Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL wants me to apologise to her DD

441 replies

cheathimsilly · 11/09/2022 07:22

I took her DD to a film whilst my DS was at school. It was a baby friendly showing, to be specific here. My own (baby) DD came along

I bought sweets along but she wanted popcorn and I fancied some too, so we got a large popcorn and a drink to share

Within 15 minutes of the show starting, she said she was scared. I said it's fine, there's a lot of funny stuff. Sit tight and enjoy her treats etc

She said again 5 minutes later, I don't like it, I'm scared. I said please will you just give it a try? Low and behold, 5 minutes later she's giggling at some of the film and fine for the rest of it

Then the credits came up, and she said she was terrified! I said what of? She said the screens gone black

My niece is 7.

OP posts:
alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 17:49

@justmaybenot You really don’t need to justify yourself to me. I’m allowed to disagree in that I would take a slightly different approach in the situation you described. What you did worked for you so all good. 🙂

TheMoonisaBalloon · 12/09/2022 17:30

I can remember years ago going with my auntie, my brother, her 3 kids and 2 other cousins to see 101 Dalmatians.

One of my cousins got scared by Cruella de Ville and started crying. My auntie took her straight out and back home.

I was left in charge of all the other kids!

Connie2468 · 12/09/2022 17:30

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 17:22

“You seem to think making children watch something that upsets them is somehow beneficial or good for their development?”

@Connie2468 I don’t understand this either. Various people have stressed the importance of supporting kids to deal with their fears. I totally agree with this if we are talking about things that can’t be avoided or a skill that is important (such as swimming). I can’t see how it applies to this situation. Thrill seeking activities such as scary films, rollercoasters etc. are not everyone’s cup of tea. Plenty of adults avoid them yet still live a full life. I asked in a previous thread how making this child sit through a film she wasn’t enjoying benefitted her. Unsurprisingly, no one has answered that question. The only thing that has been mentioned is that leaving the cinema mid film is an inconvenience to others! So it seems it’s less about the needs of the individual child and more about getting her to conform to what those around her want.

(And before anyone starts, I realise that children will encounter situations where they need to compromise. I don’t think this was one of those situations.)

I'm an adult and I don't watch adult films that feature a lot of rape, gore or torture. It doesn't seem to have stunted my development that I don't want to watch the Saw movies despite them being aimed at adults and lots of adults enjoy them.

This whole argument seems to be about making children 'tough it out' or hide their feelings, it's weird parenting at best Confused

wellhelloitsme · 12/09/2022 17:29

Hiphophippityskip1 · 12/09/2022 16:06

Totally inappropriate for a sensitive 7 year old. You should apologise to both mother and daughter and pre agree what you are going to see next time

While I don't think OP handled the subsequent situation well, when it came to what they were viewing it was the girl's mum who picked it.

Connie2468 · 12/09/2022 17:26

Whoactuallythinksthat · 12/09/2022 14:36

I would absolutely agree with you if the movie in question were a 12, 15 or 18. But this is a movie aimed at kids. The vast majority of kids will be fine with it. Therefore, I’d say it’s entirely appropriate to help that child towards a behaviour that is age appropriate.

Jurassic Park is a PG film aimed at kids - should no children have found that too scary either?
What about Princess Bride? I saw that as a child and had nightmares about the torture scene.
Just because the majority of older children should be ok to watch a PG, doesn't mean younger or more sensitive children will be or that scaring or upsetting them is good for their development.

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 17:22

“You seem to think making children watch something that upsets them is somehow beneficial or good for their development?”

@Connie2468 I don’t understand this either. Various people have stressed the importance of supporting kids to deal with their fears. I totally agree with this if we are talking about things that can’t be avoided or a skill that is important (such as swimming). I can’t see how it applies to this situation. Thrill seeking activities such as scary films, rollercoasters etc. are not everyone’s cup of tea. Plenty of adults avoid them yet still live a full life. I asked in a previous thread how making this child sit through a film she wasn’t enjoying benefitted her. Unsurprisingly, no one has answered that question. The only thing that has been mentioned is that leaving the cinema mid film is an inconvenience to others! So it seems it’s less about the needs of the individual child and more about getting her to conform to what those around her want.

(And before anyone starts, I realise that children will encounter situations where they need to compromise. I don’t think this was one of those situations.)

justmaybenot · 12/09/2022 17:11

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 09:28

I’ve already quoted exactly what you said. You can deny it all you like but it’s there in black and white. The way you worded it initially sounded awful. Now that you’ve elaborated I understand where you’re coming from but still don’t agree entirely.

you can deny it all you like I clarified my statement to your liking so why the hell are you still going on about it?

