Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Say please

133 replies

slippe · 10/09/2022 15:01

I have a two and a half year old..

Some of our relatives have taken to asking her to ' say please ' before they give her water / a cookie / whatever it is.

They then refuse to give her whatever item it is, until she says 'please'. Except, she doesn't really say please. They end up dangling the item and refusing to give it to her. Eventually they sometimes give in. Sometimes she screams and cries. She's quite defiant.

I personally don't withhold items from her until she ' says please '. I remind her that we say please and then I remind her we say thank you. She sometimes complies, sometimes she doesn't.

I think manners are important, but I'm not really enjoying how my relatives are doing it.

Am I too lax or are they a bit ridiculous ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BeanieTeen · 11/09/2022 18:46

If you are the poster who does speech therapy, you have to remember you see kids who having trouble with speech, not the average.

This made me chuckle for some reason 😄is there an award for dumbest comment of the year? I nominate this one.

sjl123 · 11/09/2022 18:40

@Luredbyapomegranate how do you think speech and language therapists make a judgement as to whether a child is delayed? By having a sound understanding of typical childhood development.
But regardless a typical developing child or not my answers would remain the same to this. There is no benefit to the child to parrot back words for the benefit of the adult when they have no understanding of the meaning.
Please refrain from doubting my credentials I have worked in this field for many years and have two children with excellent language abilities AND manners. Because I practice what I preach.

Cupofteaonesugar · 11/09/2022 17:31

She's two for god sake!
At that age I would encourage her to say it and lead by example but you can't refuse to give her something because she won't use the word. How ridiculous. As they get older it gets easier, but there's not bargaining with a two year old!

Lunabun · 11/09/2022 17:30

NuffSaidSam · 10/09/2022 15:17

They're ridiculous.

Model the behaviour, remind her and she'll soon catch on.

A forced, bribed 'please' is of no value. Just like a forced, bribed 'sorry' is of no value.

Totally agree with this.

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 17:28

PlattyJubes · 11/09/2022 17:22

@Luredbyapomegranate - don't be so ridiculous and insulting. A Speech and Language Therapist doesn't need to remember anything. You'd be hard pushed to find a professional who has a greater understanding of 'normal' child development than a Speech and Language Therapist.

@PlattyJubes

In general I’d agree, but apparently not, if that PP is the speech and language therapist (which she might not be.)

I say this as someone who used to teach early years, so my knowledge of the average pre schooler’s speech development capabilities is pretty solid.

PlattyJubes · 11/09/2022 17:22

@Luredbyapomegranate - don't be so ridiculous and insulting. A Speech and Language Therapist doesn't need to remember anything. You'd be hard pushed to find a professional who has a greater understanding of 'normal' child development than a Speech and Language Therapist.

NuffSaidSam · 11/09/2022 17:21

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 17:13

They learn the good habit first and then the meaning comes.

The vast majority of kids can say pleas and thank you this fine from about 18 months. They don’t pronounce it right, but they can do their own take.

If you are the poster who does speech therapy, you have to remember you see kids who having trouble with speech, not the average.

But why is that better then them learning it once they know what it means?

What satisfaction are you, or any other adult, getting from a baby repeating a word you know they don't understand? Why do you need them to say it? You know they're not being polite, because for it to be polite they'd have to a) understand what it means and b) be choosing to say it (not being forced to say it in order to get what they want), so what value does it hold?

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 17:13

sjl123 · 11/09/2022 16:11

@Luredbyapomegranate but then the words are meaningless if they are just habit. By modelling the correct use of please and thank you a typically developing child will naturally copy and use it in the right situation when they are developmentally ready, rather than just being pressured to say a nonsense (to them) word to get their needs met. This way when they say their manners it's sincere which seems to be more important to people than the child's actual language skills.
This whole thread demonstrates a complete lack of understanding of how children's use and understanding of language develops. And more importantly how to encourage them to develop their language skills in an age appropriate way.

They learn the good habit first and then the meaning comes.

The vast majority of kids can say pleas and thank you this fine from about 18 months. They don’t pronounce it right, but they can do their own take.

If you are the poster who does speech therapy, you have to remember you see kids who having trouble with speech, not the average.

sjl123 · 11/09/2022 16:14

And actually I would say it's more about a development stage appropriate way. As all 2 year olds are not at the same level of development.

sjl123 · 11/09/2022 16:11

@Luredbyapomegranate but then the words are meaningless if they are just habit. By modelling the correct use of please and thank you a typically developing child will naturally copy and use it in the right situation when they are developmentally ready, rather than just being pressured to say a nonsense (to them) word to get their needs met. This way when they say their manners it's sincere which seems to be more important to people than the child's actual language skills.
This whole thread demonstrates a complete lack of understanding of how children's use and understanding of language develops. And more importantly how to encourage them to develop their language skills in an age appropriate way.

sjl123 · 11/09/2022 16:03

PlattyJubes · 11/09/2022 10:10

@sjl123 - so glad to hear you say this. I'm a retired Speech and language Therapist and one of my bugbears when working was watching parents or teachers demanding their toddlers say please or thankyou when they barely had a handful of words in their vocabulary.

