Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL wants me to apologise to her DD

441 replies

cheathimsilly · 11/09/2022 07:22

I took her DD to a film whilst my DS was at school. It was a baby friendly showing, to be specific here. My own (baby) DD came along

I bought sweets along but she wanted popcorn and I fancied some too, so we got a large popcorn and a drink to share

Within 15 minutes of the show starting, she said she was scared. I said it's fine, there's a lot of funny stuff. Sit tight and enjoy her treats etc

She said again 5 minutes later, I don't like it, I'm scared. I said please will you just give it a try? Low and behold, 5 minutes later she's giggling at some of the film and fine for the rest of it

Then the credits came up, and she said she was terrified! I said what of? She said the screens gone black

My niece is 7.

OP posts:
Twillow · 11/09/2022 10:09

The kid sounds a drama llama and the mum is fostering it.
I'd say, honestly SIL, if you want to follow every whim and demand of a 7 year old child that's your decision, but when I'm in charge I'll be doing things my way.

dontyouwishyourgirlfriendwas · 11/09/2022 10:09

That film doesn’t look appropriate for a 7 year old, sorry. I also don’t think she was being whiny / manipulative / annoying it sounds like she was genuinely scared. However, I definitely wouldn’t apologise. SIL chose the film so it’s on her.

milkyaqua · 11/09/2022 10:06

Sisisimone · 11/09/2022 10:02

No milkyaqua that wasn't your point. Your point was that you had watched Psycho at 6 and that the Dark Crystal is a kids film made by the muppets creator. You say 'hardly the stuff of nightmares' . Your take on it is that this child should not have been scared as its a kids film and that you are somehow superior because you watched Psycho at 6.
I don't know anyone that would let a 6 year old watch Psycho and as a pp said have no idea why you would think it's a benchmark for anything since it's so so far from any norm.

A mind reader, now, as well as spiteful.

JustAnotherOpinion21 · 11/09/2022 10:06

cheathimsilly · 11/09/2022 07:30

Dark crystal. (Independent cinema with older films on)

I love the dark crystal, I remember being scared of the characters when I was younger though. Bad choice of film, but lovely for you to take your niece out.

milkyaqua · 11/09/2022 10:05

Lunificent · 11/09/2022 10:00

I wouldn’t apologise. Lesson learnt. Don’t take her to any more films.

This.

EkinWho · 11/09/2022 10:05

You and SIL are both unreasonable. What a terrible choice of film for a 7 year old.

Midsomerwine · 11/09/2022 10:05

YRBU its 10+. You need to talk to the child and apologise.

Beachsidesunset · 11/09/2022 10:05

I'm 46 and I'm still scared of that film (shudder).

BungleandGeorge · 11/09/2022 10:04

You’ve upset your niece, she was in floods of tears hours later when you returned her so obviously she wasn’t ok. If you’re looking after someone else’s child and they’re upset and ask repeatedly to leave I think you just need to leave, you may do differently with your own child. I think it ok to let your niece know that you didn’t realise she was upset. Take her somewhere else next time, she’s obviously not ready for the cinema!

Sisisimone · 11/09/2022 10:02

No milkyaqua that wasn't your point. Your point was that you had watched Psycho at 6 and that the Dark Crystal is a kids film made by the muppets creator. You say 'hardly the stuff of nightmares' . Your take on it is that this child should not have been scared as its a kids film and that you are somehow superior because you watched Psycho at 6.
I don't know anyone that would let a 6 year old watch Psycho and as a pp said have no idea why you would think it's a benchmark for anything since it's so so far from any norm.

Lunificent · 11/09/2022 10:00

I wouldn’t apologise. Lesson learnt. Don’t take her to any more films.

PotatoHammock · 11/09/2022 10:00

I do think the OP isn't being very kind to the young child here. But if I were the mum, I would apologise to the child myself for having picked the film in the first place, and then moved on. I'm not sure there's much mileage in one adult making another adult stage an apology to a child.

tempester28 · 11/09/2022 09:56

I would have been inclined to persevere too

milkyaqua · 11/09/2022 09:55

*made for children

Shinyandnew1 · 11/09/2022 09:53

How did the trip come about?

Did your SIL ask you for childcare for her DD and then suggested to take her to see this film?

Did you offer to have her to do something fun together-if so, whose choice was it?

I wouldn’t fancy taking her out again somewhere if I was going to be criticised for it.

milkyaqua · 11/09/2022 09:53

Sisisimone · 11/09/2022 09:47

I think for some reason we're supposed to be terribly impressed that milkyaqua watched adult horror films at 6 🙄. There's always one isn't there. Whaaaaat? Your 7 year old was scared? Good god, I used to watch The Exorcist every night before bed as a child instead of a bedtime story and at 6 I watched Psycho and jumped in the shower with glee straight afterwards. What a coward your 7 year old is 🙄

Are you feeling better now?

