Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Work full time with teens?

378 replies

HappyKoala56 · 10/09/2022 10:24

AIBU to consider a full time job with a teen and pre-teen (13 and 11)? How do other ft working parents manage with kids of these sort of ages? They are ok to stay home on their own for short times and neither are anxious with this, but it would mean 2 hours on their own after school until I get home which feels like a lot. And then what do I do in school holidays? It's a long time to be by themselves, but they don't appreciate all day clubs. I feel stuck in this middle ground of they are too old for childcare but too young for prolonged periods on their own. What does everyone do?
For context I don't HAVE to work ft, hence why I'm not sure if iabu. I have my own business and work part time currently, but I have put all career progression on hold for the past 14 years to be around for the kids and I'm eager to get back on working on myself. Do I leave it another year or 2?
YABU - stay home longer
YANBU - go get that job!

OP posts:
sheepdogdelight · 12/09/2022 10:28

Goldenbear · 12/09/2022 10:18

It is hilarious that posters don't even have teenagers and are predicting what it will be like and how they will be quids in- you literally don't have a clue whereas I have had toddlers, gave up my salary but it is still more expensive !

And other people, like me, who do have teenagers, are saying that your experience is not the same as theirs. I totally agree some of what you spend is most definitely "keeping up with the Jones'" but you have, I guess chosen to live where you do and for your child to mix with the people she does.
Even within "the norm" there are variations - I totally agree secondary age DC need a laptop for school, but it doesn't have to be new and top end. My DC have managed school work with comparatively cheap reconditioned ones.

I'd also suggest it would be the norm in your area for people to do lots of activities with their toddlers, buy more expensive clothing, go on more expensive days out (rather than local playground) etc. So I'm not sure you are comparing like with like, as you've rather dismissed the idea that toddlers cost much at all outside of childcare.

I think the question is not really "do I as an individual spend more on my teenager than I did my toddler" but more "are average toddler costs more than average teenager costs?". And of course there are variations both ways. If you had family childcare and all your baby/toddler clothes/toys/other items were from Freegle, and you never went anywhere apart from the local walking distance park, your teenager is going to cost more even if you do nothing apart from give them basic food and clothing.

Goldenbear · 12/09/2022 10:18

It is hilarious that posters don't even have teenagers and are predicting what it will be like and how they will be quids in- you literally don't have a clue whereas I have had toddlers, gave up my salary but it is still more expensive !

Goldenbear · 12/09/2022 10:11

People who use insults as arguments are usually lacking in intellect as they don't have the capacity to articulate their argument- of course paid childcare is discretionary- it is optional to use it no one is forcing you to do so and if you have no subsidises, you are obviously earning enough for it to be a choice. Forgoing a full-time salary is max 2.5 years and this completely contextual as it might be worth that I.e cheaper in the long run if as a family the earning potential of one of the parent's earnings are limited in tjje longterm due to having to share childcare commitments in the early years. Of course, there are a number of different contexts people are operating in so it may not be the case at all but it is simply untrue that categorically early years is more expensive than teenage years- not in our case.

These aren't discretionary costs in the context we live in. We had to buy laptops for both DC for secondary, that's not lifestyle or discretionary, it's a must for GCSEs, sane with a guitar for music GCSE! Ok, so no phone, no social life, no sports, no activities, no clothes, they aren't all branded in my DS's case they go to retro markets to buy second hand. These are things my eldest has for a life with his peers, it's no less a choice than childcare is for you as these things are needed for him to occupy himself in the holidays for example. It is the equivalent of paying for a summer holiday club. The phone allows him to organise the meet ups, the money for food out and about is needed or he'd starve, an activity could be swimming in the sea but he needs bus fare to get there, the activity could be going to a clothes market, money for the clothes he needs anyway as he has grown another 2 inches!

I went to guides although hated it by 12 and left, I went to the library as well but you are being disingenuous by making out this generation of teens frequent the library regularly- school one, yes, maybe.

It just baffles me that people cannot comprehend that people are living in different contexts- if my son wants to keep his friends, friendship being quite important for teenage development as opposed to very young children where they don't have a concept of friendship, then these things aren't fucking discretionary!

All those activities listed for a teenager run by council by a PP would not even cost £2-5 where I live. It is way more expensive to live in some parts of the country than others so there is 'no' categorical statement that can be made about what life is more expensive- it completely depends on context!

Tomorrowisalatterday · 12/09/2022 08:41

I begin to think @Goldenbear 's full time role must be something like tabloid journalist, given the ability to twist things and create strawmen.

