Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not accept this holiday as I can’t afford the tip?

130 replies

SillyFood · 10/09/2022 18:56

I recently inherited some money and I used most of it to pay a large chunk of the mortgage but put £10k of it aside and have booked a proper holiday of a lifetime to Thailand in October for myself and dc. My aunt, who I inherited the money from had always made me promise I’d spend a chunk of it on a big treat for myself that I’d never normally do so that’s exactly what I’ve done.

DH and I are divorced but I’m still pretty close to his family. His SIL works in the travel industry and has very kindly been helping me organise this holiday. She’s booked us various excursions that I couldn’t work out how to do and got us some amazing discounts on hotels which I’m truly grateful for. When I first starting talking to her about it one of the things she suggested was a sailing charter. They looked absolutely amazing but, although I could just about stretch to the cost of the charter itself (about £4k 😱) she said that tips of 10-20% are pretty much expected so I ruled it out and booked other stuff instead. The trip is now pretty much completely booked, all excursions paid for or deposit down and it’s cost £8,200 so I’ve got £1800 left to spend when we’re out there.

Yesterday ex SIL phoned me up to say that ex MIL was going to be calling that afternoon and that she suspected she had some news that I wouldn’t like. Ex MIL calls me and tells me excitedly that she’s booked the sailing charter for us for the holiday as she really wanted to spoil her GC’s, she didn’t want to wait until she was dead for us to have a treat and that she knew we really wanted to do it but couldn’t afford it. I told her that we had everything booked now, that it was in a different part of the country to where we’ll be on the date she’s booked it and I didn’t know if I’d be able to get everything refunded/ deposit back. She brushed this aside and said she’d send me the link, that she’d paid for it and once I saw it then she knew that I’d love it.

The link is to a charter on a bloody super yacht. Looking at the prices I think she’s spent an absolute minimum of £10k on the 3 day charter. The original one we were looking at was sailing on a traditional boat, going to nature reserves and snorkelling. This is suggesting casinos, nightlife, possible firework displays for an extra £4k, a proper chef when my kids only eat beige food. Ex PIL are not rich. I do not know why they have done this. Even if I cancel the 3 nights accommodation that I’ve booked and rearrange the whole thing so that I’m in the place I need to be for this bloody boat I still need to cut back spending so I’ve got an extra £2-3k for tips. I am so grateful that she’s thinking of us but it is neither what I want to do or what I can afford.

I’ve tried speaking to her and she just isn’t listening. She’s adamant in doing it because I’m uncomfortable accepting such a large gift (which is a part of it tbh). SIL is going to try and speak to her but I don’t know if she’ll manage to get through to her. I don’t think I’m being ungrateful but I would genuinely rather she donate the money to charity than spend it on something that makes this holiday that I’m so looking forward to into something I don’t want.

OP posts:
TinySaltLick · 11/09/2022 07:32

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/09/2022 21:37

Not quite the point, I know, but this is why I hate the whole business of expected 'tips'. People in the UK will tell you that you are 'tight' if you don't tip, as the waiting staff are counting on the money. Then, here, we hear in other much less wealthy countries that staff will be working for nothing unless you pay their wages, which are mendaciously referred to as 'tips' by the holiday operators, to artificially keep the stated prices lower.

How is this even legal? I'll bet the owners/operators don't go short in their profits - much less (technically) allow you to avoid paying them, by calling them 'tips'. How disgusting and exploitative to make the customer feel guilty if they don't make up for them not paying their employees/contractors fairly (if at all).

Am I the only person who wishes that the whole culture of tips would just disappear worldwide and be replaced by somebody telling you very clearly how much money they require you to pay them in exchange for the offered goods or services? I'm not 'tight' or grumbling about paying more in any way - just would like to know the actual price for something I might want to buy, before I decide, without any coyness, swerving, guilt-tripping, emotional blackmail or anything else when somebody gives you a price significantly lower than they're actually charging. How did we ever reach the place where somebody tells you that something costs £X, you give them £X for it and then they start complaining and bad-mouthing you for paying what they stated?!

It's just a different business model - your comment 'how did we get here' suggests thus us some sort of new invention - it's actually the opposite. Commercial transactions which involve multiple people would unsurprisingly require multiple payments - a penny for the delivery boy - a single payment which everyone behind the scenes getting compensated in line with a fair salary as outlined in an employment contract has taken hundreds of years of campaigning for workers rights.

