Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you why the title ‘Prince of Wales’ is an historical insult to the Welsh and shouldn’t exist anymore

943 replies

Upthebracket22 · 10/09/2022 07:19

I am Welsh. I was enraged yesterday when the new king decided to ‘bestow’ the title on Prince William, an English Prince without asking the Welsh if they wanted another English Prince of Wales.

here is some historical context from a petition going around at the moment:

The "Prince of Wales" title (Welsh: Tywysog Cymru) is a title historically used by native, Welsh princes since the 14th century. The last native Prince of Wales was Llywelyn the Last, killed by English soldiers in 1282 and his head was then paraded through the streets of London and placed on a Tower of London spike. Llywelyn's brother Dafydd was the first person of note to be hung, drawn and quartered and his head was placed next to Llywelyn's. Both their daughters were taken as infants and children and imprisoned.

But this happened centuries ago you might say. The truth is, that since the days of Llywelyn the Last and the "rebel" Prince of Wales, Owain Glyndwr, the title has been held exclusively by Englishmen as a symbol of dominance over Wales. To this day, the English "Princes of Wales" have no genuine connection to our country.

The title remains an insult to Wales and is a symbol of historical oppression. The title also implies that Wales is still a principality, undermining Wales' status as a nation and a country. In addition, the title has absolutely no constitutional role for Wales, which is now a devolved country with a national Parliament.

As Welsh actor, Michael Sheen put it;

"Make a break there. Put some things that have been the wrongs of the past right. There's an opportunity to do that at that point. Don't necessarily just because of habit and without thinking just carry on that tradition that was started as a humiliation to our country. Why not change that as we come to this moment where things will inevitably change."

I don’t think many people have any concept of Welsh history. I find it offensive and think now would have been a good moment to right a historical wrong.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
herecomesthsun · 15/09/2022 15:52

Actually, I've linked to the Royal family tree previously, so I would refer you back to that. It's pretty well understood that there is a very strong connection with European royalty, that is hardly a minority opinion. Much stronger than the Welsh component.

As I said before, there are a lot more points of contact with Scotland and England for the Royals than with Wales, a sizeable chunk of Welsh people are things #not my prince and that will be to do with having someone who doesn't live in Wales, isn't planning to live in Wales, doesn't speak the language etc. They seem like a very nice, very posh, very rich family based in the South of England which is lovely, but they don't seem to have much connection with Wales.

See also the definition of ethnicity. Shared culture. Don't see much evidence of it here, beyond that they might watch Strictly too? There is a Welsh language & literature & musical traditions etc.( They both like rugby I suppose.)

Also there is nothing wrong with the Guardian, it is one of the better UK papers.

DonnaHadDee · 15/09/2022 15:31

"Nationalism is based on a distortion of history" is your own point of view.

"and has been around a very short time in human history". So what? So has the welfare state , so has safe widely available contraception, antibiotics, etc. Some are good, some are bad.

Your posts are very funny to read. You might be my neighbour :)

justasking111 · 15/09/2022 15:19

We've got a fruit cake running plaid. Gordon Brown on speed dial with the senedd, no wonder folks are a bit uptight when they've a Scot pulling their strings

justasking111 · 15/09/2022 15:14

Guardian pfft 🙄

gatehouseoffleet · 15/09/2022 15:09

Maybe we want a say in who our princes are and believe in a democratic society that includes the choice and voices of its citizens

Hmm I think some of us think democracy is a bit overrated since Brexit and Boris.

And lets face it, they keep voting for the DUP in NI as well.

Maybe there's something to be said for having a benign monarchy or Prince of Wales foisted on you. People in London voted for Boris as mayor twice.

I don't know, I am not much of a royalist, but I do think entrusting important decisions to ordinary people can go very very wrong.

DownNative · 15/09/2022 15:04

Upthebracket22 · 13/09/2022 06:57

There’s a lot of ‘why can’t we all just get along’ comments on here.

Yes, we can all get along just as independent nations. Independence is normal. There are something like 75 countries smaller than Wales who are independent and manage just fine thanks.

Have you been raiding SNP literature or something?!

In saying "independence is normal", you've just fallen into the False Dilemma Fallacy there.

The reality is that UNIONS are very much normal around the world.

United Kingdom
United States
Germany
Australia
European Union

And that's just off the top of my head!

Absolutely no reason why Unionist states cannot get along, you know. You appear to be relying on the Circular Reasoning Fallacy in the rest of your post.

But it doesn't stand.