There are absolutely no grounds for you to agree or disagree slightly or entirely as I am speaking from my personal experience about what worked when my children were that age and you're not in a position to judge whether it was or was not the right thing to do at that time for my children who are now well adjusted, empathetic and courageous in all kinds of ways.

FYI I've never forced them to do anything if they said they were too scared but - as with most parents - have assessed on a case by case basis and figured out what the issue is. Sometimes it has just needed reassurance, sometimes talking through, and sometimes they just really can't cope - for whatever reason. That's normal parenting I would have thought. It isn't always possible to know what will scare a child. The key thing is knowing your own child and understanding when their fear is a temporary wobble, or when it's more deep-seated.

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 16:47

Whoactuallythinksthat · 12/09/2022 14:36

I would absolutely agree with you if the movie in question were a 12, 15 or 18. But this is a movie aimed at kids. The vast majority of kids will be fine with it. Therefore, I’d say it’s entirely appropriate to help that child towards a behaviour that is age appropriate.

As has been stated multiple times, this film is a PG, not a U. Many people have described elements of it that are quite disturbing. Why are you so adamant that a 7 year old should be ok with it?!

PG stands for Parental Guidance. This means a film is suitable for general viewing, but some scenes may be unsuitable for younger children. A PG film should not disturb a child aged around eight or older. Parents should consider whether the content might upset younger or more sensitive children.

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 16:46

Whoactuallythinksthat · 12/09/2022 14:36

I would absolutely agree with you if the movie in question were a 12, 15 or 18. But this is a movie aimed at kids. The vast majority of kids will be fine with it. Therefore, I’d say it’s entirely appropriate to help that child towards a behaviour that is age appropriate.

As has been stated multiple times, this film is a PG, not a U. Many people have described elements of it that are quite disturbing. Why are you so adamant that a 7 year old should be ok with it?!

PG stands for Parental Guidance. This means a film is suitable for general viewing, but some scenes may be unsuitable for younger children. A PG film should not disturb a child aged around eight or older. Parents should consider whether the content might upset younger or more sensitive children.

HTH1 · 12/09/2022 16:16

As SIL told you to take her to see that film, YANBU. I wouldn’t apologise or take her out again though (at least to the cinema and, if you’re providing free childcare, that should be scaled right back).

Hiphophippityskip1 · 12/09/2022 16:06

Totally inappropriate for a sensitive 7 year old. You should apologise to both mother and daughter and pre agree what you are going to see next time

Peashoots · 12/09/2022 15:59

Whoactuallythinksthat · 12/09/2022 14:36

I would absolutely agree with you if the movie in question were a 12, 15 or 18. But this is a movie aimed at kids. The vast majority of kids will be fine with it. Therefore, I’d say it’s entirely appropriate to help that child towards a behaviour that is age appropriate.

Yep.
I can’t get over how many people on this thread are claiming they were “terrified” of a kids film 🫤

Whoactuallythinksthat · 12/09/2022 14:36

Connie2468 · 12/09/2022 13:50

That's a very odd way to see things.
Lots of people (adults and children) would stop watching a movie if they found it too scary or unpleasant.
You don't get a medal for sitting through something horrible.
Children especially often have nightmares after viewing something scary or inappropriate - and it might not always be something an adult would assume would upset them.
You seem to think making children watch something that upsets them is somehow beneficial or good for their development?

I would absolutely agree with you if the movie in question were a 12, 15 or 18. But this is a movie aimed at kids. The vast majority of kids will be fine with it. Therefore, I’d say it’s entirely appropriate to help that child towards a behaviour that is age appropriate.

Connie2468 · 12/09/2022 13:50

Whoactuallythinksthat · 12/09/2022 06:58

You’re actually correct in saying that being scared of a scary movie isn’t an inappropriate emotional reaction. Scary movies are intended to scare. The inappropriate reaction is not being able to cope with that and needing to leave.

That's a very odd way to see things.
Lots of people (adults and children) would stop watching a movie if they found it too scary or unpleasant.
You don't get a medal for sitting through something horrible.
Children especially often have nightmares after viewing something scary or inappropriate - and it might not always be something an adult would assume would upset them.
You seem to think making children watch something that upsets them is somehow beneficial or good for their development?

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 10:59

@Aubriella If a child is a little upset by a film it might be appropriate to take a break and try again if they want to. But if it has caused sobbing and hysteria would you not just leave it rather than risk them getting that distressed again? That’s what I disagree with. The level of upset that’s acceptable before you call it a day.