My DC still became polite well mannered kids even without constant demands for please and thankyou. It's funny because there used to be a joke in my team at work that you could tell that a toddler had a parent who was a SLT by their advanced language but lack of constant pleases and thankyous 😁

Yes and the amount of times I've seen a child say or sign please but the adult have no idea what they want still, so the frustrations remain!

BeanieTeen · 11/09/2022 14:31

Because you are teaching them the habit of politeness that will be useful for life, at the age it’s easiest to teach it. You are also teaching them the first steps of interacting with other people, and the understanding that other people have needs as well as them.

I don’t think saying please teaches them anything about other people’s needs. It’s just something they learn they should say if they want something - that makes the whole thing very much about themselves.
I also think the OPs situation demonstrates that it’s really not the easiest time to teach children this. They are still learning to form sentences. ‘Can I have a drink?’ is pretty good going for a two year old and is perfectly polite. If you continue to model the ‘please’ yourself when you ask for things they will quickly catch on when they are ready to make sense of it. I really don’t understand creating such conflict and contention over a pretty meaningless word.
‘Thank you’ means something as an expression of gratitude. And I think young children can understand that.
’Please’ means fuck all of you really think about it. It’s just short for ‘if you please’ but that doesn’t add anything to what you’re saying. And it certainly doesn’t automatically add ‘politeness’ or bring out good manners. As previous posters said, whining ‘drink pleeaaase’ isn’t polite at all, but children mistakenly think (and some adults according to this thread) that tacking please into the end of a sentence automatically makes it polite or that they are then entitled to what they want.
As I said upthread, it’s not used half so much in other countries and some languages don’t even have a specific word for please. Or they just use ‘thank you’ or ‘pardon’ as a substitute where necessary. Seems like a massive fuss over nothing.

SirCharlesRainier · 11/09/2022 14:26

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 13:58

@SirCharlesRainier

You are being ageist and sloppy.

Saying that people in their late 40s are the rudest generation, ‘as any retail worker will tell you’ is untrue. Unless you’ve conducted a scientific survey of retail workers across the country, you can’t know this - you are purely talking about your personal experience and perhaps that of your friends / colleagues.

I used to work in retail and would say rudeness is pretty evenly spread, but both our personal experiences are purely anecdotal.

Generations have different ideas about manners. Children are now brought up differently. There are good and bad sides to this, and again it will vary from group to group. I don’t agree with the PP you were responding to that teens have bad social skills for example, but I think they are slower to learn good table manners (as eating has got much more casual, this isn’t surprising.)

Don’t make mad sweeping generalisations.

@Luredbyapomegranate

Sloppy - meh. I'm commenting on MN not contributing to a peer-reviewed journal.
And ageist, I'd say that's a bit over the top too.

But if my observations do count as sloppy ageism, does saying the "vast majority" of one's own generation have good manners compared to the "extremely bad manners" of many teens and 20somethings count too?

NuffSaidSam · 11/09/2022 14:12

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 14:07

Because you are teaching them the habit of politeness that will be useful for life, at the age it’s easiest to teach it. You are also teaching them the first steps of interacting with other people, and the understanding that other people have needs as well as them.

It’s the same as teaching your primary school kids not to expect endless sugary snacks, or your secondary school kids to build an exercise habit. Lots of snacks and no exercise probably won’t make them overweight or stiff at that age, but bad habits will catch them later on.

I disagree that it's easiest to teach something before they can really understand it. I think you'd actually have much greater success in explaining the importance of please and thank you to a slightly older child. Of course you should model it right from the start, but forcing it, withholding basic provisions until it is said is not in anyway necessary. There is no need to make an issue with a very young child.

I would expect a normally developing primary school child to have a basic understanding of nutrition and a normally developing secondary school child to have an understanding of why exercise is important.

NuffSaidSam · 11/09/2022 14:08

Stickmansmum · 11/09/2022 13:57

How dumb do you think kids are?

This is a strange question. But to answer it, I don't believe children are dumb. I do believe that there things they don't understand yet due to their developmental stage. I believe that is fact. Do you believe that babies are born with a full understanding of the world? I don't think there is any evidence to support that belief.

Maray1967 · 11/09/2022 14:07

But the dangling things in front of her is not on - knock that on the head right now, OP.

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 14:07

NuffSaidSam · 11/09/2022 13:55

But what's the point? What's the point of teaching them to say something if they don't know what it means? There's no value then is there?

Because you are teaching them the habit of politeness that will be useful for life, at the age it’s easiest to teach it. You are also teaching them the first steps of interacting with other people, and the understanding that other people have needs as well as them.

