Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools closed for the Queen’s funeral

855 replies

Notme1980 · 10/09/2022 11:09

First off, Queen Elizabeth II was an amazing ruler and an inspiration, we are a forces family and my husband has served her for 30 plus years.

but - I do not want the schools to be closed for her funeral (or for any reason at all), I want us to do what I believe she would have done, press on.

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:42

So your objection - as I have said before - is NIT about why the BH is happening, not about whether it us ‘worthy’ of a BH, not about how people spend it, but about the fact that a funeral BH is inevitably on an uncertain date.

WombatChocolate · 12/09/2022 09:42

I agree…..that the lack of notice and inability for people to plan ahead is what many are struggling with. I get that. But also, unlike Christmas or regular events or the one-off we know are coming years ahead, a death and funeral really can’t be planned for in terms of giving heaps of notice.

I guess that although the lack of notice is annoying many people and causing difficulties…in fact people in reality do understand, that there simply couldn’t have been a way to give longer notice of a funeral.

I also think that in reality, few people really think that a 70 year reign shouldn’t have a public holiday…that even those who aren’t monarchists can acknowledge that something key in society (if unimportant to themselves) has ended, and that for the nation as a whole it’s important.

These moans and groans about childcare etc tell me something about the change in society….and away from there being ‘society’ and a move towards a more individual world. Most still think community and society are important and that big national days like this funeral are important, but some people have lost that sense of community and society. Individualism reigns (haha…realise the pun) for them. It’s all about the personal impact on them and that’s all they can see or think about…for some it’s impossible to see a bigger picture or to think about anything other than their personal impact.

I suspect this is part of broader social trends which have been underway for several decades now. It’s also probably a function of the polarising of society. Significant sized groups feel increasingly marginalised, often as a result of their economic position. The cost of living crisis has put extra pressures on lots of people so that they are just about coping, but the idea of possibly losing a day of pay or having to find and pay for childcare just tips them over the edge when everything is so finely balanced. So the upset isn’t actually really about a national day or a Bank Holiday or a public day for a funeral of a 70 year monarch, but about the stresses in their own lives. Sadly, these stresses are very real and ongoing and likely to get worse. They aren’t caused by the Monarch but are part of wider societal problem of growing inequality and factors pushing people to the brink. And there’s no real answer in sight for any of them.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:37

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:35

Did you feel that the Jubilee BH prioritised the need to be part of history (or to celebrate something of historical note) over the actual needs of people?

Did the JBH get announced a week in advance and have consultation days and surgeries that needed to be moved, or was it planned for ages in advance?

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:35

Keep hospitals running like normal, keep schools open for those whose parents work in hospitals. If other employers want to open and work, say a restaurant, and they have willing staff, let them.

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:35

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:27

Actually my outcry is due to the fact the nation has prioritised the bizarre psychological need to be “part of history”, which essentially means watching TV day, over the actual needs of people.

Did you feel that the Jubilee BH prioritised the need to be part of history (or to celebrate something of historical note) over the actual needs of people?

Shinyandnew1 · 12/09/2022 09:32

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:20

But elective services don’t carry on in the NHS on normal public holidays. And people can plan in advance for them.

I believe it should be a partial public holiday with people given the option of taking if they want and essential services continuing.

That would have been mayhem. What counts as essential service?! Far simpler to have a Bank Holiday.

Phos · 12/09/2022 09:28

Why don't you want schools closed?

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:27

Actually my outcry is due to the fact the nation has prioritised the bizarre psychological need to be “part of history”, which essentially means watching TV day, over the actual needs of people.

CapMarvel · 12/09/2022 09:26

ElizabethBoland · 12/09/2022 09:23

Sure you don’t
Elective is called so for a reason. And no they aren’t.
Cheers

Clearly you don't have an actual argument to make. Toodlepip.

