Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not explain death of Queen to 4 year old?

230 replies

Schooldaysagain · 11/09/2022 08:51

I've managed to avoid explaining death to my 4 year old so far. We lost FIL during the pandemic and he believes his beloved grandfather moved far away and still sends him presents and emails (which I read out from my phone)
😔

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
milkyaqua · 12/09/2022 02:29

but I haven't continued a lie that he's still alive! Sorry if I gave that impression.

Indeed, you have.

he believes his beloved grandfather moved far away and still sends him presents and emails (which I read out from my phone)

Dinoteeth · 12/09/2022 00:56

@DayOfTheTentacle I'm so sorry for your losses, that is heartbreaking, 💐

stormywhethers321 · 12/09/2022 00:49

You have been telling a very serious lie to your child for two years. You really need to stop this.

Children will feel sad sometimes. They will have to cope with death. This is an inevitable part of life. What is NOT an inevitable part of life is feeling utterly betrayed by your parents. If you continue this deception for much longer, by the time he finds out the truth he's going to start to wonder what else you've been lying about. He'll start to wonder if he can trust you at all.

And he WILL find out the truth. An overheard conversation, a cousin or uncle or aunt, even googling family members out of boredom when he gets a bit older. You can't keep this a secret forever.

I don't particularly care about the queen one way or another but his own actual grandfather? That he needs to know about.

giveovernate · 11/09/2022 23:20

surreygirl1987 · 11/09/2022 21:07

I think YABU with the grandfather thing.

But as for the Queen... I'm kind of with you, but I don't know if I'm wrong to be. My son turns 4 in a few weeks and I just told him the Queen was very poorly and wasn't going to get better, so now we have a new king. Then he came home from nursery wearing a cardboard crown and said he made it because the Queen died. He said it very matter of factly. Then today he told me the sunflowers outside had died. I guess he knows about death from nursery and doesn't seem overly troubled by it...

Thank fuck for nursery then!

porkmarkets · 11/09/2022 21:13

Helenloveslee4eva · 11/09/2022 14:28

If this is for real honestly you are missing a brilliant opportunity to face up to death in a remote way before you actually really have people she knows and lives dying

Yeah I've used it as a learning opportunity. We had gently started with flowers and bugs and talking about departed family members. He's 5 and he has many questions about it...he's giving it a lot of thought. He doesn't understand the permanence of death but that will come with time.

surreygirl1987 · 11/09/2022 21:08

I started explaining to my ds (at the toddler stage) about death by using a flower as a comparison. See, this flower is alive, but this flower has ‘withered’…couldn’t bring myself to use the word died yet. Then when the leaves began to fall I’d say, oh look at that leaf, it withered, it died. Then I’d keep giving just a little more information every time. You absolutely must tell him his grandfather died, make it seem as it only just happened. I’d tell him about the Queen and his grandfather at the same time.

I really like the lesson with the flowers. Good idea!

surreygirl1987 · 11/09/2022 21:07

I think YABU with the grandfather thing.

But as for the Queen... I'm kind of with you, but I don't know if I'm wrong to be. My son turns 4 in a few weeks and I just told him the Queen was very poorly and wasn't going to get better, so now we have a new king. Then he came home from nursery wearing a cardboard crown and said he made it because the Queen died. He said it very matter of factly. Then today he told me the sunflowers outside had died. I guess he knows about death from nursery and doesn't seem overly troubled by it...

WhereshouldIgo · 11/09/2022 20:37

thats WEIRD re FIL - how is your child
goinf to build up any resilience for life??
better your 4 year vaguely understands death with the loss of a woman he doesn’t know than wait until someone he does know dies and you can’t cover it up…

Bretonbear · 11/09/2022 20:34

LampLighter414 · 11/09/2022 08:54

You must tell your DD about the Queen. The nation is mourning and so should all in your household.

😂😂😂😂😂

CMZ2018 · 11/09/2022 20:31

Fucking hell no wonder everyone is soft as shite these days

TowerRavenSeven · 11/09/2022 20:25

I started explaining to my ds (at the toddler stage) about death by using a flower as a comparison. See, this flower is alive, but this flower has ‘withered’…couldn’t bring myself to use the word died yet. Then when the leaves began to fall I’d say, oh look at that leaf, it withered, it died. Then I’d keep giving just a little more information every time. You absolutely must tell him his grandfather died, make it seem as it only just happened. I’d tell him about the Queen and his grandfather at the same time.

ShesThunderstorms · 11/09/2022 20:13

Is your 4 year old a big fan of the queen?