It’s the same as teaching your primary school kids not to expect endless sugary snacks, or your secondary school kids to build an exercise habit. Lots of snacks and no exercise probably won’t make them overweight or stiff at that age, but bad habits will catch them later on.

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 13:58

SirCharlesRainier · 11/09/2022 13:46

This is just rose-tinted spectacles. Although I'm sure you and your friends are lovely, I can assure you people of your age are amongst the very rudest in society, just ask any retail worker.

And they would have been just as rude at school, you just don't remember because people only tend to remember the good bits.

@SirCharlesRainier

You are being ageist and sloppy.

Saying that people in their late 40s are the rudest generation, ‘as any retail worker will tell you’ is untrue. Unless you’ve conducted a scientific survey of retail workers across the country, you can’t know this - you are purely talking about your personal experience and perhaps that of your friends / colleagues.

I used to work in retail and would say rudeness is pretty evenly spread, but both our personal experiences are purely anecdotal.

Generations have different ideas about manners. Children are now brought up differently. There are good and bad sides to this, and again it will vary from group to group. I don’t agree with the PP you were responding to that teens have bad social skills for example, but I think they are slower to learn good table manners (as eating has got much more casual, this isn’t surprising.)

Don’t make mad sweeping generalisations.

Stickmansmum · 11/09/2022 13:57

NuffSaidSam · 11/09/2022 13:55

But what's the point? What's the point of teaching them to say something if they don't know what it means? There's no value then is there?

How dumb do you think kids are?

ddl1 · 11/09/2022 13:56

YANBU. I don't think there's anything wrong with asking her to say please, but dangling things before her and not letting her have them until she says the word is bullying in a way, setting an example of rudeness rather than politeness, and not really teaching her the purpose of good manners, which is surely to make things pleasant for others, rather than to appease others into giving you something.

NuffSaidSam · 11/09/2022 13:55

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 13:47

Toddlers can be taught to say please and thank you before they understand what it means though, then it just becomes a habit.

But what's the point? What's the point of teaching them to say something if they don't know what it means? There's no value then is there?

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 13:47

sjl123 · 10/09/2022 22:14

Please and thank you are abstract words. I very much doubt the toddler understands what it means even if she can say it hence the refusing to say it. And I imagine in that moment where it is being withheld and she is becoming upset, she isn't purposefully refusing more her little mind hasn't got the theory of mind to think if I do this I get this.
Please and thank you are massively overemphasised, why don't we put emphasis on helping the child develop actually functional language thag ensures their wants and needs are Met. This will reduce any behaviours stemming from frustration. Then move on the abstract when they are developmentally ready. It's ridiculous in my opinion. Also model please and thank you and she will soon begin to do it without the pressure.

Im a speech and language therapist btw.

Toddlers can be taught to say please and thank you before they understand what it means though, then it just becomes a habit.

SirCharlesRainier · 11/09/2022 13:46

bloodyplanes · 11/09/2022 13:40

While i do understand that waving something around in front of a child and refusing to give it to them until they say please or thank you is not the right way to go about things i also don't believe the more " progressive" approach parents take now days really works either. I am in my late 40's so my manners and that of the vast majority of my generation are good, having been raised to always say please and thank you. I have 4 dc age range between late 20's to 18. I would say that so many of my dc friends have extremely bad manners and awful social skills! I worked at my eldest dc school for a while when they were small and the lack of decent manners ( and parents who smiled indulgently instead of enforcing them) astounded me! People may not say it to your face but they most certainly do judge you if you don't have good manners or you don't raise your children with good manners!

This is just rose-tinted spectacles. Although I'm sure you and your friends are lovely, I can assure you people of your age are amongst the very rudest in society, just ask any retail worker.

And they would have been just as rude at school, you just don't remember because people only tend to remember the good bits.

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/09/2022 13:45

Well they shouldn’t be dangling things in front of her, till she screams, that is weird and disruptive, and it is your job to discipline her not theirs.

However, at 2 and a a half she should be saying please and thank you as a matter of course. So you need to get on top of that.

So I would -

  • tell them it’s fine to remind her, but please stop winding her up - you are working on it.
        work on it
bloodyplanes · 11/09/2022 13:40

While i do understand that waving something around in front of a child and refusing to give it to them until they say please or thank you is not the right way to go about things i also don't believe the more " progressive" approach parents take now days really works either. I am in my late 40's so my manners and that of the vast majority of my generation are good, having been raised to always say please and thank you. I have 4 dc age range between late 20's to 18. I would say that so many of my dc friends have extremely bad manners and awful social skills! I worked at my eldest dc school for a while when they were small and the lack of decent manners ( and parents who smiled indulgently instead of enforcing them) astounded me! People may not say it to your face but they most certainly do judge you if you don't have good manners or you don't raise your children with good manners!

Swipe left for the next trending thread