It is an additional overhead, but pretending this isn't completely normal all over the world is quite naive

Even in the US the total price advertised in supermarkets doesn't include tax - which varies by state

SillyFood · 11/09/2022 00:48

I don’t doubt it is possible to have done it cheaper. As I’ve already said though I want the reassurance of knowing the excursions I want to do are available on the dates I want to do them and with a reputable company that is suitable for me to use as a single female with youngish kids. Stuff like internal flights, trains etc would definitely be cheaper but I have paid extra for stuff like a room in the sleeper train just for us so we’re not with a stranger, booking seats together on the internal flights, arranging transfers rather than grabbing a taxi at the airport. I’m confident I’ve got a good deal on most of the stuff I’ve booked and I’ve saved well over £2k by SIL booking the hotels using her discount. It’s not the way everyone would want to do it but I’m the kind of person that will find the whole thing a lot more enjoyable not having to worry about this stuff once we’re out there.

I haven’t heard from MIL yet but I’m really hoping she chooses to either do the flight upgrade or keep the money to spend on herself/ something else for dc. We’re flying with Singapore Airlines, I may have spent the last hour or so looking at the stuff you get flying business class and it looks flipping amazing.

OP posts:
daisy46 · 11/09/2022 00:26

flirtygirl · 10/09/2022 22:35

£8.2k is a rip off. I priced up similar and it was around £5k. It would have been so much better for you to book hotel and flights. Then get the details from the sil about the excursions and book the transport and day trips in Thailand. Probably 70% cheaper.

🙄🙄 You don't even know what OP is doing or where she's staying. Give over.

worriedatthistime · 11/09/2022 00:07

@Annoyingkidsmusic OP has said numerous times her sil is not a travel agent
And also as she is going with her dc she wants to pre book trips

DoIDareSayAnything · 10/09/2022 23:56

LOL at the people saying the OP has been ripped off at £8.5k.

There are luxury holidays and then there are Luxury holidays. I would have no trouble at all spending that much on a couple of weeks adventure in Thailand.

You are also quite right that tips are very much expected/relied on in Thailand OP. A shame your ExMIL didn't check first. I hope she comes through with the flight upgrades.

FictionalCharacter · 10/09/2022 23:36

You’ll have to tell her you don’t intend to go on what she’s booked, and she’ll have to cancel it.
A gift that someone absolutely doesn’t want isn’t a kind gift.

katepilar · 10/09/2022 23:33

Stuff like this annoys me to no end. SOrry you 've been put in this situation.

Whalesong · 10/09/2022 23:33

Lacey247 · 10/09/2022 23:16

We stayed in the sandalwood and the lamai in Koh Samui and the banyan tree in Bangkok. Lots of other luxury/beach front hotels in the smaller islands. Flights around Thailand were incredibly cheap £20/£30 a time.

What about the flights from the UK to Thailand and back? As the OP's budget includes that. I doubt you'd get what she describes for anything like what you claim, even if you went for "downmarket" so-called 5* hotels.
We paid almost twice as much for 4 of us in 2019. Staying in Phuket for a night either end, and 8 nights in Koh Yao Yai. Villa with private pool and jacuzzi. All inclusive. We did fly business as a special treat, but with Qatar airlines that was less expensive than Premium Economy on other airlines (and earned us silver cards with BA which are valid until next year as they were extended through Covid).

OP, I hope your MIL can get you flight upgrades! Business class on Qatar, with private pods (small private "rooms") with super comfy chairs that turned into flat beds, amazing food and drink and the latest movies on tap was the highlight of the holiday for our teenagers!

Annoyingkidsmusic · 10/09/2022 23:31

All of this is so utterly far fetched, it cannot be true.
If your sil is truly a travel agent, she would 100% be telling you to book your excursions yourself in Thailand with the locals, and barter for the best price. If not, she’s lost you a considerable amount of money.

As for the charter sail situation…. I don’t even know where to begin

PegasusReturns · 10/09/2022 23:21

As I said I spent 5 weeks in lots of different areas of Thailand staying in some beautiful 5 star hotels. We spent a fraction of the cost the op has stated

Which ones? The OPs budget for your five weeks works out at less than £250 per day. Without flights. I simply don’t believe you had the sort of luxury holiday the OP is planning for a fraction of her budget.

Thisbastardcomputer · 10/09/2022 23:20

Have you watched the programme, Below Deck ? They expect a £25k in cash tip for a four day trip, it's ludicrous.

Lacey247 · 10/09/2022 23:16

worriedatthistime · 10/09/2022 23:10

@Lacey247 please link the hotels you stayed in , especially 5 star ones ?
I mean flights you got as well as they must if only been a couple hundred each ?

We stayed in the sandalwood and the lamai in Koh Samui and the banyan tree in Bangkok. Lots of other luxury/beach front hotels in the smaller islands. Flights around Thailand were incredibly cheap £20/£30 a time.

worriedatthistime · 10/09/2022 23:10

@Lacey247 please link the hotels you stayed in , especially 5 star ones ?
I mean flights you got as well as they must if only been a couple hundred each ?

worriedatthistime · 10/09/2022 23:07

@Lacey247 you got all that for £2000 , please link the flights you used , hotels etc

worriedatthistime · 10/09/2022 23:06

@RoutineLow exactly or how many dc etc
I mean i can stay in a hotel in brighton for £100 or £1000
People on here often say I only pay this or that but rarely can link

SillyFood · 10/09/2022 23:06

I have started watching Below Deck after someone mentioned it earlier and it does look a hoot tbf. My kids would definitely not appreciate it though!

OP posts:
worriedatthistime · 10/09/2022 23:04

@Nelia5 £8500 for oP and her dc sounds reasonable with trips flights hotels, and super yachts don't have a rainy season discount

worriedatthistime · 10/09/2022 23:03

@Libre55 no and if i ever win the euros thats what i plan to spend it on , have it all worked out in my head , what i can order , do etc . Daydreaming at its best

Lacey247 · 10/09/2022 23:02

DrivingDown · 10/09/2022 22:58

Thailand really is an extremely cheap country so it’s shocking to me that your trip is costing 8k!

Not really. You can spend $30 a night on budget accommodation on the main strip on chaweng beach or you can spend (at least) 10 times that at the four seasons or six senses.

As I said I spent 5 weeks in lots of different areas of Thailand staying in some beautiful 5 star hotels. We spent a fraction of the cost the op has stated and we did excursions every other day for the duration.

worriedatthistime · 10/09/2022 23:02

Tbf we just chartered a ctarmaran foe 4 hrs and still tipped 10%

worriedatthistime · 10/09/2022 22:59

Going by below the deck , programme on tv about super yachts etc and charters the tip seems to be what the staff work for

DrivingDown · 10/09/2022 22:58

Thailand really is an extremely cheap country so it’s shocking to me that your trip is costing 8k!

Not really. You can spend $30 a night on budget accommodation on the main strip on chaweng beach or you can spend (at least) 10 times that at the four seasons or six senses.

Hotandbothereds · 10/09/2022 22:55

flirtygirl · 10/09/2022 22:35

£8.2k is a rip off. I priced up similar and it was around £5k. It would have been so much better for you to book hotel and flights. Then get the details from the sil about the excursions and book the transport and day trips in Thailand. Probably 70% cheaper.

Considering you have absolutely no idea what accomodation the OP has booked to stay in or what exactly her excursions are you can’t possibly comment on whether she’s paid the right price.

I backpacked round Thailand for a few months and spent very very little, nowhere near £5k but that doesn’t mean that you can’t spend more for luxury if you can afford it.

PegasusReturns · 10/09/2022 22:55

I’ve chartered yachts before (certainly not “super” ones) but you’re looking at starting prices of £1800 per day for a 45-50ft with 3-4 crew.

Typically you’ll be asked a few days in advance to choose a menu and also to provide drinks and snacks list. Generally everything is billable, although I have seen options where your three meals are included, unsurprisingly the day rate is then more.

And you absolutely have to tip.

Lacey247 · 10/09/2022 22:53

flirtygirl · 10/09/2022 22:35

£8.2k is a rip off. I priced up similar and it was around £5k. It would have been so much better for you to book hotel and flights. Then get the details from the sil about the excursions and book the transport and day trips in Thailand. Probably 70% cheaper.

Absolutely agree. I think it’d be quite an achievement to spend 8k on a Thai holiday