Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not explain death of Queen to 4 year old?

230 replies

Schooldaysagain · 11/09/2022 08:51

I've managed to avoid explaining death to my 4 year old so far. We lost FIL during the pandemic and he believes his beloved grandfather moved far away and still sends him presents and emails (which I read out from my phone)
😔

OP posts:
FourChimneys · 11/09/2022 11:19

I don't believe in heaven or any sort of afterlife. When my MIL died we told our young DC that she was turning into special compost and would be helping the trees to grow (woodland burial). They were happy with that.

NiceCupOfTea2 · 11/09/2022 11:15

Are you being serious here, you are pretending someone is still alive? That's bizarre and slightly disturbing. My children go to a Catholic school so even though we don't really believe ourselves we just use heaven as part of the explanation. When someone dies they know they are gone forever at least from earth, they've known this from a very young age. We told them you mainly die when you are very old (so they aren't worried they will any moment) but my husband has a gran alive in her 90s and they can be quite blunt saying "is she going to die soon" my 4 year old asked if she'd died yet yesterday, I said no (hoping he wasn't a weird psychic). Being mostly honest is the best thing, not to the point you frighten them, but death is as much a part of life as birth, happens to everyone one day.

Cw112 · 11/09/2022 11:15

It's really important that children are taught in age appropriate ways how to cope with and understand death as a natural part of life. It helps build their resilience when it happens. I think you've got a good opportunity here to have a natural opener that doesn't directly impact your close family so I'd take it. Get some books from the library to read together and allow time for questions. At 4 don't use ambiguous or vague terms like passed away or gone be honest about being dead meaning you aren't alive anymore. If they ask questions you aren't sure how to answer say that's a really good question why don't we try to find out together. Coco is a really lovely movie to watch together because it's all about losing relatives but them staying close by in our memories and from our love for them. It sounds a little like you find the topic daunting to broach (which most people do you're not alone in that) but it really is best not avoided. Having pets also helps young ones understand loss, grief and resilience

Mischance · 11/09/2022 11:10

I am hoping that you have got the message now and that my input is superfluous.

You have done a very wrong thing lying to your son about his grandfather - that is beyond immoral and defies belief. Sort it out now.

My OH died a couple of years ago and all my GC, even the smallest, were involved in all that went on - they saw him gradually getting more ill, they helped in his care - and marvelled at his catheter! And they saw him when he was dying - and wanted a photo taken with him - which we did. They were involved in the funeral and the wake. One of them makes little gifts to put on his grave - "Just going to take this down to Grandpa". They are far from being traumatised by it - they have experienced their own grief, and seen mine and been able to comfort me and their mums (his DDs). They have seen real life and death and know that people get through it.

My DGC now ask me when I am going to die! - they understand that it is nearer for me than them and take this in their stride.

ErrolTheDragon · 11/09/2022 11:08

Wow...
Read her some stories such as Badger's Parting Gifts and Goodbye Mog, pronto.
The former was in a nice children's anthology we had when DD was small, so she'd heard that story before the first family death (a great uncle she was fond of when she was three.) I read it to her again then, and she asked for it specifically a few more times.

She also knew that when goldfish die, they get buried in the garden and their atoms end up as part of the honeysuckle and roses.

FourChimneys · 11/09/2022 11:07

Pinkflipflop85 That's dreadful. Why on earth shouldn't children know that meat is dead animals. Mine have always been vegetarian but knew all about meat. I remember being in a busy cafe when DS was four or five. He looked at the plate of the man on the next table and very politely asked "Is that dead cow or dead pig?" Not one of his finest moments!

OP, someone has suggested Mog as a good book. Badger's Parting Gifts is another one. I think it's still in print, we bought it when our DC were small.

YourLipsMyLipsApocalypse · 11/09/2022 11:01

LampLighter414 · 11/09/2022 08:54

You must tell your DD about the Queen. The nation is mourning and so should all in your household.

Wowza 😆

Noteverybodylives · 11/09/2022 10:59

Wow what a lot of religious people - do you really believe in heaven or have you just swapped one lie for another?

A bit if both.

I don’t know what happens after death but I’m not religious.