DownNative · 15/09/2022 14:56

GobbolinoTheWitchesCat · 13/09/2022 14:29

Haven't read through all 16 pages yet but has anyone made the point that Wales never existed as a separate and whole kingdom?

It was a group of a principalities (which is why the Welsh dragon isn't represented on the Union flag).

If Wales as it is now, with its evolved cultural identity, wishes to become independent from the UK then that is something to which it's entitled under the principles of self-determination, but I do find the ideas of nationalism which are rooted in politics from 1000+ years ago somewhat erroneous.

No, self-determination is balanced against the parent states right to territorial integrity. Places like Wales, Scotland and Catalonia are only entitled to devolution in international law. They have that.

And so, there is zero democratic right to independence. Nearly every country in the world regards it as illegal and not a democratic right.

Just two regard it as a democratic right.

Nationalism is based on a distortion of history and has been around a very short time in human history. Since the 18th century. Before that, people identified with their tribes which is why ancient maps outline lots of different territories across the British Isles, for example.

DownNative · 15/09/2022 14:46

herecomesthsun · 11/09/2022 06:58

I have, they are still predominantly of Anglo German descent, I'm afraid. "Predominantly" means "mostly", you see.

It is not "reading hate", at all, as I don't hate either English or German people (I am very pre European in fact), and so I can respect and even admire their heritage. Which is minimally Welsh, even you must agree.

As regards the extremely tenuous links to Welsh ancestry, as I have said before, going that far back, huge numbers of ethnic Welsh will be connected by lines of descent to Llewelyn and Owain Glyndwr and the princes of old. If we could do DNA analysis we would find that random Welsh people walking the streets of Wrexham and Chirk had more connection with these old princes than William.

So I would say (which is a very positive and love-filled statement) that we are all princes by descent in Wales. And we don't need a (predominantly) English bugger thanks.

On the contrary, you have not demonstrated the current Royal Family ancestry is mostly Anglo aka English and German. Rather, you've asserted it as opposed to demonstrating so.

I, for example, laid out Queen Elizabeth II's Irish ancestry which is quite substantial. Likewise, the Welsh ancestry was laid out which isn't insignificant either. The Scottish ancestry is very significant as well. Already, that chips away at the idea the ancestry is mostly English and German.

King George I's mother was the granddaughter of James VI of Scotland and I of England, so he wasn't fully German either.

The Royal House Of Windsor has deep ancestry that isn't English or German. You might attempt to ignore that, but that just reveals your bias.

cakeorwine · 15/09/2022 08:01

I’ve had my DNA done and it confirmed the family tree I’d built back to 13th century

So you have traced EVERY single relative up the family tree to the 13th century?

That's 2 ^ 21 grandparents - which is a massive number.

herecomesthsun · 15/09/2022 07:59

I agree that ethnicitiy is complex and individual and if you read my posts, you will see that the factors which I suggest contribute to ethnicity are diverse.

I'm in fact arguing for a pretty broad approach to the concept of nationality here.

I'd say there's considerable doubt about whether it is right for a modern Wales to have William as Prince of Wales and we will see what the consultation looks like before the investiture.

Constitutional royalty only hold their positions under sufferance from the ordinary people who live in the lands they supposedly rule.

Discovereads · 14/09/2022 23:46

cakeorwine · 14/09/2022 23:07

So ethnicity doesn’t mean you can only be a member of one social group at any one time, and you can inherit ethnicity via ancestry

How far back do you go though?

I have 4 grandparents, 8 great grandparents, 16 great grand parents etc

They all come from different parts of the UK and abroad. Then I look at the relations further back.

32, 64, 128, 256 etc.....

At what point would you say - that 'ethnicity' does not count?

Or really - what does ethnicity mean?

At least 1 of my great grandparents came from Dublin. I know that people who can trace an ancestor back to Ireland claim to be Irish or to have Irish roots. The fact that one of my 8 great grandparents - well, at least 1, came from Ireland doesn't make me have any real connection to Ireland.

Well, the truth is that we are all mixed to a certain extent and it shows up in DNA tests. So, in my opinion, it’s up to the individual what counts most to them, there’s no set rules on ethnicity. It’s part of a persons identity and everyone can choose which bits they identify with.