ElizabethBoland · 12/09/2022 09:23

Sure you don’t
Elective is called so for a reason. And no they aren’t.
Cheers

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:21

It seems clear - from the contrast between the out ry here and the non- outcry for the extra day for the Jubilee bank holiday (whether that was taken on the designated day or a separate occasion as schools did) that the main issue people are complaining about is the - inevitable - lack of notice.

A planned BH for an in many ways less important reason - a Royal wedding, a Jubilee - is ok.

An unplanned one fir a Royal state funeral is not.

I suppose the way I see it us that this day would have had to be taken at some point - the Queen would have died and had a funeral at some point - so this BH was always going to happen, we just didn’t know when. If we accept the ‘planned BH for Riyal celebrations’ without outcry, it’s clearly not aboit the lost learning or the day of no earnings. It us about the inconvenience of the - completely inevitable - lack of notice.

neverbeenskiing · 12/09/2022 09:21

Let the children watch the funeral (or the highlights, for God knows they won’t watch the whole thing, which will take HOURS on TV) in school, where they are looked after, warm and fed.

If your objection isn't about not wanting to be personally inconvenienced and you're actually just worried about children not being "looked after, warm and fed" surely you're far more concerned about the 6 weeks a year school is closed for the summer, 2 weeks at Christmas, 2 weeks at Easter, October half term, febuary half term, all the other bank holidays, inset days, not to mention even single evening and weekend rather than this one day. Perhaps we should be open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week 365 days a year so parents never have to take responsibility for feeding and supervising their own children?

If it is genuinely the case that children will come to significant as a direct result of being at home for an additional 6-7 hours then something has gone very wrong in our society and schools are not responsible for that.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:20

But elective services don’t carry on in the NHS on normal public holidays. And people can plan in advance for them.

I believe it should be a partial public holiday with people given the option of taking if they want and essential services continuing.

ElizabethBoland · 12/09/2022 09:19

100% agree

Shinyandnew1 · 12/09/2022 09:18

I’m amazed that anyone is actually surprised the Queen’s funeral is going to be a Bank Holiday. What did people seriously think would happen?!

CapMarvel · 12/09/2022 09:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

  1. Don't have multiple accounts, thanks.

  2. Elective procedures will be cancelled. This has already started happening.

Ta.

WombatChocolate · 12/09/2022 09:15

Are people suggesting it shouldn’t be a Bank Holiday and that the country should carry on as normal on the day of the Queen’s funeral? That it shouldn’t be a national and centrally decided day?

I fully get that there are consequences of choosing to have the Bank Holiday, and also like most things, they aren’t equally felt by all. But is there anyway to ever make a decision for something national, without there being winners and losers?

The government has decided that there are more benefits than costs of doing this. Many of the benefits might not be measurable benefits, but they think it is worth doing, even amongst the downsides which will exist.

You might be in one of the groups who feels they are not a ‘winner’ from this. Maybe your medical appt will be delayed. Maybe you will need to work still and need childcare. Maybe your firm will close and your contract is such that you won’t get paid. Do you think that these things mean it shouldn’t be a national day, and because of these individuals impacts, the funeral should happen on a ‘normal’ day? Do you think 70 years as Head of State shouldn’t be given a day, because of the difficulties it causes? I guess those are the questions really.

ElizabethBoland · 12/09/2022 09:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:12

If it were a Royal Wedding, no doubt there would be a holiday and schools closed and no-one would bat an eyelid.

When William and Kate got married the date was known about a long time in advance.

I don’t think people have any idea how difficult it is to move patients with a week’s notice. The manpower required to contact patients, the logistics of trying to find another time and date, the emotional toll on staff and patients, all for the sake of allowing people the chance of sitting at home watching the BBC drone on and on…”And now, the coffin makes its way from Westminster Hall, to Westminster Abbey. Tell me [studio guest], what are your memories of Her Majesty?”

CapMarvel · 12/09/2022 09:04

funtycucker · 12/09/2022 08:32

It's not privilege at all. You wouldn't get this much notice if schools were closed for extreme weather or power cuts. Same applies to the NHS. They have been many instances where procedures have been cancelled due to power failures or systems going down. You don't get notice for that. Just accept it's a bank holiday and move on

The difference being of course that we are choosing to shut down on the 19th rather than being forced to.

Some people will have procedures/operations/appointments they have been waiting months or years for.

Some people will lose a day's pay when - admittedly the blanket Queenwankcoverage has overtaken actual problems - there is a cost of living crisis.

Some people don't have child care because - like it or not schools do provide an essential childcare service to many.

It's easy to say "deal with it" when you are going to be able to smugly take a day off with no consequence, isn't it.

gogoinamercedes · 12/09/2022 08:57

Unfortunately, some of us have to work the day of the Queen's funeral - like it or lump it. Those who have children and may I say it - use the schools as a babysitting service - will get preference for time off. The rest of us, although we may not have young children or children of school age, have to work. My profession is not alone - nurses, Police et al. As other Mumsnetters have said, it is an historical event. If it were a Royal Wedding, no doubt there would be a holiday and schools closed and no-one would bat an eyelid.

Walkden · 12/09/2022 08:56

"That “worse for some” is cancer surgery being postponed, all because of “history”. People won’t get the healthcare they need because NHS staff will be at home watching the BBC give a minute-by-minute account of the location of a coffin"

As I've previously commented the NHS waiting list is not in the millions because of two extra bank holidays this year. People on this thread get very indignant on this thread on the minor causes of delays and ignore major ones

Like it or not the government decide things all the time for the greater good which means someone else suffers. Prevaccines we sent kids back to school because it was important but some school staff got long covid or died, some kids lost parents or grandparents and yes a few key died as a result.

Now the government have decided a bank holiday to commemorate the queen Is worth kids missing a school day ( and we know how vital they repeatedly said it was this didn't happen) people missing NHS appointments, whether that be cancer scans or something else.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 08:53

And of course that’s annoying and yes of course, like any other NHS delay (which is regular) it can have impacts on health. This is what happens when extreme weather hits and when staff illness prevent services happening and all kinds of other things which occur far more regularly than once in 70 years.

It’s incredibly trivialising to say it’s merely “annoying”. It will be life affecting for many. And as I pointed out above, unforeseen impacts that make proceeding physically difficult or impossible are not anywhere near the same as “people want the day off to watch a coffin being driven around London”.

It’s not a macro decision if it affects hundreds of thousands of people. And Christmas Day is the same day every bloody year, so it’s not like stuff is ever booked in then postponed on the 15th of December is it? 🙄

It’s happening, but it’s not too late to keep the health services out of it.

LifesTooShortForYourNonsense · 12/09/2022 08:53

The whole plan as to what will happen has been published for many years, so yes you are unreasonable to question it now.

WombatChocolate · 12/09/2022 08:46

Emergency services will continue on Monday. Many other businesses will continue to operate (which incidentally will upset many who feel they are missing out on the event or a day off)

It will be routine things which are delayed. And of course that’s annoying and yes of course, like any other NHS delay (which is regular) it can have impacts on health. This is what happens when extreme weather hits and when staff illness prevent services happening and all kinds of other things which occur far more regularly than once in 70 years.

I fully get that the closure will upset and annoy and inconvenience some people. No-one denies that…but at the same time, that doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be a Bank Holiday. It’s not a question of it benefitting the privileged. It’s a question of recognising a historic moment and the nation having the opportunity to choose to engage or not. Whether people acknowledge and value that moment is a matter for personal choice, but a Bank Holiday has to be a macro decision.

Many people don’t celebrate Christmas or enjoy it. Services are reduced then too. It inconveniences some and annoys some. No doubt, some people’s health deteriorates over Christmas. These things don’t mean Christmas shouldn’t be a Bank Holiday. And this is very similar.

And it’s happening. People can accept it and make the most of it, or they can spend the day feeling bitter and annoyed. That’s their choice.