Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL wants me to apologise to her DD

441 replies

cheathimsilly · 11/09/2022 07:22

I took her DD to a film whilst my DS was at school. It was a baby friendly showing, to be specific here. My own (baby) DD came along

I bought sweets along but she wanted popcorn and I fancied some too, so we got a large popcorn and a drink to share

Within 15 minutes of the show starting, she said she was scared. I said it's fine, there's a lot of funny stuff. Sit tight and enjoy her treats etc

She said again 5 minutes later, I don't like it, I'm scared. I said please will you just give it a try? Low and behold, 5 minutes later she's giggling at some of the film and fine for the rest of it

Then the credits came up, and she said she was terrified! I said what of? She said the screens gone black

My niece is 7.

OP posts:
Howardsbend · 11/09/2022 12:00

I'm not sure we can know that these moments were minor sofa . You are up a tree thinking that inconvenient fear goes away if you ignore and repress it. The fact that you think a response equates to making a fuss says it all.

Perhaps she should apologise to the OP for being such a drama queen, as well as a snitch.

A snitch? She's seven. She needs to have an open line of communication to her mother. Is she supposed to know it's right to tell her mother if someone has touched her inappropriately? If so, then there is no such thing as snitching about an adult's behaviour. There are no little secrets. How depressing to think there are people walking around like this. Your username is apt.

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 11/09/2022 11:56

Twillow · 11/09/2022 11:46

Well, yes! Not to make a point about being in charge, but clearly the adult is in charge and makes the decisions. And given that the OP felt the child would be ok and has habit of being overly dramatic and that the child's mother had picked the film deliberately

I can’t relate to this attitude at all. If I took a child out somewhere I’d be hoping for more than them just surviving the experience. I’d like them to actually enjoy themselves. It’s not the dentist or a school lesson that she needs to get through. A trip to the cinema is supposed to be fun!

aSofaNearYou · 11/09/2022 11:51

If resilience these days means sitting through the dark crystal then we're all in trouble. People bandy that word around way too much. If you don't like a film, then you don't like it, end of. Boundaries are healthy and it's great the niece spoke up a few times to try to protect hers. It has nothing to do with resilience. I'd have watched Nightmare on Elm Street at barely over 7 - but resilient isn't exactly the word I'd have used to describe myself - maybe someone with poor parental supervision and questionable film voices, but not resilient

My point was clearly wider than just watching the dark crystal. It's about the fuss level made over minor moments of fear.

Aubriella · 11/09/2022 11:49

SIL has shot herself in the foot, behaving like this about a film she had vetted and approved.

OP is unlikely to want to take niece anywhere again.

mustbetheseasonofthebitch · 11/09/2022 11:47

I think the child has been indulged quite enough already. Perhaps she should apologise to the OP for being such a drama queen, as well as a snitch.

I would point out to her mother, who chose the film, and insisted it would be suitable for her daughter, that if her child is prone to being terrified by a black credits screeen, she really can't be taken to the cinema, or allowed to watch the television, ever again.

MelodyPondsMum · 11/09/2022 11:47

Even CommonSenseMedia parents and DCs say over 9 and considering most of their parent reviews are written by DCs trying to get to watch films that are too old for them, that means a general consensus that it's not appropriate for a 7 year old.

Twillow · 11/09/2022 11:46

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 11/09/2022 10:22

So you’d continue an activity that the child clearly wasn’t enjoying just to make the point that you’re in charge?!

Well, yes! Not to make a point about being in charge, but clearly the adult is in charge and makes the decisions. And given that the OP felt the child would be ok and has habit of being overly dramatic and that the child's mother had picked the film deliberately

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 11/09/2022 11:39

“I can't imagine apologising to a seven year old in these circumstances.”

@justmaybenot Why on earth not? If you upset someone, even unintentionally, you apologise. Their age has nothing to do with it.

Howardsbend · 11/09/2022 11:38

aSofaNearYou · Today 11:01

Maybe for your kid, not for everyone's 🤷‍♀️

Well, that's precisely the point.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 11/09/2022 11:35

If your SIL suggested the film, I actually think she's more to blame. Maybe she's feeling guilty, and it's easier for her to blame you than to take personal responsibility? A way to purge herself of guilt perhaps?
I actually feel a bit sorry for OP. It was kind of her to look after her niece, and she didn't mean any harm. It was an error of judgement, but nothing deliberate.

katepilar · 11/09/2022 11:34

SO you basically told a 7yo to shut up when she said she was scared. Thats not a good way to handle a child's fear.
In my world we do apologize to 1.5 yo if we accidentally scare them so I dont think your SIL in unreasonable . You would -I hope- apologise to any random adult if you scared them. It doesnt matter that you didnt mean to or dont understand why they got scared.

From your post it feels like its you wanted to go to the cinema.

justmaybenot · 11/09/2022 11:33

I can't imagine apologising to a seven year old in these circumstances. Your SIL should believe you when you say it wasn't clear that the DD was scared, but really I think it might have been better for you to tell the child to let you know if it was too much and you would leave if she found it too scary after x amount of time. We can't always rely on a 7-year old to be able to assert themselves without being invited to.

