Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think everyone loves traditions/culture unless it is our own? (UK)

138 replies

vitahelp · 10/09/2022 09:54

This week has made me wonder about the above. I find so many people appreciate and enjoy tradition and culture when they are travelling overseas, but back in the UK will declare it outdated and embarrassing.

Things such as religion and places of worship are almost romanticised when abroad in certain countries, but back here are considered ridiculous by many. And I can’t help but think if we were watching from afar at a country who had just lost their Queen, the same people who are moaning this week would find it quite beautiful that people were wearing black and events were cancelled.

Is it just me who finds that culture and tradition are appreciated until they are on our doorstep?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 11/09/2022 16:19

There are plenty of wonderful British traditions and cultures, some of which are rooted in religion, most of which are not. You only have to visit cities such as York, Bath, Stratford, the major London museums, or any of the old English Heritage monuments, to see as much. The UK has a rich enough cultural and artistic heritage to rival any nation on earth. Our sporting and popular culture is pretty formidable, too.

The problem arises when some people seem to believe 'Britishness' begins and ends with the Mountbatten-Windsor family. It doesn't. It's also disappointing to see Britain (and its national anthem) reduced to the brouhaha over one tiny group of obscenely over-privileged but fairly unremarkable people. Some might say this was selling our country extremely short.

As for traditions playing out, pity about the Lionesses' victory parade and all ...

pointythings · 11/09/2022 16:14

@cakeorwine massive round of applause from me. A country and its people ought to be able to accept that there are always things that can be done better. The British are actually a bit thin skinned in this area, or at least a subset of them are.

HappyKoala56 · 11/09/2022 16:01

I suppose where we live has an impact on our opinions. Personally the town I live in has lots of traditions of its own (carnival, Christmas festival etc) which do get the people of the town out and embracing those traditions.
Religion I don't think is a particularly good example. The people I know of round here who claim to be religious may do the going to church on Sunday, but don't tend to do anything else Christian until the next Sunday service. I don't think that is necessarily behaviour to swoon over.
Things like flags, I think unless they are on a public building are crass here and abroad.
I do see where you are coming from in a way. Abroad a fleeting meet with someone may make people decide they are living a wholesome life because they live off the land, or make their own clothes, or have many generations living in one house. But here society thinks to have a great life you should have a big house, a range rover and a high flying career which keeps you from your family.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 15:45

Our society is pretty much dominated by the liberal-left. They dominate the BBC, publishing and academia. And they hate their own country. George Orwell was writing about this nearly 100 years ago - the way the British left hate Britain, and especially England. People then absorb/internalise that self-hatred

This country is not bad. It does a lot of things well.

There are also things that it's not so good at - but if people dare to mention this, then they get shouted down and demonised for not having pride in Britain or even hating it.

I have travelled a lot. Seen a lot of things. I know what we are good at and what we could do better. But any criticism of Britain and you get called a 'hater, a Remoaner' and told to go and leave the UK.

It's like some people don't like being told that Britain is not perfect.

There are plenty of things to be proud of about this country. Plenty of good traditions. Plenty of things our ancestors have achieved.

And there are things that could be improved.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 15:41

But we’re never encouraged to take pride in any of this

What never?
No never...

..Well hardly ever....

Suetwo · 11/09/2022 15:39

Our society is pretty much dominated by the liberal-left. They dominate the BBC, publishing and academia. And they hate their own country. George Orwell was writing about this nearly 100 years ago - the way the British left hate Britain, and especially England. People then absorb/internalise that self-hatred.

For me, it’s not so much the royals I’m proud of. I respected the queen, and I kind of like Charles, but in general the royals embarrass me. We should be most proud of our intellectual and cultural achievements, especially our literature. To me, being British is bound up with Chaucer and Shakespeare and Dickens and Jane Austen and Virginia Woolf. I’m proud to live on a small island that contains not one but two of the oldest and greatest universities in the world - universities that produced Newton and Darwin, where DNA was discovered and the atom was first understood.

But we’re never encouraged to take pride in any of this. On the contrary, every time I go in Waterstones, all I see under ‘new books’ are titles like ‘How to De-Colonise Your Bookshelves,’ or ‘Evil Empire: A History of British Colonialism,’ and so on. Or take Radio 4. Last time I bothered with it, there was a programme on about Jane Austen. Within five minutes they were linking her to slavery and colonialism, and that was all they spent the half hour discussing. Is it any wonder the young are ashamed of their own identity? Every young person I know seems proud that their grandmother is Italian, or that their dad is Greek, etc. But their British identity means nothing to them.

