Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think everyone loves traditions/culture unless it is our own? (UK)

138 replies

vitahelp · 10/09/2022 09:54

This week has made me wonder about the above. I find so many people appreciate and enjoy tradition and culture when they are travelling overseas, but back in the UK will declare it outdated and embarrassing.

Things such as religion and places of worship are almost romanticised when abroad in certain countries, but back here are considered ridiculous by many. And I can’t help but think if we were watching from afar at a country who had just lost their Queen, the same people who are moaning this week would find it quite beautiful that people were wearing black and events were cancelled.

Is it just me who finds that culture and tradition are appreciated until they are on our doorstep?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 11:01

thefoggiest · 10/09/2022 10:41

YANBU. God is ridiculed as a big sky fairy, except when we're talking about non Christian religions, at which point the tone is one of deference.

Flags are racist, except when we go on holiday to France where they're all over the place and that looks nice.

To aspire to a mono cultural society is knuckle dragging, except when we go on holiday to Italy or Greece, where we'd be gutted to find anything other than an untouched 1950s postcard world with only Italian and Greek restaurants.

Any religion should be discussed - and not treated with deference just because it's not Christian.

We do live in a country where Christianity is the State Religion (not many countries have a state religion) so it's reasonable that this should be discussed - especially at a time when more and more people are secular. Yet Christianity still has a massive hold in this country.

Flags is interesting - I know that the French flag is everywhere in France on public buildings. Along with the EU flag as well.

Some of our traditions - especially around Christianity and the State should be discussed. When we have the Coronation, I bet God will feature heavily.

Which is why I can't take it seriously.

NoodleSnow · 10/09/2022 11:00

I think it’s reasonable for many British people to be uncomfortable with the idea of unquestioning pride in British traditions and institutions. History is complicated and much of it is ugly, particularly when you look at how the behaviour of our ancestors continues to drive global inequalities.
That doesn’t mean we have to throw away all our traditions, but it would be odd not to feel uncomfortable about some of them and question whether they might be inappropriate now.

jetadore · 10/09/2022 11:00

No I think people uncritically accept traditions in their own culture without considering the meanings behind them. Think India and the caste system and UK celebrating the torture and execution of a catholic every November, the Netherlands and “black Peter”, fgm, honour killings, ….

People are (mostly) ignorant and respectful of traditions and cultures they don’t know so will be less likely to challenge them/appear to be more accepting of them.

senua · 10/09/2022 10:57

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 10:34

But when it comes to our own rituals we proclaim they're old fashioned, embarrassing and should be binned

Have you got some examples that are to do specifically with the UK?

Morris dancing.
Other peoples' traditional dances are seen as interesting, a manifestation of their culture. But morris dancing here is seen as an embarrassment. Abroad is "historic", here is "old fashioned".
It may be an English thing. The Welsh are allowed their Eisteddfod and the Scots their Ceilidh but the English are derided for their historic culture.

Funkyblues101 · 10/09/2022 10:53

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 10:34

But when it comes to our own rituals we proclaim they're old fashioned, embarrassing and should be binned

Have you got some examples that are to do specifically with the UK?

Morris dancing. Maypole dancing (for fair maidens - obviously cute when it's the primary school kiddiwinkies). Travelling minstrels. Barn dancing in England now usually called ceilidhs (sp?).

Janie94 · 10/09/2022 10:51

Agree OP

vitahelp · 10/09/2022 10:50

Slightly different but I also know of people who hope not to be recognised as English when abroad because it’s such an embarrassment. It is usually due to not wanting to be associated with football hooligans or drunks abroad, as though no other country has those.

OP posts:
vitahelp · 10/09/2022 10:48

Slushycuppa · 10/09/2022 10:42

I think if you go abroad, you see the people from those countries have similarly abandoned the traditions of their own culture and counties. For instance you don't see many people in Japan wearing Kimonos in day to day life. But I'm sure they love to come over to the UK and watch the trooping of the colour etc.

We have plenty of traditions in this country that are secular and that people still enjoy.

@Slushycuppa Very good point. What I’m describing probably happens in all countries.

OP posts:
ScotsWhaHae77 · 10/09/2022 10:46

In my experience this applies more to English culture. In Scotland, at least where I am, a lot of Scottish culture still upheld, enjoyed and celebrated with no embarrassment.

vitahelp · 10/09/2022 10:44

thefoggiest · 10/09/2022 10:41

YANBU. God is ridiculed as a big sky fairy, except when we're talking about non Christian religions, at which point the tone is one of deference.

Flags are racist, except when we go on holiday to France where they're all over the place and that looks nice.

To aspire to a mono cultural society is knuckle dragging, except when we go on holiday to Italy or Greece, where we'd be gutted to find anything other than an untouched 1950s postcard world with only Italian and Greek restaurants.