However, explaining to a child how your body decomposes and once your dead, you’re dead and you can never speak to your parents again, is much harder for a child to process.

Even as an adult I have to tell myself that if my child or even my dog dies, that I will see them again or that they’d be watching over me.

My friends baby was recently killed by his dad. His brother only knows that he died and doesn’t know the ins and outs because it’s hard enough to deal with his brother dying.
They often visit the grave and talk to him and leave presents etc.

Many cultures believe in the afterlife and I would never judge someone who finds a way to cope with death.

LizzieW1969 · 11/09/2022 10:58

crossstitchingnana · 11/09/2022 09:46

IMO it's not a good idea to say someone has "gone to heaven" as they may infer they can come back. It's part of life and it's normal to feel sad, confused etc. Shielding them from life just fucks them up.

My mum told me our cat had gone to live on a farm, I was really upset when I learned it had been put down.

I made this mistake when my DCat died. She’d moved to my DM’s house when very poorly, as she was very stressed around my DD1 (then aged two and a half). A few days later, I had to make the very sad decision to have her PTS, on the vet’s advice.

I let my DD think DCat was still at her Granny’s house and then avoided talking about what had happened. But obviously, we couldn’t go on pretending that she was still there, but I still couldn’t bring myself to tell her the truth.

I was then really surprised, and very relieved, when DD1 asked straight out whether DCat was dead. I guess she must have heard us talking about it. It certainly taught me an important lesson about being honest with her.

Your DS might already have heard you talking about his Grandad to other people. Or he’ll hear the truth from another family member, who assumes that he already knows.

Or if he hasn’t yet, he will do at some point, probably sooner rather than later. He really should hear the truth from you directly.

I wouldn’t worry too much about the Queen’s death, he’s going to find out anyway whether you tell him or not. Especially as we now have a King who has taken over from her! And he won’t think too much about that.

slashlover · 11/09/2022 10:57

Not only is it bad to not tell your DS, it was downright cruel to your husband to made him pretend his dad was still alive.

SnoozyLucy7 · 11/09/2022 10:52

I don’t think your 4 year really cares and I really wouldn’t make a big deal of it.

daisychain01 · 11/09/2022 10:51

Bpdqueen · 11/09/2022 09:49

This is why films like bambi and finding nemo exist, kids need to learn young about death as it's a part of life that they can't be shielded from.

OMG not Bambi - that's a brutal way to teach a child about death. Typical bloody Disney, didn't have the foggiest.

Choconut · 11/09/2022 10:50

Wow what a lot of religious people - do you really believe in heaven or have you just swapped one lie for another?

Just tell him that the queen got very, very old and she died. That means she's not alive any more and so no one can see her anymore - but they can remember her in lots of lovely ways.

You told him that his grandfather moved far away and you read out emails from him. Then when everyone says this is terrible you change your story to not pretending he was alive and only getting presents the first year - sounds even more confusing for the poor child. Tell him the above about the queen and then tell him that he's now old enough to know that his GF died too and then talk about some nice things you can do to remember him. He died when he was 2, I doubt he'll even remember him so he is unlikely to be devastated by this news, he might just need reassurance that you're not going to die any time soon.

Noteverybodylives · 11/09/2022 10:47

YABVU

You could die today.
Any of his friends and family could die today.

We want to keep bad stuff from them but the truth is bad things do happen.

Tell him the truth that people die, if you act like it’s a completely normal thing (which it is) then he will be able to cope so much better when it happens to someone he loves.

I actually got my DD some fish for this exact reason.
When one died I would explain that things can die when they’re old or poorly and that they get to go to heaven and have a lovely time etc.
So we can feel sad because we miss them. But we don’t need to feel sad for them as they are in a happy place.

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 11/09/2022 10:47

Death is one of the only certainties of life. You are doing your child no favours shielding him from it. My 5 year old knows about death etc.... it should not be a taboo subject.

MyEasterEggs · 11/09/2022 10:44

There’s a lovely book called Lifetimes, which I used to talk about death with my little one when she was a similar age.

She was 1.5 when her baby brother died during pregnancy and at the time we gently explained that there was no baby in mummy’s tummy anymore and since then we’ve taken her to butterfly releases, grown flowers in his memory and we do something to mark his birthday.

