Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whinging on holiday threads

34 replies

Alltheholidays · 10/09/2022 22:29

Why oh why? I love holiday threads. Started one today, and get loads of ideas from them, and generally love hearing about people’s plans!

You know what you’re getting when you click on one! Yet every time, within a few posts there are posters who pop us to tell everyone they haven’t had a holiday in years, they can’t understand how anyone could spend so much on a holiday yada yada!
Honestly, what is the point of this. Why on earth click on a thread when you know exactly what it’s going to be about, and then complain about it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 10:50

@justfiveminutes Yes, seen it on other threads as well. I don’t go on the S& B threads, cos i’m
not especially interested, but I can only imagine the comments!
if someone wants to spend all their spare cash on personal grooming or fancy clothes than good on them.
I’d rather spend on holiday, but neither is right or wrong.
i wonder if these people are as miserable in real life or just on here.

OP posts:
NotSure87 · 11/09/2022 10:44

Well, I'm probably being unreasonable because I don't read the holiday board but I have no doubt what you say is true OP. When I joined mumsnet I was just stunned at some of the replies. And I started a thread once about a question about relationships and got replies asking if I thought about how hard that would have been as a single person, which I had to respectfully answer no, because that wasn't my situation. You are always going to get posters who are looking to BE annoyed, as well as posters who are looking TO annoy. I'm glad it's not every poster though, because that would be disheartening!

I just skim posts and ignore the ones that are tone deaf, missing the point, stupid or looking to start a fight. It's not right but the bloody annoying thing about a forum is they let anyone in! (Including me!). I read something once that said, how you react to others is your responsibility (not lecturing you at all btw), just saying mumsnet is an excellent place to practice that philosophy!

justfiveminutes · 11/09/2022 10:33

I've noticed these too, but it's not just holidays. It's every type of thread and I noticed it on S&B recently too. People can't ignore a thread that doesn't apply to them or interest them. They have to share their miserable, angry, unrequested opinion and we are apparently supposed to care about it.

Arenanewbie · 11/09/2022 10:26

I haven’t seen the whole threads about this but bizarre comments are happening on any threads. Obviously Holiday section is exactly for this - to discuss holidays. I’ve found the info very helpful. Lots of people do more holidays then me and more expensive holidays and more adventurous holidays but it’s the same in real life. I love reading about them so I can see if it’s something I’d like or not.

Glittertwins · 11/09/2022 10:14

I'm not too fussed about going away on holidays but spend time and money on other things instead. But this is my choice. Holidays are a big deal for other people, like my parents, and if they wish to spend their money on that so what - no different to other hobbies.
I like seeing where people are thinking of going and the replies though, it tends to make me more enthusiastic about the idea of a holiday!!

gogohmm · 11/09/2022 10:10

I know what you mean. I love holidays and go away a few times a year (combination of longer and shorter trips, I only get 25 days of annual leave!) I budget to be able to afford them and don't spend money on things others regard as essential (my thermostat at home has been set at 17 for years, long before the price rises, we wear thick jumpers!)

AuntieStella · 11/09/2022 10:07

Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 09:54

@AuntieStella Funnily enough I know you can use the train for weekend away. I use the train often. I also fly often and that’s not going to change.
Did you think you were telling me something I don’t already know?

I don't know you at all. And chances are you've not said enough for anyone else to know your personal consumption patterns, let alone which options you would reject out of hand

RetreatRetreatRetreat · 11/09/2022 10:06

It pisses me off too. I work a second job for the reason that I want holiday every 3 months. Often these are very cheap last minute package deals but once a year I do a big holiday, USA, SE Asia etc.

I don't have a new car, I work 6 days a week and I don't have lots of new clothes/and expensive phone etc. In my experience most (not all) people that are skint have other options such as getting a part time job etc, but they chose to value other things, such as a big house, spending time with family. That's their choice. Mine is to go on holiday.

Bubblebubblebah · 11/09/2022 10:02

Having a break might be much wanted/needed, but having a holiday is a luxury.

Really depends on circumstances but many of us around me including me spent years on NMW and still went on holidays. Budget, but lovely and also another travelvisiting families abroad at least once a year.

I see luxury holiays as luxury, but holidays can be done pretty cheaply still even on £9.50 an hour.

Of course there will be people who genuinely can't afford even the budget ones, but it is, comparing again to food as is my habit, like saying beef roasting meat is luxury because someone can only afford spam. Luxury is relative, isn't it

Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 10:00

Bubblebubblebah · 11/09/2022 09:53

Oh yes! There are two types in this case.
1 who did their travelling and now "seen the light" so everyone else must cease immediately and those who "never fly or the planet because it's horrible and no one should fly and even if I could afford it I wouldn't fly".
Eco activism in many cases is very much based on what you can't or don't want to do anyway...

Yes there are! I pat attention to neither! My favourite is the sack cloth and ashes type ones though.
They can be quite funny 😀

OP posts:
Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 09:54

@AuntieStella Funnily enough I know you can use the train for weekend away. I use the train often. I also fly often and that’s not going to change.
Did you think you were telling me something I don’t already know?

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 11/09/2022 09:53

Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 09:36

There are also the others who come on to berate people about the environment and flying.