For the last time: parenting a toddler has as totally non discretionary either spending £1000/month minimum (more like £1400 in London) on childcare or giving up a salary (similar minimum but obviously depends on how much you earn. What you spend on your teenagers' activities is discretionary - you can choose to spend a lot or a little. I genuinely feel sorry for teenagers raised by someone too thick to understand that

theveg · 12/09/2022 08:06

Goldenbear you are being utterly ridiculous and insulting to people who use library books, go to scouts and buy clothes from supermarkets.

I ticked all those boxes as teen (well guides) and know plenty of teens who do too.

If ever there was a time to use the cringe phrase "check your privilege".......

Goldenbear · 12/09/2022 07:53

Childcare fulltime at full rate is arguably discretionary as if you have no subsidises, no help then you are earning enough to make that choice to work. Compared to when my 15 year old was a baby there is more help!

If you think it is a ridiculous notion then you have to understand that teenagers and their associated costs are not discretionary and it as ridiculous s suggesting that you can persude your teenagers to continue to wear clothes from supermarkets- even if you can, to stunt their growth by eating like a toddler so you don't have to pay for rapidly changing costs of clothing sizes that incidentally you have to also pay VAT on , to not socialise, not have any technology for studying aswell as communication with peers, go to a school that doesn't have a uniform, finish school at 16 and have an apprenticeship as cheaper than 6th form and uni, be happy to spend their time reading library books!

Jaaxe · 12/09/2022 07:49

Hastingsontheup · 12/09/2022 05:32

Interestingly the local authority think it's either more difficult or more expensive to care for teenagers......

Is this for foster children? Because if it is you are really clutching at straws….

The cost and difficulty of a child in care is a completely different ball game

deedledeedledum · 12/09/2022 07:37

Hastingsontheup · 12/09/2022 05:32

Interestingly the local authority think it's either more difficult or more expensive to care for teenagers......

Duh. That's because foster carers don't pay for childcare. They are the childcare. Add in childcare costs and it's not even a competition

Tomorrowisalatterday · 12/09/2022 06:59

Hastingsontheup · 12/09/2022 05:32

Interestingly the local authority think it's either more difficult or more expensive to care for teenagers......

That's because they are not expecting you to use childcare for under 5s

Hastingsontheup · 12/09/2022 05:32

Interestingly the local authority think it's either more difficult or more expensive to care for teenagers......

Work full time with teens?
MichaelAndEagle · 11/09/2022 21:15

TheMoth · 11/09/2022 20:30

There was no way we could have saved for uni when the kids were toddlers. Nursery fees were the equivalent of one of our wages. Childcare for the remaining dc in primary school is 400quid a month.

I didn't actual think I'd have to save for uni- I thought the loan + part time job would cover them. Looks like I may the first and last person in my entire family to go to uni then. Unless the l
Kids go local.

Other option is they have a year at home working to save up before they go.
Might be something mine will have to do.

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 20:56

TheMoth · 11/09/2022 20:30

There was no way we could have saved for uni when the kids were toddlers. Nursery fees were the equivalent of one of our wages. Childcare for the remaining dc in primary school is 400quid a month.

I didn't actual think I'd have to save for uni- I thought the loan + part time job would cover them. Looks like I may the first and last person in my entire family to go to uni then. Unless the l
Kids go local.

i wouldn’t worry, I would imagine kids who go to the local uni do just as well as if they studied further away they probably just don’t get the whole uni experience of living away from home for the first time with their peers.

pickledpotato · 11/09/2022 20:38

TheMoth · 11/09/2022 20:30

There was no way we could have saved for uni when the kids were toddlers. Nursery fees were the equivalent of one of our wages. Childcare for the remaining dc in primary school is 400quid a month.

I didn't actual think I'd have to save for uni- I thought the loan + part time job would cover them. Looks like I may the first and last person in my entire family to go to uni then. Unless the l
Kids go local.

Depending on your salary you should save for uni

As your child's entitlements to financial support will be based on that

TheMoth · 11/09/2022 20:30

And there's no way we can save now.

TheMoth · 11/09/2022 20:30

There was no way we could have saved for uni when the kids were toddlers. Nursery fees were the equivalent of one of our wages. Childcare for the remaining dc in primary school is 400quid a month.

I didn't actual think I'd have to save for uni- I thought the loan + part time job would cover them. Looks like I may the first and last person in my entire family to go to uni then. Unless the l
Kids go local.