@thefoggiest A much better explanation than mine and captures exactly what I was attempting to explain.

OP posts:
MissWired · 10/09/2022 10:43

It's not our original religion though, is it? It's a Middle Eastern culture forced down the throats of a people from a very much older one, and used as a tool of erasure of that older culture, of control and oppression, not to mention misogyny.

Stonehenge, Mae's Howe, Scara Brae, mistletoe and the Green Man, May Day and Beltane (whoops, sorry, I mean bonfire night) the Triple Goddess in the Chapter House at York Minster, Yule, well dressing, Morris Dancing...all the old stuff that still endures, as it has for thousands of years. THAT'S who we are, that's our culture, not this recent imposition.

Small wonder it didn't last!

Slushycuppa · 10/09/2022 10:42

I think if you go abroad, you see the people from those countries have similarly abandoned the traditions of their own culture and counties. For instance you don't see many people in Japan wearing Kimonos in day to day life. But I'm sure they love to come over to the UK and watch the trooping of the colour etc.

We have plenty of traditions in this country that are secular and that people still enjoy.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 10:42

Neilsfavouritechilli · 10/09/2022 10:39

Only anecdotal I'm afraid @cakeorwine Lots of people I know and lots of comments online (including mumset) suggesting the all the ceremony and protocol around the Queens death and the Kings ascension, should be scrapped as its antiquated and cringworthy.

That's the Monarchy though.

Which is a very different debate.

mamabear715 · 10/09/2022 10:41

I adore our traditions & am sad when they fade away.. being in my 60's, I remember Whitsuntide & the marches, church bands going round the streets, children dressed up in their Whit new clothes! Wonderful.
I wouldn't go out of my way to see Morris dancers, but I'd be gutted if they ever stopped..

thefoggiest · 10/09/2022 10:41

YANBU. God is ridiculed as a big sky fairy, except when we're talking about non Christian religions, at which point the tone is one of deference.

Flags are racist, except when we go on holiday to France where they're all over the place and that looks nice.

To aspire to a mono cultural society is knuckle dragging, except when we go on holiday to Italy or Greece, where we'd be gutted to find anything other than an untouched 1950s postcard world with only Italian and Greek restaurants.

Branleuse · 10/09/2022 10:41

The example of the maltese being proud of their culture isnt exactly the best example. The catholic church is ever present in Malta. Abortion is banned in all circumstances. They still shoot migratory birds every year and most of the maltese way of life is unrecognisable from how it was when i was a child due to tourism and overdevelopment, but they are still staunchly catholic, but with quite a low tolerance in general to other religions and races.

Neilsfavouritechilli · 10/09/2022 10:40

@sarahandquack That's a very valid point. Grass and greener spring to mind.

Neilsfavouritechilli · 10/09/2022 10:39

Only anecdotal I'm afraid @cakeorwine Lots of people I know and lots of comments online (including mumset) suggesting the all the ceremony and protocol around the Queens death and the Kings ascension, should be scrapped as its antiquated and cringworthy.

SarahAndQuack · 10/09/2022 10:39

But, you know, it's not really a surprise if someone who's grown up with umpteen dozen harvest festival assemblies, sitting cross-legged on the floor looking at a wonky display of tins of beans on straw bales, isn't blown away by the romance of it, whereas going to see something totally unfamiliar in another country is going to be much more exciting.

mrsjusticestain · 10/09/2022 10:39

It's the difference between visiting and living. I love to visit traditional, distinctive societies rooted in tradition. But live there full time? Not a chance in hell! Same applies in the UK.

SarahAndQuack · 10/09/2022 10:37

I suspect it depends where you are in the country, and what you mean by tradition/culture.

hangonsnoopy · 10/09/2022 10:37

The UK is renowned globally for music. We also have amazing folk traditions! I am mystified by those being used as examples.

vitahelp · 10/09/2022 10:35

I never said whether I appreciate religion or care about the Queen. I’m not trying to preach to anyone. It is the just hypocrisy I’ve observed in some (not all) and I just wondered if anyone else had noticed.

OP posts:
KnotKnot · 10/09/2022 10:34

I love the English language, love a lot of our literature, some of the art and music of recent centuries, our military history. Compared to some countries we probably lack with respect to folk traditions and music, and to architecture. Also, these things do change and evolve. If you look at the cultural and social changes during the lifetime of our last queen it's been huge. The loss of the the empire, decline in world and economic standing, social changes, ... etc ... it's different place. But we still have our language, books, art and music to be proud of.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 10:34

But when it comes to our own rituals we proclaim they're old fashioned, embarrassing and should be binned

Have you got some examples that are to do specifically with the UK?

Swipe left for the next trending thread