Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a size 14 viewed as overweight?

357 replies

Ilovemycatalot · 11/09/2022 10:31

Just reading online that uk size 16 is the average size of a uk woman right now. Im a size 14 and 5ft 3 so always felt overweight anyway but in reality would you view someone as a size 14 overweight? For me anyone who can fit into a size 10 would be considered slim although I know clothes sizes come up different depending on shop. Just curious what dress size people on here buy and if they consider themselves overweight.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Butterflytown · 11/09/2022 12:39

It will depend on your height but for the vast majority of people yes, a size 14 will be overweight. I’m 5’11 and currently wear a size 14. I weigh 13 stone so have a bmi of just over 25, just tipping me into the overweight category. I am definitely carrying too much weight and look overweight especially around my stomach. When I weighed 12 stone and had a bmi of 23.5 I was still a size 14. I felt quite slim at that weight. It was only at less than 11 1/2 stone so a bmi of 22.5 or less that I could get into a size 12.

nokitchen · 11/09/2022 12:39

I'm a 14 and 5 ft 3. I am definitely overweight. Vanity sizes have changed things so much over the years. What is now a 14 would have been a 16 a few years ago in many ships

JuneBrowning · 11/09/2022 12:39

A lot depends on your measurements. So it's not a cert that a size 14 is overweight.

My Mum was a size 14 for years because she has massive boobs- a 34F. But she was slim everywhere else, weighing about 8st 7, at 5 3".

She had to buy 14 tops because of her bust but could get away with a 12 in dresses and skrts.

These are OLD sizes. Now, she wears a 10 partly as she's lost some of her bust in old age but also with size-inflation (vanity sizing.)

I get fed up with buying her clothes and returning them as in her head she is still a size 14, whereas because of changing sizes she is really a 12 or a 10!

But she's never weighed more than 9st and when she hit that she went to a slimming class, lost half a stone and has kepyt it off.

Ilovemycatalot · 11/09/2022 12:39

I never eat breakfast first meal normally at 12 . I go long periods of not eating and then I will binge eat whatever is at hand. I do eat a lot of cheese (my biggest weakness) and processed food. I have a sweet tooth and get sugar cravings normally about 4pm. Mainly drink fizzy water and cappuccinos. Basically my diet is a mess. I don’t eat big meals as I get bloated easy just snack throughout the day. For example my evening meal could be something random like a tin of soup and a bit of cheese especially if I’ve been at work all day and am tired.

OP posts:
Wisteriaroundthedoor · 11/09/2022 12:38

Ilovemycatalot · 11/09/2022 12:16

I’m definitely not in denial but it’s easy to look at others that are big and think well at least I’m not as big as them which still doesn’t mean your not big of course. I see more overweight women than slim where I live so it’s easy to see it as the norm. And definitely see more over weight women than men.

But do you also not look at women smaller and understand you’re bigger? You must see slimmer women, both in real,life and in the media. I think it’s a sign of denial if you only look at bigger women and comfort yourself you’re not that large. It would need to be extreme before you didn’t see anyone bigger that you/

LindaEllen · 11/09/2022 12:37

Clothes sizes are so different now that you really can't use them as a measure of whether it's overweight or not.

For example, when I was a completely healthy weight (on the lower end of the range, even) I could wear size 8 on the top but size 14 on the bottom due to wide hips - no fat on them though! I was not overweight. But now I AM overweight am size 14 on top 18 on bottom.

bruffin · 11/09/2022 12:37

Ilovemycatalot · 11/09/2022 10:38

Did the BMI calculator thing and I was considered obese. Just upset me a bit guess I’m looking for reassurance but yeah I’m definitely overweight by at least a couple of stone.

But it does depend how muscular you are. I weigh bordering obese but the gym boditrax says i am standard muscular with no visceral stomach fat.
I have done more exercise recently and lost inches but not lost any weight. A dress i bought a few months ago was slightly tight is now a perfect fit.
I am 60 today but a metabolic age of 49!
The egym puts my legs muscles at 37 years old!

Foldingchair · 11/09/2022 12:36

I'm 5'9 and a 12. 14 is overweight for me, but I'd be able to hide it easily with clothes. I'm slim at a 12, with some stomach definition, but I'm definitely losing my very defined waist- hip ratio, now that menopause approaches.

LimeTwists · 11/09/2022 12:36

I’m a size 10. 12 would be overweight for me and I’d have a flabby tummy etc. As soon as my size 10 clothes feel snug, I eat a bit more carefully.

Minikievs · 11/09/2022 12:35

I'm 5 8 and was big at a 14. Not massively fat but definitely chubby.
At 5 3 and a 14, unless you were a weight lifter/fitness instructor etc then I think this would count as overweight, yes

Marvellousmadness · 11/09/2022 12:33

5ft3 and size 14?of course you are overweight. You are severely overweight
And the fact that you question that tells me that society has come to a point that being overweight has now become normal. It is sad and scary ..

