Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think everyone loves traditions/culture unless it is our own? (UK)

138 replies

vitahelp · 10/09/2022 09:54

This week has made me wonder about the above. I find so many people appreciate and enjoy tradition and culture when they are travelling overseas, but back in the UK will declare it outdated and embarrassing.

Things such as religion and places of worship are almost romanticised when abroad in certain countries, but back here are considered ridiculous by many. And I can’t help but think if we were watching from afar at a country who had just lost their Queen, the same people who are moaning this week would find it quite beautiful that people were wearing black and events were cancelled.

Is it just me who finds that culture and tradition are appreciated until they are on our doorstep?

OP posts:
Branleuse · 10/09/2022 11:39

sagalooshoe · 10/09/2022 11:15

II'm about to generalise massivly but its just an observation. I 've noticed a few times that when English people visit other countries we (often but I'm sure many that dont too!) immerse ourselves in their traditions and ceremonies, yet when some people visit us from abroad they expect to carry out their traditions here instead of partaking in ours. I lived with 2 French girls that refused to eat any English dishes, only French cheese etc. I am friends with an Italian family who insist on Italian traditions at Christmas rather than taking part in their English families meals etc. Almost as if we don't stick up for our traditions and food enough.

I spent xmas in spain a few years ago and it was very obvious where the brits were living. They seemed to insist on having a british christmas, almost like the spanish werent sticking up for spanish xmases enough

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 11:37

we’ll have a bland pick and mix of everyone else’s culture instead

I think that the impact of immigration and the change in - especially food - has opened us up to some great experiences.

I was watching Rick Stein in India and he was talking about how when people from the UK came over in Victorian times, they would incorporate Indian foods and spices into British food. Same for other cultures - integrating foods from other cultures into our own.

Personally I love the wide variety of food available in the UK. I do like a stew though. But not liver.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 10/09/2022 11:36

People like to travel abroad to experience “the other”. Taking an interest in a country’s traditions is just that. You’re an observer noting differences in how another country does things. It doesn’t mean that you’re in awe of them necessarily.

I’d guess that most visitors to Britain find the royal stuff fascinating because they don’t have it where they’re from. Or because a lot of it is familiar from fairy tales and Disney films. Eg palaces, footmen, crowns, robes, coaches etc. If people are brought up on these things in stories from a very young age, it must seem very quaint to visit a country that still has them.

I remember watching 2 Japanese teenage girls taking a ride in a horse and carriage at Hampton Court about 30 years ago. They were giggling ecstatically, so excited. It must have been very different to anything they had in their own country, but it must have seemed very similar to things like Cinderella. I can understand people finding it all very interesting in that way. However I’m sure they’d find all the privy council protocol exceedingly boring.

Branleuse · 10/09/2022 11:35

thefoggiest · 10/09/2022 10:41

YANBU. God is ridiculed as a big sky fairy, except when we're talking about non Christian religions, at which point the tone is one of deference.

Flags are racist, except when we go on holiday to France where they're all over the place and that looks nice.

To aspire to a mono cultural society is knuckle dragging, except when we go on holiday to Italy or Greece, where we'd be gutted to find anything other than an untouched 1950s postcard world with only Italian and Greek restaurants.

French flags in places that arent government buildings is seen similarly in france as english flags are in england as they have simar racist and colonialist history

feelingsareweird · 10/09/2022 11:35

Lol as a Morris dancer I can assure you it is not dying out. In many places in fact having rather a resurgence, despite covid struggles. There are too many folk festivals for us to get round each year. People have a laugh about it but when we dance in public I only see enthusiasm from people watching. I hope you’ll all be coming to join us to help keep culture alive!!

pointythings · 10/09/2022 11:34

@cakeorwine vegetarian curries can be made very very cheaply, you know.

pointythings · 10/09/2022 11:34

Meh, I have a grinch-like disregard for religion and tradition no matter where I am. I will respect it, but I don't find it particularly beautiful. Seeing religious symbolism in Malta would just remind me that it's a country that would happily have allowed a US tourist to become another Savita Halappanavar because of the dominance of the Catholic faith and its stance on abortion.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 11:32

Example - how many of us regularly enjoy pizza, Indian curry, Thai curry, lasagne, stir fry etc but how many children are being raised today familiar with liver and bacon, steak and kidney pudding, Irish stew etc

I think that with the cost of living crisis, people are going to have to explore some more traditional foods such as liver and offal that are cheaper.

Abhannmor · 10/09/2022 11:31

MissWired · 10/09/2022 10:43

It's not our original religion though, is it? It's a Middle Eastern culture forced down the throats of a people from a very much older one, and used as a tool of erasure of that older culture, of control and oppression, not to mention misogyny.