I’ve had my DNA done and it confirmed the family tree I’d built back to 13th century. It’s also pretty typical for where I am ethnically from, though not where I was born, or was educated, or grew up, as I was a military brat and so had a nomadic childhood. So for me, ethnicity isnt about birth place, schools, or where I’ve lived because they were always temporary stops. For others, ethnicity is about those things, and that’s absolutely fine. I just think ethnicity is actually pretty complex and very individual.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 14/09/2022 23:28

Thank you @TheLassWiADelicateAir
An excellent post.

cakeorwine · 14/09/2022 23:07

So ethnicity doesn’t mean you can only be a member of one social group at any one time, and you can inherit ethnicity via ancestry

How far back do you go though?

I have 4 grandparents, 8 great grandparents, 16 great grand parents etc

They all come from different parts of the UK and abroad. Then I look at the relations further back.

32, 64, 128, 256 etc.....

At what point would you say - that 'ethnicity' does not count?

Or really - what does ethnicity mean?

At least 1 of my great grandparents came from Dublin. I know that people who can trace an ancestor back to Ireland claim to be Irish or to have Irish roots. The fact that one of my 8 great grandparents - well, at least 1, came from Ireland doesn't make me have any real connection to Ireland.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 14/09/2022 22:39

I think if you analysed the DNA of a lot of people living in Wales you would find a heady mix of many European cultures.

Nationalism is a path to fascism and we should fight it because we are on a slippy path.

Discovereads · 14/09/2022 18:27

herecomesthsun · 14/09/2022 07:35

lol William has not been in a diaspora.

The title he has been awarded, Tywysog Cymru, means leader of Wales. There is not much evidence of leadership and less evidence of any sense of him being actually Welsh (see my previous helpful posts). So it is meaningless.

I wouldn't argue for full independence, and if the clear majority of English and Scots want a monarchy, let them have one

But the situation in Wales warrants some intelligent discussion with Mr Drakeford.

I didn’t say he had, but people are pretty mobile beings. They emigrate and immigrate, the set up lives across borders or seas. But that doesn’t change their ethnicity. Especially when we are talking about a very ancient ethnic difference between one part compared to another part of the same tiny island. And of course, when Welsh Royalty took the throne…of a country which included Wales and England, they kind of had to move to the capitol city of London.

Ethnicity is more complex than where you live, where you went to school, what language you speak, and where your children are raised. It’s more complex than that. We have lots of ethnic minorities born, raised, educated, speaking English and raising children here that while British also belong to ethnicities other than those native to Great Britain. There are Irish, Jamaican, Nigerian, Pakistani, Indian, Swiss, German, Polish, French, Spanish, etc…they’re British but they are also the ethnicity of their original homelands and many of them keep alive the traditions and cultures they brought with them. So ethnicity doesn’t mean you can only be a member of one social group at any one time, and you can inherit ethnicity via ancestry.

herecomesthsun · 14/09/2022 07:37

ethnicity
/ɛθˈnɪsɪti/

noun
the fact or state of belonging to a social group that has a common national or cultural tradition.

herecomesthsun · 14/09/2022 07:35

lol William has not been in a diaspora.

The title he has been awarded, Tywysog Cymru, means leader of Wales. There is not much evidence of leadership and less evidence of any sense of him being actually Welsh (see my previous helpful posts). So it is meaningless.

I wouldn't argue for full independence, and if the clear majority of English and Scots want a monarchy, let them have one

But the situation in Wales warrants some intelligent discussion with Mr Drakeford.

Discovereads · 13/09/2022 23:23

herecomesthsun · 13/09/2022 23:08

why is the current royal family not “native” Welsh

Well, re William in particular

  • he doesn't apparently identify as Welsh in particular as far as we know
  • wasn't born there
  • didn't grow up there
  • wasn't educated there
  • doesn't speak the language (but learnt the anthem phoneticzlly
  • doesn't live there
  • doesn't plan to make it his main home
  • isn't educating his kids there
  • doesn't speak Welsh

Why do you think he's Welsh? Seems fairly obvious he isn't

Dont be silly, ethnicity is independent of where you are born, live and what language you speak. Just ask anyone who’s been in a diaspora.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 13/09/2022 23:21

Discovereads · 13/09/2022 15:43

@LetMeSpeak
A little fact for you. England has oppressed every single country/tribe/ethnicity that they have ever had contact with and the ones they haven’t were simply too strong for them to do so.

That’s a lie remarkable only for it’s absolutism, arrogance and hatred of the English.

Everyone has been invaded, colonised and oppressed…the whole world has done it to each other since history began. The English are no worse (or better) than any other country/tribe/ethnicity.