RedHelenB · 11/09/2022 15:25

CherryGenoa · 11/09/2022 13:04

I don’t see much of this happening any more.

It never did. Totally made up. All schools did and still do nativity plays .

FictionalCharacter · 11/09/2022 14:57

I agree, we’re a very self-critical country and I do think we’ve taken self-deprecation too far. Leaving religion aside, there are traditions like folk dance that are viewed as embarrassing and outdated in the UK, but we happily watch other countries’ traditional dance and don’t criticise it.

Abhannmor · 11/09/2022 14:22

We didn't bother with the Jack o Lanterns tbh. Happy enough with the brack.

The Wren is making a comeback in some parts. Good to see.

CulturePigeon · 11/09/2022 14:08

Oh God, OP, you're not wrong.

Always worked in education in one way or another, mainly in museums and galleries, so at the sharp end of every trend in ideology as you can imagine.

Incidents that stick in my mind:

Colleague saying with sinister intonation and narrowed eyes, after mention of children's traditional stories: "Hmm...and what do they mean by traditional, I wonder?" as if there was a risk the kids were going to be indoctrinated with Hitler Youth propaganda. God help us! I think Goldilocks and Cinderella was what she was referring to. (Yes, I know these tales were collected by German folklorists, the Grimms, but they have become part of British culture too.)

When in a training session about dance in primary schools, we saw videos of Indian, Irish, Scottish, Greek and other national dances. All good, and well-received by the trainees. The tutor concluded by saying 'That's some just of the possibilities, but you could also use English traditional dances such as May-pole dancing or Morris dances." Cue scornful snorting from a competitively right-on woman behind me, who couldn't believe this was a serious suggestion and said 'Isn't all that stuff really corny and outmoded?" Well...it might be, but I'm willing to bet that all the dances we'd just watched so earnestly from other cultures might well be their equivalent of Morris dancing!!! Had any trainees come from India or the other featured cultures, they might well have had a bit of a titter!!! But that's OK, because we only sneer at British stuff.

So very tiresome and silly. British culture is just as interesting as any other and I think we're pretty alone in dissing our own stuff in the way we do. Can't imagine the French doing that!

RocketPanda · 11/09/2022 14:06

They were hardier people than I am to be carving turnips, jaysus the arms would fall off you.
DH was a wren boy years ago and we have been known for an aul sing song.

malificent7 · 11/09/2022 13:45

You are right op. Whilst travelling in Nepal as a teen, i wondered at traditions like the Kumari ( child goddess) but would hate that to be a tradition here. I'm a bit less naive now.

Abhannmor · 11/09/2022 13:39

@RocketPanda Conas a déirí leat? Lots of kids here will be carving pumpkins too . And ould turnip isn't good enough anymore!

They'll be around saying Trick or Treat ! Whereas we used to say ' Apples or Nuts'. I'd imagine the English had Halloween traditions fadó but they were replaced by Guy Fawkes night , probably?

At least the Wren Boys on St Stephens Day have not been Disneyfied yet.

CherryGenoa · 11/09/2022 13:04

BourbonBiscuits20 · 11/09/2022 09:38

I think an example of this might be when I was at uni there were emails sent out to wish those celebrating a happy Eid (fine) but the fundraiser Christmas jumper days name had to be changed to 'festive jumper' Day so as not to cause offence and I think the Easter and Christmas holidays were renamed for the same reason too. Grated against me that.

I don’t see much of this happening any more.

ThistleSifter · 11/09/2022 10:38

Sneering at Britain with outright pompous vitriol is epitomised by James o’Brien on LBC. Actually unbearable to listen to more than half the time.

I appreciate his linguistics but not the ultra-staunch dripping-with-condescension personality that is there 95% of the time, and his frothing and barbed insults are usually aimed squarely at U.K./England. I’ve never heard anything like it, but hear him echoed in others more recently.

(Also he’s unable to construct valid arguments half the time relying on false suppositions and hoping no one will notice, then he denigrates and bullies dissenting callers who disagree and point these holes out, so that also contributes to unlistenableness; his intellectual totalitarianism which isn’t based on superior thinking or logic).

But leaving him totally to one side, yes I agree with you op!

Sciurus83 · 11/09/2022 10:03

Dug hard to find something to be annoyed about with this one didn't we?!

RocketPanda · 11/09/2022 10:01

I live in an Irish speaking part of the West Coast of Ireland, not a lot of traditions survived ( not talking about religion ) and a lot of our language died out so I suppose our pride in our heritage and traditions comes from trying to preserve them against the odds. Theres been a huge surge in young people using and appreciating the Irish language both native and abroad.