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 20:25

Goldenbear · 11/09/2022 20:12

Yes, probably if you are having to save for uni accommodation costs and considering what a short time you spend over a £1000 a month for that level of childcare as opposed to the 7 years of having a teenager costs!

People with toddlers could be saving for their child’s uni fees too?? That’s not something that has to be spent per month during the teenage years that’s a long term cost….I thought we were talking based per month? Obviously they’re teenagers for longer that’s not a fair comparison of what people spend on a toddler compared to a teen 🤷‍♀️

luxxlisbon · 11/09/2022 20:14

I love the dramatic comparisons! Teenagers “need” multiple pairs of trendy brand trainers, 100s of pounds of hobbies, hair cuts every 3 months minimum, money for socialising etc and toddlers need nappies and a bit of food.
Its comparing a luxury teenager lifestyle to an absolute bare bones toddler lifestyle, hardly a useful comparison.
Seriously £100 a month for everything a toddler needs when you are saying multiple pairs of expensive trainers is an absolute necessity for teens? Ignoring toddlers grow out of clothes and shoes at a rapid rate. Never fit clothes from the previous season, go up in car seat sizes, need a buggy, eat way more than about £30 a month for a balanced diet, also need their hair cut, also have birthdays and want scooters/bikes/toys etc.

Goldenbear · 11/09/2022 20:12

Yes, probably if you are having to save for uni accommodation costs and considering what a short time you spend over a £1000 a month for that level of childcare as opposed to the 7 years of having a teenager costs!

Jaaxe · 11/09/2022 19:53

Come off it, do teenagers actually cost over a grand a month, every month, per teenager? Because that’s how much nursery fees cost for one child, EVERY month….JUST THE CHIlDCARE…that’s not even including other essentials like nappies, food, milk, clothing, shoes, equipment and everything else toddlers need never mind the non essentials like taking them out places (which I’m not sure why people are saying it’s ok to palm toddlers off and to not do anything with them but teens you absolutely cannot say no to 🤷‍♀️🤣)

MissyB1 · 11/09/2022 19:52

luckylavender · 11/09/2022 18:37

Millions of people work FT with teens.

Yes, lots probably have no choice though. I believe the OP said that financially she did have a choice.
I think it’s good to hear different views and experiences of working full time with teens. I honestly believe until you’ve had teens it is hard to comprehend how much they still us.

Goldenbear · 11/09/2022 19:30

Yes and I am one of them, the derailment point was the one I was discussing- hilarious that toddlers cost more with their clothes- even logically speaking they are very small people so the cost of material is next to nothing, they don't care what they are wearing (so you can fob them off with supermarket t-shirts and theyybdoont care) whereas for a teenager, more often than not, it is an expression of who you are and what tribe you hang out with, this is developmentally very normal, well it is with all the teenagers I know and that is probably many more than PP with young children demonstrating not an ounce of a clue about teenagers. I have had toddlers so I actually do know the difference between the two!

luckylavender · 11/09/2022 18:37

Millions of people work FT with teens.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 11/09/2022 18:33

Lol, I give up at the point where different socks for school and home are counted as a vital expense for a teen but a toddler doesn't need anything...

Goldenbear · 11/09/2022 18:25

Soft play is not even expensive, bikes, scooters pushchairs even i could get those all for free where I live as people give pass that stuff on to green around here. Extra curricular clubs are arguably discretionary for infants, what toddler has to do baby yoga or have to be instructed on playing an instrument as the most they can manage is banging a drum or shaking a rattle. The enrichment is necessary for development but it can be achieved for free, the same developmental need for enrichment is not going to be achieved for free with a teenager. Equally, even well made shoes aren't comparably expensive and of course 11+ are still growing and can grow very quickly

I am not sure many 15 year olds are happy with the social life that comes with Scouts - it really proves your references are around young children and don't have a clue!

Childcare at it's most expensive before subsidies is about the a 2 year length not comparable with the teenage years. Contextually, even forgoing my income for those 2 years was cheaper for us as the long term earning potentially of my DH as a qualified Architect would have been missed out on if he couldn't have completed his qualification and work.

Again, context is key to this, my DDs haircut is at Supercuts so cheap but still £26.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 11/09/2022 18:22

I had a look at our local youth club which offers martial arts/art/football/music classes for teens for between £2 and £5 a time. I appreciate this is area dependent but I don't think your average teenager is doing multiple £150/term activities