Todays English are all mixed ancestry anyway because England itself has been invaded, colonised and oppressed many times over- Celts, Romans, Anglo-Saxons, Vikings (esp the Danes), and Normans. The 11th century invasions of Wales, Scotland and Ireland were done from England but by their Norman conquerors (not the English). Saying it was “the English” is a bit like claiming the Goths (Germans) invaded us when they were a conquered people compelled to serve in the Roman army during their occupation of Britain.

But these Norman invasions of Wales were not the first. Irish Scoti had invaded and colonised both North Wales and Scotland preRoman invasion and conquest.

Then of course, the Romans invaded and colonised Wales.

Lothian Scots then also invaded Wales in the 5th century after the Romans withdrew and Welsh legend holds that the kingdom of Gwynedd was established by Cunedda Wledig one of these Scottish invaders called the Goddodin. 500yrs later, his descendent Llywelyn ap Gruffudd is called the “last native prince of wales”. So if 500yrs of a Scottish family ruling Wales makes them “native” Welsh…then why is the current royal family not “native” Welsh despite definitely having Welsh royal blood from Welsh royalty that actually originated in Wales (not a kingdom established in Wales by a Scottish invader) and having ruled Wales since 1485?

Wonderful post.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 13/09/2022 23:19

JustAnotherPoster00 · 13/09/2022 05:30

The devolved nations really are stuck in an abusive relationship with the English, we tell them we want our own voice they scorn us for it, they isolate us from our friends (the EU), they control our money and don't give us enough to make any meaningful difference yet berate us when we don't priorities what they think we should and when we tell them we want to leave were told that we'll never make it on our own or in the case of Scotland they're told they're not even allowed to ask themselves if they want to, the devolved nations really need to do the Freedom Program

What a load of cobblers. (From a resident in a devolved nation)

Legrandsophie · 13/09/2022 23:14

@Discovereads 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Best post if the thread!

Also, there’s strong evidence of Irish settlers and raiders in West Wales in the post-Roman period.

I love how nationalist try to use snippets of history to support their bigoted arguments and get owned by the wider story.

And it makes me laugh to see @herecomesthsun making a long list of ways William can’t be Welsh and not realising that it makes them look entirely closed
minded and exclusionary. Slow clap.

herecomesthsun · 13/09/2022 23:08

why is the current royal family not “native” Welsh

Well, re William in particular

  • he doesn't apparently identify as Welsh in particular as far as we know
  • wasn't born there
  • didn't grow up there
  • wasn't educated there
  • doesn't speak the language (but learnt the anthem phoneticzlly
  • doesn't live there
  • doesn't plan to make it his main home
  • isn't educating his kids there
  • doesn't speak Welsh

Why do you think he's Welsh? Seems fairly obvious he isn't

Discovereads · 13/09/2022 15:43

@LetMeSpeak
A little fact for you. England has oppressed every single country/tribe/ethnicity that they have ever had contact with and the ones they haven’t were simply too strong for them to do so.

That’s a lie remarkable only for it’s absolutism, arrogance and hatred of the English.

Everyone has been invaded, colonised and oppressed…the whole world has done it to each other since history began. The English are no worse (or better) than any other country/tribe/ethnicity.

Todays English are all mixed ancestry anyway because England itself has been invaded, colonised and oppressed many times over- Celts, Romans, Anglo-Saxons, Vikings (esp the Danes), and Normans. The 11th century invasions of Wales, Scotland and Ireland were done from England but by their Norman conquerors (not the English). Saying it was “the English” is a bit like claiming the Goths (Germans) invaded us when they were a conquered people compelled to serve in the Roman army during their occupation of Britain.

But these Norman invasions of Wales were not the first. Irish Scoti had invaded and colonised both North Wales and Scotland preRoman invasion and conquest.

Then of course, the Romans invaded and colonised Wales.

Lothian Scots then also invaded Wales in the 5th century after the Romans withdrew and Welsh legend holds that the kingdom of Gwynedd was established by Cunedda Wledig one of these Scottish invaders called the Goddodin. 500yrs later, his descendent Llywelyn ap Gruffudd is called the “last native prince of wales”. So if 500yrs of a Scottish family ruling Wales makes them “native” Welsh…then why is the current royal family not “native” Welsh despite definitely having Welsh royal blood from Welsh royalty that actually originated in Wales (not a kingdom established in Wales by a Scottish invader) and having ruled Wales since 1485?

Culldesack · 13/09/2022 15:27

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 13/09/2022 13:45

It's a pity the British couldn't follow the example of those other empires like the Mongols and the Moghuls and establish their empire with tea and cakes and handing out fluffy kittens.

😂