Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU .. to work on 19 September?

265 replies

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 10/09/2022 17:57

It's the first day back at work for me and the first day of freshers week. Of course the student activity planned for the day will not take place but I'd got several meetings planned with colleagues and student ambassadors as well as a couple of employers. These meetings will affect what we do in the rest of the week.

It's not about not showing respect or not caring about the queen and nothing whatsoever to do with the social side of university or drinking activities. Yes we can rearrange some things. But it's going to be rather awkward and have a knock on effect on the following week when the returners come back.

If the others are amenable - and I'm aware they might not be - I want to have the meetings, probably on Zoom.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 11/09/2022 11:53

@QuebecBagnet "totally agree that this toxic atmosphere is endemic in academia. The unspoken disapproval, the expectations, the phonecalls at 6pm, at 8am. Emails from SLT at 11pm"

None of the above has ever applied in my job. Ever.

OP posts:
QuebecBagnet · 11/09/2022 11:33

do not want people to give up their bank holiday. I've never said that at all and have no idea why you think that.

really? You can’t see how asking people to attend meetings on a bank holiday is asking them to give up their bank holiday? You surely must see it’s the same thing.

totally agree that this toxic atmosphere is endemic in academia. The unspoken disapproval, the expectations, the phonecalls at 6pm, at 8am. Emails from SLT at 11pm

It’s akin to me saying I don’t celebrate Christmas and therefore asking people if they mind attending some zoom meetings on Xmas day.

TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber · 11/09/2022 11:27

@freckles20 I hope some other parents are offered appointments for Monday instead of those for whom a bank holiday is more important than their children's attendance at a clinic. If I had a child on the list, I'd be ringing up in the hope of there having been cancellations on that day!

TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber · 11/09/2022 11:24

Sounds like you have a chip on your shoulder that some people get bank holidays and some don’t. That’s a problem with your thinking

Not in fact. I accept that bank holidays happen throughout the year. However, I find it immensely frustrating that the people who can just take the time off unexpectedly because their jobs and livelihoods are safe can't understand that there's nothing wrong or disrespectful about asking other people to carry on as normal. There's very much an 'us' and 'them' when it comes to unexpected time off/cancellations.

In fact the bank holiday doesn't matter a flying fuck to me as I'll be working and my work on that Monday won't involve anyone else. I have no particular interest in the funeral - or not enough to give myself a day off. And I'm not remotely anti-monarchy.

In@ImJustMadAboutSaffron's case, if she can't do the work on Monday, she'll end up with a massive admin headache later on in the week. University teachers always end up picking up the slack themselves; there's nobody to whom you can delegate. Asking someone to attend a short meeting/have a short Zoom on the unexpected bank holiday is very different from failing to plan to accommodate a bank holiday which you have known about all year. And she certainly shouldn't give up her annual leave (planned in advance), though I dare say that if something came up unexpectedly during her leave, she'd end up dealing with it. Because that's what university teachers do.

MomsnetAdmin · 11/09/2022 11:18

freckles20 · 10/09/2022 23:54

My friend is a hospital consultant in paediatrics. She runs two clinics on Mondays. Waiting lists are enormous and she works evenings and weekends to try to reduce the backlog.

She decided that she wanted her clinics to go ahead as planned on Monday 19th so her and her students have begun calling the parents of children with appts on that day to let them know that the appointments will go ahead.

4 sets of parents have already complained- they don't want up attend as it is now a bank holiday and they expect an alternative appt to be conjured up over the following few days instead!

FFS people!

Did the consultant also call the nurses, HCAs , secretaries and admin to tell them to come in on a bank holiday or arrange locum rates for them? What a doughnut.

Beezknees · 11/09/2022 11:16

TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber · 11/09/2022 10:58

I strongly suspect that people who were furloughed are the same people who are insisting that they are not going to work on the sudden Bank Holiday, and that anyone who does work is "disrespectful" or "uncaring".

It's always the people who are basically paid to do sod all who are happy to inflict their days off on other people who don't have that luxury.

@ImJustMadAboutSaffron I would be happy for you to contact me if I were one of the people whom you were supposed to be meeting, and I'd be happy to go ahead. It would be another job ticked off the list.

Well that's wrong, I was furloughed and I'd happily go to work on the 19th, I don't care about the royals. Furlough was not a choice, in case you forgot. I'd sooner have been at work rather than my pay reduced by 20%.

MomsnetAdmin · 11/09/2022 11:14

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 10/09/2022 20:24

I'm on holiday.

That's OK. Just do the few quick zooms so you can set up the following week ? Don't fancy it? Probably don't ask others to do it on their bank holiday ..

freckles20 · 11/09/2022 11:06

@TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber I agree with you.

This is all getting very boring now. Some people will take the BH off and be paid, some people will take the BH off and not get paid, some people will not find their work impacted, for others the BH will cause chaos at work and / or home.

There is no right or wrong.

However the amount of people insisting that it is disrespectful to work if needed on that day is ridiculous and shows a lack of empathy towards people for whom an unexpected BH causes chaos.