Recycledblonde · 11/09/2022 19:43

www.childbereavementuk.org/telling-a-child-that-someone-has-died

This is a really helpful website about explaining death to a very young child. It is enormously important to be honest with them otherwise you store up problems for the future. They really deserve to know the truth.

clpsmum · 11/09/2022 19:37

Schooldaysagain · 11/09/2022 08:51

I've managed to avoid explaining death to my 4 year old so far. We lost FIL during the pandemic and he believes his beloved grandfather moved far away and still sends him presents and emails (which I read out from my phone)
😔

Why would you lie like that? That's awful

Heyheyitsanotherday · 11/09/2022 19:35

Oh dear. I agree with pp, children need to learn about death. Unfortunately it is part of life and by lying about it it actually makes it worse. Kids are more resilient than we give them credit. But it’s so important that they learn about death and how it’s normal to feel sad and let them show their emotions.

my dd was 3 when my dad died. She came to visit him everyday until the day of his death. And we explained to her that he’d gone forever but would watch over us. She was incredibly close to him but now she’s happy grandpa is watching over us and looking after our dead pets 🙈 she often says she misses grandpa and it makes her sad. I agree with her and tell her im sad too. We can’t protect them from death. It’s the one thing we have no control over when or how it happens.

Mischance · 11/09/2022 19:05

My GC knew when my OH died that he was not coming back. They also knew how ill he was so grasping that his body had stopped working properly was not hard. In a child appropriate way I used the law of conservation of matter to talk about how we are all made up of stardust and that his has gone back to the heavens and the earth. I also talked about the fact that in a way he would never die because we all have the love he gave us which will go on forever as we will pass it on to those around us in the way we behave.

BertieBotts · 11/09/2022 18:14

toomuchlaundry · 11/09/2022 14:16

@BertieBotts is your DC either at school or nursery? I am sure it will have been mentioned there last week

Not here as we don't live in the UK. I'm sure if we did he probably would have known who she was from the jubilee celebrations.

agriefobserved · 11/09/2022 18:08

I've been trying to explain death to my 2yo but she's not really taking it in. I did manage to make her say "The Queen died yesterday". I was proud.

PepsiMaxandPringleStacks · 11/09/2022 18:07

Why would you gaslight your child like that 😶

DayOfTheTentacle · 11/09/2022 18:04

Wow what a lot of religious people - do you really believe in heaven or have you just swapped one lie for another?

Yes I believe in a heaven/afterlife. I'm religious and we attend church.

When my DS2 died shortly after birth, wr explained it to DS1, (then nearly 4) that baby brother had died, his body was very poorly and his heart stopped beating. His body on earth had a funeral and then got sent to be made into stardust, ashes, he was cremated, which we got back.

He's nearly 6 now and understands about burial and cremation and it's how you get rid of somebody's body. I work in funerals so he hears a lot about death, and obviously the crucifixion is mentioned a lot at Easter. He's also had two dogs, my MIL and his baby sister die since then.

He knows that stars are balls of burning gas and rock, he's looking at a science book of the universe as I type. But also likes to say that they're windows from heaven where baby brother can wave to him from.

ScruffGin · 11/09/2022 15:15

You need to explain this to him... My 4 year old has had a great grandad die, a dog and a few chickens... She's fine with it. Understanding death is part of life, I think you're being very unfair, it'll become a very big thing when he gets older and doesn't understand

purpleme12 · 11/09/2022 14:36

I can't understand people who think this way
My child has also always known about death.
When we were passing insects on the ground for example, just in life really. Why wouldn't you just say the truth. It sounds like OP has said he's moved away, not he's died so it's sounds like she has lied
Can't understand it

Helenloveslee4eva · 11/09/2022 14:28

If this is for real honestly you are missing a brilliant opportunity to face up to death in a remote way before you actually really have people she knows and lives dying

TurquoiseDress · 11/09/2022 14:26

YABU

You'll never get the death of the Queen to fly under the radar of your 4 yr old!

Wall to wall coverage on TV, newspapers & magazines

Presumably they are at school they will definitely hear about it there

It's normal to be curious & ask questions about death at this age

My DC was obsessed with death shortly after starting reception, asking so many questions including when would me & DH die

This is normal 4 year old stuff

As for the grandfather story, that's just very strange & not helpful for your DC

toomuchlaundry · 11/09/2022 14:16

@BertieBotts is your DC either at school or nursery? I am sure it will have been mentioned there last week

Swipe left for the next trending thread