My daughter is almost 8 now and is quite matter of fact about it all. She understands that death is a part of life and will ask about how he died and where he is. As she’s grown older the questions and conversations have become more detailed and I just answer honestly, in a child-friendly way. You can tell the truth without revealing everything or sharing upsetting details.

I don’t think pretending his grandfather is far away is very healthy as it leaves room for wondering why he’s not coming back if he’s alive, or why he’s left people behind. I say that with total compassion having lost my dad as a child and known he was dead and would therefore never come back. It must’ve been the hardest thing in the world for my mum to tell us he was gone but it was totally the best thing for us.

Is this a chance to explain the queen’s death and perhaps talk about his grandad since he’s old enough to understand a bit better now?

Hbh17 · 11/09/2022 10:42

Apparently, the death of The Queen had been explained to her great-grandson, Prince Louis. He is 4 years old.
A child needs the people around them to be honest, and also to know that death is absolutely not something to be scared of.

Snowiscold · 11/09/2022 10:42

I would assume the school will already have talked to pupils about the Queen’s death.

Pinkflipflop85 · 11/09/2022 10:41

maddiemookins16mum · 11/09/2022 10:36

This is exactly why we have a generation of some children with poor life/coping skills, they are protected from everything by over anxious (usually quite young) parents.

Quite.

I've received complaints recently after teaching a science lesson about living, dead and never alive.

Apparently I was out of order for telling year 2 children that meat came from an animal that was once alive...

Onandgrowing · 11/09/2022 10:39

I really really really hope this isn’t true, because you are actively harming your 4yo by not telling them the truth about your FIL in an age appropriate way.

giveovernate · 11/09/2022 10:38

Reminds me of a work colleague who told their 7 year old son that the dog had gone to sleep and was sleep elsewhere! Totally ridiculous.

How is this child ever going to process death? And agree with PP, you sand presents and emails plural, that you read to him. That's so confusing for him! When are you going to stop and tell him he's no longer going to get presents and emails.

JaninaDuszejko · 11/09/2022 10:38

My Dad died when DD1 was 3. Didn't go to the service or graveyard but was at the reception afterwards. She spoke a lot about death after that as she processed it. DS was 4 when FIL died. Catholic funeral so all the DC were at the service and graveyard. I (not catholic) was very unsure about taking such young children to a funeral but it was really good and helped them process FIL's death (FIL was in his 80s so had lived a long and happy life), DD1 was 9 and MIL had her sit in the front row next to her, she felt very grown up being the one holding her granny's hand.

Death is part of the cycle of life and the death of an old person who has lived a full life is not a challenging concept for a child.

PenYGore · 11/09/2022 10:37

Neolara · 11/09/2022 08:57

I would say the queen has died. This happened because she was very, very old. Being dead means that her body stops working. She can't move or eat or drink or think. When people die it's forever - their body won't start working again. Some people will feel sad that the queen has died because she was important person in their lives.

This is sensible.

As for the grandfather thing... oh dear. This is wrong on so many levels.

If you find it impossible to talk about death, OP, there are some good books aimed at young children (one of them is the final "Mog" book, in which Mog dies - there will be loads of others, but my children are now adults and it's a long time ago). Books can often help you talk to children about things that you can't talk about yourself. But please don't let your child think his grandfather is still alive.

I wouldn't mention Heaven unless you actually believe in it. Both of my much loved grandmothers died when my DC were small. I said I was sad because they had died and I would not see them again. I said they died because they were very, very old (bear in mind anyone over the age of about 20 is old to a toddler, though my grandmothers were in their 80s/90s) and their bodies stopped working because they were old and worn out. I said I was sad now, but I would stop being sad. Fortunately having toddlers takes your mind off being sad for too long.

maddiemookins16mum · 11/09/2022 10:36

This is exactly why we have a generation of some children with poor life/coping skills, they are protected from everything by over anxious (usually quite young) parents.

flyingant · 11/09/2022 10:34

I should clarify that the presents and message was just the Christmas immediately after his death.

@Schooldaysagain Oh, come on, you're completely backpedalling. You clearly said in your OP that he still sends him presents and emails. I hope you're seeing the error of your ways and will take advice from this thread.