HailAdrian · 11/09/2022 11:26

The real drama llamas are the ones who are basically saying they're still traumatised over an 80s kids' film. I was terrified of ET as a kid, I'm not scarred for life though. 🙄

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 11/09/2022 11:23

“Dark crystal is pg so parental guidance to me in that case means watching the comfort levels of the child you're with and intervening as necessary.”

I think @Cw112 is spot on with this.

FacebookPhotos · 11/09/2022 11:22

I think lots of people talking about teaching resilience or pandering to fear making it worse are being ridiculous. If you are a parent you absolutely have to think about those things and make a judgement call. As an aunt if a child says they’re scared you believe them as ask them if they want to leave. Because as an aunt you don’t know the child as well as their parents do, so you are more likely to make the wrong call (as apparently happened here).

Even if she wasn’t scared but wanted to leave for some other reason it really isn’t the end of the world to go home early, and you want the child to enjoy their time with you. The money for the tickets etc had already been spent so the only reason to stay is if you fall victim to the sink costs fallacy.

OP, you make a mistake and should apologise. No need for drama, just next time you see her “I’m sorry I didn’t realise how scared you were, we should have left earlier. Are you feeling better now?”

girlmom21 · 11/09/2022 11:22

zingally · 11/09/2022 11:14

I might be inclined to phone and say "I'm sorry you were scared. You hadn't seemed that bothered during it, but hey ho, you ready for school tomorrow?" No point dwelling on it, it's done now.

And then you don't take her to the cinema again.

Odd choice of film though, gotta say.

She said before the film started she was scared. Don't gaslight a 7 year old.

Tigofigo · 11/09/2022 11:19

So many posters saying "never take your niece out again" - for being scared? WTAF? Why should you never take her out ever again for her mum being a bit of a CF? Overreaction much? I mean, maybe don't rush back to the cinema, but to never take her out again over this is spiteful and pathetic. Mind you, this is AIBU, I'm not surprised...

I think you probably should have taken her out, once she had mentioned being scared twice and you'd insisted she stayed she probably put on a brave face as felt asking you repeatedly was futile.

She certainly isn't BU for feeling scared. Maybe she's less scared with her mum because it's her mum and she feels safe with her.

I think SIL is a bit of a CF to ask you to apologise. Really, SHE should apologise to her daughter for suggesting the film... But equally an apology from you for not taking her out when she was scared wouldn't be amiss either.

Day20 · 11/09/2022 11:17

aSofaNearYou · 11/09/2022 11:01

Maybe for your kid, not for everyone's 🤷‍♀️

🤣🤣🤣🤣

Exactly you can't treat other people's kids like that because they are not yours.

zingally · 11/09/2022 11:14

I might be inclined to phone and say "I'm sorry you were scared. You hadn't seemed that bothered during it, but hey ho, you ready for school tomorrow?" No point dwelling on it, it's done now.

And then you don't take her to the cinema again.

Odd choice of film though, gotta say.

Softplayhooray · 11/09/2022 11:14

aSofaNearYou · 11/09/2022 11:01

Maybe for your kid, not for everyone's 🤷‍♀️

If resilience these days means sitting through the dark crystal then we're all in trouble. People bandy that word around way too much. If you don't like a film, then you don't like it, end of. Boundaries are healthy and it's great the niece spoke up a few times to try to protect hers. It has nothing to do with resilience. I'd have watched Nightmare on Elm Street at barely over 7 - but resilient isn't exactly the word I'd have used to describe myself - maybe someone with poor parental supervision and questionable film voices, but not resilient😂

fruitbrewhaha · 11/09/2022 11:10

I can still remember being scared watching the Dark Chrystal! They pulled his shell off, and were really mean. Goodness, bad choice of film

Softplayhooray · 11/09/2022 11:09

That would scare the crap out of one of my son's and he's older than her!!

Me, I'd watch anything at any age 😄. Every kid is different. I think it was wrong to have your niece specifically sit through it though, but I do love the dark crystal so can understand why you wanted to stay! It would have really upset my son to have to stay and I think she cried at the dark part of the credits because she was already scared, and cried to her mum as she'd been holding it in.

Cw112 · 11/09/2022 11:04

You're being very unreasonable imo. Can you imagine how out of control she felt when she told you multiple times she was afraid and you wouldn't take her out? Knowing she was too little to leave by herself? Probably wanting to please you and be polite as you'd taken her out? It doesn't really matter what the age of the child is or the age rating of the film the more I think about it, what matters is the child's comfort levels. She didn't need to find the entire film scary, certain parts were and that was enough. You made a mistake without bad intentions but you called it wrong and you do need to apologise. Dark crystal is pg so parental guidance to me in that case means watching the comfort levels of the child you're with and intervening as nessecary.

aSofaNearYou · 11/09/2022 11:01

Howardsbend · 11/09/2022 10:55

it's perfectly fine to be a bit scared and get through it now and then and will teach her resilience

Nice try but that's not how resilience works.

Maybe for your kid, not for everyone's 🤷‍♀️

Howardsbend · 11/09/2022 10:57

tryfly

It doesn't make a difference. She still took the child and should have been prepared to take her out. Does she have less responsibility to a frightened child because someone else chose the film? Don't be ridiculous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread