Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools closed for the Queen’s funeral

855 replies

Notme1980 · 10/09/2022 11:09

First off, Queen Elizabeth II was an amazing ruler and an inspiration, we are a forces family and my husband has served her for 30 plus years.

but - I do not want the schools to be closed for her funeral (or for any reason at all), I want us to do what I believe she would have done, press on.

OP posts:
forinborin · 12/09/2022 11:57

I understand the importance of the occasion, but as a day rate temp staff it just means that I cannot invoice my client for a bank holiday, but will have to work unpaid regardless as no one moves the project delivery deadlines, obviously. Plus one more day of emergency childcare at £150.

Ithinkthatisenoughnowthanks · 12/09/2022 11:55

My issue is the privileged refusing to see why this is an issue

I think all the teachers that have posted here are more than able to understand that school closures at short notice may cause problems for a number of their parents. I also think we are capable of understanding our relative priviledge compared with many of the children we teach and the financial state of the homes they come from given that we too are impacted by the cost of living crisis and indeed, our wages have depreciated considerably in real terms since 2010. Many of us are feeding children on a regular basis from our own pockets and many schools are collecting and distributing uniform as well as washing it for some children. And that's despite our own personal circumstances which, in some cases, are really not good.

I get that closing on one additional day, at short notice, will exacerbate the issues mentioned above in some households. But opening won't solve those issues either and, frankly, it isn't the responsiblity of schools to somehow manage the cost of living for it's students and their families. We have been told to close. If you don't like it, complain to the government.

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 11:17

Bank holidays as a whole aren't that equitable in the way they work, so of course a very short notice one, however unavoidable it might have been, is going to be a problem for many people.

I completely agree. The only issue I have with this thread is the demand that schools and their employees should be the ones required to mitigate the problem.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 12/09/2022 10:59

I'm not saying we shouldn't have a BH but the privileged saying 'ffs it is just one day have some respect ' would do well to realise their privileged and that others are not.

Yes, exactly this. I say this as one of the privileged who does get them off work.

Bank holidays as a whole aren't that equitable in the way they work, so of course a very short notice one, however unavoidable it might have been, is going to be a problem for many people. It's not actually a very big deal to not argue against something that's so blatantly obvious.

EssentialGarage · 12/09/2022 10:36

My issue is the privileged refusing to see why this is an issue.

We are in the biggest cost of living crisis (which has conveniently been forgotten/put on hold)

Either businesses have to pay an extra holiday or people have to take it unpaid, where is this money coming from?
It isn't as easy as staying open as all businesses are connected. When the supplier closes it is impossible for the customer to continue.

Regards it happens for the weather, I've never known a full UK wide closure due to weather.

I'm not saying we shouldn't have a BH but the privileged saying 'ffs it is just one day have some respect ' would do well to realise their privileged and that others are not.

MoveMore · 12/09/2022 10:31

I don’t understand why some are complaining that it’s a lack of notice siting two years notice was provided for the Jubilee. It’s a funeral! How exactly was more notice suppose to be provided for that?!

Regardless of personal feelings around the monarchy we all live in a constitutional monarchy system of govt and our head has just died. It seems entirely appropriate to make that a national holiday. It’s also been left as always at discretion of employers as to how that actually works and doesn’t not mean every business has to close (and clearly many people police nhs care staff the list is long!) will be working as normal.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 10:28

You have not extended your offer of childcare to teachers, who would then face their own challenges as many have children themselves.

Yep, same for teachers. Include them as well.

You are asking schools to break their contractual obligations to their staff - whose contracts allow them BH

If you can announce a BH a week in advance, why can’t there be special employment rules announced for it too?

Consider - had Covid not happened, with schools stepping in to fill so many of the gals this opened up, from food to social service intervention to health to childcare - would you EVER have suggested this?

Of course. Covid just demonstrated the need to come up with a workable system that allowed healthcare workers to keep going. Covid demonstrated the impact of short term decisions on long term health, making this even more important. We know that patients had care delayed, and that impacted long term outcomes for non-Covid illnesses, and that was when dealing with the strain of a pandemic. But this is self- inflicted pain because it’s been deemed important staff get the day off because of “history”.

EssentialGarage · 12/09/2022 10:27

non- outcry for the extra day for the Jubilee bank holiday

There was loads orf outcry when it was first announced as people had things planned for the bank holiday Monday.

wentworthinmate · 12/09/2022 10:22

TeenDivided · 10/09/2022 11:16

I would think it highly inappropriate if they kept them open.

This.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 10:21

Shinyandnew1 · 12/09/2022 10:07

It’s a Bank Holiday-schools are closed, you just need to accept that. Expecting them to open on a Bank Holiday is not going to happen.

I accept it’s going to happen and nothing I say or do will change anything.

But it would be nice if people examined their bizarre need to be “part of history” - which if everyone was honest with themselves will really just be most of the nation sat in front of the telly bored witless for hours - means that there will be a very real impact on people who were relying on that day.

Yes, it’s only one day. But for the hundreds of thousands of people with appointments for that day, it’s important and will be much more than an “inconvenience”.

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 10:18

So it’s unreasonable and entitled to ask schools to do what they were always going to be doing until Friday? I’m not suggesting they do anything extra, just do what they were always going to be doing on the 19th of September up until a few days ago, carry on like normal.

It cannot be ‘like normal’ when you only have the children of some NHS workers in school - it is childcare pure and simple.

You have not extended your offer of childcare to teachers, who would then face their own challenges as many have children themselves.

You are asking schools to break their contractual obligations to their staff - whose contracts allow them BH.

Consider - had Covid not happened, with schools stepping in to fill so many of the gals this opened up, from food to social service intervention to health to childcare - would you EVER have suggested this? It seems to me that the more schools take on to paper over the cracks in society and in other services, the more is expected and taken for granted,

IhateHermioneGranger · 12/09/2022 10:10

Are the ones complaining that children should be at school also are the ones that book term time holidays and take their kids away? 🤔

WombatChocolate · 12/09/2022 10:08

People are inconsistent in their thoughts about this.

Some want a paid day off work, but also want all services up and running….without thinking about the fact those workers then need to work.

They forget that other people want something else. Lots are being told they will need to work, but they feel ‘cheated’ when others are having the day off.

People complain about the sudden nature and lack of time to plan ahead…..but everyone knows deaths and funerals don’t give advance notice.

People have all kinds of elaborate and complex hybrid suggestions of undivudyals and businesses choosing if to be open or not, or certain services being prioritised ….without thinking really about those workers.

Essentially, lots of people really only see it all from their own point of view and what works for them. They don’t spit that it’s impossible to please everyone on this and a central decision has to happen.

Honestly, it’s a ‘one-off’ in its lack of notice nature. The last one like this was 1965. Charles is likely to live 20 years or more. There won’t be another short notice one for another 20 years. Spare a thought for the countless individuals who will have worked 50+ hrs already putting together plans to make the Monday happen and who will work 100+ hrs before the funeral to make it all happen. But of course, lots of people can only think about themselves and the personal impact and have zero interest in anyone else.

HappyHappyHermit · 12/09/2022 10:08

I think a lot of parents will appreciate being able to have their children at home with them on a day that, for many across the world, is considered quite a momentous occasion. I do appreciate how hard it is to work everything out last minute as we've had to do so ourselves on several occasions, but it would be wrong for them not to close for the day in this case.

Shinyandnew1 · 12/09/2022 10:07

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 10:03

So it’s unreasonable and entitled to ask schools to do what they were always going to be doing until Friday? I’m not suggesting they do anything extra, just do what they were always going to be doing on the 19th of September up until a few days ago, carry on like normal.

It’s a Bank Holiday-schools are closed, you just need to accept that. Expecting them to open on a Bank Holiday is not going to happen.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 10:03

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:57

Schools, under the exceptional circumstances of Covid, became childcare for essential workers, including during holidays. They did so as part of their contribution to a national emergency.

To therefore expect that they will continue to provide this service - adding it on to all of the other health , nutrition and social care responsibilities they have already taken on over the years in addition to their core education role - is obviously unreasonable and smacks of entitlement.

So it’s unreasonable and entitled to ask schools to do what they were always going to be doing until Friday? I’m not suggesting they do anything extra, just do what they were always going to be doing on the 19th of September up until a few days ago, carry on like normal.

eastegg · 12/09/2022 09:59

Walkden · 11/09/2022 19:53

"Let's hope the health care professionals, emergency services workers, law enforcers and food infrastructure workers who take care of us will be able find childcare while everyone else watches the TV"

The hysteria around this is ridiculous. If we really gave a fuck about healthcare workers we would give them payrises, take steps to fill the enormous vacancies resulting in the enormous pressure they are under. Similarly many courts were sold, legal aid slashed finally resulting in a barristers strike. We'd also not support real term pay cuts for the key workers that "take care of us"

None of these causes the wailing the government closing schools for a single day for the monarch's funeral has on this thread.

Thanks for posting this as I’ve been thinking similar.

The terrible underfunding of legal aid and the problems which have reached crisis point in terms of cases having to wait years to reach a conclusion and barristers leaving the criminal bar, for example, have been building up for decades and have been in the news if people care to take an interest. Generally, though, they don’t seem to give a toss, and that indifference is exploited by the government and the problems get worse.

So forgive me for being just a tiny bit cynical when, for example, a poster says they are heartbroken about a pps tribunal client whose case is going to have to be adjourned. I wonder if that same poster has been coming out in support of the barristers during their recent strikes? Hmmm. (I’m using this issue as an example because it’s the one I have a particular interest in, but you could make the same argument about the NHS I suppose).

Seems to me there’s a lot of cherry picking here, people using issues to have a pop at the RF.

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:57

Schools, under the exceptional circumstances of Covid, became childcare for essential workers, including during holidays. They did so as part of their contribution to a national emergency.

To therefore expect that they will continue to provide this service - adding it on to all of the other health , nutrition and social care responsibilities they have already taken on over the years in addition to their core education role - is obviously unreasonable and smacks of entitlement.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:55

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:51

In any ‘long term plan fir Bank Holidays’, though, an extra one fir the Queen’s funeral was inevitable, just of unknown date. There would inevitably have been one day of inconvenience - just nobody knew when it would be.

There’s that word again, “inconvenience”. It’s not “inconvenient” to have potentially life saving/changing surgery postponed, particularly because it’s been deemed more important that people watch a ceremony on TV.

The patient is ready.
The surgeon is free.
The theatre is free.
There has been no natural disaster.
There is still power to the building.
There are plenty of staff.

But the Queen’s coffin is on the move between 10am and 11am, so sorry for the inconvenience!

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:52

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:48

Why is it that schools have the responsibility to provide that childcare? Would you also say that nurseries with pre-school children of NHS staff also have to open and oay their staff BH rates?

If a hospital chose to, could it hire / borrow a venue - even a school hall - and employ childcare professionals, sports coaches or even volunteers to offer care from 9-3? That way, the childcare could be provided for those who wanted to to work?

Because it’s school, and kids are school age. It’s like Covid lockdowns. Yes, child care should also keep going for NHS staff.

Why can’t normal child care services just keep going on that day? How does it help the NHS function if it has to somehow become a child care provider with a week’s notice too?

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:51

In any ‘long term plan fir Bank Holidays’, though, an extra one fir the Queen’s funeral was inevitable, just of unknown date. There would inevitably have been one day of inconvenience - just nobody knew when it would be.

NoAprilFool · 12/09/2022 09:48

Abraxan · 11/09/2022 22:19

My daughters school was in on 29 August. Pretty sure they were in on the May holiday too.
*
NoAprilFool*

Where does your child go to school?
In England schools do not open on bank holidays.

Scotland.

cantkeepawayforever · 12/09/2022 09:48

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:35

Keep hospitals running like normal, keep schools open for those whose parents work in hospitals. If other employers want to open and work, say a restaurant, and they have willing staff, let them.

Why is it that schools have the responsibility to provide that childcare? Would you also say that nurseries with pre-school children of NHS staff also have to open and oay their staff BH rates?

If a hospital chose to, could it hire / borrow a venue - even a school hall - and employ childcare professionals, sports coaches or even volunteers to offer care from 9-3? That way, the childcare could be provided for those who wanted to to work?

MishaBukvic · 12/09/2022 09:47

We're letting our heating engineers have the day off.

I've had the horrible job of ringing their customers to re-arrange the appointments they had on 19th September.

60% of the customers were fine, they understood why we were rearranging their appointments. 40% gave me hassle and vitriol . It's like this 40% expect to have the day off but don't expect anyone else to have the day off! It's not a jolly holiday, we're not slacking off for the sake of it.

NotBadConsidering · 12/09/2022 09:43

The Jubilee Bank Holiday was announced two years beforehand:

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/extra-bank-holiday-to-mark-the-queens-platinum-jubilee-in-2022

So I’m pretty confident there was adequate time to make sure patients weren’t impacted like they will be next Monday.