As an observer of English culture, having lived there and seen so much of it on TV its such a mix of cultures. One can't expect to colonise so many different countries and expect their culture not to seep into lifestyle. I mean how many of you are going to buy Halloween costumes and carve pumpkins in a few weeks?

BourbonBiscuits20 · 11/09/2022 09:38

I think an example of this might be when I was at uni there were emails sent out to wish those celebrating a happy Eid (fine) but the fundraiser Christmas jumper days name had to be changed to 'festive jumper' Day so as not to cause offence and I think the Easter and Christmas holidays were renamed for the same reason too. Grated against me that.

MangyInseam · 11/09/2022 09:36

YANBU, but it isn't everyone.

It's basically people who see themselves as more international and liberal. And not confined to England either, you see it to some extent among the same group in the US, Canada, etc.

It's always seemed odd to me that people like this will be very blase about their own cultural patrimony but will regularly travel abroad to enjoy that of other people, and seem to see doing so as a sign of sophistication. But I wonder if maybe it's because they can stay in the observer role to a large extent - it doesn't demand anything of them.

What's more annoying is they can also be very nasty about other people in their own culture who do take these things seriously.

DonnaHadDee · 11/09/2022 09:24

@RightDressingDown, I live in NI in one of those areas where flying of flags, parades and so on are part of the culture (and some other folk here on MN know me in RL). I've lived in West Coast US, and there was a significant amount and pride in US flags, more so in rural areas than urban though. While I lived in England I did see a good number of flags too, especially for football games, and I must say I really liked it too!

In general, I'd not associate with English flag waving or US flag waving with what happens in the area where I live. Some is indeed well intentioned, but much of it here sadly is provocative, mean spirited, more akin to KKK messaging in the the deep south of the US. Of course that happens on both sides of the sectarian divide, but I can only comment for where I live (there are no Catholics).

There is lot of culture in NI, but like everywhere with pros/cons. Same for England. Be proud of the the good parts! (be aware of the not so good).

LondonWolf · 11/09/2022 09:22

@blushcheese

Great post.

Fairislefandango · 11/09/2022 09:21

Well of course. It's the novelty of the traditions of other cultures, isn't it? It's perfectly normal and understandable to feel at least a bit 'meh' about them. And it's good to question whether we shpild keep on doing a particular thing just because it's always been done.

I seriously doubt this is a feeling exclusive to the UK. Presumably in other countries lots of people regard upholding certain old traditions as stuffy and old-fashioned too, and in some cases embarrassing (due to them now being viewed as potentially non-pc, tone deaf, classist etc). There are and always have been people keen to cling onto the past and those keen to move on.

blushcheese · 11/09/2022 09:13

LondonWolf · 11/09/2022 08:34

Agree OP. Seems to be quite the thing to express shame at being British and sneering at our culture and traditions or claiming it was all made on the backs of other nations, so worthless anyway. Millions of people visit our countries to experience their various cultures and history. Why do they come if there's nothing worthwhile here?

I've always been baffled at this.

My husband is from Afghanistan and afghans are so proud of their "graveyard of empires" forgetting that ghengis khan was probably one of the most ruthless killers and the fact the country has multiple different ethnicities because of them all being conquered against their will.

The Dutch are allowed to be proud to be Dutch even though they basically was the first "white" nation to start slavery of the Africans.

Germans are allowed to be proud (no comment there we all know)

Indians are allowed to be proud even though they still treat majority of their own casts like shit if they deem them lower than their own cast.

If any other country could have conquered 75 percent of the world they would have!

If Africa had our jewels I'm pretty sure there would not be a massive deal to return them if anything it would be "we won get over it"

I'm sick of Britain being torn apart when it was just the done thing back in the days.

LondonWolf · 11/09/2022 09:11

Newrumpus · 11/09/2022 09:07

It’s not really embarrassment about the tradition but about those who engage with it. Lots of working class people engage with their national sports and cultures and those who claim to hate football culture and are currently moaning about ‘all the forelock tugging’ are really stating their distaste of what they see as the uncultured lower classes. When the moaners travel abroad and observe cultures they can appreciate them without the fear of being absorbed into them because their travel reinforces their superiority to their own lower classes back home.

I think you're absolutely right.

RightDressingDown · 11/09/2022 09:10

CurlyhairedAssassin · 10/09/2022 11:39

re flags. We’ve just been to the US for the first time. I loved seeing how many flags were displayed on everyone’s houses. I mean, they were EVERYWHERE. They fly them with pride and why not? WE are the weird ones in this country. Is it a shame about the empire or something? Can’t understand it.

Go to Northern Ireland in July - see what you think?