I’ll be getting a stunt scooter for my son and some good quality art supplies for my daughter). It’s what we’ve always done so we’re not really cutting back this year. Budget varies depending what they want, but usually £50-100. They get a stocking each too, I aim for a limit of £20 per stocking. My kids do also get presents from grandparents, aunts and uncles so end up with quite a few presents altogether. Everyone’s different, with different budgets, but like others have said, there are things kids remember and value much more than presents. I loved Christmas as a child, we had so many traditions and it was brilliant having all the family together, it didn’t matter that we didn’t have much money so just small presents.

Tiredalwaystired · 11/09/2022 22:53

Think about your childhood christmases. Can you remember all the gifts you ever got?

you might remember the main present or one novelty gift that made you smile but the rest of it just blurs.

They don’t need loads. They’ll remember the time you spent and the things you did ten years from now, not the LOL doll knock off. I promise.

Lcb123 · 11/09/2022 22:09

I think you can be honest with them about money and how it’s earned and spent. Important they understand that. I think £50 per child is plenty - why not get 2nd hand bikes and talk to them about how buying 2nd hand is good for the environment

zoeFromCity · 11/09/2022 22:07

When my sister was young, she believed in Santa for relatively long time and she has always been very considerate, so she suggested to our parents that she doesn't want/need stuff "now", she can just select them or try the cloths on and than write to Santa, so they wouldn't have to spend money on her :)))

I think you can tell the oldest the truth, less money available, so she will get one bigger thing of your choice, one bigger of her choice and some smaller stuff around.
With the younger ones I'd aim for the same, let them indicate several things for Santa to choose from and hope that one of them will be reasonable.

woodhill · 11/09/2022 21:51

FrownedUpon · 11/09/2022 21:51

Spend what you can afford and nothing more. No one should be getting into financial trouble for Christmas. A happy household free of debt is more important than crappy presents.

Absolutely

FrownedUpon · 11/09/2022 21:51

Spend what you can afford and nothing more. No one should be getting into financial trouble for Christmas. A happy household free of debt is more important than crappy presents.

Mumspair1 · 11/09/2022 21:37

Just go low key and drive home the point that the main gift is an expensive one so there will be 1/2 other smaller ones. My ds is 6yo and completely understands this already. For his birthday we got him one gift and took him on a day out which he absolutely loved and still talks about. He turned 6 just before the summer holidays and got an obscene amount from his class party- very expensive gifts as well. The first thing he said was we don't need to buy him Christmas gifts. Children have expectations because we set them.Your 3yo has no concept about what's alot of presents - that comes from you. Your 9yo is well old enough to understand, and your 5yo will probably take the lead from the others.

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 21:36

ForestofD · 11/09/2022 20:29

Just an aside, OP- we have a retired chap in our area, takes in unwanted bikes from peoples garages, does them up (new brakes, tyres, checks etc) polishes them so they look tidy and sells them with all proceeds to the MS Society. Kids bikes are from £30-£50

Perhaps get looking on local Facebook noticeboards for someone like this in your area? You may not have anyone but it may be worth a look.

@ForestofD thanks I will have a look around

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 11/09/2022 21:29

I think everyone will be making cutbacks and curving frivolous spending.

I definitely intend on cutting back.

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 21:27

Vinylloving · 11/09/2022 21:20

I am keeping it low key, focus on quality time and simple activities. I think a bike plus say 3-4 other things to open is enough. But then my DC has lots of aunts and uncles so get presents from wider family. I've seen them get overwhelmed with too much. I said last year definitely less next year and.plan to stick to it

This is exactly what I thought last year and am thinking this year. Thanks

OP posts:
ElvisLeftTheBuilding · 11/09/2022 21:27

"but as my eldest was always used to getting tonnes (as she was the only child for a good few years) I’ve not wanted to disappoint or her wonder why she gets less now there is 3 of them"

Seems like now is the perfect time to teach your 9yr old the very valuable lesson of quality over quantity! She's old enough to appreciate that one big present equals the same as several smaller presents.

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 21:22

Mumspair1 · 11/09/2022 19:44

I'm surprised that you haven't had any discussions with your 9yo who is well old enough to understand if you need to cut back. We are fortunate that we can spend whatever we want on my dc but we don't. I do think children should learn the value of something not the price of it. You're getting them expensive bikes so shouldn't that and something else that's small be enough? The fact that you are concerned about the pile of gifts being smaller, shows that quantity over quality means more to you and that's what your kids will expect.

No as I said up thread, quality over quantity means more to me but I’m not sure the same applies to my children. They’ve always just had a mix of good quality gifts and things I’ve added in that I know they’ll love that are cheap but I hate….and it’s just to make it as magical for them as possible but I’m fed up of the tat and I’m trying to cut costs a little this year which for me means getting rid of the tat first.

And I have had a discussions with my 9 year old in the past about costs of things etc…for example on her birthday she knew she would only be getting one gift as she wanted an iPad and I explained the cost of this and she understood and was more than happy with this and perfectly made up on her birthday….However Christmas has always been a little different than birthdays in our house…they get the stockings of tat then their main present and a few good quality gifts but I’ve found they end up with a lot of presents…just trying to cut back really without them wondering why they didn’t get this or that like last year from Santa etc

OP posts:
Vinylloving · 11/09/2022 21:20

I am keeping it low key, focus on quality time and simple activities. I think a bike plus say 3-4 other things to open is enough. But then my DC has lots of aunts and uncles so get presents from wider family. I've seen them get overwhelmed with too much. I said last year definitely less next year and.plan to stick to it

lanthanum · 11/09/2022 21:08

Mysteryallergy · 11/09/2022 18:00

My daughter goes through her toys before Xmas to get together anything she doesn't want any more, Santa takes these ones away and gifts to other children and this is why she also gets some second hand gifts. Santa is recycling. It's so much cheaper, and sometimes free.

This year, perhaps there should be some publicity around the fact that Santa's fuel bills have gone up massively, and so he may not be able to manage as many presents per child.

ForestofD · 11/09/2022 20:29

Just an aside, OP- we have a retired chap in our area, takes in unwanted bikes from peoples garages, does them up (new brakes, tyres, checks etc) polishes them so they look tidy and sells them with all proceeds to the MS Society. Kids bikes are from £30-£50

Perhaps get looking on local Facebook noticeboards for someone like this in your area? You may not have anyone but it may be worth a look.

LastWordsOfALiar · 11/09/2022 20:06

Personally I'd get the 3 year old a Marketplace bike (mine cost £10 for my preschooler) and spend the money elsewhere or just save it.

I'd think about writing a list got each child of what they consistently want and need. Then buy based on that. No impulses. No cheap stuff for the sake of it (that adds up to a decent gift anyway). Just a few well thought out gifts each (secondhand where possible/appropriate).

DappledThings · 11/09/2022 20:05

Never had or did a "main present". It was just the present. One present from parents. Plus stockings from Farher Christmas was are really just bits; chocolate coins, sticker books, bubbles. Nothing expensive.

They also gets presents from other members of the family so are still overwhelmed with stuff even with us only getting them one present.

Grumpybutfunny · 11/09/2022 19:46

We are making a real effort to be sustainable. This year DS will be getting a main present, art stuff, PJs, Xmas day outfit and a few small collectibles he's asked for. This is in comparison to the electric scooter and hoverboards he's had as surprises in the past.

We save every month towards Xmas so tempted to use the money to book a weekend at theme park and give him the tickets.