My point is, all children are different. This child was taken to a movie suggested by her mother. A movie made from children, with a rating of PG. She was scared at two points and seemed to enjoy the rest of the movie, laughing, etc. One of the moments she was "scared" was the black screen of the credits. I think she has gone home and beaten up how scared she was to get attention from her mother. Presumably you think differently.

But it's always good to milk the fangs on some stranger online, isn't it.

Adventurine · 11/09/2022 09:50

Dark Crystal??

I'd be pissed off if you took my 7yo to the pictures and didn't listen if they were frightened. You're not the one dealing with nightmares, new fears, sadness, mistrust etc that can come from
adults not respecting a child's feelings of fear. It's kind of like turning the light off and closing the door when you know they're scared of the dark because YOU want it like that, and then asking them to cope with it.

Asking you to apologise to her DD is the nicer way she could be dealing with this.

autienotnaughty · 11/09/2022 09:49

I think it's wrong to dismiss a child's feelings if she said she was scared you could have spoken to her about leaving and made sure she knew it was an option. She is unlikely to have felt comfortable to express her feelings a third time so there's a risk she felt unable to say she was unhappy.I would say to sil that you checked on her at the time and thought she was ok . but you will speak to her next time you see her, then next time you see her I would say she can always tell you if she's upset/scared and your sorry she didn't feel able to this time. I agree I probably wouldn't do cinema again.

NotMyDust · 11/09/2022 09:48

Hillrunning · 11/09/2022 09:05

Don't give a stupid fake apology about her feelings (sorry you were scared) thoes are manipulative and pointless. Apologies are for what YOU did or didn't do. 'I'm sorry I misunderstood how scared you were, sometimes adults forget to see things from a child's perspective and thats what happened. I promise that next time I will listen to you properly.'

It's irrelevant that SIL chose the film, you were responsible for the child in your care. You dismissed her initial attempt to tel you she was scared, of course she was going to try to muddle through the rest of it if the only adult she was with told her not to make a fuss. When she felt safe enough back in her mothers presence, her true emotions could come out. This is such straightforward stuff, how do you not see it?

This, OP.
Maybe she was scared, maybe she has zero resilience, who knows.
Point is parenting is all about this kind of thing happening and you need to learn to flex it. You've been lucky with your DS if this hasn't happened yet.
Apologise with no "buts" .

Sisisimone · 11/09/2022 09:47

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/09/2022 09:39

Developmentally a 6 year old won’t have understood a lot of what was happening, whereas a little older, it would have been a lot more scary. There is a lot of innuendo and offscreen stuff.

Idk how this happened as it wasn’t in any stretch of the imagination ok. Idk why that’s something to use as a benchmark.

I think for some reason we're supposed to be terribly impressed that milkyaqua watched adult horror films at 6 🙄. There's always one isn't there. Whaaaaat? Your 7 year old was scared? Good god, I used to watch The Exorcist every night before bed as a child instead of a bedtime story and at 6 I watched Psycho and jumped in the shower with glee straight afterwards. What a coward your 7 year old is 🙄

Soubriquet · 11/09/2022 09:46

milkyaqua · 11/09/2022 09:38

And?

Well... Psycho is a psychological horror movie for adults.

The Dark Crystal is a PG fantasy film by the guy who created The Muppets.

The point I was making, was, it didn’t scare you. It would scare some children.

The films my dc watched didn’t scare them. But it would others.

The dark crystal, is one that is generally quite disturbing for most children.

LannieDuck · 11/09/2022 09:43

I assumed you were going to say it was the Minions movie, or something. But the Dark Crystal... omg! 😳

It's one of my DH's favourite films, and our kids (8 and 10) haven't seen it yet.

Viostep · 11/09/2022 09:43

Your sil is a bit of a drama queen and her apprehension is rubbing off on her daughter. I'd say something like, sorry she got scared when the screen went dark. I thought she was fine when she was giggling through the film but clearly not. Perhaps it was a poor choice of film for her. Lesson learned.

Then I wouldn't take her out by myself again. Not worth the hassle imo.

Midlifemusings · 11/09/2022 09:42

aSofaNearYou · 11/09/2022 09:31

I think it would do the opposite. OP needs to validate the child's feelings and apologise for ignoring them. This 'bashing down' of children feelings is what creates people who are frightened to voice their feelings when they need to

That's one take on it. My experience is that making far too much of a fuss over normal moments of apprehension creates children who are frightened of everything. You can treat their fear kindly at the time whilst encouraging them, without needing to ring them up hours later when they have moved on emotionally to remind them how awful" it was.

Yes OP did not treat the fear kindly or with encouragement and there is nothing wrong with adults apologzing to kids when they mess up.

No one is saying to make it awful. Just an apology to say I should have listened when you told me you were scared.

Sisisimone · 11/09/2022 09:41

ItsJustLittleOlMe · 11/09/2022 09:32

She sounds bloody annoying. I wouldn't be taking her out again.

It's her 7 year old niece. 7. Who got a bit scared in a cinema. And you'd never take her out again? Yeah right.

I take it you don't have any children or know of any. If no-one ever took a child out again because they were a bit annoying they would be locked in the house 24/7