They’ve done their travelling and now have seen the light, and will never set foot inside a plane again, and they think everyone else should do the same.
This is more funny than annoying.😀

Oh yes! There are two types in this case.
1 who did their travelling and now "seen the light" so everyone else must cease immediately and those who "never fly or the planet because it's horrible and no one should fly and even if I could afford it I wouldn't fly".
Eco activism in many cases is very much based on what you can't or don't want to do anyway...

AuntieStella · 11/09/2022 09:46

There are also the others who come on to berate people about the environment and flying

Climate change is real and could be disastrous. Last chance saloon for taking the edge off it. Nowt wrong with reminding those who want a weekend away that destinations reachable by train exist.

If you're seeking holiday options, then options which have the lowest detriment are valid and extremely important responses

Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 09:43

@Darbs76 Ah, we had some fab sun holidays in the past for very little. Went to France and Holland a few times, and lots of weekends in the uk!

OP posts:
Arbesque · 11/09/2022 09:43

I think poster are too quick to shout 'jealousy' on mumsnet.

But I agree about people who come on threads simply to sourly criticise the topic of the thread. You see it over and over:

"Not this again"
"Is this all you have to worry about"
"Yawn"

etc etc

Just scroll on by if you've nothing relevant to add. No one wants to hear your non opinion.

AuntieStella · 11/09/2022 09:42

Thread derailments of all types can be irritating (and they never seem to be witty these days)

These are no worse than any others.

Worth remembering that COL is straitening the circumstances for many, and unless energy bills crisis is headed off it could get very difficult for a lot of people.

Having a break might be much wanted/needed, but having a holiday is a luxury.

I think all threads about spending of luxuries will need to be very tactfully worded for a while.

(Also I think some posters have been emboldened by the massed pissing on threads about paying respects to HM QEII, where any spending other than to food bank or another charity is being shouted at)

SavoirFlair · 11/09/2022 09:36

Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 09:12

i posted my holiday thread on holidays not Aibu.

I don’t understand the obsession with opening threads where people are discussing holidays, when you, for whatever reason don’t/can’t to go on holidays yourself!

Apologies @Alltheholidays - and, this proves your point even more !

I fully agree with you. The people coming on a board called Holidays, to then moan about someone being able to afford a destination?? Mind blown.

Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 09:36

There are also the others who come on to berate people about the environment and flying.

They’ve done their travelling and now have seen the light, and will never set foot inside a plane again, and they think everyone else should do the same.
This is more funny than annoying.😀

OP posts:
Darbs76 · 11/09/2022 09:29

annoys me too. Everyone had a different financial situation. I used to go on £9.50 Sun newspapers holidays, now I can afford to go most places, as I’ve worked my way up to a good salary, and I’ve worked 6 days per week for the last 18 months. Not saying that those who can’t afford don’t work hard. But if you can’t afford to go on holidays don’t come on threads and complain, best to avoid them altogether.

Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 09:25

FourTeaFallOut · 11/09/2022 09:17

I mean, I'm recovering from pneumonia. I'm just off to the exercise board to complain about their conspicuous and unapologetic display of lung function. Bastards.

This just sums it up! There will always be someone who is richer than you, fitter than you, has a better job than you, shops in Waitrose while your budget is more Aldi (me)

If we had to think about other people’s situations before we discussed anything then this forum would be redundant!

I hope you feel better soon. Pneumonia is a fucker.

OP posts:
FayeGovan · 11/09/2022 09:24

I cant afford a holiday right now but i enjoy reading the threads about them and if someone is having a shit time i feel sorry for them.

PAFMO · 11/09/2022 09:23

I've seen it too.
It's competitive hairshirt wearing.
If you namesearch , very often the people doing this will have other threads where they run 3 cars, buy posh handbags and have their hair and nails done professionally.
I haven't got a car, dh has an old Fiat Panda. I cut my own hair. We've got one telly.
I spend what money I have over on holidays and travel.
It's worse if you dare go abroad. Because UK holidays are so cheap. (my arse)

FourTeaFallOut · 11/09/2022 09:17

I mean, I'm recovering from pneumonia. I'm just off to the exercise board to complain about their conspicuous and unapologetic display of lung function. Bastards.

Alltheholidays · 11/09/2022 09:12

i posted my holiday thread on holidays not Aibu.

I don’t understand the obsession with opening threads where people are discussing holidays, when you, for whatever reason don’t/can’t to go on holidays yourself!

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 11/09/2022 09:12

FourTeaFallOut · 11/09/2022 09:04

I didn't see the other thread. It's not new news that some people can't afford to go on holiday but it's only recently that holiday threads are swamped with sniffy responses about being tone deaf and other bollocks. If it was perfectly acceptable six years ago you would think it would be perfectly fine now and if it isn't, you'd think there would be a much more interesting conversation about double standards?

Absolutely.

Yes, some people really can't spare the few hundred, that is true, but most people are in situation when they can't afford something. It is like going on a thread about steak and whining that it's tone deaf because someone can only afford chicken.

And most people around me still go on holidays. It's a mix of professionals and nmw workers in hospitality etc. It's not AS bleak as some threads make it sound. Don't take me wrong, the whole cost of living is bleak (though there is lots of misunderstanding and exaggeration imho in many cases), but it looks like lots of people rejuggled expenses to be able to afford x instead of x,y and z and the x in our cases seem to be holidays.

Swipe left for the next trending thread