ColourChartMadness · 11/09/2022 12:33

Education on food is needed across the board. I just don't think little pie chart drawings with pictures of bananas and steaks really do it. I started learning how to cook good meals by accident with an old style one-pot recipe book that was actually full of healthy recipes, and that started off my interest in cooking. It wasn't even marketed as healthy. And just little things like learning that pastry is not good for you and should be a treat was kind of surprising to me (I was brought up to finish my pastry!). That kind of thing... I'm not the brightest person in the world so I need things spelled out over and over again!

I do think slimming world can be good for learning basics (although I have too much dairy - really concerned about osteoporosis!)

Not that I can give advice on anything, but I don't want my kids to have my problems (and they don't).

firef1y · 11/09/2022 12:33

Well I'm a 10-12 and according to bmi I'm considered to be overweight/on the cusp of obese. In the middle of a cut right now and even a week ago I was considered obese.
But what bmi doesn't take in to account is I lift heavy weights, have a higher than average muscle mass and also have a lot of loose skin from 10stone weightloss.

JuneBrowning · 11/09/2022 12:32

@Ilovemycatalot If you walk for an hour a day -fast- not strolling- that will definitely help.

I know you may not want to do this, but do you fancy posting what you normally eat in a day and then posters could give you a bit of help?

Fearneyox · 11/09/2022 12:30

Yes I’d consider that very overweight at your height (unless you’re a bodybuilder) . Just because the average is a 16 it doesn’t make it okay. We are walking into an obesity crisis in the UK at the moment and are so used to seeing overweight people it is becoming the norm. Google photos of groups of people from 50-100 years ago and look at the difference in their size. You’d rarely see overweight people back then, it’s a modern crisis.

JuneBrowning · 11/09/2022 12:30

For comparison, I'm size 10 (sometimes an 8) and am 5 3" I weigh 7.7st.
I have tiny hands and wrists and have to get all rings made to measure. I am skinny, just small framed.

You say you don't know how to eat healthily @Ilovemycatalot
There is masses of info online and all the supermarkets have good recipes on their sites, usually sorted into 'healthy eating' sections.

You don't need to make complicated meals.

Just work on the basis of real food - basic things like fish, chicken, eggs and pulses, and add lots of veg and fruit.

Cut out sugar, processed and white flour things like pizza, white pasta, white rice, white bread, cake, biscuits, crisps, sugary drinks etc.

AnnabelC · 11/09/2022 12:26

www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/255712 . You might find this interesting OP.

sponsabillaries · 11/09/2022 12:23

I am 6' tall and at my very thinnest I was a size 12. I was unwell and looked absolutely awful. Family were visibly concerned about me. At a size 14 I am slim but healthy. The width of my skeleton, particularly at my shoulders, ribcage and hips, means I could not physically become smaller than a size 12 even if I starved myself 😔

MumE78 · 11/09/2022 12:23

I'm 43 5ft 2 and I weigh 9st 10lb and west a size 10, I have muffin top
My 16 daughter weighs 9st 5ft 3 and is a size 4

It's hard to generalise a size

Ilovemycatalot · 11/09/2022 12:23

Also not a fan of the gym but thinking even if I try a brisk walk for an hour each day would that help? Although I think 90% of weight loss I’d due to the foods you eat.

OP posts:
PalePurplePumpkin · 11/09/2022 12:21

Someone with a past eating disorder knows what they’re getting into from the thread title, and can take responsibility for managing their own triggers.

Exactly. I don't know why every time there's a thread like this, someone says they hope it doesn't trigger people with EDs. It's quite ridiculous.

Ilovemycatalot · 11/09/2022 12:19

Also I feel uneducated in how to eat healthy I mean yeah we all know eat more fruit and veg but I’m not good with different recipes how to make healthy but fulfilling meals so I don’t feel hungry just need to educate myself.

OP posts:
Xtraincome · 11/09/2022 12:18

Even in the best shape of my life and really loving my Kardashian type curves with a tighter body I was still a 12- have wide hips and big bum, sometimes a 10 in tops as smaller waisted.

I am overweight and bigger by almost 3/4 stone since having kids. I am still a 14/16 but fatter in parts yet not noticeably fat but still overweight if that makes sense? I don't ever call myself fat but just hate how out of shape I am more than anything.

Size 14 is not overweight on the average person. But if you have rolls of fat then I suppose you are? Every single body is so vastly different and I don't look at people and judge how overweight they are! BMI is a bit of a weak method of measuring body fat though.

NerrSnerr · 11/09/2022 12:18

I am 5ft1 and a size 12-14 and my BMI is on the overweight/ obese borderline so in my case definitely overweight.

Ilovemycatalot · 11/09/2022 12:16

I’m definitely not in denial but it’s easy to look at others that are big and think well at least I’m not as big as them which still doesn’t mean your not big of course. I see more overweight women than slim where I live so it’s easy to see it as the norm. And definitely see more over weight women than men.

OP posts: