Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a size 14 viewed as overweight?

357 replies

Ilovemycatalot · 11/09/2022 10:31

Just reading online that uk size 16 is the average size of a uk woman right now. Im a size 14 and 5ft 3 so always felt overweight anyway but in reality would you view someone as a size 14 overweight? For me anyone who can fit into a size 10 would be considered slim although I know clothes sizes come up different depending on shop. Just curious what dress size people on here buy and if they consider themselves overweight.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Caroffee · 18/09/2022 23:20

5ft 5in, one stone overweight, BMI around 27 which is overweight and wear size 14 in almost everything.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 18/09/2022 22:52

ReneBumsWombats · 18/09/2022 22:44

People like to say we've lost sight of a healthy weight these days, but the 90s were all about being absolutely pin thin...heroin chic, waif look. You were literally supposed to look like you were on drugs. It may have given us a warped view then of what fatness was.

We've got fatter, of course. No question. But the 90s were a fucking awful time for healthy weights too.

I agree. Just check out Monica from Friends in the early episodes (1994/1995.) She must have had a 22 inch waist and weighed about 7 stone. She was not slim, she was thin, very thin. Too thin. Loads of women in the late 1980s and in the 1990s were very VERY thin with teeny tiny waists. Like a 10 year old girl's waist. When you look back now, some of them looked ill and gaunt. Women pre 1980s were slim and had smallish waists, but they looked normal, and looked good. As you said, the late 1980s and the 1990s was a breeding ground for being as super skinny as possible.

Girls/young women these days have much healthier bodies, not so uber skinny, and with more muscle mass. My DD is 5 ft 8 and is 10 stone 9. Not an ounce of fat on her. She is toned and trim, but not skinny. She has a decent sized booty, average sized thighs, and slightly bigger than average boobs, and a 28 inch waist. She looks amazing, and looks good in everything she wears.

ReneBumsWombats · 18/09/2022 22:44

People like to say we've lost sight of a healthy weight these days, but the 90s were all about being absolutely pin thin...heroin chic, waif look. You were literally supposed to look like you were on drugs. It may have given us a warped view then of what fatness was.

We've got fatter, of course. No question. But the 90s were a fucking awful time for healthy weights too.

Underroad · 18/09/2022 21:48

I have noticed how people are bigger these days recently. I used to know a girl many years ago who was cast in a tv programme in the late 90s. I remember her as being a big girl - not morbidly obese, but she was big. I watched this programme again recently for the first time since it first aired and was shocked at how slim she was. She looks about an average size for these days - maybe a 12 or perhaps a 14 at a push. She doesn’t look big to me at all. But I very clearly remember that she was when she filmed the programme. All I can think is that people have got larger in general so she doesn’t stand out now. Clothing sizes are also bigger these days (I know this from experience as I remember wearing a size 12 in the 90s but my size 10-12 self can’t even get my old clothes from them over my thighs now and haven’t been able to for 20 years).

ReneBumsWombats · 18/09/2022 19:15

Kennykenkencat · 18/09/2022 19:12

I think people refer back to the argument that we have got taller so we have got heavier and reference the height and weight of people 2 centuries ago.

I agree we have got taller and heavier but it is the amount of weight we have put on in the last 42 years compared to the new average height that I think we need to wake up to.

The average height of a U.K. woman has only gone up 1” since 1980

However the average weight in 1980 was 10st and to day stands at 11stone 2lbs

16lbs heavier for being 1” taller

I think that is why a size 14 is the equivalent to a size 10 in the 80s

We have definitely got fatter, no question. So sizing has normalised to the mean, just like chairs and cars and doorways. It's not because clothes manufacturers are trying to flatter us. It's just practical. If sizing didn't adapt as we get bigger, clothes wouldn't fit and companies would go out of business.

It's size inflation, not vanity sizing.

Kennykenkencat · 18/09/2022 19:14

Wrong way round

I think that is why a size 10 now is the equivalent to a size 14 in the 80s

Kennykenkencat · 18/09/2022 19:12

I think people refer back to the argument that we have got taller so we have got heavier and reference the height and weight of people 2 centuries ago.

I agree we have got taller and heavier but it is the amount of weight we have put on in the last 42 years compared to the new average height that I think we need to wake up to.

The average height of a U.K. woman has only gone up 1” since 1980

However the average weight in 1980 was 10st and to day stands at 11stone 2lbs

16lbs heavier for being 1” taller

I think that is why a size 14 is the equivalent to a size 10 in the 80s

Crunchingleaf · 14/09/2022 20:04

It hugely depends on your height and probably where you carry weight. I am 5ft5 and when I have been a size 14 and I was overweight at that size.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/09/2022 19:58

If dress sizes really were uniform across all manufacturers, it would be even harder to find a good fit. It might even be impossible.

As it is, shops profile their customers, so if you're the target market for Shop X, there's a good chance they can fit you. If you have some difficult sizing feature like a large bust, small waist, long legs or whatever, you've got a better chance of finding your fit if you know which shops cater for you. If everywhere were completely uniform, nowhere would cater for your specifics.

I share everyone's frustration as I have a hard shape to dress as well, but it just isn't realistic to expect to be able to walk into any old high street shop, pluck any mass produced item off the peg and expect it to fit you specifically. You may complain that, say, not everyone with wide hips has a large waist and you'd be right, but overall, if one body part is larger, the rest are likely to be larger too. It's just statistics.

My advice is to learn which shops suit you, prioritise quality over quantity and befriend a local dressmaker for alterations and commissions. Even made to measure stuff doesn't have to be madly expensive and if it fits you perfectly and will last ten years, it's worth it.

OldAndTubby · 14/09/2022 16:57

2 years ago I weighed 12 stone and was a size 14. According to the weight charts I was overweight.

I'm now 10 stone and also a size 14 (that's another thread and I'm quite frustrated!!) But now the weight charts put me right in the middle of the healthy weight range.

So basically, a.size 14 can mean you are overweight, yes. But it can also mean you are a healthy weight!

Best way to know is to weigh yourself and look your weight up on the weight charts for your height and age

Jets121 · 14/09/2022 16:56

It’s so personal

I’m 5”7 and really really unhappy with how I look above a size 10. Ideally I’d like to be an 8 again.

But that’s how I feel about my body. I am not judging or commenting on other women.

jennakong · 14/09/2022 16:54

I bought a hoodie the other day (Elle Sport) and although it fits me fine around the middle etc, the sleeves are too tight to roll up. I washed some dishes and had to change because my cuffs got wet. I am well used to ridiculous women's clothing with sewn-up pockets etc, but that was a new one on me.

FinallyHere · 14/09/2022 16:20

Dress sizing should be the same no matter how tall or short you are and all stores should conform to the same standard sizing

This would be perfect, if ... people came in a standard shape and size.

Fatballs · 14/09/2022 10:05

When you look in the mens clothing section their sizing is based on actual sizes

Men’s clothes sizes aren’t infallible. My husband often moans that clothes makers assume that all tall men all have massive stomachs.

Wanderingowl · 14/09/2022 10:02

Kennykenkencat · 14/09/2022 09:07

It doesn’t matter whether MM had a dressmaker or not. The measurements you quoted would have made her a size 14. She was just top heavy
Her Bust at 37” was a U.K. size 14
Her waist at 22” was a U.K. size 10
and hips at 36” was a UK size 12

I have seen the dresses. she wore and at the time I thought the clothing was quite big as I was 32” 18” 35”
Try getting clothes to fit those measurements without a dressmaker when the smallest waist size was a size 10 22” waist

Dress size is based on waist not hips or bust. A 22-23 inch waist would have been, from the 90s up until a decade or so ago, a UK4-6 or a US 0-2. With current flatter sizing, I wear a UK 4-6 and have a 24-25 inch waist. Obviously, with a 39 inch bust and hips, I can't wear every single dress or top in a UK6, some won't go over my hips or totally squash my breasts but I still find plenty of clothing with the right material and cut to fit my shape properly. Women's clothing tends to default to an hourglass shape, so it's perfectly possible to find dresses that fit my waist properly but also go easily around my hips and bust without looking over stretched. There are plenty of disappointments and there are some brands that I love but know from experience will never fit my shape, but that's true for everyone, as not everything can fit every body.

Tbh, the main area that I find it hardest to get clothing to fit is skinny jeans on my calves or capped sleeved tops on my shoulders as I'm naturally broad with a lot of muscle and women's clothing isn't designed for muscularity. The second is in height as I'm very short. But even with my bust and hips, I can get away with wearing bigger children's clothes quite a bit, so I'll sometimes go for kids' clothes for height. As a short, muscular, hourglass anything I wear that doesn't fit my waist makes me look utterly ridiculous. By your logic I'd be wearing a UK 16 and even when I was literally tipped into obesity, I never wore anything bigger than a UK12.

thewalrus · 14/09/2022 09:57

I'm 5ft, generally a size 10, an 8 in some shops, narrow shoulders, little hands and feet - towards the top of the ideal BMI range for my height. I'd definitely be very overweight as a size 14, but also know plenty of people who are a 14 and I'd guess aren't overweight. I think height and build have a lot to do with it. Also muscle. I'm 5kg heavier since I started strength training, but still the same clothes size.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/09/2022 09:57

Also can someone explain why a longer length pair of trousers means that you have a longer bum and the same length legs.

That's the more common shape.

That's the trouble with mass produced clothing. There's a lot of variation in shapes, even within the same size. You can't just pick up a size X anywhere and expect it to fit as if tailored for you.

Shops profile their customers and try to get the best fit for their average buyer. Teenage girls tend to be slimmer than middle aged women, so a size 10 in a teenage store will be smaller than Bon Marche or whatever. What people call vanity sizing is really just manufacturers adapting to larger people. Cars and seats and beds have got bigger too. Are we supposed to be using the same dress patterns that people used in 1850?

Kennykenkencat · 14/09/2022 09:53

knitnerd90 · 12/09/2022 01:00

Dress sizes really are next to useless as they vary so much and people carry weight differently. I'm 5'9". Normal BMI correlates to about 9-14st. That's a massive range! At a size 14 I'd be fine. I think people are overestimating just how large a UK 14 is especially if someone is tall. It's about proportions. Someone 5' with a 30" waist is going to look much heavier than someone who is 5'10" with the same waist measurement.

Dress sizing should be the same no matter how tall or short you are and all stores should conform to the same standard sizing

A 24” waist is the same for someone who happens to be 6ft 1” or 5ft 1”

Whether you are top heavy, an apple or have bigger hips. You choose the clothing on the design.

When you look in the mens clothing section their sizing is based on actual sizes. 34” waist 31” leg or jackets size 38” means that if you have a 38” chest it should fit you. If you are shorter or taller, have longer arms and body then the sizing letter should give you an indication of which jacket to pick

Imagine if you were shopping for a pair of trousers for a guy and he measured as 36” waist 34” leg but the size you needed to look for was 32” waist 38” leg but then in other stores it is 30” waist 36” leg.

There used to be a somewhat standard size in womens clothing which ever shop you were in. Now who knows what size I am supposed to be. I don’t have time to play the guess what size you are today game.

Also can someone explain why a longer length pair of trousers means that you have a longer bum and the same length legs.

Just because you are tall doesn’t mean you have the same length legs as everyone else but your waist to crotch measurement just gets longer.
Shopping with Dd she can only find the longer length leg without the enormous bum length in the childrens department.

BaileySharp · 14/09/2022 09:29

14 on most people I would think of as a little overweight yes (I'm 14-16, I am definitely overweight)

NovaDeltas · 14/09/2022 09:21

5 foot 2, size 6 to 8. So, no. 14 on me would be enormous. My mum's a 14/16 and my height and she's having health troubles now. If we were 6 foot 5 we could probably be size 10 or 12 and be slim, but at a short height, no.

Kennykenkencat · 14/09/2022 09:07

deedledeedledum · 12/09/2022 11:52

@Kennykenkencat sorry I'm having a slow morning but I'm not understanding your reply to my post. Marilyn had a buzzard figure. Her dressmaker notes showed she fluctuated a little and was geverslly 35-37 bust
22-23 waist
35-36 hips
5'1"
36D
Whatever size she wore would not be reflective of many other women who wore that size. She has a very extreme hourglass shape!!!! If you get a chance to see any of her clothes in an exhibition, it's so interesting. Her waist was minuscule but she had a modern day size bust. Very unique! Everything would have had to have been tailored to fit her so she wasn't really any size

It doesn’t matter whether MM had a dressmaker or not. The measurements you quoted would have made her a size 14. She was just top heavy
Her Bust at 37” was a U.K. size 14
Her waist at 22” was a U.K. size 10
and hips at 36” was a UK size 12

I have seen the dresses. she wore and at the time I thought the clothing was quite big as I was 32” 18” 35”
Try getting clothes to fit those measurements without a dressmaker when the smallest waist size was a size 10 22” waist

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/09/2022 08:22

IamnotSethRogan · 13/09/2022 13:16

I don't even know if it is true if you're taller you can carry more weight off. I'm quite tall and already feel massive and gangly. When I carry extra weight it doesn't feel like there's anywhere to hide if you know what I mean.

Of course it is. If you are 5ft and weigh 60kg you are overweight. If you are 6ft anf weight 60kg you are underweight. Similar for clothes sizes, if you body is proportionally smaller because you are small then you will need to carry more weight to need the same clothes size someone naturally and proportionately bigger does.

It doesn't mean that tall people necessarily carry excess weight better.

UniBallEye · 13/09/2022 13:18

Yes. I am 5ft 9" & size 14. I weight 12 stone 12oz & I am overweight.

IamnotSethRogan · 13/09/2022 13:16

I don't even know if it is true if you're taller you can carry more weight off. I'm quite tall and already feel massive and gangly. When I carry extra weight it doesn't feel like there's anywhere to hide if you know what I mean.