Stonehenge, Mae's Howe, Scara Brae, mistletoe and the Green Man, May Day and Beltane (whoops, sorry, I mean bonfire night) the Triple Goddess in the Chapter House at York Minster, Yule, well dressing, Morris Dancing...all the old stuff that still endures, as it has for thousands of years. THAT'S who we are, that's our culture, not this recent imposition.

Small wonder it didn't last!

Surely bonfire night would be Samhain / Halloween rather than Bealtaine? Though there used to fires and may poles I suppose.

I went to secondary school in England in the 60s. I recall asking my classmates what they did for Halloween. Not a single one knew what I meant. It was only hanging on in Ireland and Scotland til the films came out...

Lesserspottedmama · 10/09/2022 11:30

It’s absolutely true. Example - how many of us regularly enjoy pizza, Indian curry, Thai curry, lasagne, stir fry etc but how many children are being raised today familiar with liver and bacon, steak and kidney pudding, Irish stew etc. I was talking to my mum and my two sisters about this only yesterday. I see the shops selling tat pertaining to ‘day of the dead’, ‘mardi gras’ and 4th of July - in England! And lots of white British now do things for diwali, eid etc. Fine, but how many of them celebrate Michaelmas, candlemas, Beltane, midwinter? Scottish and Welsh and Irish still hold much of their heritage dear, but not us English - we’ll have a bland pick and mix of everyone else’s culture instead!

Arou · 10/09/2022 11:24

I appreciate traditions and culture.

I don’t appreciate and have never agreed with the idea that some people (just because they’re inbred and truhhdition) deserve to have multiple massive multi million pound houses and funded by the taxpayer when there are people starving, struggling, can barely make ends meet working 40 hour weeks. Just because of the circumstances of their birth. It’s not charity work if you’re living in a palace for your trouble and you’re being given mandatory donations for your trouble. What else are they going to do with their day. I don’t get how people can see what’s happening in this country and still be okay with people (who will never give a fig about you by the way lmao) being so elevated above everyone else.

I don’t appreciate supporting nonce protectors.

I don’t appreciate supporting pro fox hunters.

I don’t appreciate supporting people with a fan base (because that’s what it is) who think a wayward son and his wife are so much more of a detriment to the future of the royal family than protecting said n*.

Love fish and chips, a Sunday road though.

Abhannmor · 10/09/2022 11:21

Rosewaterblossom · 10/09/2022 10:06

I agree. Very minor example but I saw a post on Instagram(it was tongue in cheek) saying they asked the waiter if they could have chicken on their Greek salad and the Greek waiter said no, because then it wouldn't be a Greek salad 🤷🏼‍♀️😃 I thought imagine that being England for something similar! They'd not only be adding the chicken they'd probably change the whole traditional dish to suit!

Ditto for Ireland. The customer is King. Avoca in Co Wicklow was sort of renamed Ballykissangel after some godawful TV series was filmed there.

Back to normal now but you get the idea.Our culture is whatever $$$ say it is.

TedMullins · 10/09/2022 11:21

vitahelp · 10/09/2022 10:20

@Bubblebubblebah I think religion is the best example, however I was reluctant to use it since I didn’t want the thread to become a religion argument. But I’ve travelled to Malta many times and discussed it with various people over the years who have also been there. So many observed how beautiful the presence of religion is over there, small examples like the bus drivers having a cross hanging from the mirror and other relics on the dash. However the exact same people have said what a waste of time church is at home and how could anyone possibly believe any of it.

I just feel when travelling, witnessing very old fashioned activity is seen as beautiful and a sign that culture has managed to carry through into the modern age. Yet here we seem keen to leave it behind because it no longer has a place in modern society. It think it stems from a lack of pride in our country.

You seem to be conflating two different things here - religion and a sense of national identity. The former, I can’t speak for everyone but I don’t think it’s as simple as people think it’s beautiful when observed abroad but outdated here.

There are elements of religious society that are interesting in a historical and cultural sense both here and abroad - the buildings and architecture and art, for example. People appreciate those things in the U.K. and abroad. But I don’t believe religion should be a driving force in societal norms or policy making, here or in other countries. It tends to lead to punitive policies like no abortion access, no gay marriage, or in extreme cases like the Middle East a severe curtailing of women’s rights. That doesn’t mean that Middle Eastern Islamic art and architecture isn’t beautiful.

As for nationalism, I think that’s become uncomfortably associated with the far right in some ways because they’ve co-opted the imagery like the St George cross. Nationalism can be just as dangerous in other countries too - look at the violence that’s happened between Spanish and Catalan separatists in the past, for instance. But for small communities whose language and traditions faded out/are being faded out with history like the Cornish or Welsh for example, nationalism is a source of pride and identity.

basically, it’s complicated. In the case of the queen, you can feel proud of the symbolism of the monarchy as a mark of Britishness but also conflicted about its involvement with colonialism and violence.

phishy · 10/09/2022 11:21

HarpicHarpy · 10/09/2022 10:32

I think your confusing 'what is the traditional name for Greek salad' with 'what do they call Greek salad in Greece'. They call it Greek salad. Everyday all day. Greeks and tourists alike.

Every cookery website says the Greeks call it Horiatiki.

The authentic Greek salad or what Greek call it as ‘Horiatiki’, which means village or peasant salad

organicallyblissful.com/modern-tradition-greek-salad/

hangonsnoopy · 10/09/2022 11:16

I would want to experience...

Day trip to historic theme park rides. The Grand National at Blackpool.
Sunday lunch.
A festival. Cambridge Folk Festival or Glastonbury.
Hiking in the English lake district or Highlands.
Afternoon tea.
Walking in a historic city. The city walls at York. The Shambles.

Cornettoninja · 10/09/2022 11:16

I think it's a massive positive that the British can mock Christianity. Look what happens when religion is taken too seriously and deferred to all the time!

I don’t entirely disagree but I do think that we, as a society, haven’t been very good at neutering an alternative for the more positive parts. People are increasingly isolated within their own communities and less exposed to support systems and just different personalities they wouldn’t necessarily be drawn to independently. I think the loss of traditional pub ‘locals’ is sad for much the same reason. Churches and pubs give people somewhere to go for no particular reason iyswim. I do think it adds to the difficulty some have with finding a sense of nationality or being part of community.

Fairyliz · 10/09/2022 11:15

Well it’s certainly true on MN where you have to be ashamed/embarrassed to be British (in particular English) and apologise for even existing. As to praising anything about our country including our traditions that’s a big no no; every other country in the world is automatically much better.
Back in the real world not so much. After spending time on MN I am constantly amazed at how many people are willing to risk their lives to get here.

sagalooshoe · 10/09/2022 11:15

II'm about to generalise massivly but its just an observation. I 've noticed a few times that when English people visit other countries we (often but I'm sure many that dont too!) immerse ourselves in their traditions and ceremonies, yet when some people visit us from abroad they expect to carry out their traditions here instead of partaking in ours. I lived with 2 French girls that refused to eat any English dishes, only French cheese etc. I am friends with an Italian family who insist on Italian traditions at Christmas rather than taking part in their English families meals etc. Almost as if we don't stick up for our traditions and food enough.

Quveas · 10/09/2022 11:13

The Americans fought a war to get rid of our "culture and traditions" but still travel here to soak it up. What you are describing is a phenomenon of every country - you simply romanticise meaning that often isn't there into people and places that you are unfamiliar with.

vitahelp · 10/09/2022 11:12

I think it’s productive to question and challenge local traditions and cultures if they no longer apply or actually conflict with your own beliefs.

I am referring to people who blindly oppose it for no particular reason at all other than they are embarrassed or it is uncool, or just to be different/difficult. They will proudly declare how silly it is but have no actual argument. Understandable in teenagers but I’m talking about grown adults.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 11:08

If you were a tourist coming to the UK, what traditions would you like to experience?

A pub?
Afternoon tea?
Fish and chips at the seaside?

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 11:07

Delabruche · 10/09/2022 11:05

I agree OP. People are always sniffy about Morris dancing - and it's dying out. No wonder people don't want to do it! It also annoys me that some people never go to church except for weddings and Christmas but still expect it to be there for them when they want it.

Maybe fewer people don't believe in God?

But it's hypocritical to go to church for a wedding if you don't go to church normally

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 11:06

Funkyblues101 · 10/09/2022 10:53

Morris dancing. Maypole dancing (for fair maidens - obviously cute when it's the primary school kiddiwinkies). Travelling minstrels. Barn dancing in England now usually called ceilidhs (sp?).

Travelling minstrels? Are they still a thing?

We do have a lot of traditions that still carry on.

Rolling cheese down a hill
Weighing the swans
Gurning

www.oxford-royale.com/articles/eccentric-british-traditions/

Delabruche · 10/09/2022 11:05

I agree OP. People are always sniffy about Morris dancing - and it's dying out. No wonder people don't want to do it! It also annoys me that some people never go to church except for weddings and Christmas but still expect it to be there for them when they want it.

Charley50 · 10/09/2022 11:03

I think it's a massive positive that the British can mock Christianity. Look what happens when religion is taken too seriously and deferred to all the time!

People do put effort into keeping more local traditions alive. Those scarecrow things (sorry don't know any detail) in Yorkshire, Summer Solstice etc. Monarchy, cockney pearly king and queen, but these aren't everyday things.

Getting pissed and riotous abroad is a British tradition in a way, albeit an embarrassing one.