BackT · 12/09/2022 10:53

Jeez. I'm scared and creeped out by Dark Crystal.
Usually I'd be on your side but that film is seriously weird

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 10:49

Aubriella · 12/09/2022 10:36

She didn't say she would take a sobbing, hysterical child back into the film HmmSt twisting her words. She said

If one of my DCs had said they felt scared at the start of a film, then unless they were being completely hysterical I would also have asked them to wait a few minutes, and then if they seemed to be enjoying it would have thought they got over the fear. Nothing to apologise for!

That’s not the quote I’m talking about.

“If they were full-on sobbing and hysterical obviously I wouldn't force them to stay but I might take them out and have a chat and then try again. I'd think that's pretty normal parenting.”

Taking child back into the film that caused sobbing and hysteria after having a chat. I appreciate the child is no longer hysterical when they go back in and can see how my comment wasn’t clear on that point. My objection is that she is ok with returning them to the source of such stress instead of accepting that the film isn’t for them.

Aubriella · 12/09/2022 10:37

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 09:28

I’ve already quoted exactly what you said. You can deny it all you like but it’s there in black and white. The way you worded it initially sounded awful. Now that you’ve elaborated I understand where you’re coming from but still don’t agree entirely.

Please never become a journalist @alwaysdarkestbeforedawn

Aubriella · 12/09/2022 10:36

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 11/09/2022 16:03

You said you would take a sobbing, hysterical child back into the film that had caused the sobbing and hysteria after you’d had a chat. I don’t agree with that. If a film causes that much stress, you just don’t watch that film. That’s not remotely the same as encouraging them to sit upstairs on a bus or try a poached egg!

And the giggling. Have you never known anyone laugh when they’re nervous? Once again, it is very clear from her emotions afterwards that she did not enjoy that film.

She didn't say she would take a sobbing, hysterical child back into the film HmmSt twisting her words. She said

If one of my DCs had said they felt scared at the start of a film, then unless they were being completely hysterical I would also have asked them to wait a few minutes, and then if they seemed to be enjoying it would have thought they got over the fear. Nothing to apologise for!

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 09:28

justmaybenot · 12/09/2022 06:06

I didn't. I said if they were hysterical then I'd take them out and if, after a chat, they wanted to try again we would. It happened a few times with one of my children. Once or twice they were too upset and we just left, other times they tried again and stayed.

I’ve already quoted exactly what you said. You can deny it all you like but it’s there in black and white. The way you worded it initially sounded awful. Now that you’ve elaborated I understand where you’re coming from but still don’t agree entirely.

maddening · 12/09/2022 07:26

I find asking what is scaring ds helps, and then Iay be able to allay those fears.

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 07:25

@Whoactuallythinksthat a more extreme version of a similar scenario. The Dark Crystal is not suitable for younger kids. It’s a PG, not a U so not necessarily appropriate for a 7 year old (would depend on the individual child). The films I watched were worse, but I was older than seven. I doubt having an adult sitting next to me saying “it’s ok, keep watching and eat your popcorn” would have made any difference. Perhaps if I had been able to talk through it afterwards that would have helped but there’s nothing to say that’s happening with this little girl. I hope it does because there are some dark themes in that film that probably need unpicking.

I just assumed pp was exaggerating. Haven’t re read the post. I can’t imagine she is genuinely unable to watch the film.

MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 12/09/2022 07:18

The child told you she was scared. She effectively withdrew her consent, but you ignored that and forced her to stay. If this was adult on adult behaviour nobody would be saying it's ok.

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 12/09/2022 07:14

“The inappropriate reaction is not being able to cope with that and needing to leave.”

@Whoactuallythinksthat If you started watching a film and really weren’t enjoying it would you continue? When something is supposed to be fun but you aren’t enjoying it the sensible thing to do is stop. Apply your logic to a few other scenarios and you soon get into pretty dangerous territory. Is it really a good idea to teach a young girl to ignore her feelings and just continue to do what she is asked?

Whoactuallythinksthat · 12/09/2022 07:07

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 11/09/2022 21:34

@Whoactuallythinksthat I’m sure the 47 year old PP would be fine if she watched it. I watched a lot of scary films when I was young because my best friend’s mum didn’t monitor what we watched and her older brother was really into horror films. I didn’t want to watch them but went along with it so as not to seem like a wimp in front of my friends. Some of them really disturbed me. I’m sure they wouldn’t be scary if I watched them now but I wouldn’t choose to do it because I remember how they made me feel at the time. Had I waited until I was more mature I doubt they would have affected me nearly as much. Had I not watched them at all they wouldn’t have affected me at all. So basically, I think the exact opposite of what you said!

Thats a very different scenario. Presumably the movies you were watching were not age appropriate and you had no parental supervision or support whilst watching them.
I’m also intrigued by how you’re sure that the 47 yr old pp would be fine watching the movie now…..when she specifically said she wouldn’t.