Andromachehadabadday · 11/09/2022 11:03

TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber · 11/09/2022 10:58

I strongly suspect that people who were furloughed are the same people who are insisting that they are not going to work on the sudden Bank Holiday, and that anyone who does work is "disrespectful" or "uncaring".

It's always the people who are basically paid to do sod all who are happy to inflict their days off on other people who don't have that luxury.

@ImJustMadAboutSaffron I would be happy for you to contact me if I were one of the people whom you were supposed to be meeting, and I'd be happy to go ahead. It would be another job ticked off the list.

What’s furlough got to do with anything?

I wasn’t furloughed. My teams were, for a short period. I haven’t even spoken to them about the bank holiday.

I just wouldn’t ask them. Despite that meaning (as it does every bank holiday) that we have to do 5 days in work in 4. If they ask me to work, that’s fine. I won’t be asking them.

and this is my first job that’s actually had all bank holidays off.

Sounds like you have a chip on your shoulder that some people get bank holidays and some don’t. That’s a problem with your thinking.

TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber · 11/09/2022 11:00

LuftBalloons · 11/09/2022 10:56

senior academic staff want to do something, it sets a certain 'tone at the top' which then permeates. I'm quite surprised you don't understand this. I'm not saying they definitely will be perceived poorly - quite the reverse, more likely you will be - but a junior member of staff might worry that they could be, by saying no.

The thing is, that at department level senior academic staff tend to pick up the work if others decline to do it. It’s easy to say - “Let the management sort it out” but at department level, managers sort it out by working extra themselves.

The work still needs to be done. And one only has to look at public commentary on tuition fees etc - you parents expect that everything is laid on for your DC at university, while kvetching about tuition fees.

Who do you think does the work in an underfunded system? People like @ImJustMadAboutSaffron and her department colleagues. If we academics worked strictly out 37 hours per week, and took all the holidays due us, the university system would fall apart within a couple of months.

And this is 100% true (I resigned from a Senior Lectureship some years ago because things were so bad; I can only imagine they are even worse now).

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 11/09/2022 10:59

KweenieBeanz · 11/09/2022 10:46

Their managers. Who might feel pressured if senior staff want to hold a meeting. This is endemic in universities - senior academic staff want to do something, it sets a certain 'tone at the top' which then permeates. I'm quite surprised you don't understand this. I'm not saying they definitely will be perceived poorly - quite the reverse, more likely you will be - but a junior member of staff might worry that they could be, by saying no. So they put on a 'can-do attitude' and say yes, I can do it, I'll have to park the kids in front of the box or something but I'll make sure I join.....' or similar. Even though they rather wish they didn't have to.

Only one of these people is employed by the University. This is another senior lecturer. I don't for one second imagine they'd refer to the head of department if I suggest they have a short meeting with me next Monday. We don't work like that. We have agency.

The employers I'm talking about own their companies and wouldn't have to ask permission.

OP posts:
TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber · 11/09/2022 10:58

MissingNashville · 10/09/2022 21:14

You can work, just don’t in any way involve others.

I strongly suspect that people who were furloughed are the same people who are insisting that they are not going to work on the sudden Bank Holiday, and that anyone who does work is "disrespectful" or "uncaring".

It's always the people who are basically paid to do sod all who are happy to inflict their days off on other people who don't have that luxury.

@ImJustMadAboutSaffron I would be happy for you to contact me if I were one of the people whom you were supposed to be meeting, and I'd be happy to go ahead. It would be another job ticked off the list.

LuftBalloons · 11/09/2022 10:56

senior academic staff want to do something, it sets a certain 'tone at the top' which then permeates. I'm quite surprised you don't understand this. I'm not saying they definitely will be perceived poorly - quite the reverse, more likely you will be - but a junior member of staff might worry that they could be, by saying no.

The thing is, that at department level senior academic staff tend to pick up the work if others decline to do it. It’s easy to say - “Let the management sort it out” but at department level, managers sort it out by working extra themselves.

The work still needs to be done. And one only has to look at public commentary on tuition fees etc - you parents expect that everything is laid on for your DC at university, while kvetching about tuition fees.

Who do you think does the work in an underfunded system? People like @ImJustMadAboutSaffron and her department colleagues. If we academics worked strictly out 37 hours per week, and took all the holidays due us, the university system would fall apart within a couple of months.

brookstar · 11/09/2022 10:55

If you genuinely think there is no power imbalance between you and students then there a bigger issues here.
It doesn't matter how well you know them.

LuftBalloons · 11/09/2022 10:51

DelilahBucket · 11/09/2022 10:23

I'm self employed and so is DH. No work = no pay. I can still work, DH can't, so he loses a day's pay and there is naff all we can do about it 😔. Less money coming in really isn't what we need right now and companies who are struggling as it is having to pay everyone to have the day off is also not what we need in this country right now.

I agree - it’s really ill-thought through.

Like @ImJustMadAboutSaffron it’s going to make MORE work for many people, many people will lose income, and many people will not be able not to work.

I think those castigating @ImJustMadAboutSaffron need to think this through a bit more.

LittleBearPad · 11/09/2022 10:49

If you can’t see what effect this I'm a senior lecturer in an academic department. has on this I've asked what people think about suggesting three short meetings. All with different people. None of whom I bully or manage. All of whom don't have to say yes and that's absolutely fine. I know these two students very well. No one can help you as you’ll do what you want to anyway.

KweenieBeanz · 11/09/2022 10:46

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 11/09/2022 10:22

Who exactly would perceive these people poorly?

Their managers. Who might feel pressured if senior staff want to hold a meeting. This is endemic in universities - senior academic staff want to do something, it sets a certain 'tone at the top' which then permeates. I'm quite surprised you don't understand this. I'm not saying they definitely will be perceived poorly - quite the reverse, more likely you will be - but a junior member of staff might worry that they could be, by saying no. So they put on a 'can-do attitude' and say yes, I can do it, I'll have to park the kids in front of the box or something but I'll make sure I join.....' or similar. Even though they rather wish they didn't have to.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 11/09/2022 10:37

Andromachehadabadday · 11/09/2022 10:23

So, you asked peoples opinions and if you would be unreasonable to this.

The majority tell you, you are. But you don’t want to accept that. So why ask?

You want people to give up their bank holiday, but won’t give up anytime of your own holiday. And again, you could phone these people and do a meeting. If it requires sharing data and presentations, it’s not going to be a quick meeting. But you still think, it’s ok for you to encroach on other people time off, but not your own. You can’t see the hypocrisy.

You are a SENIOR lecturer, but don’t understand that there’s a power imbalance between you and students? Really?

I do not want people to give up their bank holiday. I've never said that at all and have no idea why you think that.

I've asked what people think about suggesting three short meetings. All with different people. None of whom I bully or manage. All of whom don't have to say yes and that's absolutely fine. I know these two students very well.

I've asked people for opinions, yes. Does that mean I should simply accept all the comments as being correct? How does that work? As I've been misquoted so many times, I don't think so.

And, in fact, on the voting more people tell me I'm not being unreasonable. They just haven't commented.

OP posts:
Andromachehadabadday · 11/09/2022 10:23

So, you asked peoples opinions and if you would be unreasonable to this.

The majority tell you, you are. But you don’t want to accept that. So why ask?

You want people to give up their bank holiday, but won’t give up anytime of your own holiday. And again, you could phone these people and do a meeting. If it requires sharing data and presentations, it’s not going to be a quick meeting. But you still think, it’s ok for you to encroach on other people time off, but not your own. You can’t see the hypocrisy.

You are a SENIOR lecturer, but don’t understand that there’s a power imbalance between you and students? Really?

DelilahBucket · 11/09/2022 10:23

I'm self employed and so is DH. No work = no pay. I can still work, DH can't, so he loses a day's pay and there is naff all we can do about it 😔. Less money coming in really isn't what we need right now and companies who are struggling as it is having to pay everyone to have the day off is also not what we need in this country right now.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 11/09/2022 10:22

KweenieBeanz · 11/09/2022 08:38

You just don't get it though - you expressing willingness to work makes people feel they have to express that same willingness, too, or they will be perceived poorly. Why don't you understand that?

Who exactly would perceive these people poorly?

OP posts:
brookstar · 11/09/2022 10:20

Even those of us who work in HE and are senior academics are saying you're unreasonable......

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 11/09/2022 10:17

Andromachehadabadday · 11/09/2022 08:47

There absolutely is a power imbalance.

Unfortunately, you seem to be one of those people that don’t how their behaviour contributes to the toxic work environment

But everyone around you will.

If you say so. Seeing as you know so much about me, my colleagues and work environment, you must be absolutely correct.

OP posts:
ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 11/09/2022 10:14

KweenieBeanz · 11/09/2022 08:35

OP if you work in a role with any sort of involvement at all with Freshers week/start of term arrangements what on earth made you think the second week of September was an appropriate time to take leave 😳 I'm amazed you were allowed to take it then. Admissions staff don't take leave in Aug/Sept. And frankly if this stuff is so urgent it needs sorting Monday 19th or things will go tits up, you should have sorted it before you went on holiday, or put arrangements in place for others to sort.
Also you definitely can join a zoom on holiday. As others have said simply get colleagues to invite you with a link to your mobile phone, and ask them to share the documents by sharing screen on zoom. Your colleagues can invite you just as they would if they needed someone external to the university to join a call, it happens all the time with suppliers, outside agencies.
If that's not enough, these meetings aren't just 'quick zooms' that it's no big deal to ask people to join on Monday. If you can post on mumsnet you have WiFi and can join the zooms (at least some of them, rescheduled) this friday. You just don't want to!

Please don't presume to know what I do and don't want to do.

I always take these two weeks and have done for years. I work bloody hard in the weeks leading up to freshers week to ensure everything is planned, and come back to an organised plan that works. I don't have children and I want to be on holiday when schools are back. I also take leave around the middle of July for the same reason.

I'm not admissions staff, I'm a senior lecturer in an academic department.

OP posts:
DeadbeatYoda · 11/09/2022 09:42

I suspect you might be in the minority amongst university staff when it comes to saying no thanks to a day off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread